Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2plfb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T05:51:55.231Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Review of Current Research on the Turrets and Curtain of Hadrian's Wall

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2011

J.G. Crow
J.G. Crow
Affiliation:
The University, Newcastle upon Tyne
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

‘The principal periods in the history of the monument were firmly fixed and the complicated relationship between its component parts was securely defined’. With these words Sir Ian Richmond in 1950 reviewed more than a decade's work on Hadrian's Wall. Ten years before he had written: ‘As the great scheme proceeded, modifications were introduced, some structural, of interest only in defining the order of progress, others amounting to a thorough revision of the design. The most important of the latter was the construction of forts on the Wall itself. His analysis of ‘the fort - decision’ remains unchallenged, but in his 1950 paper Richmond reported on details of the structure of the Wall: in particular those observed during the consolidation of Turret 26b and the relationship between the Narrow and Broad Walls. In conclusion he wrote: ‘Plainly these are minor puzzles beyond immediate solution here, important for those who would follow centuriae at work, yet not obscuring a vision of the main intention’.

Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 22 , November 1991 , pp. 51 - 63
Copyright
Copyright © J.G. Crow 1991. Exclusive Licence to Publish: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Richmond, I.A.. JRS xl (1950). 43Google Scholar.

2 Richmond, I.A.. Antiquity xiv (1940). 296Google Scholar.

3 Richmond, op. cit. (note 1). 44.

4 This paper was originally given to the Royal Archaeological Institute's Seminar on Hadrian's Wall at Durham in April 1990. The text is largely unaltered, but I am grateful to the organisers Brian Dobson and Martin Millett for inviting me to address the meeting, and for the helpful comments and questions which the paper elicited. In particular. I would like to acknowledge the assistance from fellow excavators. Paul Austen and Paul Bidwell. and the support from David Sherlock and Charles Daniels.

5 E. Birley. Research on Hadrian's Wall (1961).

6 Haigh, D. and Savage, M., Arch. Ael5 xii (1984), 71–4Google Scholar.

7 F.G. Simpson. Watermills and Military Works on Hadrian's Wall (1976).

8 C. Daniels. The Eleventh Pilgrimage of Hadrian's Wall (1989). Steel Rigg to Housesteads. 50-5: Denton. 73; Austen, P.. Current Archaeology 108 (1988). 18–19Google Scholar.

9 See Bennett, J.. Arch. Ael5 xi (1983), 27–60: see also. P. Bidwell and N. Holbrook, Hadrian's Wall Bridges (1989)Google Scholar.

10 CW2 xxv (1935), 244–7Google Scholar.

11 Bennett, op. cit. (note 9): P. Bidwell in Daniels, op. cit. (note 8). 73.

12 J.C. Bruce. Handbook to the Roman Wall (13th edition by C.M. Daniels. 1978). 33.

13 Daniels, op. cit. (note 8). 50-5; Crow, J., Current Archaeology 108 (1988), 14–17Google Scholar.

14 Simpson, op. cit. (note 7). 109-10. 114-15, pl. v.

15 Donaldson, G.. Arch. Ael5 xvi (1988). 125–37Google Scholar.

16 F. Haverfield, The Academy 21 October 1893.

17 Bruce, op. cit. (note 12). 220-1.

18 Simpson, op. cit. (note 7). 98-107, 110-13.

19 Blair, P.H.. Arch. Ael.5 xi (1934). 103–20; J.G. Crow. Housesteads Roman Fort (1989). 30-2Google Scholar.

20 Bidwell and Holbrook, op. cit. (note 9), 58-61.

21 Bruce, op. cit. (note 12), 253; P. Brewis, Arch.Ael4 iv (1927). 112-15, pls 19. 20Google Scholar.

22 Bruce, op. cit. (note 12). 225.

23 I. Crow, ‘Construction and Reconstruction in the Central sector of Hadrian's Wall’, in V. Maxfield and M.J. Dobson (eds). The Proceedings of the XVth International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies (1959). 44-7.

24 Frontinus, De Aquis II. 123; he also recommends that building work should avoid the excessive heat of high summer. Such restrictions were not applicable in northern Britain.

25 RIB 1389.

26 Britannia xv (1984), 280Google Scholar.

27 F.E. Winter. Greek Fortifications (1971). 314-5.

28 Diodorus Siculus xiv. 18; I owe this reference to Brunt, P.A., JRS lxx (1980). 93Google Scholar.

29 D.J. Breeze and B. Dobson. Hadrian's Wall (1987). 80-1.

30 Bidwell in Daniels, op. cit. (note 8), 73.

31 Salway, P., Current Archaeology 98 (1985), 94Google Scholar.

32 J.P. Adam. La Construction Romaine (1984), 139, 235-46, fig. 295.

33 D. Baatz. Die Wachtürme am Limes (1976), 22-33; Figlis, M.N., ‘Bemalte Kellernischen’, Archäologie in Deutschland iv (1987), 36–9Google Scholar.

34 C. Foss and D. Winfield. Byzantine Fortifications (1986). 27-8; A.J. Taylor, The King's Works in Wales 1277-1330 (1974), 307, at Aberystwyth: ‘To David the mason for whitewashing (dealbacione) the top of a tower and the battlements in the outer bailey’.

35 Dobson, B., Arch. Ael1 xiv (1986), 6Google Scholar.

36 Bruce, op. cit. (note 12), 19-20: Bidwell and Holbrook, op. cit. (note 9). 58-9.

37 Jobey, G.. Arch. Ael4 xxxvi (1958). 59–60Google Scholar.

38 J. Crow and P. Bidwell in P. Bidwell et al. (eds), Portae cum turribus. Studies in Roman fort gates (1988). 149-51; 175-6. fig. 7.8.

39 Crow. op. cit. (note 13), 16.

40 Bennet. op. cit. (note 9). 48. n.44; Bidwell. op. cit. (note 38). 174-5. 200-7. fig. 7.8.

41 Richmond, I.A. and Gillam, J.P.. CW2 lii (1953). 14–40. pl. III, 1Google Scholar.

42 See the reconstruction of a coastal tower with merlon capstones, but narrower embrasures. Bellhouse, R.. CW2 lxix (1969), 83; also Crow. op. cit. (note 38), fig. 6.1. a reconstruction made before the significance of the Solway House stones was recognizedGoogle Scholar.

43 Baatz. op. cit. (note 33). 35-42.

44 Newbold, P.. Arch. Ael3 ix (1913). 60Google Scholar.

45 D. Charlesworth, in M. Apted et al. (eds.), Ancient monuments and their interpretation: essays presented to A.J. Taylor (1977), 22.

46 Newbold. op. cit. (note 44). 68-70, pl. IV.

47 Dobson. op. cit. (note 35). 3.

48 Collingwood, R.G.. Proc. Soc. Antiq. Newcastle4 iv (1930). 184Google Scholar.

49 Breeze, D. and Dobson, B.. Britannia iii (1972), 190Google Scholar.

50 Woolliscroft, D., Arch. Ael5 xvii (1989). 5–19Google Scholar.

51 Simpson, op. cit. (note 7). 125-30. figs 46. 47.