Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T23:14:56.188Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The beginnings of human palaeontology: prehistory, craniometry and the ‘fossil human races’

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 October 2016

MATTHEW R. GOODRUM
MATTHEW R. GOODRUM*
Affiliation:
Department of Science and Technology in Society, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA. Email: [email protected].
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Since the nineteenth century, hominid palaeontology has offered critical information about prehistoric humans and evidence for human evolution. Human fossils discovered at a time when there was growing agreement that humans existed during the Ice Age became especially significant but also controversial. This paper argues that the techniques used to study human fossils from the 1850s to the 1870s and the way that these specimens were interpreted owed much to the anthropological examination of Stone, Bronze, and Iron Age skeletons retrieved by archaeologists from prehistoric tombs throughout Europe. What emerged was the idea that a succession of distinct human races, which were identified using techniques such as craniometry, had occupied and migrated into Europe beginning in the Ice Age and continuing into the historic period. This marks a phase in the history of human palaeontology that gradually gave way to a science of palaeoanthropology that viewed hominid fossils more from the perspective of evolutionary theory and hominid phylogeny.

Type
Special Section: Palaeonarratives and Palaeopractices: Excavating and Interpreting Deep History
Information
The British Journal for the History of Science , Volume 49 , Issue 3 , September 2016 , pp. 387 - 409
Copyright
Copyright © British Society for the History of Science 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Clermont, Norman and Smith, Philip E.L., ‘Prehistoric, prehistory, prehistorian: who invented the terms’, Antiquity (1990) 64, pp. 97–102 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rowley-Conwy, Peter, ‘The concept of prehistory and the invention of the terms “prehistoric” and “prehistorian”: the Scandinavian origin, 1833–1850’, European Journal of Archaeology (2006) 9, pp. 103–130 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gräslund, Bo, ‘The background to C.J. Thomsen's three age system’, in Daniel, Glyn (ed.), Towards a History of Archaeology, London: Thames and Hudson, 1981, pp. 45–50 Google Scholar.

2 Gräslund, Bo, The Birth of Prehistoric Chronology: Dating Methods and Dating Systems in Nineteenth-Century Scandinavian Archaeology, Cambridge, 1987 Google Scholar; Rowley-Conwy, Peter, From Genesis to Prehistory: The Archaeological Three Age System and Its Contested Reception in Denmark, Britain, and Ireland, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007 Google Scholar.

3 Benes, T., In Babel's Shadow: Language, Philology, and the Nation in Nineteenth-Century Germany, Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 2008 Google Scholar; Olender, M., The Languages of Paradise: Race, Religion, and Philology in the Nineteenth Century, tr. Goldhammer, A., Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1992 Google Scholar; Mallory, James Patrick, In Search of the Indo-Europeans: Language, Archaeology and Myth, London: Thames & Hudson, 1989 Google Scholar.

4 For example Pictet, Adolph, Les origines indo-européennes, ou, les aryas primitifs: Essai de paléontologie linguistique, 2 vols., Paris: Joël Cherbuliez, 1859–1863 Google Scholar; Müller, Max Lectures on the Science of Language, London: Longman, Green, Longman, and Roberts, 1861 Google Scholar.

5 Gundling, Tom, First in Line: Tracing Our Ape Ancestry, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2005 Google Scholar; Regal, Brian, Human Evolution: A Guide to the Debates, Oxford: ABC-CLIO, 2004 Google Scholar; Tattersall, Ian, The Fossil Trail: How We Know What We Think We Know about Human Evolution, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995 Google Scholar; Bowler, Peter J., Theories of Human Evolution: A Century of Debate, 1844–1944, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1986 Google Scholar.

6 Worsaae, J.J.A., The Primeval Antiquities of Denmark (Danmarks oldtid oplust ved oldsager og gravhøie), tr. Thoms, William John, London: J.H. Parker, 1849, pp. 128–133 Google Scholar.

7 Worsaae, op. cit. (6), pp. 133–134.

8 Blanckaert, Claude, ‘“Les vicissitudes de l'angle facial” et les débuts de la craniométrie (1765–1875)’, Revue de synthèse (1987) 108, pp. 417–453 Google Scholar; Meijer, M., Race and Aesthetics in the Anthropology of Petrus Camper (1722–1789), Amsterdam: Editions Rodopi, 1999 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Retzius, Anders, ‘Kraniologische’, Archiv für Anatomie, Physiologie und wissenschaftliche Medizin (1849), pp. 554–582 Google Scholar.

10 Blanckaert, Claude, ‘L'indice céphalique et l'ethnogénie européenne: A. Retzius, P. Broca, F. Pruner-Bey (1840–1870)’, Bulletin de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1989) n.s. 1, pp. 165–202 Google Scholar.

11 Retzius, Anders, Om formen af Nordboernes Cranier, Stockholm: P.A. Norstedt et Söner, 1843 Google Scholar.

12 Retzius, op. cit. (9). On Retzius's research and its relation to his contemporaries see Kyllingstad, J., Measuring the Master Race: Physical Anthropology in Norway, 1890–1945, Cambridge, 2014, 1–24 Google Scholar.

13 Prichard, James Cowles, The Natural History of Man, London: H. Bailliere, 1843, pp. 184–186 Google Scholar.

14 Thurnam, John, ‘On the two principal forms of ancient British and Gaulish skulls’, Memoirs of the Anthropological Society of London (1865) 1, pp. 120–168 Google Scholar, 459–519, 120–121, 139–140.

15 Thurnam, op. cit. (14), pp. 121–125, 166–167.

16 Thurnam, op. cit. (14), p. 145.

17 Thurnam, op. cit. (14), p. 167.

18 Thurnam, op. cit. (14), p. 167.

19 Rütimeyer, Ludwig and His, Wilhelm, Crania helvetica: Sammlung schweizerischer Schädelformen, Basel and Geneva: H. Georg, 1864 Google Scholar.

20 Livingstone, David, The Preadamite Theory and the Marriage of Science and Religion, Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1992 Google Scholar.

21 Buckland, William, Reliquiae Diluvianae, London: John Murray, 1823, pp. 83–92 Google Scholar. For an examination of the discovery and Buckland's conclusions see Sommer, Marianne, Bones and Ochre: The Curious Afterlife of the Red Lady of Paviland, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007, pp. 21–120 Google Scholar.

22 Tournal, Paul, ‘Observations sur les ossemens humains et les objects de fabrication humaine confondus avec des ossemens de mammifères appartenant à des espèces perdues’, Bulletin de la Société géologique de France (1830) 1, pp. 195–200 Google Scholar; de Christol, Jules, Notice sur les ossemens humains fossiles des cavernes du département du Gard, Montpellier, 1829 Google Scholar; Schmerling, Philippe-Charles, Recherches sur des ossements fossiles découverts dans les cavernes de la province de Liège, 3 vols., Liège: Collardin, 1833–Google Scholar.

23 For a full discussion of those discoveries and the debates surrounding them see Grayson, Donald, The Establishment of Human Antiquity, New York: Academic Press, 1983, pp. 55–138 Google Scholar.

24 Spring, Antoine, ‘Sur des ossements humains découverts dans une caverne de la province de Namur’, Bulletin de l'Académie royale des sciences, des lettres et des beaux-arts de Belgique (1853) 20(3), pp. 427–449 Google Scholar, 430–431, 433–434.

25 Spring, op. cit. (24), pp. 431–435.

26 Spring, op. cit. (24), pp. 435–440.

27 See Zängl-Kumpf, Ursula, ‘Hermann Schaaffhausen (1816–1893) and the Neanderthal finds of the 19th century’, in Schmitz, Ralf W. (ed.), Neanderthal 1856–2006, Mainz am Rhein: Verlag Philipp von Zabern, 2006, pp. 45–53 Google Scholar; Trinkaus, Erik and Shipman, Pat, The Neandertals: Changing the Image of Mankind, New York: Knopf, 1993, pp. 46–90 Google Scholar; Reader, John, Missing Links: The Hunt for Earliest Man, 2nd edn, New York: Penguin Books, 1988, pp. 1–15 Google Scholar; Schott, Lothar, ‘125 Jahre Neandertaler’, Ethnographische–Archäologische Zeitschrift (1981) 22, pp. 703–712 Google Scholar.

28 Schaaffhausen, Hermann, ‘Zur Kenntniß der ältesten Rassenschädel’, Archiv für Anatomie, Physiologie und wissenschaftliche Medicin (1858) 5, pp. 453–478 Google Scholar, 454–459.

29 Schaaffhausen, op. cit. (28), 461.

30 Schaaffhausen, op. cit. (28), pp. 453–454, 460.

31 Schaaffhausen, op. cit. (28), 454, 460.

32 Schaaffhausen, op. cit. (28), 477.

33 King, William, ‘The reputed fossil man of the Neanderthal’, Quarterly Journal of Science (1864) 1, pp. 88–97 Google Scholar.

34 Cohen, Claudine and Hublin, Jean-Jacques, Boucher de Perthes (1788–1868): Les origines romantiques de la préhistoire, Paris: Belin, 1989 Google Scholar.

35 Grayson, op. cit. (23), pp. 113–138, 168–223; van Riper, A. Bowdoin, Men among the Mammoths: Victorian Science and the Discovery of Human Prehistory, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1993, 74–143 Google Scholar.

36 This is discussed in greater detail in Goodrum, Matthew R., ‘Crafting a new science: defining paleoanthropology and its relationship to prehistoric archaeology’, Isis (2014) 105, pp. 706–733 Google Scholar.

37 Dupont, Edouard, ‘Etude sur cinq cavernes explorées dans la vallée de la Lesse et le ravin de Falmignoul pendant l’été 1866’, in Notices préliminaires sur les fouilles exécutées sous les auspices du gouvernement belge, dans les cavernes de la Belgique, 2 vols., Brussels: Mucquardt, 1867, vol. 2, pp. 3–23 Google Scholar.

38 Edouard Dupont, ‘Etude sur l'ethnographie de l'homme de l’âge du Renne, dans les cavernes de la vallée de la Lesse, ses caractères; sa race; son industrie; ses moeurs’, in Notices préliminaires, op. cit. (37), vol. 2, 4, pp. 33–68.

39 Dupont, op. cit. (38), pp. 29–31.

40 Lartet, Louis, ‘Une sépulture des troglodytes du Périgord’, Bulletins de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1868) 3, pp. 346–347 Google Scholar.

41 Lartet, Louis, ‘Mémoire sur une sépulture des anciens troglodytes du Périgord,’ Annales des sciences naturelles: Zoologie et paléontologie (1868) ser. 5, 10, pp. 133–145 Google Scholar.

42 Lartet, op. cit. (41), p. 144; Lartet, op. cit. (40), p. 349.

43 Blanckaert, Claude, De la race à l’évolution: Paul Broca et l'anthropologie française (1850–1900), Paris: L'Harmattan, 2009 Google Scholar.

44 Pruner-Bey, Ignaz, ‘Sur l'origine asiatique des européens’, Bulletins de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1864) 5, pp. 223–242 Google Scholar; Pruner-Bey, , ‘Sur les origines indo-européennes’, Bulletins de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1864) 5, pp. 331–334 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 Pruner-Bey, Ignaz, ‘Sur les ossements humains des Eyzies’, Bulletins de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1868) 3, pp. 416–446, 416, 419Google Scholar.

46 Pruner-Bey, Ignaz, ‘Description sommaire des restes humains découverts dans les Grottes de Cro-Magnon, prés de la station des Eyzies, arrondissement de Sarlay (Dordogne), en Avril 1868’, Annales des sciences naturelles: Zoologie et paléontologie (1868) ser. 5, 10, pp. 145–155 Google Scholar, 153; Pruner-Bey, op. cit. (45), pp. 420–422.

47 Broca, Paul, ‘Sur les crânes et ossements des Eyzies’, Bulletin de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1868) 3, pp. 350–352 Google Scholar.

48 Broca, op. cit. (47), pp. 358–362.

49 Broca, op. cit. (47), pp. 388–389.

50 Broca, op. cit. (47), pp. 358, 361–362.

51 Broca, op. cit. (47), pp. 351–352.

52 Hamy, Ernest-Théodore, ‘Sur quelques ossements humains fossiles de la seconde caverne d'Engihoul, près Liège’, Bulletin de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1871) 6, pp. 372–374 Google Scholar.

53 Malaise, Constantin, ‘Note sur quelques ossements humains fossiles et sur quelques silex taillés’, Bulletin de l'Académie royale des sciences, des lettres et des beaux-arts de Belgique (1860) ser. 2, 11, pp. 538–546 Google Scholar.

54 Hamy, op. cit. (52), pp. 374–386.

55 de Quatrefages, Armand and Hamy, Ernest-Théodore, ‘Races humaines fossiles: Races de Canstadt’, Bulletin de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1873) 8, pp. 518–523, 520Google Scholar.

56 Regarding the discovery of the latter fossil see Massénat, Elie, Lalande, Philibert and Cartailhac, Emile, ‘Découverte d'un squelette humain de l’âge du renne, à Laugerie-Basse (Dordogne)’, Matériaux pour l'histoire primitive et naturelle de l'homme (1872) ser. 2, 7, pp. 224–228 Google Scholar.

57 de Quatrefages, Armand and Hamy, Ernest-Théodore, ‘Races humaines fossiles: Race de Cro-Magnon’, Comptes rendus de l'Académie des sciences Paris (1874) 78, pp. 861–867 Google Scholar; Quatrefages, and Hamy, , ‘La race de Cro-Magnon dans l'espace et dans le temps,’ Bulletin de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1874) 9, pp. 260–266 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

58 de Quatrefages, Armand and Hamy, Ernest-Théodore, ‘Races humaines fossiles: mésaticéphales et brachycéphales’, Bulletin de la Société d'anthropologie de Paris (1874) 9, pp. 819–826 Google Scholar.

59 Quatrefages and Hamy, op. cit. (58), p. 822.

60 Quatrefages and Hamy, op. cit. (55), p. 522.

61 Quatrefages and Hamy, op. cit. (57), pp. 264–265.

62 Quatrefages and Hamy, op. cit. (55), p. 520.

63 Delisle, Richard, Debating Humankind's Place in Nature, 1860–2000: The Nature of Paleoanthropology, Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2007, pp. 47–69 Google Scholar.

64 Fraipont, Julien and Lohest, Max, ‘La race humaine de Néanderthal ou de Canstadt en Belgique: Recherches ethnographiques sur des ossements humains, découverts dans des dépôts quaternaires d'une grotte à Spy et determination de leur âge géologique’, Archives de biologie (1887) 7, pp. 587–757 Google Scholar; Gorjanović-Kramberger, Dragutin, Der diluviale Mensch von Krapina in Kroatien, Wiesbaden: C.W. Kreidel, 1906 Google Scholar.

65 Schwalbe, Gustav, ‘Der Neanderthalschädel,’ Bonner Jahrbücher (1901) 106, pp. 1–72 Google Scholar.

66 Theunissen, Bert, Eugène Dubois and the Ape-Man from Java: The History of the First Missing Link and Its Discoverer, Dordrecht and Boston: Kluwer Academic, 1989, pp. 1–19, 79–117Google Scholar.