Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-vdxz6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T10:03:02.210Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A house built on rock? A reply to nevett, sharples and vellinga

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 January 2009

Fokke Gerritsen
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Nevett, Sharples and Vellinga have commented on my paper in a heartening and inspiring way, and I would like to thank them for their comments of agreement as well as for the points of criticism that they raise. In my reply I will attempt to engage in discussion by addressing a few of their issues. Two points of my paper that appear to have created some confusion, notably in Vellinga's comment, may be dealt with first of all. With regard to the timing of the construction of a house, I did not intend to suggest – as hopefully the diagram of figure 2 makes clear – that new houses were always built subsequent to the abandonment of an old one. In fact, in the case of wandering farmsteads I would envisage this as the exception rather than the rule. This may seem a minor point, but it has some relevance to the topic of variability that I will address below. The other point of confusion concerns the ulterior aims of the paper and the biographical approach, which Vellinga takes as explaining the long-term transformation of the settlement patterns. I would not want to claim that the notion of a cultural biography in itself has enough explanatory force in this respect, and in the introduction I described it as a way of taking a first step along the road towards a more balanced understanding. The aims of the paper were precisely that, but Vellinga certainly makes a valid point in raising the issue of explaining long-term changes, and it deserves further consideration.

Type
Discussion
Information
Archaeological Dialogues , Volume 6 , Issue 2 , December 1999 , pp. 107 - 114
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bailey, D.W., 1990: The living house: signifying continuity, in Samson, R. (ed.), The social archaeology of houses, Edinburgh, 19–48.Google Scholar
Bakels, C.C., 1978: Four linearbandkeramik settlements and their environment: a paleoecological study of Sittard, Stein, Elsloo and Hienheim, Leiden.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
van Beek, W.E.A., 1991: Individu en gemeenschap. Trends in de ontwikkeling van het Kapsikihuis, in Nas, P.J.M., and Prins, W.J.M. (eds), Huis, cultuur, en ontwikkeling, Leiden, 77–95.Google Scholar
Bloch, M., 1995: The resurrection of the house amongst the Zafimaniry of Madagascar, in Carsten, J. and Hugh-Jones, S. (eds), 69–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bodegraven, N. van, 1991: Nederzettingssporen uit de late bronstijd en de vroege ijzertijd op de Everse Akkers in St. Oedenrode, in Fokkens, H. and Roymans, N. (eds), 129–140.Google Scholar
van den Broeke, P.W., 1987: De dateringsmiddelen voor de ijzertijd van Zuid-Nederland, in van der Sanden, W.A.B. and van den Broeke, P.W. (eds), Getekend zand. Tien jaar archeologisch onderzoek in Zuid Nederland, Waalre, 23–43.Google Scholar
van den Broeke, P.W., 1991: Nederzetting, graf en samenleving in de metaaltijden, in Bloemers, J.H.F. and van Dorp, T. (eds), Pre- en protohistorie van de Lage Landen, Houten, 251–264.Google Scholar
van den Broeke, P.W., 1999: Van mesolithicum tot middeleeuwen: het archeologische potentieel van het Betuwse deel van Nijmegen (Nl.), Lunula. Archaeologia protohistorica 7, 26–31.Google Scholar
Brongers, J.A., 1976: Air photography and celtic field research in the Netherlands, Amersfoort.Google Scholar
Brück, J., 1999: What's in a settlement? Domestic practice and residential mobility in Early Bronze Age southern England, in Brück, J. and Goodman, M. (eds), Making places in the prehistoric world. Themes in settlement archaeology, London, 52–75.Google Scholar
Carrier, J.G., 1998: Property and social relations in Melanesian anthropology, in Hann, C.M. (ed.), Property relations. Renewing the anthropological tradition, Cambridge, 85–103.Google Scholar
Carsten, J., 1997: The heat of the hearth. The process of kinship in a Malay fishing community, Oxford.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carsten, J., and Hugh-Jones, S., 1995: Introduction: about the house – Lévi-Strauss and beyond, in Carsten, J. and Hugh-Jones, S. (eds), 1–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carsten, J. and Hugh-Jones, S. (eds), 1995: About the house. Lévi-Strauss and beyond, Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Çevik, A., 1995: Social meanings of household spaces, Archaeological dialogues 2, 39–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coppet, D. de, 1985: …Land owns people, in Barnes, R.H., Coppet, D. de, and Parkin, R.J. (eds), Contexts and levels. Anthropological essays on hierarchy, Oxford, 78–90.Google Scholar
Ellen, R., 1986: Microcosm, macrocosm and the Nuaulu house: concerning the reductionist fallacy as applied to metaphorical levels, Bijdragen tot de taal-, land- en volkenkunde 142, 1–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ellison, A., 1978: The Bronze Age, in Drewett, PL. (ed.), The archaeology of Sussex to 1500 AD, London, 30–37.Google Scholar
Fokkens, H., 1996: The Maaskant project. Continuity and change of a regional research project, Archaeological dialogues 3, 196–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fokkens, H., and Roymans, N. (eds), 1991: Nederzettingen uit de bronstijd en de vroege ijzertijd in de Lage Landen, Amersfoort.Google Scholar
Fontijn, D., 1996: Socializing landscape. Second thoughts about the cultural biography of urnfields, Archaeological dialogues 3, 77–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, T., 1995: Having your house and eating it: houses and siblings in Ara, South Sulawesi, in Carsten, J. and Hugh-Jones, S. (eds), 129–148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gerritsen, F.A., in prep.: Late Bronze Age and Iron Age societies in the Meuse-Demer-Scheldt region, Amsterdam (Ph.D. thesis, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam).Google Scholar
Giffen, A.E. van, 1963: Het bouwoffer uit de oudste hoeve te Ezinge (Gr.), Helinium 3, 246–253.Google Scholar
Gijn, A. van, 1987: Site N. Assendelver Polders, in Brandt, R.W., Groenman-van Waateringe, W., and van der Leeuw, S.E. (eds), Assendelver Polder papers 1, Amsterdam, 99–112.Google Scholar
Groenewoudt, B.J., and Verlinde, A.D., 1989: Ein Haustypus der NGK und eine Vorratsgrube aus der frühen Eisenzeit in Colmschate, gem. Deventer, Berichten van de Rijskdienst voor het Oudheidkundig Bodemonderzoek 29, 269–295.Google Scholar
Guilbert, G. 1981: Double-ring roundhouses, probable and possible, in prehistoric Britain, Proceeding of the Prehistoric Society 47, 299–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harsema, O.H., 1980: Drents boerenleven van de bronstijd tot de middeleeuwen, Assen.Google Scholar
Hiddink, H.A., 1999: Germaanse samenlevingen tussen Rijn en Weser, 1ste eeuw voor – 4de eeuw na Chr, Amsterdam (Ph.D. thesis, University of Amsterdam).Google Scholar
Hill, J.D., 1995: Ritual and rubbish in the Iron Age of Wessex. A study on the formation of a specific archaeological record, Oxford.Google Scholar
Hodder, I., 1990: The domestication of Europe. Structure and contingency in Neolithic societies, Oxford.Google Scholar
Hulst, R.S., 1973 [1975]: A contribution to the study of Bronze Age and Iron Age house-plans: Zijderveld, Berichten van de Rijksdienst voor het Oudheidkundig Bodemonderzoek 23, 103–107.Google Scholar
Hvass, S., 1993: Settlement, in Hvass, S. and Storgaard, B. (eds), Digging into the past. 25 years of archaeology in Denmark, Copenhagen-Hojbjerg, 187–194.Google Scholar
Impe, L. van, 1998: La nécropole à tombelles de Wijshagen (commune de Meeuwen-Gruitrode, Limbourg): dernière demeure d'une famille aristocratique de La Tène I, Revue archéologie de Picardie 1/2, 9–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jansen, R., Ball, E., Fokkens, H., and Schiltmans, D., 1999: Oss-Horzak: een nederzettingsterrein uit de ijzertijd en Romeinse tijd (N1.), Lunula. Archaeologia protohistorica 7, 50–54.Google Scholar
Kopytoff, I., 1986: The cultural biography of things: commodization as a process, in Appadurai, A. (ed.), The social life of things, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Kortlang, F., 1999: The Iron Age urnfield and settlement of Someren – ‘Waterdael’, in Theuws, F. and Roymans, N. (eds), 133–198.Google Scholar
Kossack, G., 1997: Dörfer im nördlichen Germanien vornehmlich aus der römischen Kaiserzeit. Lage, Ortsplan, Betriebgefüge und Gemeinschaftsform, München.Google Scholar
Kossack, G, Behre, K.-E., and Schmid, P. (eds), 1984: Archäologische und naturwissenschaftliche Untersuchungen an ländlichen und frühstadtischen Siedlungen im deutschen Küstengebiet vom 5. Jahrhundert v. Chr. bis zum 11. Jahrhundert n. Chr., Band 1: Ländliche Siedlungen, Weinheim.Google Scholar
Küchler, S., 1987: Malangan. Art and memory in a Melanesian society, Man (n.s.) 22, 238–255.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Küchler, S., 1993: Landscape as memory. The mapping of process and its representation in a Melanesian society, in Bender, B. (ed.), Landscape. Politics and perspectives, Providence-Oxford, 85–106.Google Scholar
Lévi-Strauss, C., 1983: The way of the masks, London.Google Scholar
Lévi-Strauss, C., 1984: Paroles donneés, Paris.Google Scholar
Lévi-Strauss, C., 1987: Anthropology and myth: Lectures 1951–1982, Oxford.Google Scholar
Lévi-Strauss, C., 1991: Maison, in Bonte, P., and Izard, M. (eds), Dictionnaire de l'ethnologie et de l'anthropologie, Paris, 434–436.Google Scholar
London, H. van, 1994: Midden-Delfland 4. Woudse polder, vindplaatsen 1.17 en 1.23, Holland 26, 427–431.Google Scholar
Marshall, Y. and Gosden, C., (eds), 1999: The cultural biography of objects, London (World Archaeology 31.2).Google Scholar
Moore, H.L., 1986: Space, text and gender. An anthropological study of the Marakwet of Kenya, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Oliver, P. (ed.), 1997: Encyclopedia of vernacular architecture of the world: Vol., Cambridge.Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M., and Richards, C. (eds), 1994: Architecture and order. Approaches to social space, London.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., 1991: Late Urnfield societies in the Northwest European Plain and the expanding networks of Central European Hallstatt groups, in Roymans, N. and Theuws, F. (eds), 8–89.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., 1995: The cultural biography of urnfields and the long-term history of a mythical landscape, Archaeological dialogues 2, 2–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roymans, N., 1999: The Early Iron Age urnfield of Beegden, in Theuws, F. and Roymans, N. (eds), 63–76.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., and Fokkens, H., 1991: Een overzicht van veertig jaar nederzettingsonderzoek in de Lage Landen, in Fokkens, H. and Roymans, N. (eds), 1–20.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., and Gerritsen, F., in prep.: Landscape and settlement dynamics in the Meuse-Demer-Scheldt area. Culture and ecology in a longue-durée perspective (provisional title of article in preparation).Google Scholar
Roymans, N., and Hiddink, H., 1991: Nederzettingssporen uit de bronstijd en de vroege ijzertijd op de Kraanvensche Heide te Loon op Zand, in Fokkens, H. and Roymans, N. (eds), 111–128.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., and Kortlang, F., 1999: Urnfield symbolism, ancestors and the land in the Lower Rhine region, in Theuws, F. and Roymans, N. (eds), 33–62.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., and Theuws, F. (eds), 1991: Images of the Past. Studies on Ancient Societies in Northwestern Europe, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., and Theuws, F., 1999: Long-term perspectives on land and people in the Meuse-Demer-Scheldt region. An introduction, in Theuws, F. and Roymans, N. (eds), 1–32.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., and Tol, A. (eds), 1996: Opgravingen in Kampershoek en de Molenakker te Weert, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
Roymans, N., Tol, A. and Hiddink, H. (eds), 1999: Opgravingen in de Kampershoek en de Molenakker te Weert. Campagne 1996–1998, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
Russell, M. 1996: Problems of phasing: A reconsideration of the Black Patch middle Bronze Age ‘Nucleated Village’, Oxford journal of archaeology 15, 33–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Samson, R. (ed.), 1990: The social archaeology of houses, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
van der Sanden, W.A.B., 1986: Houtsnijwerk uit de late ijzertijd uit een waterput in Oss-Ussen, in Fokkens, H., Banga, P., and Bierma, M. (eds), Op zoek naar mens en materiële cultuur, Groningen, 73–83.Google Scholar
Schinkel, K., 1999: Unsettled settlement. Occupation remains from the Bronze Age and the Iron Age at Oss-Ussen. The 1976–1986 excavations, in Fokkens, H. (ed.), The Ussen project. The first decade of excavations at Oss, Leiden, 5–306.Google Scholar
Schmid, P., 1984: Siedlungsstrukturen, in Kossack, G., Behre, K.-E. and Schmid, P. (eds), 193–244.Google Scholar
Slofstra, J., 1991a: Changing settlement systems in the Meuse-Demer-Scheldt area during the Early Roman period, in Roymans, N. and Theuws, F. (eds), 131–199.Google Scholar
Slofstra, J., 1991b: Een nederzetting uit de vroege ijzertijd op de Heesmortel bij Riethoven, in Fokkens, H. and Roymans, N. (eds), 141–152.Google Scholar
Smith, K. 1977: The excavation of Winklebury Camp, Basingstoke, Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 43, 31–129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spek, T., 1993: Milieudynamiek en locatiekeuze op het Drents Plateau (3400 v.Chr – 1850 n. Chr.), in Elerie, J.N.H., Jager, S.W. and Spek, T., Landschapsgeschiedenis van De Strubben/Kniphorstbos. Archeologische en historisch-ecologische studies van een natuurgebied op de Hondsrug, Groningen, 169–235.Google Scholar
Therkorn, L.L., 1987: The structures, mechanics and some aspects of inhabitant behaviour, in Brandt, R.W., Groenman-van Waateringe, W. and van der Leeuw, S.E. (eds), Assendelver Polder papers 1, Amsterdam, 177–224.Google Scholar
Theuws, F., and Roymans, N. (eds), 1999: Land and ancestors. Cultural dynamics in the Urnfield period and the Middle Ages in the southern Netherlands, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
Theuws, F., Verhoeven, A., and van Regteren Altena, H.H., 1988: Medieval settlement at Dommelen, parts 1 and 2, Berichten van de Rijksdienst voor het Oudheidkundig Bodemonderzoek 38, 229–430.Google Scholar
Thomas, J., 1996: Time, culture and identity. An interpretive archaeology, London-New York.Google Scholar
Tol, A., 1999: De bewoningsgeschiedenis van Kampershoek, in Roymans, N., Tol, A. and Hiddink, H. (eds), Opgravingen in de Kampershoek en de Molenakker te Weert. Campagne 1996–1998, Amsterdam, 7–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trier, B., 1969: Das Haus im Nordwesten der Germania libera, Münster.Google Scholar
Tringham, R., 1995: Archaeological houses, households and the home, in Benjamin, D.N. (ed.), The home. Words, interpretations, meanings, and environments, Aldershot, 79–107.Google Scholar
Vanderhoeven, A., 1991: Botanisch onderzoek van de vroege ijzertijd-nederzetting op de Heesmortel bij Riethoven, in Fokkens, H. and Roymans, N. (eds), 153–162.Google Scholar
Verwers, G.J., 1972: Das Kamps Veld in Haps in Neolithikum, Bronzezeit und Eisenzeit, Leiden.Google Scholar
Verwers, W.J.H., 1991: Bewoningssporen uit de vroege ijzertijd aan de Kloosterstraat te Den Dungen, in Fokkens, H. and Roymans, N. (eds), 163–170.Google Scholar
Verwers, W.J.H., 1998: North Brabant in Roman and Early Medieval times: habitation history, Amersfoort.Google Scholar
Verwers, W.J.H., and Kooistra, L.I., 1990: Native house plans from the Roman period in Boxtel and Oosterhout, Berichten van de Rijksdienst voor het Oudheidkundig Bodemonderzoek 40, 251–284.Google Scholar
Waterbolk, H.T., 1982: Mobilität von Dorf, Ackerflur und Gräberfeld in Drenthe seit der Latènezeit, Offa 39, 97–137.Google Scholar
Waterbolk, H.T., 1995: Patterns of the peasant landscape, Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 61, 1–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waterson, R., 1990: The living house. An anthropology of architecture in South-east Asia, Oxford.Google Scholar
Waterson, R., 1995: Houses, graves and the limits of kinship groupings among the Sa'dan Toraja, Bijdragen tot de taal-, land- en volkenkunde 151, 194–217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar