Hostname: page-component-5cf477f64f-h6p2m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-03-31T09:16:20.971Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Big Brother’ at Brothers Home: Exclusion and Exploitation of Social Outcasts in South Korea

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 March 2025

Kim Jae-hyung ,
Kwak Kwi-byung ,
Kim Il-hwan ,
Park Hae-nam ,
So Jun-chol ,
Lee Sang-jic ,
Choi Jong-sook  and
Choo Ji-hyun
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article exposes human rights violations committed at Brothers Home in Busan, South Korea in the 1970s and 1980s, identifying their structural causes and discussing Korean society's efforts to address them. From 1975 to 1987, Brothers Home was the largest group residential facility for the homeless, the ill, the disabled, and the poor—a program that was even commended by the Korean government. However, over the years, various human rights abuses led to the death of 657 residents. While these violations remained hidden from public view for almost 25 years, survivors and supporters waged a long battle to bring them to light. Recently, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission investigated and confirmed the human rights violations as state violence. In this essay, the authors assess the significance this case holds for Korean society.

Keywords

Brothers HomeHuman Rights ViolationsTruth and Reconciliation Commission of the Republic of KoreaState ViolenceHomelessness
Type
Research Article
Information
Asia-Pacific Journal , Volume 21 , Issue 6 , June 2023 , e1
Copyright
Copyright © The Authors 2023

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Beminor, 비마이너. 2017. “진정한 자유 찾아 부산 에서 청와대까지” [From Busan to the Blue House in search of true freedom] (September 6)Google Scholar
Brothers Home Foundation 형제복지지원재단. 2010a. 형제복지원 운영자료집 제6권 [Operation Documents of Brothers Home vol. 6], 형제복지지 원재단 [Brothers Home Foundation].Google Scholar
Brothers Home Foundation 형제복지지원재단. 2010b. 형제복지원 운영자료집 제7권 [Operation Documents of Brothers Home vol. 7], 형제복지지 원재단 [Brothers Home Foundation].Google Scholar
Brothers Home Research Group in Department of Sociology SNU 서울대 사회학과 형제복지원연 구 팀. 2021. 절멸과 갱생 사이 [Between Extermination and Rehabilitation: A Sociology of Brothers Home]. 서울대학교출판문화원 [SNU Press].Google Scholar
Ji-Hyun, Choo. 추지현. 2018. “박정희 정권의 ‘사회 악’ 호명— 형사사법의 효율성 확보 전략을 중심으 로” [Ideological Interpellation of ‘Folk Devil’ in the Park Chung-hee Regime: Strategy for Efficiency of Criminal Justice]. 사회와 역 사 [Society and Hisotry] 117: 201–235.Google Scholar
Sook, Choi Jong. 최종숙. 2018. “민주화 이후 과거 청산과 소수자 인권운동 : 형제복지원사건을 중심 으로” [Transitional Justice and Minority Human Rights Movement after Democratization: Focusing on the Brothers Home Incident], 민주 화운동기념사업회 보고서 [Korea Democracy Foundation Research Report].Google Scholar
Sook, Choi Jong. 최종숙. 2019. “형제복지원사건 진상규명운동의 등장: 당사자운동주체 형성에서 지 식 인 활 동 가 의 역 할 을 중 심 으 로” [The Appearance of the Fact-Finding Movement of the Brother Asylum: Focused on the role of intellectual activists for making the movement subject], 담론 201 [Damron201] 22 (1): 81–119.Google Scholar
Ha, KeumChul. 하금철. 2022. “국가의 형제복지원 문제 해결 노력의 의의와 한계” [The Significance and Limitations of National Efforts to address the Brothers Home Incident]. 1970-80 년대 한국의 사회적 배제와 인권문제: 집단수용시설의 사회 사 [Social Exclusion and Human Rights Problems during 1970-80's in Korea: Social History of Group Residential Facilities], Symposium, held in Academy of Korean Studies, Seongnam, 27 October.Google Scholar
Joo, Yungeong, et al. 주윤정 외. 2017, 1980 년대 부랑인·장애인 관리체계와 형제복지원 사건 관련 자 II [The Regulation System on the vagrancy and the disabled in 1980's and the person concered on Brothers Home case (Interview transcript]. 국사편찬위원회 [National Institute of Korean History].Google Scholar
Kwak, Kwi Byung. 곽귀병. 2019. “총체적 기관 안 에서 나타나는 폭력의 미시사회학: 부산 형제복지 원 사례를 중심으로” [Micro-sociology of violence in the total institution: Focusing on the case of Hyeongje-welfare Institution]. 민주주의 와 인권 [Democracy and Human Rights] 19 (2): 191–233.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Kwanwook. 김관욱. 2022. “부랑인 집단시설 의 의료화와 약물화” [Medicalization and Pharmaceuticalization in Vagrants Facilities]. 1970-80 년대 한국의 사회적 배제와 인권문제: 집 단수용시설의 사회사 [Social Exclusion and Human Rights Problems during 1970-80's in Korea: Social History of Group Residential Facilities], Symposium, held in Academy of Korean Studies, Seongnam, 27 October.Google Scholar
Kim, Ilhwan. 김일환. 2019. “복지는 어떻게 ‘사업’ 이 되었는가:한국 사회복지법인의 역사로 본 형제 복지원” [How did social welfare become ‘business'?: ‘Hyeongje-welfare Institution’ and trajectory of social welfare foundation in Korea], 민주주의와 인권 [Journal of Democracy and Human Rights] 19 (1): 39–87.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Jaehyung. 김재형. 2017. “망각된 인권, 형제 복지원” [Forgotten human rights issues in Brothers Home], 창비주간논평 [Changbi Weekly Commentary]. (2017.9.6)Google Scholar
Kim, Jaehyung. 김재형. 2018. “형제복지원 특별법 을 제정하라” [The Case for Special Law for the Brothers Home Incident]. 창비주간논평 [Changbi Weekly Commentary] (October 17)Google Scholar
Kim Jae-hyung, Kim Kwan-wook, Il-hwan, Kim, Jun-min, Yeo, Myo-rang, Lee, Chu-Ji-hyeon, , Ji-seong, Hwang 김재형, 김관욱, 김일환, 여준민, 이묘랑, 추지현, 황지성. 2021. 집단시설 인권침해 실태조사 연구용역사업: 수도권(서울∙경기∙인천) 강원권: 최종보고서 [Final Reports of Research Project on Human Rights Violations in the Group Residental Facilities in Seoul/Gyeonggi/Incheon Area], 진실∙화해를위한 과거사정리위원회 [The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Korea].Google Scholar
Shinmin-Party 신민당. 1987. 부산 형제복지원 사 건 신민당 진상조사 보고서 [Shinmin-Party Investigation Report on the Busan Brothers Home Incident]. 신민당 [Shinmin-Party].Google Scholar
So, Junchol. 소준철. 2020. “정부의 ‘자활정책’과 형제복지원 내 사업의 변화” [State-Sponsored “Self-Sufficiency Policy” and Hyeongje-Welfare Institutional Change], 사회와 역사 [Society and History], 125: 243–279.Google Scholar
Truth and Reconciliation Commission 진실∙화해 를위한과거사정리위원회. 2023. 2022 년 하반기 조 사보고서: 제5권 결정서 모음 [Investigation Report for the second half of the Year 2022]. 진 실∙화해를위한과거사정리위원회 [Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Korea].Google Scholar