Mental health problems affect one in ten men during their partner's pregnancy.Reference Cameron, Sedov and Tomfohr-Madsen 1 These problems tend to persist into the postpartum periodReference Paulson, Bazemore, Goodman and Leiferman 2 , Reference Ramchandani, Stein, O'Connor, Heron, Murray and Evans 3 and predict increasing severity of maternal depression symptoms from pregnancy to postpartum;Reference Paulson, Bazemore, Goodman and Leiferman 2 in turn, paternal postpartum depression has been associated with adverse child mental health outcomes both via and independently of maternal depression.Reference Ramchandani, Stein, O'Connor, Heron, Murray and Evans 3 , Reference Gutierrez-Galve, Stein, Hanington, Heron and Ramchandani 4 Early identification of men at risk of antenatal mental health problems could inform the development of targeted intervention strategies within existing preconception and perinatal healthcare systems.Reference Frey, Navarro, Kotelchuck and Lu 5 , Reference Garfield 6 However, little is known about paternal risk factors, as prospective studies including data prior to pregnancy are scarce. Using data from a 20-year, two-generation study, we aimed to examine the extent to which common mental disorders in the decades prior to conception predicted antenatal paternal mental health problems.
Method
Participants
The Victorian Intergenerational Health Cohort Study (VIHCS) is a prospective study of preconception predictors of child health. It arose from a cohort study commencing in 1992 in Victoria, Australia (the Victorian Adolescent Health Cohort Study; VAHCS).Reference Patton, Coffey, Romaniuk, Mackinnon, Carlin and Degenhardt 7 A close-to-representative sample of 1943 mid-secondary school students (943 male) was selected using a two-stage sampling procedure. Participants were assessed 6-monthly during adolescence (waves 1–6: mean age 14.9–17.4 years) and three times in young adulthood (waves 7–9: 20.7, 24.1 and 29.1 years).
Between 2006 and 2013, when participants were aged 29–35 years (encompassing median paternal age for Australian births 8 ), the 1645 study members (773 male) still active in VAHCS were screened 6-monthly for participation in VIHCS. Study members were invited to complete telephone interviews in trimester three (VIHCS wave 1), 2 months' postpartum (VIHCS wave 2) and 12 months' postpartum (VIHCS wave 3) for every child born during screening. Here, we used data from male VAHCS participants who participated in VIHCS. Participants' parents or guardians provided informed written consent at VAHCS recruitment, and participants provided informed verbal consent at subsequent waves. Data collection protocols were approved by the human research ethics committee at the Royal Children's Hospital, Melbourne, Australia.
Measures
Exposure
Preconception common mental disorder was measured at VAHCS waves 1–7 using the Revised Clinical Interview Schedule (CIS-R), with caseness defined as score ≥12 to identify mixed depression–anxiety symptoms at a level lower than major depressive or anxiety disorder, but which a general practitioner would view as clinically significant.Reference Lewis, Pelosi, Araya and Dunn 9 At VAHCS waves 8–9, we used the 12-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12) to identify symptoms of psychological distress.Reference Goldberg and Williams 10 GHQ-12 caseness was defined as standard score ≥3,Reference Goldberg, Gater, Sartorius, Ustun, Piccinelli and Gureje 11 previously found to indicate a CIS-R threshold of ≥12.Reference Lewis, Pelosi, Araya and Dunn 9 Continuity of mental disorder was defined as none, adolescent-only, young adult-only, or adolescent and young adult disorder.
Covariates
Analyses were adjusted for health risk behaviours (≥20 drinks on one day in the past week, daily smoking, and weekly cannabis use at one or more adolescent waves), Australian-born/not Australian-born, and participants' parents' education and separation/divorce status.
Outcome
Antenatal mental health was assessed at VIHCS wave 1, in trimester three of each subsequent pregnancy, using the GHQ-12.Reference Lewis, Pelosi, Araya and Dunn 9 – Reference Goldberg, Gater, Sartorius, Ustun, Piccinelli and Gureje 11
Analysis
We estimated the prevalence and relative risks of paternal antenatal mental health problems stratified by continuity of preconception common mental disorder, using generalised estimating equations owing to family clustering. We included participants assessed in all phases: adolescence, young adulthood, and antenatal. Missing preconception data were addressed using multiple imputation. Most variables had fewer than 10% values missing; only four had 10–20% (common mental disorder, risky drinking, cannabis use and smoking at wave 6). Estimates were obtained by pooling results across 50 imputed data-sets using Rubin's rules.Reference Rubin 12 We used Stata 14.2. 13
Results
Supplementary Appendix A, available at https://doi.org/10/1192/bjo.2017.10, shows the flow of men through VAHCS and VIHCS. Of 332 male VAHCS participants who reported 545 pregnancies during VIHCS recruitment, 214 (65%) men participated in VIHCS with 295 (55%) pregnancies. VIHCS participants were less likely to use cannabis weekly in adolescence (P = 0.007) or be born outside Australia (P < 0.001), and more likely to have at least one parent who completed high school (P = 0.001), than those who did not participate, but did not differ on other preconception analysis variables (supplementary Appendix B).
Antenatal mental health problems were reported in 23 (10.7%, 95% CI 6.6–14.9) men and 31 (10.5%, 95% CI 7.0–14.0) pregnancies. In total, 85 (39.7%) men reported preconception common mental disorder at least once: 35 (16.4%) adolescent only; 25 (11.6%) young adult only; and 25 (11.6%) both adolescent and young adult (supplementary Appendix C).
In over two-thirds of pregnancies where men reported antenatal mental health problems, there was a history of preconception common mental disorder, compared with around one-third of those without antenatal problems (68.1% (95% CI 49.8–86.3) v. 34.3% (95% CI 28.3–40.1)). Those with preconception common mental disorder in both adolescence and young adulthood had the greatest risk of antenatal mental health problems (adjusted RR (aRR) 4.60, 95% CI 1.71–12.35), and those with common mental disorder in young adulthood only were also at increased risk (aRR 3.75, 95% CI 1.37–10.22) (Table 1).
Estimates were obtained from imputed data. Frequency estimates were calculated using imputed percentage estimates and total number of pregnancies. Preconception common mental disorder at waves 1–7 defined as Revised Clinical Interview Schedule score ≥12 and at waves 8–9 defined as General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) score ≥3. Antenatal mental health problems defined as GHQ score ≥3. RR, risk ratio.
a. Model adjusted for health risk behaviours (≥20 drinks on one day in the path week, daily smoking, and weekly cannabis use) at one or more adolescent waves, country of birth, and participants' parents' education and separation/divorce status.
Men with a history of persistent common mental disorder from adolescence to young adulthood did not go on to experience mental health problems in 23 (72.1%, 95% CI 55.4–88.9) pregnancies. For ten (31.9%, 95% CI 14.4–49.4) of the 31 pregnancies during which men reported antenatal mental health problems, there was no history of preconception common mental disorder.
Discussion
Overall, one in ten men reported antenatal mental health problems, similar to a recent meta-analytic estimate of third-trimester prevalence of 9%.Reference Cameron, Sedov and Tomfohr-Madsen 1 In over two-thirds of these pregnancies, there was a history of common mental disorder prior to conception. Our findings suggest that mental health problems in the transition to parenthood are often a continuation or recurrence of persistent or recent preconception problems.
Nearly three-quarters of men with preconception common mental disorders did not experience antenatal mental health problems. This may reflect the natural resolution of mental health problems for some men during young adulthood.Reference Patton, Coffey, Romaniuk, Mackinnon, Carlin and Degenhardt 7 Previous research has found that, overall, men's mental health does not worsen from preconception to expectant fatherhood.Reference Leach, Mackinnon, Poyser and Fairweather-Schmidt 14 , Reference Leach, Olesen, Butterworth and Poyser 15 Our findings are consistent in that overall prevalence was similar across the preconception and antenatal windows (supplementary Appendix C), but the lack of prior history in one-third of antenatal cases suggests that risks are heightened for some. Other factors may increase or mitigate risk, including physical health and perceived stress,Reference Underwood, Waldie, Peterson, D'Souza, Verbiest and McDaid 16 partner's mental health,Reference Cameron, Sedov and Tomfohr-Madsen 1 partner conflict, and social support.Reference Wee, Skouteris, Pier, Richardson and Milgrom 17
Strengths of this study include the prospective two-generational design, and repeated assessment of common mental disorder across adolescence and young adulthood. Our sample size was small, and results may not be generalisable to trimesters one and two, or to younger and older fathers. Attrition and non-response may have affected results. We used multiple imputation to address biases due to missing VAHCS data. This would not have addressed differential recruitment to VIHCS; nonetheless, prevalence of adolescent common mental disorder did not differ between VIHCS participants and non-participants. We did not use diagnostic measures and our estimates of association are likely to be conservative, as greater continuity might be expected for more severe disorders.
A number of countries have moved to implement or improve maternal mental health screening antenatally, but fathers have yet to be systematically included.Reference Rominov, Pilkington, Giallo and Whelan 18 Given that risk for antenatal mental health problems is high for men with a persistent or proximal preconception history, an opportunity exists during pregnancy and the perinatal period to identify and support fathers with pre-existing vulnerability. Particularly in light of men's disinclination to proactively seek help for mental health problems,Reference Isacco, Hofscher and Molloy 19 early intervention to improve adolescent mental health may also yield benefits for their own continuing mental health and that of future generations.Reference Garfield 6
Funding
This work was supported by the National Health and Medical Research Council; Australian Rotary Health; Colonial Foundation; Perpetual Trustees; Financial Markets Foundation for Children (Australia); Royal Children's Hospital Foundation; Murdoch Children's Research Institute; Australian Postgraduate Award to E.S.; and the Australian Research Council. Research at the Murdoch Children's Research Institute is supported by the Victorian Government's Operational Infrastructure Program.
Acknowledgements
We thank the families who have participated in the Victorian Adolescent Health Cohort Study and the Victorian Intergenerational Health Cohort Study, and the study research team involved in the collection and management of Victorian Intergenerational Health Cohort Study data.
Supplementary material
Supplementary material is available online at https://doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2017.10.
eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.