No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
The Acquittal of Hakamada Iwao and Criminal Justice Reform in Japan
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 14 March 2025
Abstract
Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.
In September 2024, after 56 years under a sentence of death, Hakamada Iwao was acquitted in a retrial in Japan. This article summarizes what went wrong in his wrongful conviction case and what should be learned from it. The Shizuoka District Court's retrial decision concluded that police and prosecutors conspired to frame Hakamada with evidence they had fabricated, but there is more to the case than that. This tragedy occurred because of mistakes and misconduct that were exacerbated by underlying weaknesses in Japan's criminal process. To prevent a recurrence, many things need to change in Japanese criminal justice. The conclusion identifies five priorities for reform.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Authors 2024
References
Asahi Shimbun. 2023. “Seiiki: Torishirabe no Bengoshi Tachiai” (seven part series, November 15-21).Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun. 2024a. “‘Omae wa Hannin Da’: Semetateru Keiji, Jinbutsuzo kara Utagawareta Hakamada Iwao san” (September 24, part 1 of the 14-part series, “Naze Shikeishu ni Sareta no ka: Hakamada san Jiken 58nen”Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun. 2024b. “Saishin no Ana: Moto Saibankan no Chumon” (September 24), p. 3.Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun. 2024c. “Saishin Keiken no Saibankan ‘Seido Fujubun’” (September 24), p. 1.Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun. 2024d. “Hakamada san Muzai, Kensatsu ga Koso Dannen Happyo: ‘Netsuzo ni wa Fuman’ - Irei no Socho Danwa” (October 8).Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun. 2024e. “Kensatsu o Shinyou Dekimasu ka” (November 2, in the series “be between dokusha to tsukuru”).Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun/Asia & Japan Watch. 2024a. “The Sister Who Never Stopped Believing in His Innocence” (September 27).Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun/Asia & Japan Watch. 2024b. “Revising Judicial System Starts with an Apology to Hakamada” (October 9).Google Scholar
Asahi Shimbun/Asia & Japan Watch. 2024c. “Hakamada Gets Apology, But Prosecutors Keep Vexing His Team” (November 27).Google Scholar
Awano Masao. 2024. Hakamada Iwao to Sekai Ichi no Ane: Enzai Hakamada Jiken o Meguru Hitobito no Negai. Kadensha.Google Scholar
Chunichi Shimbun. 2024. “Saishin ni Michi Hiraku Ho Kaisei Koso” (September 27), p. 5.Google Scholar
Davis, John H. 2014. “Courting Justice, Contesting ‘Bureaucratic Informality’: The Sayama Case and the Evolution of Buraku Liberation Politics.” In Steinhoff, Patricia G., editor, Going to Court to Change Japan: Social Movements and the Law in Contemporary Japan (University of Michigan Press), pp. 73–100.Google Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 1991. “Confessions and the Right to Silence in Japan.” Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law. Vol. 21, pp. 415–488.Google Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 1992a. “The Benevolent Paternalism of Japanese Criminal Justice.” California Law Review. Vol. 80, No. 2, pp. 317–390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 1992b. “From Japan's Death Row to Freedom.” Pacific Rim Law & Policy Journal. Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 11–103.Google Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 1993. “‘The Door That Never Opens’? Capital Punishment and Post-Conviction Review of Death Sentences in the United States and Japan.” Brooklyn Journal of International Law. Vol. 19, No. 2, pp. 367–521.Google Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 2014. “Citizen Participation: Appraising the Saiban'in System.” Michigan State International Law Review. Vol. 22, No. 3, pp. 755–775.Google Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 2021. “‘Benevolent Paternalism’ Revisited.” US-Asia Law Institute East-West Studies. Vol. 1, No. 5, pp. 1–11, at https://usali.org/comparative-views-of-japanese-criminal-justice/benevolent-paternalism-revisited.Google Scholar
Shinichiro, Fukuzaki. 2024. “Shoko no Netsuzo-Inpei.” In Hiroaki, Murayama and Hiroyuki, Kuzono, editors, Saishin Seidotte Nanda? Hakamada Jiken kara Manabu (Iwanami), pp. 72–85.Google Scholar
Sumio, Hamada. 2020. Hakamada Jiken no Nazo: Torishirabe Rokuon Teepu ga Kataru Jijitsu. Iwanami.Google Scholar
Hirano, Ryuichi. 1989. “Diagnosis of the Current Code of Criminal Procedure” (translated by Daniel H. Foote). Law in Japan. Vol. 2, pp. 129–142.Google Scholar
Keiko, Horikawa. 2024. “Shikei Seido no Dodai Yurugasu.” Nihon Keizai Shimbun, September 27, p. 39.Google Scholar
Hoyle, Carolyn, and Sato, Mai. 2019. Reasons to Doubt: Wrongful Convictions and the Criminal Cases Review Commission. Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Human Rights Watch. 2023. “Japan's ‘Hostage Justice’ System: Denial of Bail, Coerced Confessions, and Lack of Access to Lawyers” (May 25), pp. 1–105. https://www.hrw.org/report/2023/05/25/japans-hostage-justice-system/denial-bail-coerced-confessions-and-lack-access.Google Scholar
Makoto, Ibusuki, and Johnson, David T.. Forthcoming. “Judges and Wrongful Convictions in Japan: A Study of Judicial Culture.” Law and Culture in Japan: Institutions, Justice, and Media, edited by Deflem, Mathieu, Takahashi, Hiroshi, Vanoverbeke, Dimitri, and Karlin, Jason G.. Leeds, UK: Emerald Publishing.Google Scholar
Rinshiki, Ishida. 2024. “Shoko Kaiji.” In Hiroaki, Murayama and Hiroyuki, Kuzono, editors, Saishin Seido-tte Nan Da? Hakamada Jiken kara Manabu (Iwanami), pp. 62–71.Google Scholar
Tetsuo, Ito. 2024. “Koso no Kanosei: Muzukashii Handan.” Asahi Shimbun, September 27, p. 31.Google Scholar
Japanese Ministry of Justice. 2024. “Public Prosecutors Office.” https://www.moj.go.jp/ENGLISH/PPO/ppo-01.htmlGoogle Scholar
Japan Times. 2024. “Many Acquitted Murder Suspects Initially Found Guilty for Confessions” (October 13).Google Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2002. The Japanese Way of Justice: Prosecuting Crime in Japan. Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2010. “Capital Punishment without Capital Trials in Japan's Lay Judge System.” Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus, Vol. 8, Issue 49, No. 1 (December 6), pp. 1–40. https://apjjf.org/david-t-johnson/3461/articleGoogle Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2015. “Hakamada Iwao and the Problem of Wrongful Convictions in Japan.” Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus, Vol. 13, Issue 6, No. 2 (February 9). https://apjjf.org/2015/13/6/david-t-johnson/4272Google Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2020. The Culture of Capital Punishment in Japan. Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2022. Japan 's Prosecution Review Commission: On the Democratic Oversight of Decisions Not to Charge. Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2024. “Enzai wa, Tada Hitotsu no Ayamari no Kekka de wa Nai: Hakamada Jiken Saishin Muzai: Yottsu no Kyokun” (translated by Yuki, Akimoto). Sekai, November 2024. https://websekai.iwanami.co.jp/posts/8338?prevGoogle Scholar
Johnson, David T., and Vanoverbeke, Dimitri. 2020. “The Limits of Change in Japanese Criminal Justice.” Journal of Japanese Law. Vol. 25, No. 49, pp. 109–165.Google Scholar
Kage, Rieko. 2017. Who Judges? Designing Jury Systems in Japan, East Asia, and Europe. Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kilgannon, Corey. 2022. “They Were Unjustly Imprisoned. Now, They're Profit Centers.” New York Times, November 27.Google Scholar
Akira, Kitani. 2024. “Saishin Tetsuzuki Fubi Minaoshi o.” Nihon Keizai Shimbun, September 27, p. 39.Google Scholar
Hiroyuki, Kuzono. 2024. “Saishin Seido to wa Nani ka.” In Hiroaki, Murayama and Hiroyuki, Kuzono, editors, Saishin Seido-tte Nan Da? Hakamada Jiken kara Manabu (Iwanami), pp. 28–49.Google Scholar
Kyodo News. 2024. “Japan Court Nixes Request for Retrial of 1992 Schoolgirl Murder Case” (June 5).Google Scholar
Mainichi, The. 2024a. “Japan Prosecution Reform an Urgent Task Following Prosecutor's Indictment (August 17).Google Scholar
Mainichi, The. 2024b. “Editorial: Japanese Law Enforcers Gravely Responsible for Ruining Acquitted Man's Life” (September 27).Google Scholar
Mainichi, The. 2024c. “Japanese Man's Acquittal of 1966 Quadruple Murders Finalized” (October 9).Google Scholar
Mainichi, The. 2024d. “Japan Prosecutor Apologizes to Ex-Death Row Inmate Acquitted Over 1966 Murders” (November 27).Google Scholar
Mujitsu no Shikeishu - Moto Puro Bokusa Hakamada Iwao o Sukuu Kai, editor. 1992. Shuyo, Itsu made Desu ka. Shinkyo Shuppansha.Google Scholar
National Registry of Exonerations. 2024. https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/Pages/about.aspx.Google Scholar
NHK video. 2024 (September 29). https://www3.nhk.or.jp/lnews/shizuoka/20240929/3030025592.html.Google Scholar
Shimbun, Nihon Keizai. 2024b. “Keiji Shiho no Arikata Tou Hakamada san Saishin Muzai” (September 27), p. 2.Google Scholar
Shimbun, Nihon Keizai. 2024c. “Ososugita Muzai: Hakamada san Saishin Hanketsu: Zusan Sosa Saibansho mo Tsuinin - Ginen Daita Tojisha mo” (September 29), p. 27.Google Scholar
Yoshiyuki, Nishi. 2023. Enzaigaku: Enzai ni Manabu Genin to Saihatsu Boshi. Nihon Hyoronsha.Google Scholar
Yoshiyuki, Nishi. 2024. “‘Netsuzo’ Nintei Saiki teki Hanji.” Shizuoka Shimbun (September 27), p. 28.Google Scholar
Hideyo, Ogawa. 2024a. “Defense lawyers’ closing argument” (saishu benron yomiage genko). Shizuoka District Court (May 22), pp. 67–72.Google Scholar
Hideyo, Ogawa. 2024b. “Hakamada Saishin Muzai kara Shikei Haishi e.” Forum 90 Newsletter, Minato Godo Horitsu Jimusho (Tokyo), Vol. 193 (October 30), pp. 1–8.Google Scholar
Seiki, Ogata. 2023. Hakamada Jiken o Sabaita Otoko: Muzai o Kakushin Shinagara Shikei Hanketsubun o Kaita moto Erito Saibankan Kumamoto Norimichi no Tenraku. Asahi Shimbunsha.Google Scholar
Putnam, Robert. 1993. Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
RAIS [Right Against Interrogation Society] (Torishirabe Kyohiken o Jitsugen Suru Kai). 2024. https://rais2024.jp/.Google Scholar
Kana, Sasakura, and Johnson, David T.. 2020. “Kensatsukan to Gohan: ‘Hitei no Bunka’ kara no Dakkyaku wa Kano ka: Amerika no Saikin no Doko kara Kangaeru.” Kikan Keiji Bengo, No. 103, pp. 50–57.Google Scholar
Sato, Mai. 2014. The Death Penalty in Japan: Will the Public Tolerate Abolition? Springer VS.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SBSnews 6 video. 2024. “Honto wa Muzai Da to Omotte Ita: Mujitsu o Shinjita Futari no Saibankan” (August 26). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSoyWfbzohw.Google Scholar
Yuta, Shimasaki, and Kaori, Yamada. 2024. “Can Japan Learn from Taiwan Over Acquittal of Death Row Inmate?” Nikkei Asia (September 27).Google Scholar
Shizuoka District Court (Chief Judge Kunii Koshi), decision of September 26, 2024 (Hakamada Iwao saishin muzai hanketsu), pp. 1–84.Google Scholar
Shizuoka District Court (Chief Judge Murayama Hiroaki), decision of March 27, 2014 (Hakamada Iwao saishin seikyu jiken: kettei).Google Scholar
Yasuyuki, Takai. 2024. “Jokyushin no Handan Hitsuyo.” Yomiuri Shimbun (September 27), p. 30.Google Scholar
Turow, Scott. 2003. Ultimate Punishment: A Lawyer's Reflections on Dealing with the Death Penalty. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.Google Scholar
Union of Catholic Asian News. 2017. “The Japanese Judge and the Boxer He Condemned to Death” (May 1).Google Scholar
Osaburo, Ueji. 2024. “Kensatsukan Kokoku.” In Hiroaki, Murayama and Hiroyuki, Kuzono, editors, Saishin Seidotte Nanda? Hakamada Jiken kara Manabu (Iwanami), pp. 125–135.Google Scholar
Vanoverbeke, Dimitri. 2024. “From Confession to Conviction: Why Japan's Criminal Justice System Resists Change.” Frontiers of Socio-Legal Studies (Oxford University), October 30, at https://frontiers.csls.ox.ac.uk/from-confession-to-conviction/#continue.Google Scholar
Yamaguchi, Mari. 2024. “A Japanese Police Chief Apologizes to a Man Acquitted After 50 Years on Death Row.” Associated Press (October 21).Google Scholar
Shimbun, Yomiuri. 2024. “Saishinho Kaisei Tsuyomaru Koe: Shoko Kaiji no Giron Nanko” (September 30), p. 28.Google Scholar
You have
Access