Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-mlc7c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T07:26:50.308Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

D.G. Hogarth (1862–1927): ‘…A Specialist in the Science of Archaeology.’

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 September 2013

Abstract

David G. Hogarth (1862–1927) was the second student to be admitted to the newly-established British School at Athens in February 1887. In 1897 he became its fourth Director. Hogarth conducted much fieldwork and excavation in the eastern Mediterranean in the period 1888 to 1911 and has left a fine series of eleven excavation daybooks covering such important sites as Phlylakopi, Naucratis, Ephesus and Carchemish. Based upon this material the paper examines Hogarth as a theoretical and practical archaeologist of his day.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © The Council, British School at Athens 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Acknowledgements. I am particularly grateful to Dr Caroline Barron who is writing a life of her grandfather for the extended loan of the Hogarth daybooks in her possession and for much help and encouragement. I would like to thank the Keepers of the Departments of Egyptian Antiquities, Greek and Roman Antiquities, and Western Asiatic Antiquities of the British Museum for access to the daybooks in their custody. Thanks also go to Miss Janet Wallace of the B.M. Central Archives, Mrs Elaine Hart of the Illustrated London News Photographic Archive, the Staff of the Borthwick Institute, York, to Mr Stephen MacGillivray for making a copy of the photograph of Hogarth at the British School at Athens and to the Managing Committee of the School for permission to use it here, to Mrs Patricia Wardell for typing the text and to Caroline Barron, Benjamin Braude, Ann Brown, Dyfri Williams and Jeremy Wilson for many helpful comments and observations on D.G. Hogarth.

1 Copy of the firman in translation in the B.M. Central Archives, Carchemish File, 53.

2 See Appendix 1.

3 Breasted, J.H., The Geographical Review, 18 (1928), 159Google Scholar: The Times, November 7, 1927: 19.

4 Winstone, H.V.F., Gertrude Bell (London, 1978) 111Google Scholar; Breasted, art. cit., 160.

5 Petrie, W.M.F., Methods and Aims in Archaeology (London, 1904) 35.Google Scholar Hogarth, perhaps a little wistfully, had also acknowledged this necessity, see Authority and Archaeology, Sacred and Profane (London, 1899), xiii.

6 See Appendix 1.

7 1901 Zakro Daybook, entry for 2–6 April; Horwitz, Sylvia, The Find of a Lifetime (London, 1981), 144–5Google Scholar; B.M. Central Archives, Carchemish File, 28–9, letter from Hogarth to Sir Edward Maunde-Thompson, dated 17 February 1908; Wilson, Duncan, Gilbert Murray O.M. 1866–1957, (Oxford, 1987), 188.Google Scholar

8 Brown, Ann, Arthur Evans and the Palace of Minos (Oxford, 1983), 25–6Google Scholar; Lawrence, M.R. ed., The Home Letters of T.E. Lawrence and his Brothers (Oxford, 1954), 157209Google Scholar (Carchemish, 20 May, 1912); Sutcliffe, Peter, The Oxford University Press (Oxford, 1978), 176.Google Scholar

9 There was a Chair of Methods and Practice of Archaeology established at the University of Liverpool in 1907, but its holder until 1941, John Garstang, wrote no treatise on archaeological techniques; see Anatolian Studies 6, (1956), 27. Comments by Thompson, R. Campbell, A Pilgrim's Scrip (London, 1915), 16.Google Scholar

10 Hogarth, D.G., Accidents of an Antiquary's Life (London, 1910), 11.Google Scholar

11 James, T.G.H., ed., Excavating in Egypt: The Egypt Exploration Society 1882–1982 (London, 1982), 58Google Scholar: Der-el-Bahari Daybook 1894, entries for 16, 17, 25–28 July.

12 Ramsay, W.M., The Historical Geography of Asia Minor (London, 1890), 45Google Scholar and for M.R.James' view of Hogarth at Paphos see Cox, Michael, M.R. James, an informal Portrait (Oxford, 1983) 84–5.Google Scholar Hogarth was unusual in not having worked under the supervision of Petrie in Egypt. Most of his contemporaries from Gardner (born 1862) to Garstang (born 1876) had – many of them were the named dedicatees of Petrie's 1904 handbook.

13 Der-el-Bahari Daybook 1894 passim but especially the entries for 1, 3, 16 January and 7 February.

14 Petrie, W.M.F., Koptos (London, 1896), pages 2635 were by Hogarth.Google Scholar

15 Loring, William in his annual report to subscribers on 20 October 1898 in BSA 4 (18971898), 103.Google Scholar

16 Zakro Daybook 1901; Garbieh Tour Daybook, 1903.

17 Lawrence, M.R. ed., The Home Letters of T.E. Lawrence and his Brothers (Oxford, 1954), 135Google Scholar (letter written from Damascus, 26 February 1911); James, M.R., Eton and Kings (London, 1926), 192–3Google Scholar; Evans, Joan, Time and Chance (London, 1943), 340.Google Scholar It was in fact Gregori who opened the excavations at Knossos at 11.00 a.m. on Friday 23 March 1900. See Crete Daybook 1900.

18 Waterhouse, Helen, The British School at Athens, The First Hundred Years (London, 1896), 94–5Google Scholar; Fletcher, C.R.L., ‘David George Hogarth’, in The Geographical Journal, 71 (1928), 322.Google Scholar

19 Crete Daybook 1900, 21 June entry; Zakro Daybook 1901, entries for 22 and 25 June.

20 Hogarth, D.G., Accidents of an Antiquary's Life (London, 1910), 152.Google Scholar

21 See Appendices 1 and 2 below.

22 Hogarth, D.G.et al, ‘Naukratis, 1903’, JHS 25 (1905), 112CrossRefGoogle Scholar; 1898–9 Daybook, entries for 2 and 13 March 1899.

23 M.R. Lawrence, ed., op. cit., 149 (letter written at Carchemish, about 16 April 1911).

24 Childe, V.G., ‘Retrospect’, Antiquity, 32 (1958), 69CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Thompson, R. Campbell, A Pilgrim's Scrip (London, 1915), 294.Google Scholar

25 Hoffmann, Michael, Egypt Before the Pharoahs (London, 1984), 137–9.Google Scholar

26 Hogarth, D.G., Authority and Archaeology, Sacred and Profane (London, 1899), xi.Google Scholar

27 Petrie, W.M.F., Methods and Aims … (London, 1904), 4950Google Scholar; Droop, J.P., Archaeological Excavation (Cambridge, 1915) 27.Google Scholar

28 Zakro Daybook entry for 13 May. See also 1898–9 Daybook for February 25, 1899.

29 M.R. Lawrence, ed., op.cit., 159 (Carchemish, 19 May 1911).

30 Mackenzie, Duncan, Daybook of the Excavations at Phylakopi in Melos 1896–1899 (typewritten transcript by Renfrew, C., 1963).Google Scholar Copy in the Museum of Classical Archaeology, Cambridge. Hogarth's daybooks contain frequent references to his assistants' notes. For his use of them in an excavation report, see Atkinson, T.D. et al. , Excavations at Phylakopi in Melos (London, 1904), 5.Google Scholar

31 Der-el-Bahari Daybook 1894, entry for December 15 1893.

32 Hogarth, D.G. and Benson, E.F., Report on the Prospects of Research in Alexandria (London, 1895), 3.Google Scholar

33 Ibid., 15; Wheeler, Mortimer, Archaeology from the Earth (Oxford, 1954), 51.Google Scholar

34 Baikie, James, Egyptian Papyri and Papyrus-Hunting (London, 1925), 237Google Scholar; Hogarth, D.G., Philip and Alexander of Macedon (London, 1897), 2.Google Scholar

35 Hogarth, D.G., The Wandering Scholar in the Levant (London, 1986), 161–2; 165.Google Scholar

36 T.G.H. James, ed., op. cit., 162–3.

37 The History of the Times, III (1947), 715. Hogarth does not seem to have been the only member of the British School so employed.

38 BSA, 6 (1899–1900), 132.

39 Baedeker, Karl, Greece (3rd. edition, London, 1905), xi.Google Scholar

40 BSA, 4 (1897–8), 107.

41 T.D. Atkinson et al., op. cit., 2.

42 BSA, 5 (1898–9), 100.

43 Gill, D.W J., ‘Two Herodotean dedications from Naucratis’, JHS, 105 (1986), 184–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

44 B.M. Western Asiatic Dept., Carchemish Expedition File, Box 3. For a graphic description of conditions of work see Bosanquet, R.C., ‘Archaeology in Greece, 1899–1900’, JHS, 20 (1900), 171.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

45 Platon, Nicholas, Zakros, the Discovery of a Lost Palace of Ancient Crete (New York, 1971) 2433.Google Scholar For the contemporary view which applied the name Mycenaean to a whole class of monuments that more or less resembled those found at Mycenae by Schliemann in 1876 see Ridgeway, W., ‘What People produced the Objects called Mycenaean’, JHS, 16 (1896), 77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

46 Zakro Daybook, Monday 6 May.

47 B.M. Department of Greek and Roman Antiquities, Ephesus Archive, entries for 13 and 14 October 1904. Dr Dyfri Williams of that Department is shortly to publish the 1904/5 daybooks. The entry for 18 October 1904 shows that Petrie's Methods and Aims … formed part of Hogarth's dig reading in 1904.

48 M.R. Lawrence, ed., op. cit., 211 (letter dated 2 June 1912), 294 (letter of 20 April, 1914).

49 B.M. Western Asiatic Department, Carchemish Expedition File, Box 3: letter from William Morrison to Hogarth dated 19 January 1914.

50 M.R. Lawrence, ed., op. cit., 161–2 (letter dated 23 May 1911).

51 See the two articles by Mallowan, M.E.L. and Hawkins, J.D. in Anatolian Studies, 22 (1972), 6386.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

52 B.M. Central Archives, Carchemish File, 55: copy of a letter from the British Museum to the Foreign Office, dated 23 June 1910. An interesting list of the field-workers' equipment is also contained in this file, 35, dated 30 May 1908.

53 Hogarth, D.G. and Munro, J.A.R., Modern and Ancient Roads in Eastern Asia Minor (London, 1893), 644–5.Google Scholar

54 Ramsay, W.M., The Revolution in Constantinople and Turkey (London, 1909), 217.Google Scholar

55 Thubron, Colin, Journey into Cyprus (Harmondsworth, 1986), 45–6.Google Scholar

56 Harper, R.P. and Bayburtluoglu, Inci, Anatolian Studies, 18 (1968), 149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

57 D.G. Hogarth and J.A.R. Munro, op. cit., 690.

58 Opinion of a fellow Delegate of the Clarendon Press cited by Fletcher, C.R.L., The Geographical Journal, 81 (1928), 342.Google Scholar

59 Breasted, J.H., The Geographical Review, 18 (1928), 160.Google Scholar

60 The Times, November 7, 1927: 19.

61 Fletcher, art. cit., 324.

62 Listed in Appendix 3. Three of Hogarth's ILN articles are published in Bacon, Edward, ed., The Great Archaeologists (London, 1976) 124–6Google Scholar; 133–5; 144–6.

63 Hogarth, D.G., The Nearer East (London, 1902), ix.Google Scholar

64 Fletcher, art. cit., 342.

65 In addition to the Daybook extracts, Myres, J.N.L., The Tenth J.L. Myres Memorial Lecture: Commander J.L. Myres R.N.V.R. The Blackbeard of the Aegean (London, 1980), 9Google Scholar: Higgins, Reynold, The Archaeology of Minoan Crete (London, 1973), 78–9Google Scholar; Mallowan, Max, Mallowan's Memoirs, (London, 1977), 28.Google Scholar

66 Barnett, R.D., ‘T.E. Lawrence and the British Museum’, TLS, 16 October, 1969: 1210–1.Google Scholar In response to Knightley, Philip and Simpson, Colin, The Secret Lives of Lawrence of Arabia (London, 1969).Google Scholar

67 It is proposed to publish an edition of some of these daybooks in due course.