Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T08:56:58.107Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Xenophobia and Economic Decline: The Haitian Case, 1820-1843

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2015

Robert K. Lacerte
Robert K. Lacerte*
Affiliation:
Whitworth College, Spokane, Washington
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The international situation in which the early Haitian republic found itself between 1820 and 1843 aggravated its internal problems and precipitated its economic decline. The economic structure of the new country had been weakened by the destruction of the colonial sugar plantations during the war of liberation against France (1791-1804). It proved impossible to resurrect these in the republican era, because of the lack of capital and the unwillingness of the ex-slaves to return to plantation life. They wanted property of their own, and this insistence forced successive governments to distribute land to them. Only Henri Christophe, who ruled the North as a kingdom (1806-1820), succeeded in maintaining the old system through forced labor; an experiment which died with him. Dramatic as these changes were, however, they were not sufficient to prevent the resurgence of a new economy based on coffee; a crop which was well suited to peasant cultivation. The shift towards coffee exports had begun in the last years of the colonial era and accelerated in the years after 1804. An economy of smallholders engaged in the cultivation of coffee and provisions existing alongside the remaining plantations could have provided a modest foundation for economic growth. Alexandre Pétion, the first president of Haiti (1806-1818), had envisioned this possibility and it was one of the reasons which he gave for carrying out the first land reform in Latin America. Haiti was a major exporter of coffee in the first half of the nineteenth century, and there were a number of foreign merchants already present in the country to purchase the crop. Instead of economic prosperity, the years after 1820 witnessed an economic decline which made the first black nation virtually ungovernable after 1843 save by the rule of caudillos.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Americas , Volume 37 , Issue 4 , April 1981 , pp. 499 - 515
Copyright
Copyright © Academy of American Franciscan History 1981

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Lacerte, Robert K., “The First Land Reform in Latin America: the Reforms of Alexandre Pétion, 1809–1814,” Inter-American Economic Affairs (March, 1975), 77–85.Google Scholar

2 There were twenty-four merchant houses in Port-au-Prince in 1818. New York Public Library, Hearne Papers. Similar figures for the second city, Cap-Henri (Cap-Haitien), are unavailable, but British property there was valued at $1,041,000 in 1811. Great Britain, Admiralty 1/262, March 12, 1811.

3 de Saint-Remy, M. R. Lepelletier, Saint-Domingue (2 vols.; Paris, 1846), 2, 8.Google Scholar

4 Janvier, Louis-Joseph, Les Constitutions d’Haiti (Paris, 1886), p. 52.Google Scholar

5 Debien, Gabriel, Etudes Antillaise (Paris, 1956), p. 38.Google Scholar

6 This Constitution and its predecessor, the short-lived Imperial Constitution of 1805, tried to underwrite some social planning including the abolition of slavery, the encouragement of marriage, the legalization of divorce, and the provision of education.

7 Joachim, Bénoit, “Commerce et décolonisation: L’expérience franco-haitienne au XIX siècle,” Annales, 27 (novembre-décembre, 1972), 1498.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

8 “Correspondence entre A. Pétion et M. Esmangart,“ Almanach Rèpublicain (Port-au-Prince, 1817), 43–70.

9 British Museum, Clarkson Papers Add. 41266, Terms offered to Hati in 1816.

10 Joachim, 1498

11 Great Britain, Foreign Office 34/4 “C. Mackenzie to G. Canning, September 9, 1826.”

12 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/18 Memorandum on the expediency of renewing negotiations for the Commercial Treaty between Great Britain and Hayti, October, 1836. Hereafter cited as Memorandum.

13 Ibid.

14 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/5 “C. Mackenzie to G. Canning, January 17, 1827.”

15 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/1 “J. B. Inginac to G. Canning, December 26, 1826.”

16 Great Britain, Admiralty 1/253 Cathcart’s Report, August 1803.

17 British Museum, Clarkson Papers Add. 41266“T. Clarkson to King Henri Christophe, June 28, 1819.”

18 The Times (London), January 4, 1815.

19 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/2 “G. Canning to C. Mackenzie, January 18, 1827.”

20 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/20 Draft of a commercial treaty with Great Britain, and Captain Courtenay’s comments.

21 “G. Canning to Lord Granville, July 6, 1825,” Webster, Charles K., ed., Britain and the Independence of Latin America (2 vols.; Oxford, 1938), 2, 185.Google Scholar

22 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/14 “Captain Courtenay to Lord Palmerston, July 2, 1832.”

23 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/ 17 “W. Ussherto Lord Palmerston, November 12,1837.” That year, for instance, British exports to Haiti were valued at £365,798 only a little behind Mexico, £402,820, and Peru, £441,324, but ahead of Colombia, £132,242.

24 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/2 “G. Canning to C. Mackenzie, January 18, 1826.” 35/18 Memorandum. 35/8 “C. Mackenzie to the Earl of Aberdeen, July 18, 1828.”

25 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/10 “J. Fisher to the Earl of Dudley, January 8, 1828.”

26 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/10 “H. Thompson to A. Backhouse, May 12, 1828.” 35/4 “C. Mackenzie to G. Canning, November 6, 1826.” 35/10 “J. Fisher to the Earl of Dudley, January 8, 1828.”

27 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/2 Memorandum … respecting Hayti, October 14, 1826.

28 Code Rural (Port-au-Prince, 1826).

29 Great Britain, Admiralty 1/253 A short sketch of the situation and mutation of the Negroes during a short space of twelve years of their revolt from January I, 1792 to December 31, 1803. Hereafter cited as A short sketch. Observations sur la necessité et les moyens de recouvrer et restaurer la colonie française de Saint-Domingue. 23 octobre 1801. University of Florida, Rochambeau Papers, No. 81.

30 Franklin, James, The Present State of Hayti (London, 1828), p. 379.Google Scholar The chronic drain caused by military expenditures can be illustrated from a typical budget, that of 1837. That year revenues were $2,082,522, expenditures were $2,713,102 of which $ 1,612,293 were spent on the military. Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/20 Tableau des récettes et dépenses … pendant l’année 1837 (Port-au-Prince, 1937).

31 A short sketch.

32 Aristide, Achille, Quelques aspects du problème de la population en Haiti (Port-au-Prince, 1955), p. 53.Google Scholar The figure of 715,500 given by Franklin (p. 404) is almost certainly too high.

33 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/4 “C. Mackenzie to G. Canning, September 9, 1826.”

34 Le Temps (Port-au-Prince), 26 mai 1842.

35 Ibid., 18 aôut 1842.

36 Mackenzie, Charles, Notes on Haiti (2 vols.; London, 1830), 2, 159. Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/4 “C. Mackenzie to G. Canning, October 3, 1826,” 35/9 “J. Lister to the Earl of Dudley, April 18, 1828.”Google Scholar

37 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/20 Tableau des réceltes et dépenses… pendant l’année 1837.

38 Haiti, , Loi sur les patentes, 1832.Google Scholar

39 Le Télégraphe (Port-au-Prince), 5 janvier 1840.

40 Haiti, , Loi sur les patentes, 1837.Google Scholar

41 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/19 “Captain Courtenay to Lord Palmerston, January 26, 1937.”

42 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/25 “W. Ussher to Lord Aberdeen, September 10, 1842.”

43 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/19 “Captain Courtenay to Lord Palmerston, April 18, 1837.”

44 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/25 “W. Ussher to Lord Aberdeen, March 5, 1842.” The Haitian coin was an amalgam of silver (93.5 per cent) and copper (94.5 per cent). 35/16 Return of the Amalgam of the Haytian Coin Shewing the Quantity of Alloy.

45 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/17 Returns for the years 1834 and 1836.

46 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/19 “W. Ussher to Lord Palmerston, June 12, 1837.” 35/23 “Captain Courtenay to Lord Palmerston, June 10, 1840.”

47 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/19 “W. Ussher to Lord Palmerston, Octobre 5, 1837.”

48 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/20 “W. Ussher to Lord Palmerston, February 5, 1838.”

49 Le Phare (Port-au-Prince), 17 février 1831.

50 Ibid., 24 février 1831.

51 Ibid.

52 Ibid., 3 mars 1831.

53 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/20 “W. Ussher to Lord Palmerston, April 30, 1838.”

54 Le Manifeste (Port-au-Prince), 19 décembre 1841.

55 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/20 “W. Ussher to Lord Palmerston, October 8, 1838.”

56 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/26 “W. Ussher to Lord Aberdeen, March 12, 1843.”

57 Haiti, , Décret qui accorde l’établissement des maisons de consignation aux étrangers sans avoir besoin d’obtenir préalablement une licence, 14 juin 1843.Google Scholar

58 Great Britain, Foreign Office 35/26 “W. Ussher to the Earl of Aberdeen, August 19, 1843.”