Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-l7hp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T20:04:36.488Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Banks is the villain!’? Sir Joseph Banks and the governance of the Society of Antiquaries

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2009

Dai Morgan Evans
Dai Morgan Evans*
Affiliation:
Dai Morgan Evans, 24 Avenue South, Surbiton KT5 8PJ, UK.
*
E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The name of Sir Joseph Banks (1743–1820) is well known in scientific and exploration circles – he is undeservedly much less well known as an antiquary. This study considers his roles in relation to the premier antiquarian society of the time, the Society of Antiquaries of London. Using the Society’s records, Sir Joseph Banks is considered as an ordinary Fellow, as a member of Council, as an auditor of the finances and as a scrutator at elections. The relations between the Royal and Antiquarian Societies on first moving into Somerset House and the contemporary question of whether they might have merged is also examined. Joseph Banks’s role in the circumstances of the three contested presidential elections of 1785, 1799 and 1812 is especially considered, and these are seen not just to represent internal squabbling amongst the Fellows, but to reflect the wider social and political strains of the time. In producing the narrative of these elections, significant past mistakes are corrected. Lastly the relationship between George iii and the Society of Antiquaries is touched upon.

Résumé

Le nom de Sir Joseph Banks (1743–1820) est bien connu dans le milieu scientifique et celui des explorateurs – mas il mérite d’être bien mieux connu en tant qu’antiquaire. Cette étude prend en considération ses rôles par rapport à la plus importante société d’antiquaires de l’époque, la ‘Society of Antiquaries of London’ [Société des Antiquaires de Londres]. Par le biais des actes de la Société, Sir Joseph Banks est pris en considération en tant que membre ordinaire, en tant que membre du conseil, en tant que vérificateur de ses comptes et en tant que scrutateur lors de ses élections. Les rapports entre la ‘Royal Society’ et la ‘Society of Antiquaries’ lors de leur première installation à Somerset House et la question contemporaine de leur fusion potentielle sont également examinés. Le rôle de Joseph Banks dans les événements des trois élections présidentielles contestées en 1785, 1799 et 1812 est tout particulièrement examiné, et on peut constater que ces élections représentent non seulement les querelles internes parmi les membres mais reflètent également les tensions sociales et politiques plus générales de l’époque. La production du récit de ces élections permet de corriger d’importantes erreurs commises auparavant. En dernier lieu est abordé le sujet des rapports entre Georges III et la ‘Society of Antiquaries’.

Zusammenfassung

Der Name Sir Joseph Banks (1743–1820) ist in Wissenschaftler- und Erkunderkreisen ein Begriff – in den Kreisen der Altertumsforscher ist er unverdientermassen viel weniger bekannt. Diese Studie beschäftigt sich mit seiner Rolle, die er für die ranghöchste Gesellschaft von Altertumsforschern, der ‘Society of Antiquaries of London’ (dt.: Londoner Gesellschaft für Altertumsforschung) gespielt hat. Mit Hilfe von Quellen der Gesellschaft wird er in verschiedenen Rollen bedacht, als ein ordentliches Mitglied, ein Kollegienmitglied, als Finanzprüfer und als Wahlprüfer. Die Beziehung zwischen der ‘Royal Society’ (dt. Königliche Gesellschaft – eine Akademie der Wissenschaften) und Society of Antiquaries wird unter die Lupe genommen, insbesondere deren Umzug ins Somerset House und die aktuelle Frage ob sie sich hätten zusammengeschließen können. Die Rolle von Joseph Banks in den drei Präsidentschaftswahlen derJahre 1785, 1799 und 1812 wird besonders behandelt, da sie nicht nur von internen Gezänk under den Mitgliedern geprägt waren, sondern auch weitere soziale und politische Spannungen reflektieren. Durch die Schilderung dieser Wahlen werden bedeutende Fehler aus dieser Zeit korrigiert. Zuletzt wird die Beziehung zwischen König George III und der Society of Antiquaries kurz angesprochen.

Type
Original Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 89 , September 2009 , pp. 337 - 363
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Anderson, R W G, Caygill, M L, MacGregor, A G Syson, L (eds) 2003. Enlightening the British: knowledge, discovery and the museum in the eighteenth century, London: British Museum PressGoogle Scholar
Baigent, E 2004a. ‘Col. William Roy (1726–1790)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 48, 50–53, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Baigent, E 2004b. ‘Daniel Solander (1733–1782)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 51, 530–532, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Banks, R E R, Elliott, B, Hawkes, J G, King-Hele, D Lucas, G L L (eds) 1994. Sir Joseph Banks: a global perspective, London: Royal Botanic Gardens, KewGoogle Scholar
Bewell, A 1996. ‘ “On the Banks of the South Sea”: botany and sexual controversy in the late eighteenth century’, in Visions of Empire: voyages, botany, and representations of nature (eds D P Miller and P H Reill), 173–196, Cambridge: Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
Black, J 2006. George III: America’s last king, New Haven, Conn: Yale University PressGoogle Scholar
Brooke, J 1972. King George III, London: ConstableGoogle Scholar
Carter, H B 1987. Sir Joseph Banks (1743–1820): a guide to biographical and bibliographical sources, Winchester: St Paul’s Bibliographies in association with the British Museum (Natural History)Google Scholar
Carter, H B 1988. Sir Joseph Banks, 1743–1820, London: British Museum (Natural History)Google Scholar
Cave, K, Garlick, K Macintyre, A (eds) 1978–84. The Diary of Joseph Farington, 16 vols, New Haven, Conn: Yale University PressGoogle Scholar
Chamberlain, M E 1983. Lord Aberdeen: a political biography, London: LongmanGoogle Scholar
Chambers, N 2007. Joseph Banks and the British Museum: the world of collecting, 1770–1830, London: Pickering and ChattoGoogle Scholar
Clarke, J 1972. The Life and Times of George III, London: George WeidenfeldGoogle Scholar
Cokayne, G E 1903. The Complete Baronetage, Exeter: William PollardGoogle Scholar
Crook, J M 1995. John Carter and the Mind of the Gothic Revival, London: Society of AntiquariesGoogle Scholar
Dawson, W R 1958. The Banks Letters: a calendar of the manuscript correspondence of Sir Joseph Banks, London: British MuseumGoogle Scholar
Evans, J 1956. A History of the Society of Antiquaries, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Fleming, L 1934. Memoir and Select Letters of Samuel Lysons VPRS, VPSA 1763–1819, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Fraser, F 2004. Princesses: the six daughters of George iii, London: John MurrayGoogle Scholar
Gascoigne, J 1994. Joseph Banks and the English Enlightenment: useful knowledge and polite culture, Cambridge: Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
Gascoigne, J 1998. Science in the Service of Empire: Joseph Banks, the British State and the uses of science in the Age of Revolution, Cambridge: Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
Geikie, A 1917. Annals of the Royal Society Club, London: MacmillanGoogle Scholar
Golonski, J 1992. Science as Public Culture: chemistry and enlightenment in Britain, 1760–1820, Cambridge: Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
Goodall, J A 2001. ‘Coats of arms on the personal seals in the Society of Antiquaries Bond volumes’, manuscript shelved with the Bond volumes dated Oct 2001Google Scholar
Holmes, R 2008. The Age of Wonder, London: Harper PressGoogle Scholar
Hoock, H 2003. The King’s Artists: the Royal Academy of Arts and the politics of British culture 1760–1840, Oxford: Clarendon PressCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lewis, W S 1956. ‘Horace Walpole, Antiquary’, in Essays presented to Sir Lewis Namier (eds R Pares and A J P Taylor), 178–203, London: Macmillan & CoGoogle Scholar
Lysaght, A M 1971. Joseph Banks in Newfoundland and Labrador, 1766: his diary, manuscripts and collections, London: Faber and FaberGoogle Scholar
Macalpine, I Hunter, R 1969. George III and the Mad-Business, London: Allen LaneGoogle Scholar
McClellan, J E 1985. Science Reorganized: scientific societies in the eighteenth century, New York: Columbia University PressGoogle Scholar
Megaw, J V S 2001. ‘ “Your Obedient and Humble Servant”: notes for an Antipodean antiquary’, in Histories of Old Ages: essays in honour of Rhys Jones (eds A Anderson, I Lilley and S O’Connor), 95–110, Canberra: Pandanus BooksGoogle Scholar
Miller, D P 2004. ‘Sir Charles Blagden (1748–1820)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 6, 59–60, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Milles, J 1781. A Speech delivered to the Society of Antiquaries January 11th 1781 upon their removal into the apartments assigned to them in Somerset House etc, London: Society of AntiquariesGoogle Scholar
Nichols, J 1812. Literary anecdotes of the eighteenth century, London: John NicholsGoogle Scholar
Nurse, B 2000. ‘George Cruikshank’s The Antiquarian Society, 1812, and Sir Henry Charles Englefield’, Ant J, 80, 316–320CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nurse, B 2004. ‘Sir Henry Charles Englefield (1752–1822)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 18, 449–450, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
O’Brian, P 1987. Joseph Banks: a life, London: Collins HarvillGoogle Scholar
Riddell, R 2004. ‘John Pridden (1758–1825)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 45, 336–337, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Rodger, N A M 2004. ‘Phipps, Constantine John, 2nd Baron Mulgrave (1744–92)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 44, 178–179, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Smith, E 1911. The Life of Joseph Banks, President of the Royal Society with some notices of his friends and contemporaries, London: John LaneGoogle Scholar
Smith, E A 1999. George IV, New Haven, Conn: Yale University PressGoogle Scholar
Sweet, R 2004a. Antiquaries: the discovery of the past in eighteenth-century Britain, London: Hambledon and LondonGoogle Scholar
Sweet, R 2004b. ‘George Townsend, 2nd Marquess Townsend (1753–1811)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 55, 160–161, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Valentine, A C 1970. The British Establishment 1760–84: an eighteenth-century biographical dictionary, Oklahoma: University of OklahomaGoogle Scholar
Walpole, H 1903–5. The Letters of Horace Walpole, Fourth Earl of Orford, Oxford: Clarendon PressGoogle Scholar
Watkin, D 2004. The Architect King: George III and the culture of the Enlightment, London: Royal Collection PublicationsGoogle Scholar
Weld, C R 1848. A History of the Royal Society, London: J W ParkerGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Dai Morgan-Evans Appendices

Dai Morgan-Evans Appendices

Download Dai Morgan-Evans Appendices(File)
File 321.5 KB