Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-01T06:01:42.688Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Schliemann's mendacity—a false trail?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2015

Donald Easton
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

David Traill's article in Antiquity, LVII, debunking ‘Priam's Treasure’, will no doubt be seen by some as one more bullet in the chest for Schliemann. In recent years the firing-squad has been getting quite active. Now that Schliemann's archaeology has become the target it is time to ask: how accurate are the shots? Schliemann's new executioners trace their pedigree back to their nineteenth-century predecessors. This is unwise, for Hartmut Dohl has shown very clearly that the conduct of, among others, the Berlin clique was quite as reprehensible as any failing of Schliemann's (Dohl, 1981, 16-75). Perhaps their problem was indeed, as Calder has evidenced (Calder, 1972, 347-8; 1980, ‘so), that they found him just too provincial, too common and too rich. The new wave of disaffection actually has its genesis in a series of articles by W. G. Niederland, a Freudian psycho-analyst with a research interest in the psychology of exploration (Niederland, 1964- 5 ; 1965; 1966-7; 1967; 1971). Niederland's papers make fascinating reading. He highlights some very unusual features in Schliemann's writings, and pinpoints a number of recurrent themes. His work is of undoubted interest to anyone concerned with Schliemann. He also comes up with the startlingly original suggestion that Schliemann was all along suffering from an unresolved Oedipus complex. His relentless exploration of Mother Earth, his fascination with cemeteries and his libidinous recollection of his early love-play among them with Minna, indicate a life-long search for his dead mother.

Type
Article
Information
Antiquity , Volume 58 , Issue 224 , November 1984 , pp. 197 - 204
Copyright
Copyright © Antiquity Publications Ltd 1984

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bittel, K. 1959, Beitrag zur Kenntnis Anatolischer Metalgefässe der zweiten Hälfte des dritten Jahrtausends v. Chr., JDAI, 74, 1-34.Google Scholar
Borlase, W. 1878. A visit to Dr Schliemann’s Troy, Fraser's Magazine, 17 (February) 228-39.Google Scholar
Calder, III, W. M. 1972. Schliemann on Schliemann: a study in the use of Sources, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies, 13, 335-53.Google Scholar
Calder, III, W. M. 1980. Wilamowitz on Schliemann, Philologus, 124, 146-51.Google Scholar
Döhl, H. 1981. Heinrich Schliemann: Mythos und Ärgernis (München/Luzern).Google Scholar
Dörpfeld, W. 1902. Troja und Ilion, 2 vols. (Athens).Google Scholar
Easton, D. F. 1981. Schliemann’s discovery of ‘Priam’s Treasure’: two enigmas, Antiquity, LV, 179—83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Easton, D. F. 1982. The Schliemann Papers, BSA, 77, 93-110.Google Scholar
Easton, D. F. 1984. Priam’s Treasure, Anatolian Studies, 34 (forthcoming).Google Scholar
Eissler, K. R. 1961. Leonardo da Vinci (New York).Google Scholar
Korres, G. S. 1974-5. Inscriptions ä la possession de Heinrich Schliemann, Athena, 75, 54-67 and 492.Google Scholar
Lilly, E. 1961. Schliemann in Indianapolis (Indianapolis) .Google Scholar
Meyer, E. 1936. Briefe von Heinrich Schliemann (BerlinLeipzig).Google Scholar
Meyer, E. 1953. Heinrich Schliemann Briefwechsel vol. I (Berlin).Google Scholar
1958. Heinrich Schliemann Briefwechsel vol. II (Berlin).Google Scholar
Niederland, W. G. 1964-5. Analytische Studie über das Leben und Werk Heinrich Schliemanns, Psyche(Stuttgart/Heidelberg) 18/10, 563-90.Google Scholar
Niederland, W. G. 1965. An analytic enquiry into the life and work of Heinrich Schliemann, Drives, Affects, Behavior: Essays in Memory of Marie Bonaparte, ed. Max Schur (New’York) vol. II, 369—96.Google Scholar
Niederland, W. G. 1966-7. Das Schöpferische im Lebenswerk Heinrich Schliemanns im Lichte psychoanalytischer Forschung, Carolinum (Göttingen) 32 Jg. Nr. 46, 9—16.Google Scholar
Niederland, W. G. 1967. Psychoanalytic profile of a creative mind: Eros and Thanatos in the life of Heinrich Schliemann, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 15, 200—19.Google Scholar
Niederland, W. G. 1971. Heinrich Schliemann—Leben und Werk in tiefen-psychologischer Sicht, Carolinum (Göttingen) 37, 34-41.Google Scholar
Schindler, W. 1976. Heinrich Schliemann: Leben und Werk im Spiegel der neueren biographischer Forschungen, Philologus, 120, 271—89.Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1869. Ithaka, der Peloponnes und Troja (Leipzig).Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1872. Unpublished Troy excavation notebook for 1872.Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1873a. Unpublished Troy excavation notebook for 1873.Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1873b. Ausgrabungen in Troja, Allgemeine Zeitung (Augsburg), Beilage zu Nr. 164 (13 June) 25092510; Beilage zu Nr. 165 (14 June) 2527—2528.Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1874a. Trojanische Alterthümer (Leipzig).Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1874b. Atlas Trojanischer Alterthümer (Leipzig), cited as Atlas. Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1875. Troy and its remains (London), ed. Philip Smith, transi. Dora Schmitz. Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1880. Ilios: the city and country of the Trojans (London).Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1888. Attische Grabinschriften, Athenische Mitthei-lungen, 13, 207—10, 429.Google Scholar
Schliemann, II. 1890a. Unpublished Troy excavation notebook for 1890 (translation by Mrs Helen Cavanagh). 1890b. Bericht über die Ausgrabugen in Troja im Jahre 1890 (Leipzig).Google Scholar
Schmidt, II. 1902. Heinrich Schliemann’s Sammlung Trojanischer Altertümer (Berlin).Google Scholar
Traill, D. A. 1978-9. Schliemann’s mendacity: fire and fever in California, Classical Journal 74, 348—355.Google Scholar
Traill, D. A. 1982. Schliemann’s american citizenship and divorce, Classical Journal, 77, 336-42.Google Scholar
Traill, D. A. 1983. Schliemann’s ‘discovery’ of ‘Priam’s Treasure’, Antiquity, LVII, 181-6.Google Scholar
Traill, D. A. 1984a. Schliemann’s discovery of 'Priam’s Treasure’: a re-examination of the evidence, JfIJS, 104 (fortheom- ing).Google Scholar
Traill, D. A. 1984b. Schlicmann in the Troad in 1868, Boreas (forthcoming).Google Scholar
Weber, S. H. 1942. Schliemann’s first visit to .America, 1850—51, Gennadeion Monographs II (Cambridge, Mass.) Google Scholar
Zimmermann, K. 1982. Heinrich Schliemann—ein Leben zwischen Traum und Wirklichkeit, Klio, 64, 513-32.Google Scholar