Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T09:25:27.992Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Aspects of the Excavations in the Altinova, Elaziǧ

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 December 2013

Charles Burney
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Anyone associated for twenty years and more with Anatolian archaeology through the British Institute of Archaeology at Ankara, and thus with Anatolian Studies, has ample reason for respect and gratitude for the long, patient and understanding editorship of this journal by Oliver Gurney. For many years he has proved that efficiency and humanity can go hand in hand; and that the light touch on the editorial helm is normally sufficient. Perhaps at some sacrifice of his own interests, he has a record of service to Anatolian scholarship quite unsurpassed in our time, for to him is due the shape of Anatolian Studies as we have long known it.

This necessarily brief appraisal of aspects of the work achieved in the area of the Keban Rescue Project, under the overall auspices of the Middle East Technical University, Ankara, concentrates its attention especially upon the excavations at one site. The results of these have now been published in part in final form, with praiseworthy speed. The writer is responding to a request for a review of these publications. To attempt such a review without reference to the other reports on this site of Korucutepe, or in total isolation from the many other excavations by different teams in the same area, would of course be of little value and less interest. Yet the literature is by now so great, if in some degree repetitive, and the cultural implications for surrounding regions are so far-reaching, that a definitive assessment can scarcely be approached, and must await the final publications of the other excavations.

Type
Research Article
Information
Anatolian Studies , Volume 30 , December 1980 , pp. 157 - 167
Copyright
Copyright © The British Institute at Ankara 1980

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Final Reports on Korucutepe (Studies in Ancient Civilization: Allard Pierson Foundation, Amsterdam)Google Scholar

van Loon, Maurits N. (ed.): Korucutepe I (North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam, 1975)Google Scholar:

[Part I: Boessneck, J. & von den Driesch, A.: “Tiernochenfunde vom Korucutepe bei Elazig in Ostanatolien”, pp. 1–220. (Fundmaterial der Grabungen 1968 und 1969.Google Scholar)

Part II: van Zeist, W. & Bakker-Heeres, J. A. H.: “Prehistoric and early historic plant husbandry in the Altınova Plain, southeastern Turkey”, pp. 221–57Google Scholar.]

van Loon, Maurits N. (ed.): Korucutepe II (North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam, 1978)Google Scholar:

[Part III: – van Loon, Maurits N.: Architecture and Stratigraphy (pp. 3–45Google Scholar) (Phases A–B)

– Carol Bier, M.: The Fortification Wall (pp. 47–53Google Scholar)

Part IV: – Roelof Brandt, W.: The Chalcolithic Pottery (pp. 57–60Google Scholar)

– Brandt, Roelof W.: The other Chalcolithic finds (pp. 61–63Google Scholar)

Part V: – Kelly-Buccellati, Marilyn: The Early Bronze Age pottery – descriptive and comparative analysis (pp. 67–88Google Scholar)

– Griffin, Elizabeth E. & van Loon, Maurits N.: Early Bronze Age awls, pins, needles, spindles and whorls (pp. 89–95Google Scholar)

– van Loon, Maurits N.: The other Early Bronze Age finds (pp. 97–110Google Scholar).

Bibliography: pp. 111–15

List of plates: pp. 117–21

Plates 1–142.]

Preliminary Reports

van Loon, Maurits N. et al. : “The excavations at Korucutepe, Turkey, 1968–70: Preliminary Report” (J.N.E.S. XXXII (1973), pp. 135–47, 357–444Google Scholar; and XXXIII (1974), pp. 44–115).

van Loon, Maurits N. et al. : reports in Middle East Technical University Publications, Series 1, nos. 1 (1968Google Scholar season), 2 (1969 season) and 3 (1970 season), pp. 89–102, 59–69, 83–85 respectively. (KPP)

van Loon, Maurits N., Kelly-Buccellati, Marilyn & Güterbock, H. G.: brief reports in T.A.D. 17 (1968), pp. 79–82Google Scholar; 18 (1969), pp. 123–28; 19 (1970), pp. 127–32.

2 Korucutepe II, pp. 3–5.

3 Ibid., p. 5, with reference to excavation by layers 25 cm. thick.

4 Among the many reports on Norşuntepe may be cited those in Middle East Technical University Publications (KPP) 1968–1972; in TAD XXIII (1976), pp. 65–86Google Scholar; and briefer reports in A.S., especially “Norşuntepe, 1974” (A.S. XXV (1975), pp. 35–8Google Scholar).

5 A.S. XXIV (1974), p. 38Google Scholar.

6 Ertem, Hayri: “Korucutepe, 1973” (A.S. XXIV (1974), pp. 38–40)Google Scholar; “Korucutepe, 1974” (A.S. XXV (1975), pp. 31–2)Google Scholar; and “Korucutepe, 1975” (A.S. XXVI (1976), pp. 47–9)Google Scholar. By the 1975 season the waters were starting to engulf the site, whose summit still stands above the lake created by the dam.

7 Korucutepe II, p. 5.

8 (a) Mellaart, James: “Egyptian and Near Eastern chronology – a dilemma?” (Antiquity LIII (1979), pp. 6–18)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; (b) Easton, D. F.: “Towards a chronology for the Anatolian Early Bronze Age” (A.S. XXVI (1976), pp. 145–73)Google Scholar.

9 Easton, : A.S. XXVI (1976), p. 169Google Scholar.

10 Ibid., pp. 170–1; and Korucutepe II, p. 8.

11 Lamberg-Karlovsky, C. C.: (1) “The Proto-Elamite settlement at Tepe Yahya” (Iran IX (1971), pp. 87–96)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; (2) “The Proto-Elamites on the Iranian plateau” (Antiquity LII (1978), pp. 114–20)Google Scholar.

12 (a) Fruitstand: KPP 1972, Pl. 72(4); (b) Bevelled rim bowls: KPP 1971, Pl. 107(3) and KPP 1972, Pl. 73(2). For a bold discussion, Beale, Thomas Wight: “Bevelled rim bowls and their implications for change and economic organization in the later fourth millennium B.C.” (J.N.E.S. XXXVII (1978), pp. 289–313)Google Scholar. Only indirectly relevant to the Altınova sites.

13 Korucutepe II, p. 6 (table I).

14 Ibid., p. 74 (note 2).

15 Hauptmann, H.: A.S. XXV (1975), p. 37Google Scholar.

16 Fornaseri, M. et al. : “Analyses of obsidians from the Late Chalcolithic levels of Arslantepe (Malatya)” (Paléorient 3 (1975–1977), pp. 231–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar).

17 Whallon, R. and Kantman, S.: “Early Bronze Age development in the Keban Reservoir, east-central Turkey” (Current Anthropology X (1969), pp. 128–33)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Cf. eidem: KPP 1968, pp. 1–12Google Scholar.

18 Korucutepe II, p. 6.

19 Ibid., pp. 61–2.

20 Esin, U.: A.S. XXV (1975), p. 47Google Scholar.

21 For bibliography of the Euphrates excavations, Dornemann, R.: “Tell Hadidi — a Bronze Age city on the Euphrates” (Archaeology 31(6) (1978), pp. 20–6)Google Scholar.

22 See notes 12 and 20.

23 Palmieri, Alba: “Insediamento del Bronzo Antico a Gelinciktepe (Malatya)” (Origini I (1967), pp. 117–93)Google Scholar. See especially fig. 17 (p. 151).

24 Palmieri, Alba: “Scavi nell' area sud-occidentale di Arslantepe — ritrovamento di una struttura templare dell' Antica Eta' del Bronzo” (Origini VII (1973), pp. 55–228)Google Scholar. See especially figs. 56–63. The pottery (e.g. fig. 66) is clearly not all of ETC type: west or central Anatolian affinities are now thought more probable.

25 Maxwell-Hyslop, K. R.: “Sources of Sumerian gold” (Iraq XXXIX (1977), pp. 83–6)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Korucutepe II, p. 12.

27 Ibid., p. 13 and Chapter 5.

28 Ibid., p.68.

29 Pettinato, G.: “Testi cuneiformi del 3. millennio in paleo-Cananeo rinvenuti nella campagna 1974 a Tell Mardikh = Ebla” (Orientalia XLIV (1975), pp. 361–74) (p. 365)Google Scholar. For a partial rebuttal, Biggs, Robert: “The Ebla tablets: an interim perspective” (Biblical Archaeologist 43/2 (1980), pp. 76–87)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

30 Burney, C. A.: (1) “Excavations at Haftavan Tepe 1973” (Iran XIII (1975), pp. 149–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar); (2) “Excavations at Yanik Tepe, Azerbaijan” (Iraq XXIII (1961), pp. 138–55Google Scholar; XXIV (1962), pp. 134–53; XXVI (1964), pp. 76–87).

31 Harald Hauptmann: KPP 1972, Pl. 59 (fig. 1).

32 (a) Ian Todd, A.: “Anatolia and the Khirbet Kerak problem”, in Hoffner, H. A. (ed.): Orient and Occident – Essays Presented to Cyrus H. Gordon (1973), pp. 181–206Google Scholar; (b) Amiran, Ruth: “Yanik Tepe, Shengavit and the Khirbet Kerak ware” (A.S. XV (1965), pp. 165–7)Google Scholar; (c) Arsebük, Güven: “Altınova' da Elaziǧ koyu yuzlu ackili ve Karaz turu çömlek arasindaki ilişkiler” (VIII Türk Tarih Kongresi (Ankara, 1979), pp. 81–92 and figs. 45–52Google Scholar. The English summary is entitled “The possible origins of Karaz (Khirbet Kerak) type of pottery”.

33 (a) Korucutepe II, pp. 67–88; (b) note 14; (c) Marilyn Buccellati and Ernestine Elster, S.: “Statistics in archaeology and its application to ancient Near Eastern data” (Orientalia XLII (1973) (Gelb Volume), pp. 195–211)Google Scholar.

34 Korucutepe II, pp. 68–9, contra J.N.E.S. XXXII (1973), p. 364Google Scholar.

35 E.g. Iraq XXIII (1961), p. 151 and Plate LXXII (figs. 28–30)Google Scholar.

36 (a) Korucutepe II, p. 18; (b) KPP 1971, Pl. 79 (nos. 4–9).

37 Burney, C. A.: “Eastern Anatolia in the Chalcolithic and Early Bronze Age” (A.S. VIII (1958), pp. 157–209), especially 193 ffGoogle Scholar.

38 Korucutepe II, p. 19.

39 A.S. VIII (1958), p. 175Google Scholar.

40 Matthiae, Paolo: Ebla – Un Impero Ritrovato (Turin, 1977), pp. 235–53Google Scholar; and cf. fig. 47 (p. 191).

41 Burney, Charles and Lang, David Marshall: The Peoples of the Hills (London, 1971), pp. 48–51Google Scholar.

42 (a) von Gladiss, Almut and Hauptmann, Harald: “Norşuntepe” (Antike Welt 1974/2, pp. 9–19)Google Scholar; (b) Moulds from Arslantepe: Origini VII (1973), pp. 134–5Google Scholar; (c) Metallurgical remains: Hauptmann, H.: A.S. XXV (1975), p. 37Google Scholar.

43 Iraq XXIV (1962), p. 141Google Scholar; cf. Korucutepe II, p. 93.

44 (a) Korucutepe II, p. 109;(b) see note 30.

45 Wilcox, G. H.: “A history of deforestation as indicated by charcoal analysis of four sites in eastern Anatolia” (A.S. XXIV (1974), pp. 117–33)Google Scholar.

46 Korucutepe I, p. 218.

47 Korucutepe II, p. 23.

48 J.N.E.S. XXXIII (1974), p. 83Google Scholar.

49 Korucutepe II, pp. 47–53.

50 Ibid., p. 28.

51 Esin, U.: A.S. XXV (1975), p. 48Google Scholar.

52 See note 21.

53 Mellaart, James: “A reconciliation of calibrated C-14 dating with the historical chronology of the Near East, with special reference to Anatolia” (paper given at the Sheffield International Colloquium on Aegean Prehistory, April 1980)Google Scholar.

54 Orlin, Louis L.: Assyrian Colonies in Cappadocia (Paris, 1970), pp. 39–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar, with extensive references to earlier literature. But this book dates in effect from 1960.

55 Ozdoǧan, Mehmet: Lower Euphrates Basin 1977 Survey (M.E.T.U.) (Istanbul, 1977)Google Scholar.

56 Kramer, Carol: “Pots and peoples”, in Levine, Louis D. and Young, T. Cuyler (ed.): Mountains and Lowlands: Essays in the Archaeology of Greater Mesopotamia (Malibu, 1977), pp. 91–112Google Scholar.

57 Muhly, J. D.: Copper and Tin (New Haven, Conn., 1973), pp. 199–200, 206 and refsGoogle Scholar.

58 J.N.E.S. XXXII (1973), pp. 371–2Google Scholar.

59 The unpublished material from the writer's 1956 survey is to be published shortly by Mr. Harry Russell.

60 LAR I, 604Google Scholar.

61 Garstang, John and Gurney, O. R.: The Geography of the Hittite Empire (London, 1959), pp. 40–1Google Scholar.

62 Güterbock, H. G.: “Hittite hieroglyphic seal impressions from Korucutepe” (J.N.E.S. XXXII (1973), pp. 135–47)Google Scholar.

63 Korucutepe II, pp. 34–40.

64 Ertem, H.: A.S. XXIV (1974), pp. 38–40Google Scholar.

65 Korucutepe II, p. 39.

66 LAR I, 221Google Scholar.

67 Contra van Loon, : J.N.E.S. XXXII (1973), p. 373Google Scholar.

68 Hauptmann, Harald: “Norşuntepe: historische Geographie und Ergebnisse der Grabungen 1968/69” (Istanbuler Mitteilungen 19/20 (1969/1970), especially pp. 64–74)Google Scholar.

69 Korucutepe I, pp. 228, 230.

70 Ibid., pp. 229–30.

71 Ibid., pp. 29–37.