Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T23:38:42.892Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Matter of Faith: North America's Religion and South America's Independence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2015

William Gribbin
William Gribbin*
Affiliation:
Washington, D. C.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

For the last several decades, scholars concerned with America's foreign relations have paid increasing attention to public opinion, to national images, to the ties between domestic politics and international events. And because contemporary American diplomacy seems entangled in webs of mass behavior, the same wisdom has been applied to earlier times to investigate the way foreign policy has sometimes been an extension of passions and forces from the country's street corners, kitchen tables, and church pews. In this regard, great attention has lately been paid to American stereotypes of the Orient, as sages attempt to find in age-old popular attitudes the reasons for enduring problems of statecraft. Inasmuch as public interest shifts from one area of crisis to the next with each morning's headlines, it should be useful to examine, for areas other than the Far East, how the methods and goals of American diplomacy have been influenced or shaped, sometimes thwarted or transformed, by a kind of people's diplomacy growing out of the limited knowledge and unrestrained emotions of the man in the street.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Americas , Volume 31 , Issue 4 , April 1975 , pp. 470 - 487
Copyright
Copyright © Academy of American Franciscan History 1975

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For example, Solnick, Bruce, “American Opinion Concerning the Spanish-American Wars of Independence, 1808–1824” (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, New York University, 1960).Google Scholar

2 Andros, Thomas, The Place of the Church on the Grand Chart of Scripture Prophecy, or the Great Battle of Armageddon (Boston, 1814), 34–38.Google Scholar The exegetical confusion can be traced in a review of Smith’s, Ethan Dissertation on the Prophecies Relative to Antichrist and the Last Times in Panoplist, 4 (June 1811), 32–38 Google Scholar; (July 1811), 75–84. The application of Revelation to international events is more fully treated in Gribbin, William, The Churches Militant: The War of 1812 and American Religion (New Haven, 1973), 40–77.Google Scholar

3 King, Charles (ed.), The Life and Correspondence of Rufus King (New York, 1894), 2, 519.Google Scholar

4 Quoted by Taylor, Georgia, “The Early History of the Episcopal Church in New Orleans, 1805–1840,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly, 22 (1939), 430.Google Scholar

5 William Shaler’s report to Monroe, August 18, 1812 in Lockey, Joseph, “An Early Pan-American Scheme,” Pacific Historical Review, 2 (1933), 445 Google Scholar; Stewart, Watt, “The South American Commission, 1817–1818,” American Historical Review, 9 (1929), 48 Google Scholar; Niles’ Weekly Register, June 20,1818.

6 Whitaker, Arthur, The United States and the Independence of Latin America 1800–1830 (New York, 1962), 145–46Google Scholar. See also the accusation that an opponent of American acquisition of West Florida was a “Defender of the Faith,” in Richmond Enquirer, January 29,1811.

7 Griffin, Charles, The United States and the Disruption of the Spanish Empire, 1810–1822 (New York, 1968), 160.Google Scholar

8 United States Catholic Miscellany, IV (June 15, 1825), 378.

9 Griffin, , Disruption of the Spanish Empire, 62.Google Scholar

10 Ibid., 134; Adams, Charles F., Memoirs of John Quincy Adams (Freeport, N. Y., 1969), 5, 325 Google Scholar; Hunt, Gaillard (ed.), The Writings of James Madison (New York, 1910), 9, 155.Google Scholar

11 Cappon, Lester J. (ed.), The Adams-Jefferson Letters, 1812–1826 (Chapel Hill, 1959), 484–85,494, 523–24, 570.Google Scholar

12 Whitaker, , Independence of Latin America, 188.Google Scholar

13 Richmond Enquirer, July 16, 1811; July 10, 13, 1816; Charleston Courier, March 17, 1825.

14 Bornholdt, Laura, Baltimore and Early Pan-Americanism (Northampton, 1949), 21.Google Scholar

15 Christian Register, December 19,1823.

16 Andros, , The Place of the Church, 22.Google Scholar

17 Vanpelt, Peter, A Discourse, delivered on the Fourth of July, in the North Brick Church (New York, 1812), 12 Google Scholar; Baltimore Whig in the Richmond Enquirer, May 14, 1811.

18 Essex Register in Richmond Enquirer, March 8, 1811.

19 This is not a distortion of the view of journals like the New-England Missionary Magazine,I (1815), 18–21.

20 Rutland Herald, August 25, 1813; Farmer’s Repository, August 26, 1813; Savannah Evening Ledger, November 19, 1814; Baltimore Patriot, October 8, 1814; Niles’ Weekly Register, October 22, 1814.

21 For examples, see Centinel of Freedom, December 13, 1814; Albany Argus, December 23, 1814.

22 Niles’ Weekly Register, March 4, 1815; Herald of Gospel Liberty, June 19, 1812; Massachusetts Baptist Missionary Magazine, III (September 1812), 196; Romeyn, John B., “The Duty of America in the Present Crisis,” Sermons (New York, 1816), 363.Google Scholar

23 Richmond Enquirer, September 9, 12, 23, 1817.

24 United States Catholic Miscellany, November 16, 1825.

25 Niks’ Weekly Register, March 28, 1812; Rutland Herald, February 12, 1812.

26 American Advocate, August 14, 1813; Military Monitor and American Register, May 10, 1813.

27 Abolition Intelligencer and Missionary Magazine, I (September 1822), 69.

28 Boston Masonic Mirror, November 27, 1824; December 31, 1825.

29 Christian Herald, VIII (October 1825), 126; Boston Recorder, November 15, 1823; December 30, 1825; Christian Advocate, III (April 1825), 191.

30 Utica Christian Magazine, I (March 1814), 351.

31 Under its various titles, the Panoplist was especially rich in this regard. See Cuban material, XX (September and November 1824), 286–90, 352–55.

32 Christian Disciple and Theological Review, V (March 1823), 146.

33 Christian Magazine, I (January 1824), 32; Boston Recorder, December 27, 1823; December 9, 1825.

34 Christian Advocate, II (May 1824), 240.

35 Vermont Evangelical Magazine, VI (August 1814), 252-53; Boston Recorder, January 3, 1824.

36 Christian Secretary, April 6,1822.

37 Christian Monitor and Religious Intelligencer, March 6,1813.

38 Quoted in Kane, Harnet, Queen New Orleans (New Orleans, 1949), 10.Google Scholar

39 Wyllys, Rufus, “The East Florida Revolution of 1812–1814,” Hispanic American His-torical Review, 9 (1929), 425, 431.Google Scholar

40 Padgett, James (ed.), “The Constitution of the West Florida Republic,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly, 20 (1937), 893.Google Scholar

41 Taylor, , “Early History of the Episcopal Church,” 432–33.Google Scholar

42 Christian Advocate, II (November 1824), 520 25.

43 Richmond Enquirer, Junt 18, 1811.

44 Griffin, , Disruption of the Spanish Empire, 66.Google Scholar

45 United States Catholic Miscellany, October 6, 1824.

46 Butler, Frederick, A Catechetical Compend of General History (Hartford, 1819), 115 Google Scholar quoted in Sr.Fell, Marie Leonore, The Foundations of Nativism in American Textbooks, 1783–1860 (Washington,D.C., 1941), 102.Google Scholar

47 Robertson, William, Hispanic-American Relations with the United States (New York, 1969), 298.Google Scholar Samuel F. Bemis rightly linked early missionary activity in South Amer-ica with the modern involvement there of educational and humanitarian foundations. He saw the relationship as a proud heritage, but there are other ways to interpret the kinship. The Latin American Policy of the United States (New York, 1943 ), 316, 390.

48 Christian Advocate I (February 1823), 96; II (November 1824), 520.

49 Christian Disciple and Theological Review, I (August 1813), 127.

50 Panoplist, V (June 1812), 3; Vermont Evangelical Magazine, V (February 1813), 58; Connecticut Evangelical Magazine, V (February 1812), 51.

51 Onderdonk, Henry, “A Sermon delivered before the New York Protestant Episcopal Missionary Society,” in Christian Journal and Literary Register, 9 (February 1825), 43.Google Scholar

52 American Baptist Magazine, I (May 1818), 330.

53 Columbian Star, July 19, 1823.

54 Johnston, Henry (ed.), The Correspondence and Public Papers of John Jay (New York, 1893), 4, 485.Google Scholar

55 Bornholdt, , Baltimore and Early Pan-Americanism, 13.Google Scholar

56 Boston Recorder, July 1, 1825.

57 American Baptist Magazine, I (September 1817), 178; Massachusetts Baptist Missionary Magazine, IV (March 1815), 136–37.

58 Evangelical Guardian and Review, I (September 1817), 239.

59 Ibid., 235.

60 Boston Recorder and Telegraph, January 15, 1825.

61 Christian Secretary, July 13, 1824; Christian Advocate, II (December 1824), 575.

62 American Baptist Magazine, V (December 1825), 382. Although there were local missionary societies all over the country, the lists of donations recorded in denominational periodicals indicate that evangelical interest in Latin America was, not surprisingly, greatest in the southern states. New Englanders directed their contributions as well to the Orient, especially Burma.

63 Charleston Courier in Christian Register, October 12, 1821; Aurora in Christian Secretary, June 15, 1824; Christian Advocate, II (February 1824), 94; Philadelphia Recorder in Christian Secretary, March 28, 1825.

64 Halcyon Luminary and Theological Repository, I (October 1812), 443.

65 New York Telescope in Christian Herald, November 4, 1824; December 4, 1823.

66 Aurora in Niles’ Weekly Register, June 27, 1818; Columbian Star, November 22, 1823.

67 Whitaker, , Independence of Latin America, 413.Google Scholar

68 Boston Recorder, December 25, 1824.

69 Atlantic Magazine, I (October 1824), 467; Webster, Daniel, The Works of Daniel Webster (Boston, 1853), 3, 216 Google Scholar; Christian Advocate, III (April 1825), 240.

70 United States Catholic Miscellany, October 26, 1825.

71 Christian Secretary, April 13, 1824; Boston Recorder, December 23, 30, 1825; Christian Advocate, III (December 1825), 575.

72 United States Catholic Miscellany, October 27, November 3, 1824.

73 Moseley, Edward, “The Religious Impact of the American Occupation of Mexico City, 1847–1848,” Militarists, Merchants, and Missionaries, ed. Huck, Eugene and Moseley, Edward (University, Alabama, 1970), 47.Google Scholar One might argue that, as the Catholic Church in the United States has become more Protestant in a cultural sense, it too has adopted the attitudes of the Yankee mission. Thus the revolutionary activities of certain Catholic missionaries in Guatemala and elsewhere can be interpreted, not as a radical break from their own ecclesiastical traditions, but as an ironically conservative affirmation of an old orthodoxy among American religionists.

74 Chaplains’ letters quoted in Greer, Harold, “Southern Baptists in Cuba, 1886–1916,” Ibid., 67–68.Google Scholar

75 Whitaker, Arthur, The United States and South America, the Northern Republics (Cambridge, 1948), 233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

76 American Baptist Magazine, I (September 1818), 413.

77 Bowden, John, Observations by a Protestant, on a Profession of Catholic Faith by a Clergytnan of Baltimore (New York, 1816), 3.Google Scholar

78 Evangelical Witness, II (October 1823), 139.

79 Southern Intelligencer in United States Catholic Miscellany, June 19, 1822.

80 Christian Secretary, February 24, June 8, 1824.

81 Christian Secretary, July 22, 1825; Evangelical Witness, II (October 1823), 139; Christian Register, October 10, 1823.