Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T17:56:01.024Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Mapping Space, Mapping Time: the Thirteenth-century Vault Paintings at Salisbury Cathedral

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2011

Matthew M Reeve  and
Olivia Horsfall Turner
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This paper provides a new interpretation of the date, form, meanings and theological sources of the former painted cycle on the vaults of Salisbury Cathedral. As the cycle is now known predominantly from antiquarian evidence, we begin with a discussion of the nature and significance of that evidence, namely the series of sketches, drawings and notes produced by Jacob Schnebbelie in the late eighteenth century before the whitewashing of the medieval paintings. Through consideration of the archaeological and stylistic evidence, we propose a date for the cycle between c 1235 and 1245, thus contemporary with the new building campaign begun in 1220. Two connected interpretations of the cycle are offered: first, we argue that the painted cycle was designed to function as a map of the major liturgical sites of the eastern arm; second, we suggest that the imagery was designed to structure an allegory of religious experience and personal salvation in accord with reform-minded thinking in the post-Lateran period.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 85 , September 2005 , pp. 57 - 102
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alexander, J 1990. ‘Ideological representations of medieval peasant labour’, Art Bulletin, 72, 436–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anderson, M D 1963. Drama and Imagery in English Medieval Churches, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Armfield, H T 1873. ‘A note on the choir vault paintings’, Proc Soc Antiq, VI, 2nd ser, 477–9Google Scholar
Armfield, H T 1877-1878. ‘The ancient roof painting in Salisbury Cathedral’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 17, 129–35Google Scholar
J, Backhouse (ed) 2004. The English Medieval Cathedral: Essays in Honour of Pamela Tudor Craig, HarlaxtonGoogle Scholar
Bailey, T 1971. The Processions of Sarum and the Western Church, TorontoGoogle Scholar
Baldwin, J W 1970. Masters, Princes and Merchants: The Social Views of Peter the Chanter and his Circle, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
Binski, P 1995. Westminster Abbey and the Plantagenets: Kingship and the Representation of Power 1200-1400, New HavenGoogle Scholar
Binski, P 1997. ‘The Angel Choir at Lincoln and the poetics of the Gothic smile’, Art History, 20, 350–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Binski, P 1999. ‘The English parish church and its art in the later Middle Ages: a review of the problem’, Studies in Iconography, 20, 1–25Google Scholar
Binski, P 2004. ‘The painted nave ceiling of Peterborough Abbey’, in Backhouse, (ed) 2004, 41–62Google Scholar
Blum, P Z 1991. ‘The sequence of the building campaigns at Salisbury’, Art Bulletin, 73, 6–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bolton, B 1999. ‘Message, celebration, offering: the place of twelfth- and early thirteenthcentury liturgical drama as “Missionary Theatre”’, in Continuity and Change in Christian Worship (ed Swanson, R N), 89–103, WoodbridgeGoogle Scholar
Borenius, T 1932. ‘A destroyed cycle of wallpaintings in a church in Wiltshire’, Antiq J, 12, 393–406CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boynton, S 2000. ‘Work and play in sacred music and its social context, c 1050-1250’, in The Use and Abuse of Time in Christian History (ed Swanson, R N), 57–79, StamfordGoogle Scholar
Brenk, B 1995. ‘The Sainte-Chapelle as a Capetian political program’, in Raguin, et al 1995, 195–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brockett, C 1993. ‘A previously unknown Ordo Prophetarum in a manuscript fragment from Zagreb’, Comparative Drama, 27, 114–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, S 1999. Sumptuous and Richly Adorn'd: The Decoration of Salisbury Cathedral, LondonGoogle Scholar
Caiger-Smith, A 1963. English Medieval Wall Paintings, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Cahn, W 1976. ‘Architectural draftsmanship in twelfth-century Paris: the illustrations of Hugh of Saint-Victor's Commentary on Ezekiel's Temple Vision’, Gesta, 15, 247–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cahn, W 1994. ‘Architecture and exegesis: Richard of St.Victor's Ezekiel Commentary and its illustrations’, Art Bulletin, 76, 53–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Camille, M 1987. ‘Labouring for the Lord: the ploughman and the social order in the Luttrell Psalter’, Art History, 10, 423–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carruthers, M 2000. The Craft of Thought: Meditation, Rhetoric, and the Making of Images, 400-1200, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Cather, S, Park, D and Pender, R 2000. ‘Henry III's wall paintings at Chester Castle’, in Medieval Archaeology, Art and Architecture at Chester, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 22, 170–89, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Cave, C J P 1934. ‘The roof bosses of Worcester Cathedral’, Trans Worcestershire Archaeol Soc, II, 75–86Google Scholar
Cave, C J P and Tanner, L E 1934. ‘A thirteenthcentury choir of angels in the north transept of Westminster Abbey and the adjacent figures of two kings’, Archaeologia, 84, 63–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Caviness, M H 1974. ‘A lost cycle of Canterbury paintings of 1220’, Antiq J, 54, 66–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Caviness, M H 1995. ‘Artistic integration in Gothic buildings: a post-modern construct?’, in Raguin, et al 1995, 249–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chailley, J 1966. ‘Du drame liturgique aux prophetes de Notre-Dame-la-Grande’, in Melanges offerts a Rene Crozet (eds Gallais, P and Riou, Y), 835–41, PoitiersGoogle Scholar
Chatillon, J 1949. ‘Une ecclesiologie medievale: l'ldee de l'Eglise dans le theologie de l'ecole de Saint-Victor au XXIIE siécle’, Ire'nikon, 22, 5-38, 395–444Google Scholar
Cocke, T and Kidson, P 1993. Salisbury Cathedral: Perspectives on the Architectural History, LondonGoogle Scholar
Crossley, P 1998. ‘The man from inner space: architecture and meditation in the choir of St Laurence in Nuremburg’, in Medieval Art: Recent Perspectives: A Memorial Tribute to Reginald Dodwell (eds Owen-Crocker, G R and Graham, T), 165–82, ManchesterGoogle Scholar
Crossnoe, M E 1999. ‘Education and the care of souls: Pope Gregory IX, the order of St Victor, and the University of Paris in 1237’, Mediaeval Stud, 61, 137–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davidson, C 1994. ‘Of saints and angels’, in The Iconography of Heaven, Early Drama, Art, and Music Monograph Series, 21 (ed Davidson, C), 1–39, KalamazooGoogle Scholar
Davis, M T and Neagley, L 2000. ‘Mechanics and meaning: plan and design at Saint-Urbain, Troyes and Saint-Ouen, Rouen’, Gesta, 39, 161–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deferrari, R J 1951. Hugh of St Victor on the Sacraments of the Christian Faith, Cambridge, MassGoogle Scholar
Dodsworth, W 1792. A Guide to the Cathedral Church of Salisbury with a Particular Account of the Late, Great Improvements Made Therein under the Direction of James Wyatt, SalisburyGoogle Scholar
Draper, P 1987. ‘Architecture and liturgy’, in Age of Chivalry: Art in Plantagenet England 1200–1400 (eds Alexander, J and Binski, P), 83–91, LondonGoogle Scholar
Draper, P 1996. ‘Salisbury Cathedral: paradigm or maverick?’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Salisbury Cathedral, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 17, 21–31, LondonGoogle Scholar
Draper, P 2004. ‘Enclosures and entrances in medieval cathedrals’, in Backhouse, (ed) 2004, 76–88Google Scholar
Duranti, G 1995. Rationale Divinorum Officiorum I–IV, Corpus Christianorum, CXL, TurnhoutGoogle Scholar
Eames, E 1982. ‘Notes on the decorated stone roundels in the Corona and Trinity Chapel in Canterbury Cathedral’, in Medieval An and Architecture at Canterbury before 1220, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 5, 67–70, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Evans, G R 1983. ‘Hugh of Saint Victor on history and the meaning of things’, Studia Monastica, 25, 223–34Google Scholar
Evans, G R 1985, ‘Thomas of Chobham on preaching and exegesis’, Recherches de Theologie Ancienne et Medievale, 52, 159–70 1400Google Scholar
Evans, M 1994. ‘Fictive painting in twelfthcentury Paris’, in Sight and Insight: Essays on Art and Culture in honour of E. H. Gombrich at 85 (ed Onians, J), 73–88, LondonGoogle Scholar
Fassler, M 1992. ‘The Feast of Fools and Danielis Ludus: popular tradition in medieval cathedral play’, in Plainsong in the Age of Polyphony (ed Kelly, T Forrest), 65–99, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Fassler, M 1993. Gothic Song: Victorine Sequences and Augustinian Reform in Twelfth-century Paris, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Fassler, M 1994. ‘Liturgy and sacred history in the twelfth-century tympana at Chartres’, Art Bulletin, 75, 499–520CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fiennes, C 1949. The Journeys of Celia Fiennes, 2nd rev edn, LondonGoogle Scholar
Fliche, A 1994. ‘The advocate of Church reform’, in Innocent III: Vicar of Christ or Lord of the World? (ed Powell, J M), 55–72, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
Flint, V J 1981. ‘World history in the early twelfth century: the ‘Imago Mundi’ of Honorius Augustodunensis’, in The Writing of History in the Middle Ages: Essays Presented to Richard William Southern (ed Flint, V J), 211–38, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Fowler, J 1873. ‘On medieval representations of the months and seasons’, Archaeologia, 44, 137–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fry, T 1981. The Rule of St Benedict in Latin and English, New MexicoGoogle Scholar
Gaillard, G 1944. The Frescoes of Saint-Savin: The Nave, New YorkGoogle Scholar
Gardner, A 1956. Wells Capitals, Wells Cathedral pamphlet, WellsGoogle Scholar
Gardner, E 1911. The Dialogues of Gregory the Great, LondonGoogle Scholar
Gardner, J 1994. ‘Altars, altarpieces, and art history: legislation and usage’, in Italian Altarpieces 1250-1550: Function and Design (eds Borsook, E and Gioffredi, F S), 5–19, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Gauthier, M M 1966. ‘L'art de l'email champleve en Italie a l'epoque primitive du Gothique’, in II Gotico a Pistoia Nei Suoi Rapporti Con L'Atre Gotica Italiana, 271–93, PistoiaGoogle Scholar
Gauthier, M M 1968. ‘La cloture emaillee la confession de Saint Pierre au Vatican, lors du Conceile de Latran, IV, 1215’, in Synthronon: Art et Archeologie de la fin de I'Antiquite et du Moyen Age, 237–46, ParisGoogle Scholar
Glass, D F 1987. ‘Pseudo-Augustine, prophets, and pulpits in Campania’, Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 41, 215–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glass, D F 2000. ‘Prophecy and priesthood at Modena’, Zeitschrift fur Kunstgeschichte, 63, 326–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glass, D F 2001. ‘Otage de l'historiographie: I'Ordo prophetarum en Italie’, Cahiers de Civilisation Medievale, 44, 259–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gough, R 1786-1796. Sepulchral Monuments in Great Britain, 2 vols, LondonGoogle Scholar
Graves, P 1989. ‘Social space in the English medieval parish church’, Economy and Society, 18, 297–322CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Green way, D 1991. Fasti Ecclesiae Anglicanae 1066-1300: IV Salisbury, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Hanson, J 2000. ‘The prophets in discussion in the Middle Ages’, Florilegium, 17, 73–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henderson, G 1963. ‘The sources of the Genesis Cycle at Saint-Savin-sur-Gartempe’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 26, 11–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holdsworth, C J 1973. ‘The blessings of work: the Cistercian view’, in Sanctity and Secularity: The Church and the World (ed Baker, D), 59–76, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Hollaender, A J E 1943. ‘The Sarum Illuminator and his school’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 50, 230–62Google Scholar
Hope, W H St John 1904. ‘The imagery and sculptures on the west front of Wells Cathedral Church’, Archaeologia, 59, 143–206CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hope, W H St John 1916. ‘The Sarum Consuetudinary and its relation to the Cathedral Church of Old Sarum’, Archaeologia, 68, 111–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Horlbeck, F R 1960. ‘The vault paintings of Salisbury Cathedral’, Archaeol J, 117, 116–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
James, M R 1897. ‘On the paintings formerly in the choir at Peterborough’, Proc Cambridge Antiq Soc, 9, 178–94Google Scholar
Jansen, V 1985. ‘Lambeth Palace Chapel, the Temple Choir and southern English Gothic architecture of c 1215-40’, in England in the Thirteenth Century, Proceedings of the 1984 Harlaxton Symposium (ed Ormrod, W M), 95–9, WoodbridgeGoogle Scholar
Jansen, V 1996. ‘Salisbury Cathedral and the episcopal style in the early thirteenth century’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Salisbury Cathedral, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 17, 32–9, LondonGoogle Scholar
Jones, W H R 1878. ‘On the original position of the high altar at Salisbury Cathedral’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 17, 136–46Google Scholar
W H R, Jones (ed) 1883. Register of Saint Osmund, 2 vols, Rolls Ser, LondonGoogle Scholar
Jungmann, J A 1986. The Mass of the Roman Rite: Its Origins and Development (trans Brunner, F A), MarylandGoogle Scholar
Kemp, B 1992. ‘God's and the king's servant: Richard Poore, Bishop of Salisbury, 1217-28’, Peritia, 12, 359–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kupfer, M 1993. Romanesque Wall Painting in Central France: The Politics of Narrative, New HavenGoogle Scholar
Ladner, G 1942. ‘The symbolism of the biblical cornerstone in the medieval West’, Mediaeval Stud, 4, 43–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lamia, S 2000. ‘The cross and the crown, the tomb and the shrine: decoration and accommodation for England's premier saints’, in Decorations for the Holy Dead: Visual Embellishments on Tombs and Shrines of Saints (eds Lamia, S and Alamo, E Valdez del), 39–56, TurnhoutGoogle Scholar
Liversidge, M and Binski, P 1995. ‘Two ceiling fragments from the Painted Chamber at Westminster Palace’, Burlington Magazine, 137 491–501Google Scholar
F, Madden (ed) 1866-1869. Matthew Paris, Historia Anglorum, 3 vols, Rolls Ser, LondonGoogle Scholar
Male, E 1961. The Gothic Image: Religious Art in France of the Thirteenth Century, LondonGoogle Scholar
Marks, R 1996. ‘The thirteenth-century glazing of Salisbury Cathedral’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Salisbury Cathedral, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 17, 106–20, LondonGoogle Scholar
McCracken, H N 1911. The Minor Poems of John Lydgate, Early English Text Society 107, OxfordGoogle Scholar
McNamee, M B 1972. ‘The origin of the vested angel as a Eucharistic symbol in Flemish painting’, Art Bulletin, 54, 263–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morgan, N J 1982. Early Gothic Manuscripts I: 1190-1250, LondonGoogle Scholar
Morgan, N J 1988. Early Gothic Manuscripts II: 1250-1285, LondonGoogle Scholar
Morgan, N J 2004. ‘Marian liturgy in Salisbury Cathedral’, in Backhouse, (ed) 2004, 89–111Google Scholar
Mortet, V 1913. ‘Hugue de Fouilloi, Pierre le Chantre, Alexander Neckham et les critiques dirigees au douzieme siecle contre le luxe des constructions’, in Melanges d'histoire offerts a Charles Be'mont par ses amis et ses e'leves, 105–37, ParisGoogle Scholar
Murray, S 1996. Notre-Dame Cathedral of Amiens: The Power of Change in Gothic, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Neagley, L 1997. ‘Architecture and the Body of Christ’, in The Body of Christ in the An of Europe and New Spain, 1150-1800 (ed Clifton, J), 27–36, MunichGoogle Scholar
Nichols, J 1967. Literary Anecdotes of the Eighteenth Century, LondonGoogle Scholar
Ousterhout, R 1995. ‘Temporal structuring in the Chora Parakklesion’, Gesta, 34, 63–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Park, D 1983. ‘The wall paintings of the Holy Sepulchre Chapel’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Winchester Cathedral, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 6, 38–62, LondonGoogle Scholar
Park, D and Welford, P 1993. ‘The medieval polychromy of Winchester Cathedral’, in Winchester Cathedral: Nine Hundred Years 1093-1993 (ed Crook, J), 129–30, ChichesterGoogle Scholar
Parker, E C 2001. ‘Architecture as liturgical setting’, in The Liturgy of the Medieval Church (eds Heffernan, T J and Matter, E A), 273–326, KalamazooGoogle Scholar
F M, Powicke and Cheney, C (eds) 1964. Councils and Synods with Other Documents Relating to the English Church, 2 vols, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Proc Soc Antiq, VI, 2nd ser, 1875-1876Google Scholar
Procter, F and Wordsworth, C 1882. Breviarium Ad Usum Insignis Ecclesiae Sarum, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Raguin, V C, Brush, D and Draper, P 1995. Artistic Integration in Gothic Buildings, TorontoGoogle Scholar
Randall, R H 1959. ‘Thirteenth-century altar angels’, Record of the Art Museum: Princeton University, 18, 2–16Google Scholar
Reeve, M forthcoming a. ‘Art, prophecy and drama in the choir of Salisbury Cathedral’, Religion and the ArtsGoogle Scholar
Reeve, M forthcoming b. ‘Jacob Schnebbelie, draughtsman to the Society of Antiquaries (1760-92)’, Trans Ancient Monuments SocGoogle Scholar
Rich Jones, W H 1884. Vetus Registrum Sarisberiense: The Register of Saint Osmund, Rolls Ser, 78, LondonGoogle Scholar
Roberts, M E 1983. ‘The tomb of Giles de Bridport in Salisbury Cathedral’, Art Bulletin, 65, 559–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rudolph, C 1990. Artistic Change at Saint Denis: Abbot Suger's Program and the Early Twelfthcentury Controversy Over Art, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
Sampson, J 1988. Wells West Front: Construction, Sculpture, Conservation, StroudGoogle Scholar
Sauerlander, W 1995a. ‘Integration: a closed or open proposal?’, in Raguin, et al 1995, 3–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sauerlander, W 1995b. ‘Integrated fragments and the unintegrated whole: scattered examples from Reims, Strasbourg, Chartres and Naumberg’, in Raguin, et al 1995, 153–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schnebbelie, J 1791. The Antiquaries Museum, LondonGoogle Scholar
Scott, G G 1870. Restoration of the Choir of Salisbury Cathedral, SalisburyGoogle Scholar
Scott, G G 1879. Personal and Professional Recollections, LondonGoogle Scholar
Simpson, G 1996. ‘Documentary and dendrochronological evidence for the building of Salisbury Cathedral’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Salisbury Cathedral, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 17, 10–20, LondonGoogle Scholar
Southern, R W 1971. ‘Aspects of the European tradition of historical writing: Hugh of St Victor and the idea of historical development’, Trans Roy Hist Soc, XXI, 211–34Google Scholar
Staines, D 1983. ‘The holistic vision of Hugh of Saint Victor’, in Centre of the Labyrinth: Essays in Honour of Northrop Frye (eds Cook, E, Hoek, C, Macpherson, J, Parker, P and Patrick, J), 147–61, TorontoGoogle Scholar
Tatton-Brown, T 1999. ‘The burial places of St Osmund’, Spire (65th Annual Report of the Friends of Salisbury Cathedral), 19–25Google Scholar
Tatton-Brown, T 2000. ‘Introduction’, in Salisbury Cathedral, The West Front: A History and Study in Conservation (ed Ayers, T), 1–8, ChichesterGoogle Scholar
Tatton-Brown, T 2002. ‘Canterbury and the architecture of pilgrimage shrines in England’, in Pilgrimage, the English Experience from Becket to Bunyan (eds Morris, C and Roberts, P), 90–107, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Tatton-Brown, T 2003. ‘Recording the cathedral’, Current Archaeol, 188, 366–9Google Scholar
Thurlby, M 1986a. ‘The north transept doorway of Lichfield Cathedral: problems of style’, Revue d'art Canadienne, 13, 121–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thurlby, M 1986b. ‘The effigy of King John and the sculpture of the cathedrals of Wells and Worcester’, Trans Worcestershire Archaeol Soc, 10, 3rd ser, 55–8Google Scholar
Toke, N E 1930. ‘The Opus Alexandrinum and sculptured stone roundels in the retro-choir of Canterbury Cathedral’, Archaeol Cantiana, 42, 189–221Google Scholar
Tristram, E W 1950. English Medieval Wall Painting: The Thirteenth Century, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Vaughan, M F 1983. ‘The prophets of the Anglo-Norman “Adam”’, Traditio, 39, 81–114CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vincent, N 2002. ‘Master Elias of Dereham: a reassessment’, in The Church and Learning in Later Medieval Society: Essays in Honour of R. B. Dobson, Proceedings of the 1999 Harlaxton Symposium (eds Barron, C M and Stratford, J), 128–59, StamfordGoogle Scholar
Webber, T 1992. Scribes and Scholars at Salisbury Cathedral 1075-1125, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Webster, J C 1938. The Labours of the Months in Antique and Medieval Art to the End of the Twelfth Century, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
J, Weiss (trans) 2002. ‘Hugh of St. Victor, A Little Book About Constructing Noah's Ark’, in The Medieval Craft of Memory: An Anthology of Texts and Pictures (eds Carruthers, M and Ziolkowski, J M), 41–70, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
Williamson, B 2004. ‘Altarpieces, liturgy and devotion’, Speculum, 79, 341–406CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williamson, P 1995. Gothic Sculpture 1130-1300, New HavenGoogle Scholar
Wordsworth, C R 1901. Ceremonies and Processions of the Cathedral Church of Salisbury, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Wordsworth, C R and Macleane, D 1915. Statuta et Consuetudines Ecclesiae Cathedralis Beatae Mariae Virginis Sarisberiensis, LondonGoogle Scholar
Young, K 1922. ‘Ordo Prophetarum’, Trans Wisconsin Academy of Sciences, Arts and Letters, 20, 1–82Google Scholar
Young, K 1933. The Drama of the Medieval Church (reprinted 1967), LondonGoogle Scholar
Zinn, G A 1974. ‘Historia fundamentum est: the role of history in the contemplative life according to Hugh of Saint Victor’, in Contemporary Reflections on the Medieval Christian Tradition: Essays in Honour of Ray C. Petry (ed Shriver, G H), 135–58, Durham, NCGoogle Scholar
Zinn, G A 1986. ‘Suger, theology, and the Pseudo-Dionysian tradition’, in Abbot Suger and Saint Denis: A Symposium (ed Gerson, P Lieber), 33–40, New YorkGoogle Scholar