Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-18T11:22:47.151Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Bones, teeth, and estimating age of perinates: Carthaginian infant sacrifice revisited

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2015

J.H. Schwartz ,
F.D. Houghton ,
L. Bondioli  and
R. Macchiarelli
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Writing about the ‘Tophet’, a children's cemetery in Carthage, Smith et al. argued in these pages that the age distribution of the children peaks at 1–1.49 months, supplying “another link in the chain of evidence—funerary practices, texts, iconography—that supports the interpretation of the Phoenician Tophets as ritual sites set aside for infant sacrifice” (2011: 871). In this they had challenged Jeffrey Schwartz and colleagues, who previously argued (2010) that “skeletal remains from Punic Carthage do not support systematic sacrifice of infants”. Here Schwartz et al. restate their position for Antiquity readers, showing that the verdict on the Phoenician practice of child sacrifice is, at best, not proven.

Keywords

CarthagePunicfirst millennium BCTophetinfanticidechild burialhuman sacrifice
Type
Research article
Information
Antiquity , Volume 86 , Issue 333 , September 2012 , pp. 738 - 745
Copyright
Copyright © Antiquity Publications Ltd. 2012 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adler, C.J. & Donlon, D.. 2010. Sexual dimorphism in deciduous crown traits of a European derived Australian sample. Forensic Science International 199: 29–37.Google Scholar
Agelarakis, A.P., Kanta, A. & Stampolidis, N.. 1998. The osseous record in the Western Necropolis of Amathous: an archaeo-anthropological investigation, in Karageorghis, V. & Stampolidis, N. (ed.) Eastern Mediterranean Cyprus-Dodecanses-Crete 16th-6th cent. BC: 217–32. Heraklion: University of Crete.Google Scholar
Antoine, D., Hillson, S. & Dean, M.C.. 2009. The development clock of dental enamel: a test for the priodicity of prism cross-striations in modern humans and an evalution of the most likely sources of error in histological studies of this kind. Journal of Anatomy 241: 45–55.Google Scholar
Bartoloni, P. 2006. Il Tophet: un pietoso rito offuscato da troppo miti. Darwin Quaderni 1: 68–75.Google Scholar
Behrman, R.E. & Shiono, P.H.. 1997. Neonatal risk factors, in Fanaroff, A.A. & Martin, R.J. (ed.) Neonatal-perinatal medicine: diseases of the fetus and infant: 3–12. St Louis (MO): Mosby.Google Scholar
Benichou-Safar, H. 1981. A propos des ossements humains du tophet de Carthage. Rivista di Studi Fenici 5: 5–9.Google Scholar
Birch, W. & Dean, M.C.. 2009. Rates of enamel formation in human deciduous teeth, in Koppe, T., Meyer, G. & Alt, K.W. (ed.) Comparative dental morphology: frontiers of oral biology: 116–20. Basel: Karger.Google Scholar
Brown, S. 1991. Late Carthaginian child sacrifice and sacrificial monuments in their Mediterranean context. Sheffield: JSOT Press.Google Scholar
Chalmers, J. & Macfarlane, A.. 1980. Interpretation of perinatal statistics, in Wharton, B.A. (ed.) Topics in perinatal medicine: 1–11. Tunbridge Wells: Pitman Medical.Google Scholar
Conte, S. 2007. Child sacrifice: children of Phoenician Punic Carthage were not sacrificed to the gods. Available online at: http://phoenicia.org/childsacrifice.html (accessed 2 February 2012).Google Scholar
Deutsch, D., Tam, O. & Stack, M.V.. 1985. Postnatal changes in size, morphology and weight of developing postnatal deciduous anterior teeth. Growth 49: 202–217.Google Scholar
Durfee, R.B. 1987. Obstetric complications of pregnancy, in Wharton, B.A. (ed.) Topics in perinatal medicine: 255–78. Tunbridge Wells: Pitman Medical.Google Scholar
Fantar, M.H. 2007. Child sacrifice: children of Phoenician Punic Carthage were not sacrificed. Available at: http://phoenicia.org/childsacrifice.html (accessed 2 February 2012).Google Scholar
Fazekas, I.G. & K´osa, F.. 1979. Forensic fetal osteology. Budapest: Akademiai Kiado.Google Scholar
Fedele, F. & Foster, C.. 1988. Tharros ovicaprini sacrificiali e rituale del Tofet. Rivista di Studi Fenici 16: 29–42.Google Scholar
Gatto, E. 2003. La place de la crémation dans le traitement des défunts á la fin du Néolithique en France. Unpublished PhD dissertation, Université de Bordeaux 1.Google Scholar
Gejvall, N.-G. 1969. Cremations, in Brothwell, D., Higgs, E. & Clark, G. (ed.) Science in archaeology: 468–79. London: Thames and Hudson.Google Scholar
Harden, D. 1963. The Phoenicians. New York: Frederick A. Praeger.Google Scholar
Hillson, S. 1996. Dental anthropology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Lapeyre, R.P. & Pellegrin, A.. 1942. Carthage Punique (814-146 avant J.-C.). Paris: Payot.Google Scholar
Mckinley, J.I. 1989. Cremations: expectations, methodologies and realities, in Roberts, C.A., Lee, F. & Bintliff, J. (ed.) Burial archaeology: current research, methods and developments (British Archaeological Reports British series 211): 65–76. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.Google Scholar
Mckinley, J.I. 1994. The Anglo-Saxon cemetery at Spong Hill, North Elmham. Part 8: the cremations. Dereham: Field Archaeology Division, Norfolk Museums Service.Google Scholar
Mosca, P.G. 1975. Child sacrifice in Canaanite and Israelite religion. Unpublished PhD dissertation, Harvard University.Google Scholar
Moscati, S. 1965. The world of the Phoenicians. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.Google Scholar
Moscati, S. 1987. Il sacrificio punico dei fanciulli: realtá or invenzione? Quaderni dell’Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei 261: 4–15.Google Scholar
Poinssot, L. & Lantier, R.. 1923. Un sanctuaire de Tanit á Carthage. Revue de l’Histoire des Religions 1923: 32–66.Google Scholar
Saunders, S.R. & Barrans, L.. 1999. What can be done about the infant category in skeletal samples?, in Hoppa, R.D. & Firzgerald, C.M. (ed.) Human growth in the past: studies from bones and teeth (Cambridge studies in biological and evolutionary anthropology): 183–209. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Schwartz, J.H. 1993. What the bones tell us. New York: Henry Holt & Co.Google Scholar
Schwartz, J.H., Houghton, F., Macchiarelli, R. & Bondioli, L.. 2010. Skeletal remains from Punic Carthage do not support systematic sacrifice of infants. PLoS ONE 5: 1–12.Google Scholar
Scobie, A. 1986. Slums, sanitation, and mortality in the Roman world. Klio 2: 399–433.Google Scholar
Shellis, R.P. 1984. Variations in growth of the enamel crown in human teeth and a possible relationship between growth and enamel structure. Archives of Oral Biology 29: 697–705.Google Scholar
Simonetti, A. 1983. Sacrifici umani e uccisioni rituali nel mondo Fenicio-Punico: il contributo delle fonti letterarie. Rivista di Studi Fenici 11: 91–111.Google Scholar
Skinner, M. & Dupras, T.. 1993. Variation in birth timing and location of the neonatal line in human enamel. Journal of Forensic Sciences 38: 1383–90.Google Scholar
Smith, P., Avishai, G., Greene, J.A. & Stager, L.E.. 2011. Aging cremated infants: the problem of sacrifice at the Tophet of Carthage. Antiquity 85: 859–75.Google Scholar
Soleil, M.M., Müller, P. & Richard, J.. 1958. Contribution á la détermination de l’age des enfants sacrifices á Carthage. Annales de Medicine Legale et de Criminologie 38(1): 17–23.Google Scholar
Stager, L.E. 1980. The rite of child sacrifice at Carthage, in Pedley, J.G. (ed.) New light on ancient Carthage: 1–11. Ann Arbor (MI): University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Stager, L.E. & Greene, J.A.. 2000. An Odyssey debate: were living children sacrificed to the gods? Yes. Archaeological Odyssey 2: 29–31.Google Scholar
Stager, L.E. 2007. Child sacrifice: yes, children of Phoenician/Punic Carthage were sacrificed to the gods. Available at: http://phoenicia.org/childsacrifice.html (accessed 2 February 2012).Google Scholar
Stager, L.E. & Wolff, S.R.. 1984. Child sacrifice at Carthage: religious rite or population control? Biblical Archaeology Review 10: 31–51.Google Scholar
Taylor, C.M. & Pernoll, M.L.. 1987. Normal pregnancy & prenatal care, in Pernoll, M.L. & Benson, R.C. (ed.) Current Obstetric & Gynecologic Diagnosis & Treatment 1987: 161–77. Norwalk (CT): Appleton & Lange.Google Scholar
Zanolli, C., Bondioli, L., Manni, F., Rossi, P.F. & Macchiarelli, R.. 2011. Gestation length, mode of delivery and variation of the tooth enamel neonatal line. Human Biology 84: 1–35.Google Scholar