Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T04:24:14.250Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Stuart Relics in the Stonyhurst Collections

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 February 2015

Jan Graffius
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Stuart artefacts described in this article have not previously been examined as an entity, and many are relatively unfamiliar to scholars. This paper will consider this unique collection of relics and discuss their significance within the personal as well as national and international contexts of their origins. That significance rests largely in their royal provenance, which was valued by the custodians at the English Jesuit College of St Omers, the predecessor of Stonyhurst College, founded to educate English Catholic boys in 1593. The Stuart cause, from Mary Queen of Scots to Charles Edward Stuart represented the best hope of English Catholics for a formal restoration of the faith. Relics, such as Mary Queen of Scots’ Thorn, were powerful symbols of tenacity and hope, providing an unbroken thread from the Passion of Christ to the martyred Queen, the more valued as the College gained its own seventeenth-century martyrs. Artefacts which arrived at Stonyhurst College after 1794 were valued for their romantic association with the failed Stuart cause. The creation of the Stuart Parlour in 1911and the adoption of the Borrodale tartan as part of the girls’ uniform in the 1990s demonstrate the significance these objects possess well into the twentieth century.

Type
Articles
Information
British Catholic History , Volume 31 , Issue 2 , October 2012 , pp. 147 - 169
Copyright
Copyright © Catholic Record Society 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Guy, John, ‘My heart is my own’, The Life of Mary, Queen of Scots (Fourth Estate: London, 2009), pp. 6–7.Google Scholar

2 Guy, John, ‘My heart is my own’, p. 5.Google Scholar

3 This Book of Hours was in the collection of the Scots College in Paris until shortly before the French Revolution, when it was sold, and ended up in the Collection of Sir Gregory Osborne Page-Turner c 1822. Pope Pius V sent the book to Mary, Queen of Scots as a gift for her in captivity, but there is no clear path from her hands to the Scots College. It was clearly in the ownership of James II at some point, but there is no extant evidence for the date or the route of its arrival at the Scots College in Paris. See Guy, John, ‘My heart is my own’, p. 545.Google Scholar

4 Scottish Catholic Archives, PL/8/24.

5 Vercruysse, JE sj, The Innes Review, 61.2 (2010) Edinburgh University Press, pp. 144–9.Google Scholar

6 Dorrington, Theophilus, Observations concerning the Present State of Religion in the Romish Church (1699), p. 243.Google Scholar

7 Freeman, Charles, Holy Bones, Holy Dust (Yale University Press: London, 2011), pp. 122–30.Google Scholar

8 Cardin, Prosperi. Lambertini Postea Benedicti Xiv. Commentarii Duo De D.n. Jesu Christi Matrisque Ejus, Festis, Et De Missae Sacrificio Retractati Angelus De Giacomellis (2011)Google Scholar.

9 Cherry, John, The Holy Thorn Reliquary (The British Museum Press, 2010), p.2.Google Scholar

10 Fleury, Rohault de, Mémoires sur les instruments de la passion (Paris, 1870), pp. 199–223.Google Scholar

11 Caraman, Philip, John Gerard, The Autobiography of an Elizabethan (Longmans: London, 1951), p. 49, 62–3.Google Scholar

12 Caraman, Philip, John Gerard, The Autobiography of an Elizabethan (Longmans: London 1951), p. 39.Google Scholar

13 The Ghent reliquary was confiscated when the Jesuit Order was suppressed in 1773, and presented first to the Bishop of Ghent, then in 1808 to the Confraternity of the Holy Cross in St Michael’s, Ghent, where it can still be seen. Morris, John, ‘Queen Mary’s Holy Thorn’, The Month, vol. 44 (Burns & Oates, London, 1882), p. 555.Google Scholar

14 Morris, John, ‘Queen Mary’s Holy Thorn’, The Month, vol. 44, p. 554.Google Scholar

15 Morris, John, ‘Queen Mary’s Holy Thorn’, The Month, vol 44, p. 556.Google Scholar

16 Stonyhurst Archive, F.II.7.7.

17 The Stonyhurst Magazine, No. 329 (July 1937), p. 215.

18 See Letters and Notices, vol. 241 (1926), pp. 139–144 for a brief account of this short-lived but successful College. It educated some 400 boys, half of whom were Protestant, between its foundation in June 1687 and forced closure in the riots of December 1688. James II gave a personal donation of £800 to enlarge the chapel, and Queen Mary sent two silver sanctuary lamps.

19 See Whitehead, Maurice, ed, Held in Trust 2008 Years of Sacred Culture (St Omers Press, Stonyhurst 2008)Google Scholar, passim, for an exploration of some of the numerous items entrusted to the College since 1593.

20 Gerard, John, Centenary Record, Stonyhurst College (Ward & Co, Belfast, 1894), pp. 254–5.Google Scholar

21 Chadwick, Hubert, Stonyhurst Vestments (Internal publication, Stonyhurst 1957), pp. 5–6.Google Scholar

22 James Houghton, manuscript notes, vol 2, Stonyhurst Archives.

23 The author is indebted to Professor Peter Davidson of the University of Aberdeen for his assistance in identifying possible candidates for Robert Gordon’s identity. Frame P, Relics Collection, Stonyhurst College.

24 Frame P, Relics Collection, Stonyhurst College.

25 Holt, Geoffrey SJ, The English Jesuits, 1650–1829, CRS 70 (1984), pp. 124–5.Google Scholar

26 Weldon, Benett, Chronological Notes (1709) (Stanbrook, Worcs., 1883), pp. 244–7.Google Scholar

27 ‘The Disinterment Of James II’, The Times September 15, 1824.

28 Jesse, John Heneage, Memoirs of the Court of England during the Reign of the Stuarts, Including the Protectorate (London: Richard Bentley, 1840), vol. 4, pp. 444–445Google Scholar.

29 Stonyhurst Archives, C.4.3.59.

30 Saint-Simon in his Mémoires relates that Alberoni was admitted to the Duke’s presence while he was on the close stool. The Duke, famous for his lack of manners, had his buttocks wiped in front of the priest, who reacted by kissing them and crying “O culo di angelo!” Saint-Simon’s gossipy memoirs are not, of course, entirely reliable, and the French nobleman harboured considerable dislike for the low born Italian priest, but the story was clearly credible to Alberoni’s contemporaries whether true or not. Oeuvres complettes de Louis de Saint-Simon (Strasbourg, 1791), p. 89.

31 Harcourt-Smith, Simon, Cardinal of Spain, the Strange Life of Alberoni (New York, 1955)Google Scholar

32 The King Over the Water : Portraits of the Stuarts in Exile After 1689, ed. Edward Corp (Scottish National Portrait Gallery Catalogue: Edinburgh, 2001), pp.106–109

33 The King Over the Water, pp. 91–2.

34 The King Over the Water, p. 34.

35 Stonyhurst Archives C.iv.3.25, C.iv.3.26.

36 British Province Archives, Foreign Correspondence, f 309 r, v, 10 September 1833.

37 British Province Archives, Foreign Correspondence, ff 312–3, 29 October 1833.

38 Tayler, Alistair & Tayler, Henrietta, The Stuart Papers at Windsor (London, 1939), p. 22ffGoogle Scholar.

39 Lees-Milne, James, The Last Stuarts (London, 1983), p. 176.Google Scholar

40 Paton, Henry, ed, The Lyon in Mourning (Edinburgh University Press for The Scottish History Society, 1895), p. 322’Google Scholar

41 Stonyhurst Archives, Borrodale Files, 3.3.11.

42 Stonyhurst Archives, Borrodale Files, 3.3.11.