Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-05T13:19:59.265Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

From Ithaca to the Odyssey1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 September 2013

Helen Waterhouse
Helen Waterhouse
Affiliation:
Hinksey Hill, Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

All references to Ithaca in ancient authors are in Homeric contexts. The BSA's excavations in the island, here summarized, have shown the importance throughout classical times of the shrines at Aëtos and Polis, indicated by the objects dedicated from many parts of the Greek world. Among these, the twelve tripod-lebetes found in the Polis Cave cannot be dissociated from the Phaeacian tripods given to Odysseus. It is suggested that the dedications preceded, and inspired, that part of the Odyssey, and that the importance of Odysseus in the Homeric poems reflects that of the cults at these shrines. Problems of transmission are considered, with a discussion of Homer's island geography and pre-colonial routes to the West.

Type
Articles
Information
Annual of the British School at Athens , Volume 91 , November 1996 , pp. 301 - 317
Copyright
Copyright © The Council, British School at Athens 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2 Aristotle,Ἰθαϰησίων πολιτεία Rose, V., Aristotelis quae ferebantur librorum fragmenta (Berlin, 1870), nos. 461–5Google Scholar; Strabo x. 2.10.

3 Halliday, W. R., Plutarch: The Greek Questions (Oxford, 1928).Google Scholar

4 Kern, O., Inschriften von Magnesia am Maeander (Berlin, 1900)Google Scholar, no. 36. No. 37, beside it, has a parallel invitation from the four cities of Kephallenia to τόν ἀγῶνα τον̃ Κεφάλον.Can it be assumed that both these were athletic competitions?

5 Gell, W., The Geography and Antiquities of Ithaca (London, 1807)Google Scholar; Schliemann, H., Ithaka, Peloponnes und Troja (Leipzig, 1869), 14–46Google Scholar; Vollgraff, W., ‘Fouilles d'Ithaque’, BCH 29 (1905), 145–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

6 BSA 35 (1934–5). 1–44.

7 PAE (1986), 234–42; Ibid. (1989), 292–5; Ergon (1987), 75–6, pl. 79; Ibid. (1992), 91–2; AR 35 (1988–9), 60.

8 Earlier finds and excavations in the island are comprehensively described by Kalligas, P. in Κεφαλληνιαϰά χρονιϰά, 3 (1978–1979), 45–69.Google Scholar Full references for the British publications are: ‘Ithaca I (Aetos)’, BSA 33 (1932–3), 22–65; ‘Ithaca II (Pelikata)’, BSA 35 (1934–5), 2–44; ‘Ithaca III (the cave at Polis), part 1’, BSA 35 (1934–5), 45–73, and ‘part 2’, BSA 39 (1939), 1–51; ‘Ithaca IV: summary’, BSA 40 (1939–40), 1–13; Robertson, M., ‘Ithaca V (the Geometric and later finds from Aetos)’, BSA 43 (1948), 1–124Google Scholar; ‘Ithaca 6: further excavations at Aetos’, BSA 48 (1953), 255–358; ‘Ithaca 7: excavations at Tris Langadas’, BSA 68 (1973), 1–24; ‘Excavations at Stavros, Ithaca, in 1937’, BSA 47 (1952), 227–42.

9 Heurtley left Athens for Jerusalem at the end of 1932 to become librarian in the Palestine Department of Antiquities. He died in Jan. 1955.

10 Grave III contained a coin of Agathokles.

11 See Ithaca IV.

12 Ithaca 6 255–9.

13 As Morgan, C. A., ‘Corinth, the Corinthian Gulf and Western Greece during the eighth century BC’, BSA 83 (1988). 313–38 at 316.Google Scholar

14 Ithaca V 9.

15 Coldstream, J. N., Greek Geometric Pottery (London, 1968), 220–32.Google Scholar

16 Symeonoglou, S., PAE (1989), 292–5Google Scholar; Ibid. (1992), 91–2. Pots at Perachora: Payne, H., Perachora, The Sanctuary of Hera Akraia and Limenaia (Oxford, 1940), 60, pl. 12. 4Google Scholar; and at Vitsa: Votokopoulou, I., Βίτσα (Athens, 1986)Google Scholar, no. 5238, fig. 67 and pl. 323a.

17 Ithaca 6. 259. See also discussion by Kalligas (n. 8), 61–2, and Symeonoglou, , PAE (1986), 234–42.Google Scholar

18 Taylour, W., Mycenaean Pottery in Italy (Cambridge, 1955), 186.Google Scholar

19 Desborough, V. R., Protogeometric Pottery (Oxford, 1952), 271–2, 279–81Google Scholar; Coldstream (n. 14), 222, 224. See also Coulson, W. D. E., ‘The Protogeometric from Polis reconsidered’, BSA 86 (1991), 43–64.Google Scholar

20 Temple model: see Ithaca V 101–2, pl. 45; for arula see Ithaca 6 345–6, pl. 64; Broneer, 's discussion in ‘The Corinthian altar painter’, Hesperia, 16 (1947), 214–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

21 The exact circumstances in which the Palaikastro tripods (Benton, S., ‘Bronzes from Palaikastro and Praisos’, BSA 40 (1939–1940), 51–2) were found are not clearGoogle Scholar; some were outside and in front of the temple precincts.

22 Cook, J. M., ‘Mycenae 1939–52, p Part III: the Agamemnoneion’, BSA 48 (1953), 30–68 at 33Google Scholar; also id., ‘The cult of Agamemnon at Mycenae’, in Γέρας Κεραμοπούλλου(Athens, 1953), 112–18.

23 Benton, S., ‘The evolution of the tripod-lebes’, BSA 35 (1934–1935), 74–130.Google Scholar

24 Unpublished article in the BSA Archive; Coldstream, Geometric Greece (London, 1977), 347; Rolley, C., Magou, E., and Phillipakis, S., ‘Trépiéds géometriques de bronze’, BCH 110 (1986), 121–36.Google Scholar

25 Fouilles de Delphes, v.3 (Paris, 1977), 7.

26 S. Benton (n. 23), 125: ‘No-one would willingly travel with a tripod-lebes.’

27 Iliad xi. 698 ff.; Hes. Op. 654–8.

28 Popham, M. R., Kalligas, P. G., and Sackett, L. H. (eds), Lefkandi II: The Protogeometric Building at Toumba, part 2 (BSA supp. vol. 23; Oxford, 1993).Google Scholar

29 Popham, M. R., Sackett, L. H., and Themelis, P. G. (eds), Lefkandi I: The Iron Age Settlement (BSA supp. vol. 11; Oxford, 1979). 93–5.Google Scholar

30 Halliday (n. 3), 80; Notopoulos, J. A., ‘Homer, Hesiod and the Achaean heritage of oral poetry’, Hesperia, 29 (1960), 117–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

31 Arist. Poet. xxv. 16, 1461b; Od. xix. 394 ff.

32 Migration traditions are set out in Huxley, G. L., The Early lonians (London, 1966).Google Scholar The connections between epic heroes and Bronze Age archaeology set out in Nilsson, M. P., The Mycenaean Origin of Greek Mythology (Berkeley, 1932) esp. 87, 154–5, are not to be doubted.Google ScholarRobert, F., Homère (Paris, 1950), 306–9Google Scholar, underlines the connection between the amount of Pylian saga in the Iliad and Odyssey and the prominence of Pylian noble families in the Ionian migration.

33 Coldstream (n. 15), 221–3.

34 Ithaca 6 338–9; Morgan (n. 13), 336–7.

35 Morgan (n. 13), 330–3, 338.

36 Ithaca V 103–13. Corinthian pottery on Aetos acropolis: Ithaca III/2 22 n. 2.

37 Plut. Quaest. Graec. 11; Halliday (n. 3), 19.

38 R. 490, Ithaca V 82–3; Kallikleas, Ibid., no. 324, pl. 39. The Polis stone: IG ix.1. 653; Jeffery (n. 1), 231, 234 n. 4.

39 Dunbabin, T. J., Western Greeks (Oxford, 1948), 194–5Google Scholar; cf. Ithaca 6 340.

40 Strabo x. 2. 10.

41 Od. xii. 70.

42 Phillips, E. D., ‘Odysseus in Italy’, JHS 73 (1953), 53–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

43 (London, 1987).

44 Desborough, V. R., The Greek Dark Ages (London, 1972), 246 n. 1Google Scholar, suggests that Attic influences on western Protogeometric pottery reached the north-west round the Peloponnese rather than through the Gulf of Corinth.

45 Od. xiii. 103–12.

46 Phaeacian gift of tripods: Od. xiii. 13–15. The gifts concealed in a cave by Athena, and Odysseus, : Od. xiii. 366–71.Google Scholar

47 Od. xiv. 321–6; xix. 282–95.

48 Il. vii. 436–41; xii. 17–33.

49 Il. ii. 625–35; Od. ix. 21–8; xiii. 96–112; also iv. 844–7, 671.

50 Plut. Quaest. Graec. 14; Halliday (n. 3).

51 Dörpfeld, W., Alt Ithaka (Munich, 1927).Google Scholar This topic is fully discussed, though from differing viewpoints, by Lorimer, H. L. in Homer and the Monuments (London, 1950), 494–501Google Scholar, and by Stubbings, F. H. in Wace, A. J. B. and Stubbings, F. H. (eds), A Companion to Homer (London, 1962), 403–4.Google Scholar

52 Cuillandre, J., La Droite et la gauche dans Homère (Paris, 1944), 194–214.Google Scholar

53 Od. xii. 184–91.

54 Kirk, G. S., The Homeric Poems as History (CAH ii.2, 3rd edn; Cambridge, 1975), 849–50.Google Scholar