Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dsjbd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-29T14:11:21.472Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Catholic Representatives in Parliament: The North West of England 1918–1945

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 September 2015

John Davies
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Cardinal Manning argued that the Catholic Church had two services it should render to the world outside it; its first task was to save souls but secondly it should ‘ripen and elevate the social and political life of men . . .’ In 1890, however, he noted that none of the recent great works of charity had been initiated or promoted by Catholics. His successor Vaughan found that his main support in attempting to exercise social influence came, not from the English laity, but from the Irish (Catholic) M.P.s, fifty seven of whom had been returned to Parliament after the extension of the franchise in 1884. There were few English Catholics in Parliament and Bourne, after Vaughan, continued to rely on the Irish M.P.s. With the establishment of the Irish Free State in 1921 and the departure of the Irish M.P.s, one authority argues that Catholics were left with very few representatives in the House of Commons and that ‘politically since the withdrawal of the Irish members, the Catholic influence has, on the whole, been negligible.’

Type
Research Article
Information
British Catholic History , Volume 26 , Issue 2 , October 2002 , pp. 359 - 383
Copyright
Copyright © Catholic Record Society 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Pereiro., James ‘“Who are the Laity?’” in McClelland, V. Alan and Hodgetts, Michael (eds.), From Without the Flaminian Gate: 150 Years of Roman Catholicism in England and Wales 1850–2000, (Darton, Longman and Todd, London, 1999), pp. 169–172 Google Scholar.

2 Sheridan Gilley, ‘The Years of Equipoise, 1892–1943’ in McClelland and Hodgetts, From Without, pp. 45—46.

3 This figure excludes two who sat for Irish seats from 1918 to the founding of the Irish Free State and the Irish Sinn Fein members elected in 1918 but who did not take their seats at Westminster.

4 For an interesting comparison with this group of Catholic M.P.s see Stack, John A., ‘Catholic Members of Parliament who represented British Constituencies, 1829–1885: A Prosopographical Analysis’, Recusant History 24(3), May 1999, pp. 335–353 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Twenty of the late Professor Stack’s twenty four M.P.s were sons/grandsons of peers, baronets or landed gentry.

5 Craig, F. S., British Parliamentary Election Results 1918–1949, (Glasgow, 1969)Google Scholar: Stenton, M. and Lees, S., Who’s Who of British Members of Parliament: A Biographical Dictionary of the House of Commons, vol. 3 1919–1945, (Harvester Press, 1976)Google Scholar: Catholic Directory..

6 Robbins, K., The Eclipse of a Great Power: Modern Britain 1870–1975, (Longmans, London 1983), pp. 362–363 Google Scholar.

7 Eleven of these M.P.s sat for seats in the London area, (six Labour, five Conservative), twelve in Manchester and its region, (seven Conservative, five labour), seven for Liverpool and Merseyside, (four Labour, two Conservative and one Irish Nationalist), six for the North East of England, (three Labour, two Conservative, one Liberal), four for the Midlands, (three Conservative, one Labour), three for Yorkshire, (two Conservative, one Labour) and thirteen for the remainder of England, (eleven Conservative, two Labour). Five held seats in Scotland, (four Labour, one Conservative), seven in Northern Ireland after 1922, (six nationalist, one Unionist), and two in South Wales, (two Conservative). Two M.P.s sat at different times for more than one seat in this period, Sir Arthur Evans, Leicester East, 1923–1929, and Cardiff South, 1935–1945, and Hyacinth B. Morgan, Camberwell North West, 1924–1931, and Rochdale 1940–1950. Craig, Election Results, passim, Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s passim.

8 Hilton, J. A., Catholic Lancashire: From Reformation to Renewal 1559–1991, (Phillimore, Chichester 1994), p. 107 Google Scholar.

9 Craig, Election Results, passim.

10 Craig, Election Results, passim: Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s, passim.

11 Craig, Election Results, passim: Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s, passim.

12 Aidan Bellenger, ‘Religious Life for Men’, in McClelland and Hodgetts, From Without, p. 145.

13 The Times, 5 August 1957. Stokes’ obituary.

14 Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s, passim.

15 Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s, passim.

16 Jeffrey Paul von Arx, ‘Catholics and Politics’ in McClelland and Hodgetts, From Without, pp. 245–249.

17 Davies, S., “‘A Stormy Political Career”: Kelly, P. J. and Irish Nationalist and Labour politics in Liverpool, 1891–1936, Transactions of the Historic Society of Lancashire and Cheshire, vol 148, (Liverpool, 1999), pp. 147 ffGoogle Scholar.

18 Fielding, S., Class and Ethnicity: Irish Catholics in England, 1880–1939, (Open University Press, Buckingham, 1993), pp. 105 ffGoogle Scholar.

19 Simon, Brian, Education and the Labour Movement, (Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1965), pp. 258–259 Google Scholar.

20 Fielding, Class and Ethnicity, p. 115.

21 Simon, Education, p. 274.

22 Simon, Education, pp. 276–277.

23 Davies, J., ‘Rome on the Rates’, North West Catholic History 18 (1991) pp. 16–32 Google Scholar.

24 Skidelski, R., Politicians and the Slump: the Labour Government of 1929–31, (London, 1967, 1994), p. 322 Google Scholar.

25 Bellamy, J. and Saville, J., Dictionary of Labour Biography, IV (London, 1977) pp. 155–156: Skidelski, Politicians, pp. 232–233 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Simons, B., The Politics of Educational Reform, 1920–1940, (Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1974), p. 161 Google Scholar.

27 Simon, Politics, p. 213.

28 Simon, Politics, pp. 217–218: Waller, P. J., Democracy and Sectarianism: a political and social history of Liverpool, 1868–1939 (Liverpool University Press, Liverpool, 1981) p. 340 Google Scholar, Hinsley in The Times, 18 February 1931.

29 The Times, 14 February 1936.

30 Davies, ‘Rome on the Rates’, pp. 28–31: Waller, Democracy and Sectarianism, pp. 342–343.

31 The Times, 14 February 1936.

32 The Liverpool Daily Post, 2 November 1937.

33 Davies, J., “‘L’ Art du Possible”, the Board of Education, the Catholic Church and negotiations over the White Paper and the Education Bill, 1943–1944’, Recusant History, vol. 22, no.2, October 1994, pp. 231–250 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Davies, J., “‘A blunt unsophisticated working man”: J. T. (Joe) Tinker M.P. and the 1944 Education Act’, North West Catholic History, 21 (1994), pp. 27–35 Google Scholar.

35 Gilley, Sheridan, ‘Catholics and Socialists in Glasgow 1906–1912’ in Kenneth Lunn, ed. Hosts, Immigrants and Minorities. Historical Responses to Newcomers in British Society 1870–1914, (Dawson and Sons, Folkstone, 1980), pp. 161–191 Google Scholar. See also Gilley, entry for John Wheatley in Bellamy, Joyce and Saville, John, eds., Dictionary of Labour Biography, vol. 7, (MacMillan, London, 1984)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, Howell, David, A Lost life: Three studies in Socialism and Nationalism, (Manchester University Press, 1986)Google Scholar, Wood, I. S., ‘John Wheatley’, Innes Review 31 (20) 1980 Google Scholar, Wood, I. S., John Wheatley, (Manchester, 1990)Google Scholar, and Cooper, S., John Wheatley: a study in labour history, (unpublished Ph.D thesis, University of Glasgow, 1973.Google Scholar)

36 D. Howell, A Lost Life, p. 280.

37 Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s.

38 Howell, D., entry for Joseph Toole in Bellamy and Saville, Dictionary of Labour Biography, vol. 8 (1984), pp. 230–235 Google Scholar. See also Toole, J., Fighting Through Life, (Rich and Cowan, London, 1935)Google Scholar, and Toole, Millie, Our Old Man: a Biographical Portrait of Joseph Toole, (J. M. Dent, London, 1948)Google Scholar.

39 S. Fielding, Class and Ethnicity, pp. 107–109.

40 Howell in Bellamy and Saville, Dictionary of Labour Biography, vol. 8.

41 Liverpool Daily Post, 1 November 1937.

42 The Times, 5 August 1957.

43 Smith, Joan, ‘Labour Tradition in Glasgow and Liverpool’, History Workshop 17, 1984, pp. 36–37 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

44 Quinn, Dermot, Patronage and Piety: The Politics of English Roman Catholicism 1850–1900, (Stanford University Press, California, 1993), p. 233 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 Taplin, E., ‘The Apprenticeship of a Revolutionary’ in Nevin, D. ed., James Larkin: Lion of the Fold, (Gill and Macmillan, Dublin, 1998), p. 19 Google Scholar.

46 S.Davies, “‘A Stormy Political Career’”, pp. 169–171.

47 Liverpool Daily Post, 1 May 1920.

48 Liverpool Daily Courier, 1 May 1920, Liverpool Daily Post, 1 May 1920.

49 Liverpool Daily Courier, 3 May 1920, Liverpool Daily Post, 3 May 1920.

50 Liverpool Daily Courier, 3 May 1920, Liverpool Daily Post, 3 May 1920.

51 Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s.

52 Martin, David E., entry for Morgan in Bellamy and Saville, Dictionary of Labour Biography, vol. 8, p. 224 Google Scholar. Fyrth, J., The Signal was Spain: the Spanish Aid Movement in Britain 1936–1939, (Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1986), p. 46 Google Scholar.

53 Stenton and Lees, British M.P.s, The Times 13 December 1932 and 14 December 1932, Liverpolitan, vol. 7, October 1938.

54 Liverpool Record Office, Derby Papers, 920 DER (17), 31/8 Derby to Topping, Conservative Central Office, 8 November 1932, 6/34 Derby to Sir Thomas White, 13 December 1932, 6/33 White to Derby, 13 December 1932, 6/34 Derby to White, 15 December 1932, 31/5 Lord Stonehaven to Derby, 22 December 1932.

55 As an M.P. Blundell was noted for his campaigns on rural issues and his support for the farming community. However, he was also a forthright defender of Catholic causes. In the summer of 1924 he made a number of Parliamentary interventions in protest at the banning of a traditional Catholic procession in Carfin, Scotland. See Hansard, Parliamentary Debates, House of Commons. Fifth Series, volume 175, 1924. 175 H.C. Deb. 5 S, p. 1375, p. 1935, 1967, 1999, 176 H.C. Deb. 5 S, pp. 185–186, p. 1303, pp. 2612–2617. This was the beginning of his campaign, which culminated in the Roman Catholic Relief Act, 1926. The act enabled Catholic charities run by members of religious orders to qualitfy for the tax relief accorded to charities.

56 Derby Papers, 6 (unsorted), Shute to Derby, 23 December 1932, Derby to Shute, 26 December, 1932.

57 Derby Papers, 6 (unsorted) Derby to Sir John Reynolds, 26 December, 1932.

58 Derby Papers, 6 (unsorted), Reynolds to Derby, 27 December 1932, Reynolds to Derby, 28 December 1932.

59 Derby Papers, 6 (unsorted), Shute to Derby, 31 December 1932, 6/31, White to Derby, 4 January 1933, 6/34, Derby to White, 4 January 1933, Derby to White, 6 January 1933.

60 Derby Papers, 11/1, Derby to Shute, 22 January 1933, 6/34, Derby to White, 22 January 1933.

61 Derby Papers, 6/33, White to Derby, 25 January 1933.

62 Interview with James Dillon, February 2000. For Shute’s attendance at parish celebrations see for example, Catholic Herald, 1 July 1938 and Liverpool Daily Post, 20 June 1938.

63 P. J. Waller, Democracy and Sectarianism p. 332.

64 The Conservative Workingmen’s Clubs in Liverpool in this period were essentially Protestant in membership and closely associated with the Orange Order.

65 Derby Papers, 11/1, Shute to Derby, 28 January 1933.

66 Derby Papers, 6/34, Derby to White, 10 April 1933.

67 Derby Papers, 11/1, Shute to White, 7 November 1935, 6/34, Derby to White, 8 November 1935, 6/33, White to Shute, 8 November 1935.

68 Derby Papers, 6/34, White to Derby, 29 April 1933.

69 Hastings, , A History of English Christianity 1920–1990, (S.C.M., London, 1991), pp. 142–143 Google Scholar.

70 The Times, 31 July 1957, G. Nicholson M.P.