Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T06:34:12.603Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Dunaverney and Little Thetford Flesh-Hooks: History, Technology and Their Position within the Later Bronze Age Atlantic Zone Feasting Complex

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Sheridan Bowman  and
Stuart Needham
Sheridan Bowman
Affiliation:
Old Pitts Farm, Langrish, Hampshire GU32 1RQ, UK. E-mail: .
Stuart Needham
Affiliation:
Old Pitts Farm, Langrish, Hampshire GU32 1RQ, UK. E-mail: .
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Discovered in County Antrim and Cambridgeshire respectively, the Dunaverney and Little Thetford flesh-hooks are two of only thirty-six currently known examples from the Bronze Age of the Atlantic seaboard of Europe. Both are impressive and enigmatic objects and are among the most elaborate of later-series flesh-hooks dating to c 1100–800 BC. Not surprisingly, from the time it was found in 1829, Dunaverney was the subject of much antiquarian interest. Yet, despite their rarity and unusualness, the Dunaverney and Little Thetford flesh-hooks have never been adequately studied.

Our investigations have provided an understanding of the technology of these two fleshhooks, as well as new chronological information for the type as a whole. They have also revealed new uses of lost-wax casting in the British Isles, where the use of this technique is otherwise rare. The bird motifs on the Dunaverney flesh-hook remain unique, although it is now possible to set them against a broader background of iconographic representations on Atlantic feasting gear. Moreover, certain recurring design features may suggest that iconographic symbols were originally more often present on flesh-hooks. The findspot of Dunaverney lies at the heart of deposits of other contemporary prestige metalwork and that of Little Thetford within the greatest concentration of finds of the innovative Wilburton-stage metalworking tradition; both re-enforce the social significance of these rare objects.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 87 , September 2007 , pp. 53 - 108
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Allen, I M, Britton, D and Coghlan, H H 1970. Metallurgical Reports on British and Irish Bronze Age Implements and Weapons in the Pitt Rivers Museum, Pitt Rivers Museum Occas Pap on Technology 10, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Anon [Petrie] 1833a. ‘Ancient Irish Instrument’, The Dublin Penny Journal, I, no. 41 (6 04 1833), 324Google Scholar
Anon [T.A.] 1833b. ‘Ancient Irish Instrument’, The Dublin Penny Journal, I, no. 52 (22 06 1833), 416Google Scholar
Anon 1836–1837. ‘Beskrivelse over Nogle Mindre Fund af Maerkelige Oldsager; ved Oldsag-Committen’, Annaler for Nordisk Oldkyndighed (Kjöbenhavn), 173–6Google Scholar
Anon 1852. Descriptive Catalogue of the Collections of Antiquities, and Other Objects, Illustrative of Irish History, Exhibited in the Museum, Belfast, on the Occasion of the Twenty-Second Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, September, 1852, BelfastGoogle Scholar
Anon 1929. ‘Flesh-hook from Cambs’, Antiq J, 9, 255–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anon 1968. ‘National Museum of Ireland: archaeological acquisitions in the year 1965’, J Royal Soc Antiq Ireland, 98, 93–159Google Scholar
Armada Pita, X-L and López Palomo, L A 2003. ‘Los ganchos de carne con vástagos torsionados: un nuevo ejemplar en el depósito acuático del Río Genil (Sevilla)’, Revista d'Arqueologia de Ponent, 13, 167–90Google Scholar
Armbruster, B 1998. ‘Zu den technologischen aspekten bronzener Fleischhaken und Bratspeisse der Atlantischen Spätbronzezeit’, in L'Atelier du Bronzier en Europe du XXe au VHIe Siècle avant Notre Ère: Tome II, du Minerai au Métal, du Métal à l'Objet (eds Mordant, C, Pernot, M and Rychner, V), 183–92, ParisGoogle Scholar
Armbruster, B 2000. Goldschmiedekunst und Bronzetechnik: Studien zum Metallhandwerk der Atlantischen Bronzezeit auf der Iberischen Halbinsel, Monographies Instrumentum 15, MontagnacGoogle Scholar
Armbruster, B 2002–2003. ‘A metalurgia da Idade do Bronze Final Atlântico do Castro de Nossa Senhora da Guia, Baiões (S. Pedro do Sul, Viseu)’, Estudos Pré-históricos, 10–11, 145–55Google Scholar
Armstrong, E C R 1924. ‘The Early Iron Age, or Hallstatt period, in Ireland’, J Royal Soc Antiq Ireland, 54, 1–14, 109–27Google Scholar
Brailsford, J 1953. Guide to the Later Prehistoric Antiquities of the British Isles, LondonGoogle Scholar
Briard, J 1991. ‘Le groupe de l'épée en langue de Carpe en Armorique: une révision’, in Chevillot and Coffyn (eds) 1991, 125–44Google Scholar
Briggs, C S 1987. ‘Buckets and cauldrons in the late Bronze Age of north-west Europe: a review’, in Les Relations entre le Continent et les Iles Britanniques à l'Age du Bronze (ed Blanchet, J-C), Supplément à la Revue Archéologique de Picardie, 161–87, AmiensGoogle Scholar
Brindley, A L 2001. ‘Tomorrow is another day: some radiocarbon dates for Irish bronze artefacts’, in Patina: essays presented to Jay Jordan Butler (eds Metz, W H, van Beek, B L and Steegstra, H), 145–60, Grönigen and AmsterdamGoogle Scholar
Briscoe, G and Furness, A 1955. ‘A hoard of Bronze Age weapons from Eriswell, near Mildenhall’, Antiq J, 35, 218–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
British Museum 1904. A Guide to Antiquities of the Bronze Age, LondonGoogle Scholar
Bronk Ramsay, C 2007. <http://c14.arch.ox.ac.uk/oxcal> (20 04 2007)+(20+042007)>Google Scholar
Burgess, C and O'Connor, B 2004. ‘Bronze Age rotary spits: finds old and new, some false, some true’, in From Megaliths to Metal: essays in honour of George Eogan (eds Roche, H, Grogan, E, Bradley, J, Coles, J and Raftery, B), 184–99, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Cahill, M, ÓFloinn, R and Ireland, A 2004. ‘James Carruthers – a Belfast antiquarian collector’, in Irish Art Historical Studies in Honour of Peter Harbison (ed Hourihane, C), 219–60, DublinGoogle Scholar
Carruthers, J 1854–1855. [Communication from James Carruthers, Esq, Belfast, on 15 March 1854], Proc Trans Kilkenny South-East Ireland Archaeol Soc, 3, 64–5Google Scholar
Chevillot, C and Coffyn, A (eds) 1991. L'Age du Bronze Atlantique: Actes du ler Colloque du Parc Archéologique de Beynac, BeynacGoogle Scholar
Coffyn, A 1985. Le Bronze Final Atlantique dans la Péninsule Ibérique, ParisGoogle Scholar
Coles, J M 1959–1960. ‘Scottish Late Bronze Age metalwork: typology, distributions and chronology’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 93, 17–134Google Scholar
Coles, J M 1962. ‘European Bronze Age shields’, Proc Prehist Soc, 28, 156–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coles, J M 1963. ‘Irish Bronze Age horns and their relations in northern Europe’, Proc Prehist Soc, 29, 326–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colquhoun, I and Burgess, C B 1988. The Swords of Britain, MunichGoogle Scholar
Coombs, D 1975. ‘Bronze Age weapon hoards in Britain’, Archaeol Atlantica, I, 49–81Google Scholar
Coombs, D 2001. ‘Metalwork’, in Pryor 2001, 255–98Google Scholar
Cordier, G 1963. ‘Tintinnabulums ou sistres du Bronze Final et étuis à aiguilles de la Tène’, Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française, 60, 463–7Google Scholar
Cowell, M R 1998. ‘Coin analysis by energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometry’, in Metallurgy in Numismatics (eds Oddy, W A and Cowell, M R), vol 4, Royal Numis Soc Spec Publ 30, 448–60, LondonGoogle Scholar
Cowie, T G 1988. Magic Metal: early metalworkers in the north-east, AberdeenGoogle Scholar
Craddock, P 1978. ‘The composition of the copper alloys’, in A Catalogue of the British and Irish Prehistoric Bronzes in the Royal Ontario Museum (F Pryor), 65–76, TorontoGoogle Scholar
Dawkins, B 1885. ‘[Exhibition of] a hoard of articles of the Bronze Age, found at Eaton, near Norwich’, Proc Soc Antiq London, II, 42–51Google Scholar
Day, A and McWilliams, P (eds) 1992. Ordnance Survey Memoirs of Ireland. Volume 16: parishes of County Antrim V, 1830–5, 1837–8, Giant's Causeway and Ballymoney, BelfastGoogle Scholar
Delibes de Castro, G, Fernández Manzano, J and Celis Sánchez, J 1992–1993. ‘Nuevos “ganchos de carne” protohistóricos de la Peninsula Ibérica’, Tabona, 8(2), 417–34Google Scholar
Delibes de Castro, G, Fernández Manzano, J, Fontaneda Pérez, E and Rovira Llorens, S 1999. Metalurgia de la Edad del Bronce en el Piedemonte Meridional de la Cordillera Cantábrica: la Colección Fontaneda, Arqueología en Castilla y León monogr 3, LéonGoogle Scholar
Drew, C D 1935. ‘A Late Bronze Age hoard from Lulworth, Dorset’, Antiq J, 15, 449–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eogan, G 1965. Catalogue of Irish Bronze Swords, DublinGoogle Scholar
Eogan, G 1974. ‘Regionale Gruppierungen in der Spätbronzezeit Irlands’, Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt, 4, 319–27Google Scholar
Eogan, G 1983. The Hoards of the Irish Later Bronze Age, DublinGoogle Scholar
Eogan, G 1994. The Accomplished Art: gold and gold-working in Britain and Ireland during the Bronze Age (c. 2300–650 BC), Oxbow Monogr 42, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Evans, J 1881. The Ancient Bronze Implements, Weapons and Ornaments of Great Britain and Ireland, LondonGoogle Scholar
Gerloff, S 1986. ‘Bronze Age Class A cauldrons: typology, origins and chronology’, J Royal Soc Antiq Ireland, 116, 84–115Google Scholar
Gerloff, S 2008. Atlantic Cauldrons and Buckets. Studies in Typology, Chronology, Origin and Function of Multi-Sheet Vessels of the Late Bronze and Early Iron Age in Western Europe, Prähistorische Bronzefunde II, 18, StuttgartGoogle Scholar
Giardino, G 1995. Il Mediterraneo Occidentals fra XIV ed VIII Secolo A.C; Cerchi Minerarie e Metatturgiche, BAR Int Ser 612, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Gomez de Soto, J and Pautreau, J-P 1988. ‘Le crochet protohistorique en bronze de Thorigné à Coulon (Deux-Sèvres)’, Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt, 18, 31–42Google Scholar
Green, M 1993. Celtic Myths, LondonGoogle Scholar
Hawkes, C 1931. ‘Die Erforschung der Spätbronzezeit, Hallstatt- und La Tène-Zeit in England und Wales von 1914 bis 1931’, Bericht der Römisch-Germanisches Kommission, 21, 86–173Google Scholar
Hencken, H O'N 1942. ‘Ballinderry Crannog no 2’, Proc Royal Irish Acad, 47(C), 1–76Google Scholar
Holmes, P 1979. ‘The manufacturing technology of the Irish Bronze-Age horns’, in The Origins of Metallurgy in Atlantic Europe: proceedings of the fifth Atlantic colloquium (ed Ryan, M), 165–88, DublinGoogle Scholar
Hook, D R 1998. ‘Inductively-coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry and its role in numismatic studies’, in Metallurgy in Numismatics (eds Oddy, W A and Cowell, M R), vol 4, Royal Numis Soc Spec Publ 30, 237–52, LondonGoogle Scholar
Hughes, M J, Cowell, M R and Craddock, P T 1976. ‘Atomic absorption techniques in Archaeology’, Archaeometry, 18, 19–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jockenhövel, A 1974. ‘Fleischhaken von den Britischen Inseln’, Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt, 4, 329–38Google Scholar
Kalb, P 1980. ‘Zur Atlantischen Bronzezeit in Portugal’, Germania, 58, 25–59Google Scholar
Lang, J and Middleton, A P (eds) 2005. Radiography of Cultural Material, 2nd edn, Amsterdam and LondonGoogle Scholar
Leeds, E T 1930. ‘A bronze cauldron from the River Cherwell, Oxfordshire, with notes on cauldrons and other bronze vessels of allied types’, Archaeologia, 80, 1–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Legg, M-L 2004. ‘Petrie, George (1790–1866)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Online Edition, <http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/22O5i> (10 04 2007)+(10+042007)>Google Scholar
Le Roux, C-T 1985. ‘Circonscription de Bretagne’, Gallia Préhistoire, 28, 211–33Google Scholar
Lo Schiavo, F 1991. ‘La Sardaigne et ses relations avec le Bronze Final Atlantique’, in Chevillot and Coffyn (eds) 1991, 213–26Google Scholar
Macalister, R A S 1928. The Archaeology of Ireland, LondonGoogle Scholar
Meeks, N D, Craddock, P T and Needham, S P in press. ‘Bronze Age penannular gold rings from the British Isles: technology and composition’, Jewellery StudiesGoogle Scholar
Muckelroy, K 1981. ‘Middle Bronze Age trade between Britain and Europe: a maritime perspective’, Proc Prehist Soc, 47, 275–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Needham, S P 1979. ‘Two recent British shield finds and their continental parallels’, Proc Prehist Soc, 45, 111–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Needham, S P 1980. ‘An assemblage of Late Bronze Age metalworking debris from Dainton, Devon’, Proc Prehist Soc, 46, 177–215CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Needham, S P and Bowman, S G E 2005. ‘Flesh-hooks, technological complexity and the Atlantic Bronze Age feasting complex’, European J Archaeol, 8, 93–136CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Needham, S P and Dean, M 1987. ‘La cargaison de Langdon Bay à Douvres (Grandes Bretagne): la signification pour les échanges à travers la Manche’, in Les Relations Entre le Continent et les Iles Britanniques à l'Age du Bronze (ed Blanchet, J-C), Supplément à la Revue Archéologique de Picardie, 119–24, AmiensGoogle Scholar
Needham, S P and Hook, D R 1988. ‘Lead and lead alloys in the Bronze Age – recent finds from Runnymede Bridge’, in Science and Archaeology Glasgow 1987: proceedings of a conference on the application of scientific techniques to archaeology, Glasgow, September 1987 (eds Slater, E A and Tate, J O), BAR Brit Ser 196, 259–74, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Needham, S, Ramsey, C B, Coombs, D, Cartwright, C and Pettitt, P 1997. ‘An independent chronology for British Bronze Age metalwork: the results of the Oxford radiocarbon accelerator programme’, Archaeol J, 154, 55–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Newman, C 1997. ‘Ballinderry Crannóg no 2, Co. Offaly: the later Bronze Age’, J Irish Archaeol, 8, 91–100Google Scholar
Norfolk Museums Service 1977. Bronze Age Metalwork in Norwich Castle Museum, 2nd edn, NorwichGoogle Scholar
Northover, J P 1980. ‘The analysis of Welsh Bronze Age metalwork’, in Guide Catalogue of the Bronze Age Collections (Savory, H N), 229–43, CardiffGoogle Scholar
Northover, J P 1982. ‘The metallurgy of the Wilburton hoards’, Oxford J Archaeol, I, 69–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nouel, A 1957. ‘La cachette de bronze de Boissy-aux-Cailles (Seine-et-Marne) et les cachettes du Centre de la France’, Revue Archéologique de l'Est et du Centre-Est, 8, 298–311Google Scholar
O'Connor, B 1980. Cross-Channel Relations in the Later Bronze Age, BAR Int Ser 91, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Pautreau, J-P and Gomez de Soto, J nd. ‘Le crochet à viande de Thorigné et la cuisine du sacrifice’, in 1036 avant J.-C., Coulon (Pautreau, J- P), 26–30, La RondeGoogle Scholar
Pearce, S M 1983. The Bronze Age Metalwork of South Western Britain, BAR Brit Ser 120, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Piggott, S and Daniel, G 1951. A Picture Book of Ancient British Art, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Pryor, F 2001. The Flag Fen Basin: archaeology and environment of a Fenland landscape, Engl Heritage Archaeol Rep, SwindonGoogle Scholar
Reinach, M S 1896. ‘La sculpture en Europe avant les influences Gréco-Romaines’, L'Anthropologie, 7, 167–94Google Scholar
Rohl, B and Needham, S 1998. The Circulation of Metal in the British Bronze Age: the application of lead isotope analysis, Brit Mus Occas Pap 102, LondonGoogle Scholar
Rohl, B and Northover, J P 2001. ‘Analysis of the metalwork’, in Pryor 2001, 298–308Google Scholar
Ross, A 1967. Pagan Celtic Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
RCAHMS 1971. Argyll: An Inventory of the Monuments. Kintyre, I, Roy Comm Ancient Hist Monuments Scotland Inventories, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Staniaszek, B E P and Northover, J P 1982. ‘The properties of leaded bronze alloys’, in Proceedings of the 22nd Symposium on Archaeometry, University of Bradford (eds Aspinall, A and Warren, S E), 262–72, BradfordGoogle Scholar
Tylecote, R F 1986. The Prehistory of Metallurgy in the British Isles, LondonGoogle Scholar
Tylecote, RF and Biek, L 1991. ‘Metal-working evidence’, in The Breidden Hillfort: a later prehistoric settlement in the Welsh Marches (Musson, C R), CBA Res Rep 76, 147–9, LondonGoogle Scholar
Waddell, J 1998. The Prehistoric Archaeology of Ireland, GalwayGoogle Scholar
Waller, M 1994. Flandrian Environmental Change in Fenland, E Anglian Archaeol Rep 70/The Fenland Project 9, CambridgeGoogle Scholar