Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T13:14:53.741Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A Spiritual Cure for Scrupulosity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 October 2024

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

One of the cases of spiritual direction, which most frequently arises in the increasingly strenuous life of our age, is that of scrupulosity. The nervous tension, caused by the irritating atmosphere of great cities, is obviously conducive to psycho-neurotic troubles; and, if a rigorist educative influence saddles a hypersensitive temperament afflicted by these troubles, with the result that religion is misconceived as a repressive legalism, the effect will almost inevitably be a false conscience perhaps for ever paralysed by scruples. Whenever it makes its appearance and for the same reasons, this disease either suddenly breaks out in a violent crisis or gradually spreads in a slow, consuming progression. Much has been written about this malady : descriptions of the disorder, descriptions of the supernatural trial, the attitude to be taken towards the scrupulous by confessor and director, psychotherapeutic treatments or others in obstinate and disconcerting cases. It would seem that nothing has been overlooked and that the subject is therefore exhausted. One is tempted to conclude : the whole question has been settled once and for all. Nevertheless the scrupulous remain. It is in the West among Latins that scrupulosity is found in its endemic state, whereas it is unknown among Eastern Catholics and Orthodox . . .’

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © 1943 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers

Footnotes

1

These are but a few simple notes written by someone who has suffered acutely from this affliction. His testimony has therefore the weight of experience. All the usual remedies were prescribed to him, and he hopes he can say in all truth that he did his utmost to submit to them. He believes that the solution he proposes, which could be called the ‘historical solution,’ is the most efficacious, because it alone takes account of the whole psychological state of the soul suffering from this terrible disease.–Translated from the French in La Vie Spirituelle, Vol. XLII, Supplement pages (141) et sq.

References

The article is printed here not as nn example of a general principle of morality, but in order to show how it is possible to modify general principles in the concrete application to a very particular and exceptional case. It deals with the abnormal case and therefore the norm of moral action requires different treatment. The author suggests a treatment.–ED.

3 Cap. 21, ‘De annua confessione.’

4 Let there be no misunderstanding as to the meaning of this passage. In legal terminology it might be stated this way: The law is intended for the common good, and there are always individuals for whom it is less opportune. They are not, however, exempt from it for this reason.1 ‘In the case of the scrupulous a tacit privilege could be invoked as a kind of generalised’‘epikeia.’ Is it not in this way that the expression privilegia scrupulosorum, found in Priimmer's approvpd manual, has to be interpreted? Prummer, O.P., Manuale Theologiae Moralis, t. I, ed. 6 & 7, 1931, Friburg, Breisgau, p. 211 (No. 323).