Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T17:29:36.608Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Architectural Patronage of Two Late Medieval Bishops: Edington, Wykeham and the rebuilding of Winchester Cathedral nave

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 August 2012

John Hare
John Hare*
Affiliation:
John Hare, FSA, 7 Owens Road, Winchester SO22 6RU, UK. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper reassesses the transformation of Winchester Cathedral nave in the second half of the fourteenth century from the Romanesque to its present form. It argues for a more complex and earlier development than traditionally accepted, with the rebuilding of the nave itself beginning in the early 1370s rather than in 1394. After the construction of the new porches Edington had planned to rebuild the nave completely, but by the time of his death even the west end was incomplete. His successor, Wykeham, adopted a more cautious and staged remodelling, starting with the creation of a new great arcade which he began in the 1370s and resumed in 1394. Subsequently, Wykeham began to complete the rebuilding with remodelled aisles, the clerestory and the vault. The implications of this proposed earlier dating are explored, including providing a major work in the 1370s for William Wynford, one of the most important architects of the period.

Résumé

Ce document réévalue la transformation de la nef de la cathédrale de Winchester, dans la seconde moitié du XIVe siècle, de sa forme romane à sa forme présente. Il avance une évolution plus complexe et antérieure à celle traditionnellement acceptée, avec une reconstruction de la nef elle-même commençant au début des années 1370 et non pas en 1394. Après la construction des nouveaux porches, Edington a projeté de reconstruire la nef entièrement mais, au moment de sa mort, même l'extrémité ouest était incomplète. Son successeur, Wykeham, a adopté un remodelage plus prudent et échelonné, en commençant par la création d'une nouvelle grande arcade, qu'il a entreprise dans les années 1370 et reprise en 1394. Par la suite, Wykeham a terminé la reconstruction des bas-côtés remodelés, de la galerie et de la voûte. Les implications de cette datation antérieure proposée sont explorées, notamment par rapport à l’œuvre majeure des années 1370 de William Wynford, l'un des architectes les plus importants de cette période.

Zusammenfassung

In diesem Paper wird die Umwandlung des Hauptschiffs von Winchester Cathedral in der zweiten Hälfte des 14. Jahrhunderts von seiner romanischen in seine gegenwärtige Form einer Neubewertung unterzogen und es wird darin für eine komplexere und frühere Ausführung argumentiert, als dies bisher angenommen wurde, so dass für den Beginn des Umbaus des Kirchenschiffs die Zeit kurz nach 1370 und nicht das Jahr 1394 angesetzt wird. Nach der Errichtung der neuen Portale hatte Edington den kompletten Umbau des Kirchenschiffs geplant, doch bei seinem Tod war selbst das westliche Ende noch nicht fertiggestellt. Sein Nachfolger Wykeham ging bei der Umgestaltung weitaus vorsichtiger und stufenweise vor. Er begann in den 1370ern mit dem Bau eines neuen großen Bogengangs, der 1394 fortgesetzt wurde. In der Folge wurde unter Wykeham der Umbau mit neu gestalteten Seitenchören, den Lichtgaden und dem Gewölbe abgeschlossen. Die Bedeutung dieser zeitlichen Vorverlegung wird untersucht, da damit. in der Zeit nach 1370 für William Wynford, einen der bedeutendsten Baumeister jener Zeit, ein großangelegtes Bauprojekt geschaffen wurde.

Type
Research papers
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 92 , September 2012 , pp. 273 - 305
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Manuscript sources

HRO, 5M50/2691Google Scholar
HRO, 11M59/B1/122 m11; 124 m9; 128Google Scholar
HRO, 11M59/B2/11/19; 35/1; 55Google Scholar
WCM, 22100Google Scholar

Published sources

Biddle, M 1976. Winchester in the Early Middle Ages, Oxford: Oxford University Press Google Scholar
Biddle, M 1986. Wolvesey: the Old Bishop's Palace, Winchester, Hampshire, London: English Heritage Google Scholar
Britnell, R H 2003. The Winchester Pipe Rolls and Medieval English Society, Woodbridge: Boydell Google Scholar
Brown, R A, Colvin, H M Taylor, A J 1963. The History of the King's Works, 2 vols, London: HMSO Google Scholar
Bullen, M, Crook, J, Hubbuck, R Pevsner, N 2010. The Buildings of England. Hampshire: Winchester and the North, London: Yale University Press Google Scholar
Callé, M 2001. ‘The heraldry of the nave high vault’, Winchester Cathedral Rec, 70, 47–48 Google Scholar
Carlin, M 1985. ‘The reconstruction of Winchester House, Southwark’, London Topogr Rec, 25, 33–57 Google Scholar
Clayton, M 1929. Catalogue of Brasses and Incised Slabs, London: Victoria and Albert Museum Google Scholar
Crook, J 1993. Winchester Cathedral: nine hundred years, Chichester: Phillimore Google Scholar
Crook, J 2000. ‘The nave vaults: design and sculpture’, Winchester Cathedral Rec, 69, 10–20 Google Scholar
Crook, J 2001. ‘More on the nave high vault’, Winchester Cathedral Rec, 70, 48–49 Google Scholar
Crook, J 2003. ‘Early historians of Winchester cathedral’, Proc Hampshire Fld Club Archaeol Soc, 58, 226–241 Google Scholar
Crook, J 2010a. ‘Winchester: the cathedral’, in Bullen et al 2010, 563–618Google Scholar
Crook, J 2010b. ‘The Romanesque west front of Winchester Cathedral’, in Interactions: the archaeology and history of Christianity in England 400–1200, (eds M Henig and N Ramsay), 219–235, Oxford: Oxford University Press Google Scholar
Crook, J Kusaba, Y 1993. ‘The perpendicular remodelling of the nave: problems and interpretations’, in Crook 1993, 215–30Google Scholar
Davis, R G 2004. ‘Edington, William (d. 1366)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: Online Edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 〈http://www.oxforddnb.com./view/article/8481〉 (16 May 2012)Google Scholar
Davis, V 2007. William Wykeham: a life, London: Hambledon Continuum Google Scholar
Dunlop, G G D 1940. Pages from the History of Highclere, Hampshire, Oxford: Holywell Press Google Scholar
Gee, E A 1952. ‘Oxford masons 1370–1530’, Archaeol J, 109, 54–131 Google Scholar
Goodman, A W 1934. ‘The transformation of the nave, Prior Nevyle and William of Wykeham’, Winchester Cathedral Rec, 3, 12–14 Google Scholar
Gordon, D 1993. The Wilton Diptych, London: National Gallery Google Scholar
Greatrex, J 1977. ‘A fourteenth-century injunction book from Winchester’, Bull Inst Hist Res, 1, 242–246 Google Scholar
Greatrex, J 1979. Register of the Common Seal of the Priory of St Swithun Winchester, 1345–1497, Hampshire Rec Ser 2, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Hare, J N 1988. ‘Bishop's Waltham Palace, Hampshire: William of Wykeham, Henry Beaufort and the transformation of a medieval episcopal palace’, Archaeol J, 145, 222–254 Google Scholar
Harvey, J H 1978. The Perpendicular Style, 1330–1485, London: Batsford Google Scholar
Harvey, J H 1982. ‘The buildings of Winchester College’, in Winchester College: sixth-centenary studies (ed R Custance), 77–127, Oxford: Oxford University Press Google Scholar
Harvey, J H 1984. Medieval Architects, 2nd edn, Gloucester: Sutton Google Scholar
Harvey, J H 1985. ‘Henry Yeveley and the nave of Canterbury Cathedral’, Canterbury Cathedral Chron, 79, 20–32 Google Scholar
Heslop, T A Sekules, V A (eds) 1983. Medieval Art and Architecture at Winchester Cathedral, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans vi, Leeds: ManeyGoogle Scholar
Kingsford, C L 2004. ‘Heete, Robert (d. 1433)’ (rev F D Logan), in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: Online Edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 〈http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/12863〉 (16 May 2012)Google Scholar
Kirby, T F 1899. Wykeham's Register. Vol II, Hampshire Rec Soc 13, Winchester Google Scholar
Kirk, R E G (ed) 1892. Accounts of the Obedientaries of Abingdon Abbey, Camden Society Google Scholar
Kitchen, G W 1892. Compotus Rolls of the Obedientiaries of St Swithun's Priory, Winchester, Hampshire Rec Soc 7, Winchester Google Scholar
Lindley, P 1990. ‘Sculptural discoveries at Winchester Cathedral’, Proc Hampshire Field Club Archaeol Soc, 46, 101–111 Google Scholar
Lindley, P 1993. ‘The medieval sculpture of Winchester cathedral’, in Crook 1993, 97–122Google Scholar
Lindley, P 1996. ‘The Black Death and English art: a debate and some assumptions’, in The Black Death in England (eds M Ormrod and P Lindley), 124–146, Stamford: Watkins Google Scholar
McAleer, J P 1994–5. ‘The Romanesque facade of Winchester Cathedral’, Proc Hampshire Fld Club Archaeol Soc, 49, 129–147, and 50, 153–68Google Scholar
McLees, A D 1973. ‘Henry Yevele disposer of the King's works of masonry’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 36, 52–71 Google Scholar
Moberly, G H 1893. Life of William of Wykeham, 2nd edn, Winchester: Warren Google Scholar
Munby, J Fletcher, J 1983. ‘Carpentry in the Cathedral and Close’, in Heslop and Sekules 1983, 101–11Google Scholar
Norton, E C 1983. ‘The medieval tile pavements of Winchester Cathedral’, in Heslop and Sekules 1983, 78–93Google Scholar
Page, M 1999. The Pipe Roll of the Bishopric of Winchester 1409–10, Hampshire Rec Ser 16, Winchester Google Scholar
Partner, P 2004. ‘Wykeham, William (c 1324–1404)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: Online Edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 〈http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/30127〉 (16 May 2012)Google Scholar
Pevsner, N Lloyd, D 1967. The Buildings of England. Hampshire and the Isle of Wight, Harmondsworth: Penguin Google Scholar
Phillpotts, C 2000. ‘Plague and reconstruction: Bishops Edington and Wykeham at Highclere, 1346–1404’, in Fourteenth-century England (ed N Saul), 115–132, Woodbridge: Boydell Google Scholar
Roberts, E 1993. ‘William of Wykeham's house at East Meon, Hants’, Archaeol J, 150, 456–481 Google Scholar
Roberts, E 2003. Hampshire Houses 1250–1700: their dating and development, Winchester: Hampshire County Council Google Scholar
Robo, E 1939. Medieval Farnham: everyday life in an episcopal manor, Farnham: St Michael's Abbey Press Google Scholar
Tatton-Brown, T 1993. ‘Building stones of Winchester Cathedral’, in Crook 1993, 37–46Google Scholar
Tatton-Brown, T 1997. ‘The rebuilding of the nave and western transepts, 1377–1503’, in Canterbury Cathedral Nave: archaeology, history and architecture (ed K Blockley), 128–146, Canterbury: Dean and Chapter of Canterbury Cathedral and Canterbury Archaeological Trust Google Scholar
VCH 1956. A History of Wiltshire. Vol III, London: Oxford University Press Google Scholar
Whittingham, S 1971. ‘The chronology of the portraits of Richard II’, Burlington Mag, 113, 12–21 Google Scholar
Willis, R 1846. ‘The architectural history of Winchester cathedral’, Archaeol J, 1, 1–80 (reprinted in Willis, R 1980. The Architectural History of Winchester Cathedral, Winchester: Friends of Winchester Cathedral; and in Willis, R 1972. Architectural History of Some English Cathedrals. Part I, Chicheley: Minet)Google Scholar
Wilson, C 1986. ‘The Gothic abbey church’, in Westminster Abbey (eds C Wilson, R Gem, P Tudor-Craig and J Physick), 22–69, London: Bell & Hyman Google Scholar
Wilson, C 2004a. ‘Wynford, William (d 1405)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: Online Edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 〈http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/38160〉 (16 May 2012)Google Scholar
Wilson, C 2004b. ‘Yevele Henry (d 1400)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: Online Edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 〈http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/30220〉 (16 May 2012)Google Scholar
Woodman, F 1981. The Architectural History of Canterbury Cathedral, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul Google Scholar
Woolgar, C M 2011. Testamentary Records of the English and Welsh Episcopates, 1200–1413, Canterbury York Soc, 102, Woodbridge: Boydell Google Scholar
Wylie, J H 1884. History of England under Henry the Fourth. Vol I: 1399–1404, London Google Scholar