No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Avicenna and Western Thought in the Thirteenth Century
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 September 2024
Extract
There was something indefinite about the effect of Avicenna on the West in the thirteenth century. Constant and pervasive as his influence was—from its beginnings in Spain in the twelfth century, through the confusion of its first contacts with the Cathedral Schools and the nascent University of Paris, down to Albert and Aquinas and Scotus—yet it nowhere crystallised into a definite set of doctrines accepted by a clearly marked group or school, as did, later in the century, the influence of Averroes. Some years ago Père De Vaux brought into circulation the term ‘Latin Avicennism’, parallel to the ‘Latin Averroism’ which Mandonnet had disclosed in his great work on Siger of Brabant. But Père De Vaux’s term, unlike Mandonnet’s, has not gained general acceptance; there is too much difference between the confused eclecticism at the turn of the century, studied by De Vaux, and the clear-cut, far more unified position of the Averroists of the 1270’s. More acceptable perhaps as a name for that earlier phase is Gilson’s ‘augustinisme avicennisant’, though this denoted originally only one aspect of it—the attempt to adapt an Avicennian theory of the ‘agent intellect’ to the Augustinian tradition of the human mind’s dependence upon illumination from God. And in any case one must not overstress the Augustinian element in the currents of thought that were running at the end of the twelfth century, and that largely derived from other sources—Boethius, for example, and Erigena.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © 1951 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers
Footnotes
This article is based on a lecture given at Cambridge in March, 1951; one of a series on the life, writings and influence of the Arabian philosopher, Avicenna. Avicenna was born about the year 980 at Bukhara (to the north‐east of the frontier of modern Persia, in what is now Soviet territory) and died in 1037. His prodigiously active life was spent in Persia, but nearly all his works are written in Arabic. Equally renowned as physician and philosopher, Avicenna shares with the Spanish Arab Averroes (1126–1198) the chief place in the intellectual history of Islam in the middle ages.
References
2 Notes et Textes sur l’Avicennisme Latin aux confins des XIIe—XIIIe siécles. (Paris: Vrin, 1934.)
3 See his articles in the Archives d’histoire doctrinale et littéraire du Moyen Age: 1926, 1927, 1929, 1933.
4 Op. cit. p. 57.
5 Archives, etc., 1927.
6 Text in Mandonnet’s Siger, vol. 2, p. 1, 55. Note that the author rejects St Thomas’s thesis of the unity of substantial form.
7 One example out of many: St Thomas’s De Ente et Essentia, c. 1, par. 1.
8 See Gilson, L'Etre et l’Essence, pp. 62-47 (Paris, 1948); and on this subject generally, M.-D. Roland-Gosselin's edition of the De Ente et Essentia (Le Sanlchoir, Kain; 1926).
9 Summa Theol., I, 11, 1 ad 1.
10 Quodlibet IX, a. 11.
11 One example out of many in St Thomas: In II Sent., D. 1, Q. 1, a. 1.
12 By P. H. Vicaire in Revue de Sc. Phil. et Théol., XXVI, 3, pp. 449, ss.
13 Confess., III, 6.
14 Ed. in De Vaux, op. cit., pp. 80. ss.
15 I, 45, 5. On this matter see A. Forest: La Structure Métaphysique du Concret Selon St Th. D'Aquin; espec. c. 2 (Paris: Vrin, 1931).
16 Roland-Gosselin, op. cit.. p. 11.
17 Summa Theol., I, 110. 1 ad 3.
18 Mélanges Mandonnet II, p. 48 (Bibl. Thomiste XIV; Paris: Vrin. 1930).
19 QQ de Ver. X, 6. 20
20 cf. S.T. I, 84.4c.
21 Contra Geut., II, 74 passim.
22 cf. QQ. de Ver. X, 2c.
23 Q. de Anima, a 5 ad 2; S.T. I, 79, 4.
24 ‘in the truth that brings all minds to peace’. (Par. xxviii, 108.)