Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T17:43:51.703Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Encore Lindisfarne Priory and the Problem of its Nave Vaults

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2011

J. Philip McAleer
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

An examination of at least six views of Lindisfarne Priory dating from the late eighteenth century, at which time most of the nave was still standing, led to the surprising conclusion in an earlier study that the nave was covered by groin vaults. Because of the unequivocal evidence of ribbed vaults in the choir, transept arms and crossing, as well as in the nave aisles, it would be expected that the form of the nave vault was the same. Since the evidence provided by the early views has been greeted with some scepticism, this study documents the collapse and restoration of the nave during the nineteenth century, closely examines the only two points at which the springing of the former nave vault is preserved, and, finally, considers the continued use of groin vaults in England after the appearance of ribbed vaults at Durham Cathedral, c. 1093–-1100. None of these further investigations produced any evidence that contradicts the conclusions based on the early views as initially presented, nor does a consideration of other views from the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, during which time the nave elevations were gradually collapsing. Whether ‘logical’ or not, the nave of Lindisfarne was covered by groin vaults. This finding leads to the suggestion that groin vaults, not ribbed vaults, may have been used over the choir of Durham.

This paper was submitted for publication in November 1992.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 74 , March 1994 , pp. 169 - 210
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

A.A.S.B. 1903. Architectural Association Sketch Book, 3rd ser., 7, fols. 29–32Google Scholar
Addleshaw, G. W. O. 1953. Holy Island or Lindisfarne, SunderlandGoogle Scholar
Alcock, L. and Owen, D. E. 1954 [1955]. ‘Kirkstall Abbey excavations: fourth report, 1953’, Publ. Thoresby Soc., 43, 51–66Google Scholar
Archaeol, J. 1856. ‘Proceedings at meetings’, Archaeol. J. 13, 273–97, 375–420Google Scholar
Arnold, T. (ed.) 1882, 1885. Symeonis monachi opera omnia, i (1882), ii (1885), 2 vols., Rolls Series, 75, LondonGoogle Scholar
Aubert, M. 1936. ‘Airaines’, Congrès archéologique, 99 (Amiens), 459–67Google Scholar
Aubert, M., 1947. L'architecture cistercienne en France, 2 vols., (2nd edn), ParisGoogle Scholar
Baylé, M. 1979. La Trinité de Caen; sa place dans l'histoire de l'architecture et du décor romans, Bibliothèque de la Société française d'archéologie, 10, GenevaGoogle Scholar
Benson, G. 1911. York from its Origin to the End of the Eleventh Century, YorkGoogle Scholar
Billings, R. W. 1846. Illustrations of the Architectural Antiquities of the County of Durham: Ecclesiastical, Castellated and Domestic, DurhamGoogle Scholar
Bilson, J. 1898–9. ‘The beginnings of Gothic architecture, ii. Norman vaulting in England’, J. Roy. Inst. British Architects, 3rd ser., 6, 289–326Google Scholar
Bilson, J., 1907. ‘The architecture of Kirkstall Abbey Church’ in Hope and Bilson 1907, 73–140Google Scholar
Bilson, J., 1909. ‘The architecture of the Cistercians, with special reference to some of their earlier churches in England’, Archaeol. J., 66, 185–280Google Scholar
Bilson, J., 1917. ‘The aisle vaulting of Winchester transept’, J. Roy. Inst. British Architects, 3rd ser., 24, 65–9Google Scholar
Bilson, J., 1922. ‘Durham Cathedral: the chronology of its vaults’, Archaeol. J., 79, 101–60Google Scholar
Blake, E. O. (ed.) 1962. Liber Eliensis, Camden Soc., 3rd ser., 112, LondonGoogle Scholar
Bloe, J. W. 1923. ‘Byland Abbey’ in The Victoria History of the County of York, North Riding, (ed. Page, W.), i, 10–13, LondonGoogle Scholar
Bony, J. 1946. ‘La collégiale de Mantes’, Congres archéologique, 104 (Paris-Mantes), 163–220Google Scholar
Bony, J., 1954. ‘Le projet premier de Durham: Voutement partiel ou voûtement total?’, Urbanisme et Architecture, 41–9, ParisGoogle Scholar
Bony, J., 1976. ‘Diagonality and centrality in early rib-vaulted architecture’, Gesta, 15, 15–25Google Scholar
Bony, J., 1983. French Gothic Architecture of the 12th and 13th Centuries, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
Branner, R. 1960. Burgundian Gothic Architecture, LondonGoogle Scholar
Britton, J. 1814. Architectural Antiquities of Great Britain, iv, 5 vols., LondonGoogle Scholar
Brooke, C. N. L. with Keir, G. 1975. London 800–1216: The Shaping of a City, LondonGoogle Scholar
Butler, D. and Butler, G. 1986. British Political Facts, 1900–1985, 6th edn., Basingstoke and LondonGoogle Scholar
Caley, J., Ellis, H. and Bandinel, B. 1823, 1825. Dugdale's Monasticon Anglicanum, iv (1823), v (1825), 6 vols. in 8, LondonGoogle Scholar
Cambridge, E. 1988. Lindisfame Priory and Holy Island, English Heritage, LondonGoogle Scholar
Clapham, A. W. 1934. English Romanesque Architecture, ii. After the Conquest, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Coldstream, N. and Draper, P. (eds.) 1977 [1980]. Medieval Art and Architecture at Durham Cathedral,The British Archaeol. Assoc. Conf. Trans., iiiGoogle Scholar
Crossman, W. 1890. ‘The recent excavations at Holy Island Priory’, Proc. Berwickshire Natur. Club, 13, 225–40Google Scholar
Curry, I. 1986. ‘Aspects of the Anglo-Norman Design of Durham Cathedral’, Archaeologia Aeliana, 5th ser., 14, 32–48Google Scholar
Dimier, A. 1962. L'art Cistercian, I. France, La Pierre-qui-VireGoogle Scholar
Emmerson, H. (Sir) 1956. The Ministry of Works, LondonGoogle Scholar
Fallow, T. M. 1913. ‘The hospital of St. Leonard, York’ in The Victoria History of the County of York, iii, 336–45. LondonGoogle Scholar
Fergusson, P. 1984. Architecture of Solitude: Cistercian Abbeys in Twelfth-Century England, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
Fergusson, P., 1986. ‘The twelfth-century refectories at Rievaulx and Byland Abbeys’ in Norton and Park 1986, 160–80Google Scholar
Fowler, J. T. (ed.) 1902. The Rites of Durham, Surtees Soc., 107, DurhamGoogle Scholar
Fowler, J. T., 1907. ‘An old description of the site of the cistercian abbey of Clairvaux’, Yorkshire Archaeol. J., 19, 1–18Google Scholar
Fowler, J. T., 1909. ‘Further notes on Clairvaux, and a note on Citeaux’, Yorkshire Archaeol. J., 20, 1–5Google Scholar
Frankl, P. 1962. Gothic Architecture, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Froidevaux, Y.-M. 1958. ‘L'abbatiale de Lessay’, Les monuments historiques de la France, new ser., 4, 97–150Google Scholar
Fry, P. S. and Carter, K. (eds.) 1986. Rievaulx Abbey (English Heritage Guide), HBMCEGoogle Scholar
Gage, J. 1831. ‘Remains of the prior of Lewes’ hostelry, in the parish of St. Olave, Southwark’, Archaeologia, 23, 299–308, pis. xx–xxivGoogle Scholar
Gardner, S. 1984. ‘Two campaigns in Suger's western block at St.-Denis’, Art Bulletin, 66, 574–87Google Scholar
Gardner, S., 1986. ‘L'église Saint-Julien de Marolles-en-Brie et ses rapports avec l'architecture parisienne de la génération de Saint-Denis’, Bulletin monumental, 144, 7–31Google Scholar
Graham, R. 1907. ‘The abbey of St. Peter at Gloucester’ in The Victoria History of the County of Gloucester (ed. Page, W.), ii, 53–61, LondonGoogle Scholar
Grodecki, L. 1953. ‘Notre-Dame-sur-l'Eau de Domfront’, Congrès archéologique, 111, 221–35Google Scholar
Gwilt, C.E. 1834. ‘Drawings of a crypt discovered in making the approach to New London Bridge, on the site of the south-east angle of the hostelry of the prior of Lewes, in the parish of St. Olave's, Southwark’, Archaeologia, 25, 604–6, pls. Lxvii–lxviiiGoogle Scholar
Hart, W. H. (ed.) 1863, 1865. Historia et Cartularium monasterii Sancti Petri Gloucestriae, i (1863), ii (1865), 2 vols., Rolls Series, 33, LondonGoogle Scholar
Héliot, P. 1959. ‘Les dates de construction des abbayes de Bernay, Cerisy-la-Forêt et Lessay’, Bulletin de la Societé nationale des antiquaires de la France, 188–209Google Scholar
Henriet, J. 1985. ‘Un édifice de la première génération gothique: l'abbatiale de Saint-Germer-de-Fly’, Bulletin monumental, 143, 93–142Google Scholar
Hope, W. H. St John, 1907. ‘Kirkstall Abbey’ in Hope and Bilson 1907, 1–72Google Scholar
Hope, W. H. St John, and Bilson, J. 1907. ‘Architectural Description of Kirkstall Abbey’, Publ. Thoresby Soc., 16Google Scholar
Hope, W. H. St John, and Kaines-Smith, S. C. 1914, ‘Furness Abbey’ in The Victoria History of the County of Lancaster, viii, 287–98, LondonGoogle Scholar
Hutchinson, W. 1785, 1794. The History and Antiquities of the County Palatine of Durham, 3 vols., NewcastleGoogle Scholar
James, J. 1983. ‘The rib vaults of Durham Cathedral’, Gesta, 22/2, 135–45Google Scholar
James, J., 1992/1993. ‘Rib vaults in Italy’, Avista Forum, 6/2 (Fall 1992/Winter 1993), 5–6Google Scholar
Kidson, P. and Murray, P. 1962. A History of English Architecture, LondonGoogle Scholar
King, J. F. 1986. ‘Possible West Country influences on twelfth-century architecture and its decoration in Normandy before 1150’, J. British Archaeol. Ass., 129, 22–39Google Scholar
Kubach, H. E. and Haas, W. 1972. Der Dom zu Speyer (Die Kunstdenkmäler von Rheinland-Pfalz, v), 1, 2 vols., MunichGoogle Scholar
Kusaba, Y. 1989. ‘Some observations on the early flying buttresses and choir triforium of Canterbury Cathedral’, Gesta, 28/2, 175–89Google Scholar
Lambert, E. 1935. Caen roman et gothigue, ses abbayes et son chateau, Caen (also Bulletin de la Société des antiquaries de Normandie, 43, 5–70)Google Scholar
Lelégrand, M. 1958. ‘Aperçu historique’ in Froidevaux 1958, 100–103Google Scholar
Lesueur, F. 1923. ‘L'église abbatiale Saint-Lomer de Blois’, Bulletin monumental, 82, 36–65Google Scholar
Lloyd, V. 1988. Roger Fenton, Photographer of the 1850s (Hayward Gallery, London, 4 February to 17 April 1988), LondonGoogle Scholar
Lovegrove, E. W. 1929. ‘The cathedral church of Llandaff’, J. British Archaeol. Ass., new ser., 35, 75–90Google Scholar
Luard, H. R. (ed.) 1859. Bartholomaei de Cotton monachi Norwicensis historia Anglicana, Roll Series, 54, LondonGoogle Scholar
Lyman, C. 1905. ‘The nave of Chepstow Church’, Archaeol. J., 62, 271–8Google Scholar
MacKenzie, E. 1825. An Historical Topographical and Descriptive View of the County of Northumberland, and of those Parts of the County of Durham situated North of the River Tyne etc., 2 vols., 2nd edn, Newcastle-upon-TyneGoogle Scholar
Mcaleer, J. P. 1986a. ‘The upper nave elevation and high vaults of Lindisfarne Priory’, Durham Archaeol. J., 2, 43–53Google Scholar
Mcaleer, J. P., 1986b. ‘Some reused Romanesque material in the choir tribune at Gloucester Cathedral’, Trans. Bristol Gloucestershire Archaeol. Soc., 104, 157–73Google Scholar
Mcaleer, J. P., 1987. ‘A note about the reconstruction of the west portal-porch of Lindisfarne Priory’, Durham Archaeol. J., 3, 9–13Google Scholar
McLachlan, E. P., Thurlby, M. and Little, C. T. 1985. ‘Romanesque reassembled in England: a review’, Gesta, 24/1, 77–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michon, L.-M. 1926. ‘L'abbaye de Saint-Georges de Boscherville’, Congrèes archéologique, 89 (Rouen), 531–49Google Scholar
Musset, L. 1974. Normandie romane, ii. La Haute-Normandie, La Pierre-qui-VireGoogle Scholar
Musset, L., 1975. Normandie romane, i. La Basse-Normandie, 2nd edn., La Pierre-qui-VireGoogle Scholar
N.C.H.C. 1930. A History of Northumberland, xiii. The Parishes of Heddon-on-the-Wall, etc., Northumberland County History Committee, 15 vols., Newcastle-upon-Tyne and LondonGoogle Scholar
Norton, C. and Park, D. (eds.) 1986. Cistercian Art and Architecture in the British Isles, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Peers, C. R. 1906. ‘Peterborough Minster’ in The Victoria History of the County of Northampton (eds. Serjeantson, R. M. and Adkins, W. R. D.), ii, 431–56, LondonGoogle Scholar
Peers, C. R., 1930. Byland Abbey, Yorkshire (Official Guide-Book), HMSO (2nd rev. edn. 1952), LondonGoogle Scholar
Peers, C. R., 1931. Rievaulx Abbey, Yorkshire, HMSO, LondonGoogle Scholar
Peers, C. R., and Brakspear, H. 1912. In The Victoria History of the County of Hampshire and the Isle of Wight (ed. Page, W.), v, 50–8, LondonGoogle Scholar
Peers, C. R., and Page, W. 1908. ‘Abbey church and buildings’ in The Victoria History of the County of Hertfordshire (ed. Page, W.), ii, 483–515, LondonGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N. 1958. The Buildings of England: Shropshire, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N., 1966. The Buildings of England: Yorkshire, The North Riding, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N., 1969. The Buildings of England: North Lancashire, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N., and Lloyd, D. 1967. The Buildings of England: Hampshire and the Isle of Wight, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N., and Metcalf, P. 1985. The Cathedrals of England: Midland, Eastern and Northern England, LondonGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N., and Radcliffe, E. 1965. The Buildings of England: Essex, 2nd edn, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N., and Richmond, I. A. 1957. The Buildings of England: Northumberland, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N., and Williamson, E. 1979. The Buildings of England: Nottinghamshire, 2nd rev. edn, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Piper, A. J. 1989. ‘The first generation of Durham monks and the cult of St. Cuthbert’, in St. Cuthbert, His Cult and His Community to AD 1200 (eds. Bonner, G., Rollason, D. and Stancliffe, C.), Woodbridge and Wolfeboro (N.H.), 437–46Google Scholar
Prache, A. 1983. Île-de-France romane, La Pierre-qui-VireGoogle Scholar
Raine, J. (ed.) 1835. Reginaldi monachi Dunelmensis Libellus de admirandis beati Cuthberti virtutibus, Surtees Soc., IGoogle Scholar
Raine, J., 1852. The History and Antiquities of North Durham &c., LondonGoogle Scholar
RCHM. 1929. London, iv, The City, The Royal Commission on Historical Monuments, London, 123–7Google Scholar
RCHM. 1931. Herefordshire, i. South-West, The Royal Commission on Historical Monuments, LondonGoogle Scholar
Rigold, S. E. 1969. Lilleshall Abbey, Shropshire (Official Guidebook), LondonGoogle Scholar
Salet, F. 1933. ‘Saint-Loup-de-Naud’, Bulletin monumental, 92, 129–69Google Scholar
Salet, F., 1944. ‘Voulton’, Bulletin monumental, 102, 91–115Google Scholar
Salet, F., 1946. ‘Notre-Dame de Poissy’, Congrès archéologique, 104 (Paris-Mantes), 221–68Google Scholar
Schofield, J. 1984. The Building of London, from the Conquest to the Great Fire, LondonGoogle Scholar
Scott, G. G. 1877. ‘Hereford Cathedral’, Archaeol. J., 58, 323–48Google Scholar
Scott, W. 1814–17. The Border Antiquities of England and Scotland, 2 vols., LondonGoogle Scholar
Serbat, L. 1908. ‘Église de Saint-Nicolas’, Congrès archéologique, 75, 2 vols. (Caen), 1, 52–61Google Scholar
Snape, M. G. 1980. ‘Documentary Evidence for the Building of Durham Cathedral and its Monastic Buildings’, in Coldstream, and Draper, (eds.) 1980, 20–36Google Scholar
Stalley, R. 1978, [1981]. ‘Three Irish buildings with West Country origins’ in Medieval Art and Architecture at Wells and Glastonbury, British Archaeol. Assoc. Con. Trans., iv, 62–80Google Scholar
Stewart, D. J. (ed.) 1848. Liber Eliensis, Anglia Christiana Soc., LondonGoogle Scholar
Stewart, D. J., 1875. ‘Notes on Norwich Cathedral’, Archaeol. J., 32, 16–47Google Scholar
Stoddard, W. S. 1966. Monastery and Cathedral in France, Middletown (Conn.)Google Scholar
Thompson, A. H. 1911. ‘The cathedral church of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Southwell’, Trans. Thoroton Soc., Nottinghamshire, 15, 15–62Google Scholar
Thompson, A. H., 1949. Lindisfarne Priory, Northumberland (Official Guide-book), HMSO (repr. 1986), LondonGoogle Scholar
Thurlby, M. 1988a. ‘The former Romanesque high vault in the presbytery of Hereford Cathedral’, J. Soc. Architectural Historians, 47/2, 185–89Google Scholar
Thurlby, M., 1988b. ‘The Romanesque priory church of St. Michael at Ewenny’, J. Soc. Architectural Historians, 47/3. 281–94Google Scholar
Vallery-Radot, J. 1969. ‘L'église Saint-Georges à Saint-Martin-de-Boscherville’, Bulletin monumental, 127, 143–7Google Scholar
VCH. 1913. The Victoria History of the County of York, iii, LondonGoogle Scholar
VCH. 1914. The Victoria History of the County of Lancaster, viii, LondonGoogle Scholar
VCH. 1923. The Victoria History of the County of York, North Riding, ii, LondonGoogle Scholar
Webb, E. A. 1913. ‘The plan of St. Bartholomew's West Smithfield, and the recent excavations’, Archaeologia, 64, 165–76Google Scholar
Webb, G. 1956. Architecture in Britain: the Middle Ages, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Wharton, H. 1691. Anglia Sacra, 2 vols., LondonGoogle Scholar
Willis, R. 1845. ‘The architectural history of Winchester Cathedral’, Proceedings of the Archaeological Institute (reprinted, Winchester 1980) (1–80)Google Scholar
Wilson, C. 1981 [1985]. ‘Abbot Serlo's church at Gloucester (1089–1100): its plac in Romanesque architecture’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Gloucester and Tewkesbury, British Archaeol. Assoc. Conf. Trans., VII, 52–83Google Scholar
Wilson, C., 1986. ‘The Cistercians as “missionaries of Gothic” in Northern England’ in Norton and Park 1986, 86–116Google Scholar
Woodman, F. 1981. The Architectural History of Canterbury Cathedral, LondonGoogle Scholar