Genetic responses from selection strategies based on selection among all potential parents of the following year's crop were compared with those based on selection only within progeny crops. In the former group of strategies the duration of stay of an individual in the breeding herd is determined by the estimated breeding value of that individual, whereas in the classic model selected individuals of the same sex all remain in the breeding population for the same period. The former group of strategies, termed ‘parent selection’ strategies, were consistently superior in genetic response to the progeny selection strategies with a very large relative advantage under some conditions. The superiority of strategies that make more efficient use of genetic differences between own or parental age was greater among parent selection strategies than among progeny selection strategies. Similarly, increases in female to male mating ratios, fertility and survival rate generally resulted in larger increases i n genetic response in the more efficient strategies. The effect of changes in number of male and female age groups differs markedly between strategies.