Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-20T13:36:45.793Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

John Traherne, FSA and William Buckland's ‘Red Lady’: An Archaeological Perspective

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Russell Weston
Russell Weston
Affiliation:
Middle Cottage, Hazleton Manor, Rodmarton GL7 6PG, UK. E-mail: .
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Previously unpublished correspondence and a re-analysis of events call into question William Buckland's description of his excavation of Paviland Cave in 1823, and illustrate why his interpretation of it changed prior to publication in Reliquiae Diluvianae. Buckland appears to have manipulated the archaeological evidence from Paviland in order to support his ‘Diluvial’ theory. A synthesis of the documentary evidence also illustrates the unrecognized contribution made by John Traherne, FSA and others to the development of Buckland's Paviland story. This paper suggests that modern descriptions and interpretations of Paviland continue to be incorrectly influenced by a reliance on Reliquiae Diluvianae and that the reinterpretation of early archaeological excavations might benefit as much from the application of critical historiographical analyses as from the application of new scientific or theoretical methodologies.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 88 , September 2008 , pp. 347 - 364
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Aldhouse-Green, M and Aldhouse-Greens, S 2005. The Quest for the Shaman: shape-shifters, sorcerers and spirit-healers of ancient Europe, LondonGoogle Scholar
Aldhouse-Green, S (ed) 2000a. Paviland Cave and the ‘Red Lady’: a definitive report, BristolGoogle Scholar
Aldhouse-Green, S 2000b. ‘Climate, ceremony, pilgrimage and Paviland: the “Red Lady” in his palaeological and technoetic context’, in Aldhouse-Green (ed) 2000a, 227–46Google Scholar
Aldhouse-Green, S and Pettitt, P 1998. ‘Paviland Cave: contextualising the “Red Lady”’, Antiquity, 72, 756–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowen, D Q, Pettitt, P B, Richards, M, Sykes, B C, Ivanovich, M, Latham, A and Debenham, N 2000. ‘Radiometric dating, stable isotopes and DNA’, in Aldhouse-Green (ed) 2000a, 61–80Google Scholar
Buckland, W 1823a. Reliquiae Diluvianae: or observations on the organic remains contained in caves, fissures, and diluvial gravel, and on other geological phenomena attesting to the action of an universal deluge, LondonGoogle Scholar
Buckland, W 1823b. Letter of 6 March 1823 to John Traherne, record no. NLW MS.6598E FF.70 (24), National Library of WalesGoogle Scholar
Burek, C V and Kolbl-Ebert, M 2007. ‘Historical problems of travel for women geologists’, Geol Today, 23 (1), 30–2CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dillwyn, L W 1822. Diaries for 1817–22, National Library of Wales, <http://isys.llgc.org.uk>, s.v. ‘Lewis&Weston&Dillwyn&(I)’ (28 05 2008),+s.v.+‘Lewis&Weston&Dillwyn&(I)’+(28+05+2008)>Google Scholar
Edmonds, J M and Douglas, J A 1976. ‘William Buckland, FRS (1784–1856) and an Oxford geological lecture (1823)’, Notes Rec Roy Soc London, 30 (2), 141–67Google Scholar
Garrod, D A E 1926. The Upper Palaeolithic Age in Britain, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Howes, C J 1988. ‘The Dillwyn Diaries 1817–1852, Buckland, and the caves of Gower (South Wales)’, Proc Univ Bristol Spelaeol Soc, 18 (2), 298–305Google Scholar
Jacobi, R M, Higham, T F G and Ramsey, C Bronk 2006. ‘AMS radiocarbon dating of Middle and Upper Palaeolithic bone in the British Isles: improved reliability using ultrafiltration’, J Quat Sci, 21 (5), 557–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knight, H H 1823. Letter of 21 02 1823 to John Traherne, record no. NLW MS.6598E FF.70 (39), National Library of WalesGoogle Scholar
McComb, P 1989. Upper Palaeolithic Osseous Artifacts from Britain and Belgium: an inventory and technological description, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Mercer, D 2006. ‘The trouble with paradigms: a historical study on the development of ideas in the discipline of castle studies’, Archaeol Dialogues, 13 (1), 93–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
North, F J 1942. ‘Paviland Cave, the “Red Lady”, the deluge and William Buckland’, Ann Sci, 5 (2), 91–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Randall, H J and Rees, W (eds) 1963. Diary of Lewis Weston Dillwyn, S Wales Monmouthshire Rec Soc Publ 5, NewportGoogle Scholar
Roe, D A 1981. The Lower and Middle Palaeolithic Periods in Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
Sollas, W J 1913. ‘Paviland Cave: an Aurignacian station in Wales’, J Roy Anthropol Inst, 43, 325–74Google Scholar
Sommer, M 2004. ‘“An amusing account of a cave in Wales”: William Buckland (1784–1856) and the Red Lady of Paviland’, Brit J Hist Sci, 37 (1), 53–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Swainston, S and Brookes, A 2000. ‘Paviland Cave and the “Red Lady”: the history of collection and investigation’, in Aldhouse-Green (ed) 2000a, 19–46Google Scholar
Talbot, M 1822. Letter of 30 December 1822 to William Henry Fox Talbot, doc. no. 1035, ‘The correspondence of William Henry Fox Talbot’, Fox Talbot Museum/Lacock Abbey Collection <http://foxtalbot.dmu.ac.uk/letters/name.php?bcode=Talb-MT&pageNo=1> (15 04 2008)+(15+04+2008)>Google Scholar
Thomas, D L 2004. ‘Traherne, John Montgomery (1788–1860)’, rev Brynley F Roberts, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: online edition (eds H C G Matthews and B Harrison), <http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/27657> (15 04 2008)CrossRef+(15+04+2008)>Google Scholar
Traherne, J M 1823. Letter of 3 03 1823 to William Buckland, ‘The Buckland Papers: Eyles Collection, 24’, Oxford University Museum of Natural HistoryGoogle Scholar
Trigger, B G 1989. A History of Archaeological Thought, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Trinkhaus, E and Holliday, T 2000. ‘The human remains from Paviland Cave’, in Aldhouse-Green (ed) 2000a, 141–204Google Scholar
Turner, A 2000. ‘The Paviland mammalian fauna’, in Aldhouse-Green (ed) 2000a, 133–40Google Scholar
Wellesley, K (trans) 1964. Tacticus. The Histories, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar