Article contents
Lecture demonstrations and the real world: the case of cart-wheels
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 January 2009
Extract
A quotation from J. T. Desaguliers, one of the foremost scientific lecturers in England until his death in 1744, contrasts the use of demonstrations to show physical principles and those designed to imitate real situations:
I have indeed a Machine with brass wheels whose steel axes have very small pivots nicely made that any of the wheels set in motion will turn for the space of more than half an hour… but the use of my machine being chiefly to show how near these kinds of experiments may be brought to agree with a mathematical theory; we cannot expect that any carriage to bear weight can have so little friction. Therefore I choose to relate Monsieur De Camus's Experiments made on Models of Carriages of an inch to a Foot every way representing Carts and Waggons… because it shows us directly what is the real Friction in the carriages at present in use.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © British Society for the History of Science 1995
References
1 Desaguliers, J. T., A Course of Experimental Philosophy, 2nd edn, 2 vols., London, 1744–1745, i, 211.Google Scholar
2 Stewart, L., The Rise of Public Science, Cambridge, 1992, 106.Google Scholar
3 Stewart, , op. cit. (2), 61, 253, 361.Google Scholar
4 Morton, A. Q., ‘Lectures on natural philosophy in London, 1750–1765: S. C. T. Demainbray (1710–1782) and the “‡Inattention” of his countrymen’, BJHS (1990), 7, 411–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Also in Morton, A. Q. and Wess, J. A., Public and Private Science, Oxford, 1993, chs. 2 and 3.Google Scholar
5 Heilbron, J. L., Electricity in the 17th and 18th Centuries. A Study of Early Modern Physics, Los Angeles and London, 1979, 14.Google Scholar
6 Morton, and Wess, , op. cit. (4).Google Scholar
7 Millburn, J. R., Benjamin Martin: Author, Instrument Maker, and ‘Country Showman’, Leyden, 1976CrossRefGoogle Scholar; see also his ‘The London evening courses of Benjamin Martin and James Ferguson, eighteenth century lecturers on experimental philosophy’, Annals of Science (1983), 40, 437–55Google Scholar, and ‘James Ferguson's lecture tour of the English Midlands 1771’, Annals of Science (1985), 42, 397–415Google Scholar. Also King, H. C. and Millburn, J. R., Wheelwright of the Heavens. The Life and Work of James Ferguson FRS, London, 1988.Google Scholar
8 Hauksbee, F. and Whiston, W., A Course of Mechanical, Optical, Hydrostatical and Pneumatical Experiments. To be perform'd by Francis Hawksbee; and the explanatory notes to be read by William Whiston, M.A., London, 1714Google Scholar. Desaguliers, J. T., A Course of Mechanical and Experimental Philosophy, c. 1717, Bodleian Library, MS Rawl d. 871Google Scholar; A Course of Mechanical and Experimental Philosophy, London, 1739Google Scholar, Oxford Museum of the History of Science. Griffiss, W., A Short Account of a Course of Mechanical and Experimental Philosophy and Astronomy, 1746, P. J. Wallis's collection and the Wagner Institute of Science, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar. Jurin, J., ‘Proposals for carrying on by subscription A Compleat Course of Mechanicks’, Newcastle Courant, 1712, 24/26 NovemberGoogle Scholar. Donn, B., An Enlarged Syllabus of a course of Lectures in Experimental Philosophy, Bristol, 1780.Google Scholar
9 Morton, and Wess, , op. cit. (4), cat. nos. D51 and D22.Google Scholar
10 Morton, and Wess, , op. cit. (4), cat. no. D10.Google Scholar
11 Albert, W., ‘The turnpike trusts’, in Transport in the Industrial Revolution (ed. Aldcroft, D. H. and Freeman, M. J.), Manchester, 1983Google Scholar, and his The Turnpike Road System in England 1663–1840, London, 1972Google Scholar. Pawson, E., Transport and Economy: The Turnpike Roads of Eighteenth Century Britain, London, 1977Google Scholar. Jackman, T. W., The Development of Transport in Modern England, 3rd edn, London, 1966.Google Scholar
12 Gentleman's Magazine (1749), 19, 219.Google Scholar
13 Gentleman's Magazine (1852), 22, 552.Google Scholar
14 Albert, W., ‘Popular opposition to turnpike trusts in early eighteenth century England’, Journal of Transport History (1979), 5 (NS), 1–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
15 Pawson, , op. cit. (11), figs. 27 and 29Google Scholar, and Albert, (1983), op. cit. (11), fig. 4.Google Scholar
16 Jackman, , op. cit. (11), 285.Google Scholar
17 Hauksbee, and Whiston, , op. cit. (8)Google Scholar; Desaguliers, , op. cit. (8).Google Scholar
18 Donn, , op. cit. (8).Google Scholar
19 Desaguliers, , op. cit. (1), i, 233.Google Scholar
20 Ferguson, J., ‘The utility of large wheels in wheel-carriages demonstrated’, Gentleman's Magazine (1771), 41, 118.Google Scholar
21 Desaguliers, , op. cit. (1), i, 220.Google Scholar
22 Morton, and Wess, , op. cit. (4), cat. no. D19.Google Scholar
23 Chabrol, Le Pere F., ‘Abrege des leçons de physique experimentalle, données en 1753, par le docteur Mainbray: avec des remarques critiques’, 1753, Bordeaux Academie des Sciences.Google Scholar
24 Desaguliers, , op. cit. (1), i, 200–11.Google Scholar
25 Demainbray, S. C. T., The Syllabus of a Course of Natural and Experimental Philosophy, London, 1754Google Scholar. Oxford Museum of the History of Science.
26 Desaguliers, , op. cit. (1), i, 235–6 (kennels), 213 (shoeing with strips of iron), 234–5 (nails).Google Scholar
27 Adams, G., ‘A Description of an Apparatus for Explaining the Principles of Mechanics’, 1761/1762, MS, 74. The Science Museum.Google Scholar
28 Desaguliers, , op. cit. (1), i, 214.Google Scholar
29 Morton, and Wess, , op. cit. (4), cat. no. D112.Google Scholar
30 Gentleman's Magazine (1745), 15, 151.Google Scholar
31 Gentleman's Magazine (1751), 21, 321.Google Scholar
32 Gentleman's Magazine (1752), 22, 408.Google Scholar
33 Gentleman's Magazine (1753), 23, 291.Google Scholar
34 Gentleman's Magazine (1755), 25, 232.Google Scholar
35 Gentleman's Magazine (1754), 24, 473–4.Google Scholar
36 Gentleman's Magazine (1754), 24, 328.Google Scholar
37 Gentleman's Magazine (1754), 24, 473, and (1755), 25, 376.Google Scholar
38 Gentleman's Magazine (1755), 25, 376.Google Scholar
39 Pawson, , op. cit. (11), 53.Google Scholar
40 Sharp, J., Rolling Carts and Waggons, London, c. 1773Google Scholar. Broadsheet, Science Museum Pictorial Collection.
41 Gentleman's Magazine (1754), 24, 376.Google Scholar
42 Gentleman's Magazine (1746), 16, 318.Google Scholar
43 Albert, (1972), op. cit. (11), 134.Google Scholar
44 Gentleman's Magazine (1765), 35, 93.Google Scholar
45 Gentleman's Magazine (1773), 43, 558.Google Scholar
46 Bourn, D., A Treatise on Wheel Carriages Shewing their Present Defects With a Plan and Description of a Newly Constructed Waggon etc, London, 1763.Google Scholar
47 Sharp, , op. cit. (40).Google Scholar
48 Gentleman's Magazine (1773), 43, 558.Google Scholar
49 Jackman, , op. cit. (11), 225, footnote.Google Scholar
50 Morton, and Wess, , op. cit. (4), cat. no. D110.Google Scholar
51 Morton, and Wess, , op. cit. (4), cat. no. M58.Google Scholar
52 Jacob, J., Observations on the Structure and Draught of Wheel Carriages, London, 1773, 73.Google Scholar
53 Jacob, , op. cit. (52), 73.Google Scholar
54 I am grateful to Larry Stewart who has pointed out that Desaguliers was involved in promoting turnpikes during 1725–26. This may indicate a closer relationship between lecturers and turnpike trustees than I had previously surmised.
55 Stewart, , op. cit. (2), p. xix.Google Scholar
- 2
- Cited by