Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T11:44:37.971Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Continuity or Change: A Comparative Study of the Composition of the Cabildos in Seville, Tenerife, and Lima

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2015

Ellen Douglas Howell
Ellen Douglas Howell*
Affiliation:
University of Houston, Houston, Texas
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

An affinity for urban living has frequently been cited as one of the peculiar characteristics or long standing traditions of the Spanish people. Whether one accepts the existence of medieval Iberian cities as a heritage from the Roman municipium or as a necessary defensive establishment against the attacks of the Moors, it is evident that town life was flourishing in the Middle Ages. Municipal governments were formed to administer the communities, and as new towns were captured or created, the old models of organization were carried with the expanding frontier. In Castile the local councils were called concejos or cabildos and until the fourteenth century were often elective, representative institutions with increasing influence and power. But from the reign of Alfonso XI (1312-1350) their strength began to wane as the Castilian kings attempted to control their domains by appointing local officials and dispatching royal agents to work with them. By the sixteenth century the success of the centralizing methods was evident, for the municipal councils had become virtually the tools of the Castilian Crown.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Americas , Volume 24 , Issue 1 , July 1967 , pp. 33 - 45
Copyright
Copyright © Academy of American Franciscan History 1967

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 María Font, José y Rius, , “Les Villes dans l’Espagne du Moyen Age,” Recueils de la Societé Jean Bodin, VI (1954), 274 Google Scholar; Dyer, Lois Katherine, “History of the Cabildo of Mexico City, 1524–1534,” Louisiana Historical Quarterly, VI (July, 1923), 402.Google Scholar

2 Dyer, pp. 410–411.

3 For a sampling, see Moore, John Preston, The Cabildo in Peru under the Hapsburgs (Durham, 1954)Google Scholar; Bayle, Constantino, Los cabildos seculares en la América española (Madrid, 1952)Google Scholar; Capdequí, José María Ots, “Apuntes para la historia del municipio hispanoamericano del periodo colonial,” Anuario de la historia del derecho español, IV (1927), 225–297 Google Scholar; Kirkpatrick, F.A., “Municipal Administration in the Spanish Dominions in America,” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 3rd Series, IX (1915), 95–109 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Garfield Jones, O., “Local Government in the Spanish Colonies as provided by the Recopilación de las Leyes de los Reynos de las Indias,” Southwestern Historical Quarterly, XIX (July, 1915), 65–90.Google Scholar

4 For brief descriptions and further source material, see Carlo, Agustín Millares, Notas bibliográficas acerca de archivos municipales, ediciones de libros de acuerdo y colecciones de documentos concejiles (Madrid, 1952), pp. 46–54, 132–136.Google Scholar

5 Bleye, Pedro Aguado, Manual de Historia de España (3 vols.; 6th ed. rev.; Madrid, 1947-1956), II, 193 Google Scholar. Concerning the early adelantados, see Cunningham, Charles H., “The Institutional Background of Spanish American History,” Hispanic American Historical Review, I (February, 1918), 28–29.Google Scholar

6 Las Ordenanzas de Sevilla (1527), p. 40, hereafter cited as Ordenanzas.

7 October 20, 1497, Acuerdos del Cabildo de Tenerife (2 vols.; La Laguna de Tenerife, 1949–1952), I, 3, hereafter cited as Acuerdos. October 20, 1511, March 21, 1513, Acuerdos, II, 127, 180.

8 There were originally sixty Spanish settlers in Lima. Of these, thirty came from Jauja and eighteen from the seaport of San Gallan, Markham, Clements R., A History of Peru (Chicago, 1892), p. 90.Google Scholar

9 November 17, 1534, January 17, 1535, March 11, 1535, December 24, 1535, Libros de Cabildos de Lima (20 vols.; Lima, 1935–1961), I, 3, 15, 19, 65, hereafter cited as Libros; Cobo, Bernabé, Fundación de Lima (1639), Biblioteca de Autores Españoles (191 vols.; Madrid, 1864-1965), XCII, 293–294 Google Scholar; Aguado Bleye, II, 870.

10 Chamberlain, Robert S., “The Corregidor in Castile in the Sixteenth Century and the Residencia as Applied to the Corregidor,” Hispanic American Historical Review, XXIII (May, 1943), 240, n. 37.Google Scholar

11 Ordenanzas, pp. 12–13; Mongado, Alfonso, Historia de Sevilla (1581) (Sevilla, 1887), p. 62 Google Scholar; de Sedas, Santiago Montoto, Sevilla en el imperio (siglo XVI) (Sevilla, 1938), pp. 54–55 Google Scholar; Aguado Bleye, II, 192–193. For a general study of the Spanish corregidor, see Albi, Fernando, El corregidor en el municipio español bajo la monarquía absoluta (Madrid, 1943)Google Scholar.

12 January 3, 1536, Libros, I, 80; November 21, 1545, Libros, II, 112.

13 August 9, 1549, December 31, 1549 (1550), January 1, 1550, Libros, III, 158–160, 219–220, 225–227. The date December 31, 1549, reads December 31, 1550, in the cabildo minutes because the new year began on Christmas Day, cf. Poole, Reginald L., “The Beginning of the Year in the Middle Ages,” Proceedings of the British Academy, X (1921-1923), 137 Google Scholar. For further details on the corregidor, see Castañeda, Carlos Eduardo, “The Corregidor in Spanish Colonial Administration,” Hispanic American Historical Review, IX (November, 1929), 449–465 Google Scholar.

14 de Ayala, José Peraza and de Vallabriga, Rodrigo, “Los antiguos cabildos de las Islas Canarias,” Anuario de historia del derecho español, IV (1927), 244 Google Scholar. In general, this article contains little material on the early period.

15 September 28, 1508, Acuerdos, II, 18.

16 Ordenanzas, p. 8.

17 Morgado, p. 60. See Cunningham, pp. 31–32; Montoto de Sedas, pp. 58–59.

18 December 29, 1536 (1537), Libros, I, 118. Compare with the election described in Francisco Domínguez Compañy, “Municipal Organization of the Rancherías of Pearls,” The Americas, XXI (July, 1964), 64 Google Scholar. On the alcalde ordinario in Peru, see Kahle, Louis G., “The Spanish Colonial Judiciary,” Southwestern Social Science Quarterly, XXXII (June, 1951), 26–28.Google Scholar

19 Ordenanzas, p. 50.

20 April 22, 1513, Acuerdos, II, 191. The alcalde ordinario in smaller villages was often the presiding officer in the local cabildo.

21 Priestley, Herbert Ingram, “Spanish Colonial Municipalities,” California Law Review (September, 1919)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, reprinted in the Louisiana Historical Quarterly, V (April, 1922), 128.

22 Morgado, p. 61, stated that originally there were thirty-six regidores, but Alfonso XI reduced their number to twenty-four, hence their name. Subsequent figures are diverse. Montoto de Sedas, p. 62, said that in the mid-sixteenth century in Seville there were thirty-six regidores, and Pike, Ruth accepts his figures, “The Sevillian Nobility and Trade with the New World in the Sixteenth Century,” Business History Review, XXXIX (Winter, 1965), 441, n. 14Google Scholar; Altamira, Rafael y Crevea, , Historia de España y de la civilización española (4 vols.; 3rd ed. rev.; Barcelona, 1913-1914), III, 265 Google Scholar, placed their number at eighty-three, whereas Morgado, p. 61, wrote in 1587 that there were more than sixty regidores in the cabildo.

23 Pike, “Sevillian Nobility and Trade,” p. 441.

24 October 20, 1497, Acuerdos, I, 3.

25 Peraza de Ayala, p. 252, n. 53.

26 September 1, 1512, Acuerdos, II, 158.

27 November 9, 1513, Acuerdos, II, 211. Although King Ferdinand was serving as regent for his daughter, mentally deranged Juana of Castile, the Acuerdos speak of Queen Juana as naming the regidores.

28 December 2, 1513, Acuerdos, II, 213.

29 November 12, 1513, Acuerdos, II, 212.

30 Royal cédula of May 4, 1534, The Harkness Collection in the Library of Congress, Documents from Early Peru, 1531–1518 (Washington, D.C, 1936), p. 134.Google Scholar

31 The veedor and tesorero had royal grants entitling them to membership in the cabildo in Tumbes, which was thought to be the principal city and the residence of the governor. However, since Pizarro was residing in Lima, the officials thought their grants should apply to that city’s cabildo. Pizarro agreed to let them sit with the council until further orders could be received from the Crown, and within a year their positions as perpetual regidores were confirmed. Bernabé Cobo, pp. 296–298; March 11, 1535, January 3, 1536, Libros, I, 19, 81.

32 December 24, 1535, Libros, I, 65; Kirkpatrick, pp. 101–103.

33 December 29, 1536 (1537), December 9, 1538, Libros, I, 118, 258; January 17, 1550, Libros, III, 237.

34 Ordenanzas, pp. 13–15. See Pike, Ruth, “Seville in the Sixteenth Century,” Hispanic American Historical Review, XLI (February, 1961), 19 Google Scholar; Morgado, p. 60; Montoto de Sedas, pp. 56–57.

35 February 12, 1507, Acuerdos, I, 150; June 8, 1509, Acuerdos, II, 35; Peraza de Ayala, p. 258.

36 September 29, 1535, May 11, 1537, Libros, I, 52, 146–147; January 21, 1549, Libros, III, 53.

37 Ordenanzas, pp. 13, 46, 48–50. Morgado, p. 62, said there was a seventh fiel ejecutor, a lieutenant of the asistente. Concerning the origins of the fiel ejecutor, see Carande, Ramón, “Sevilla, fortaleza y mercado: algunas instituciones de la ciudad, en el siglo XIV especialmente, estudiadas en sus privilegios, ordenamientos y cuentas,” Anuario de la historia del derecho español, II (1925), 321–326.Google Scholar

38 April 6, 1500, January 10, 1502, Acuerdos, I, 29, 43.

39 Appendix 2, Acuerdos, II, 228–229.

40 Peraza de Ayala, p. 248.

41 September 29, 1535, Libros, I, 49–50; July 18, 1544, Libros, II, 89.

42 January 3, 1536, March 11, 1535, Libros, I, 81, 91.

43 December 29, 1536 (1537), Libros, I, 117; September 27, 1544, Libros, II, 107.

44 Ordenanzas, p. 30.

45 There is an example as early as 1512 of the purchase of the office of jurado, Pike, “Sevillian Nobility and Trade,” p. 458.

46 In 1552, they numbered fifty-six, ibid., p. 441, n. 14. Ordenanzas, pp. 15–17; Morgado, p. 61; Montoto de Sedas, pp. 63–64. For historical background of the jurado in Seville, see Carande, p. 325.

47 October 20, 1497, Acuerdos, I, 3.

48 September 17, 1508, September 18, 1508, August 17, 1509, Acuerdos, II, 14–15, 41.

49 July 7, 1544, Libros, II, 86.

50 August 17, 1509, Acuerdos, II, 41; Peraza de Ayala, p. 257.

51 November 9, 1506, Acuerdos, I, 132; March 21, 1513, December 9, 1513, Acuerdos, II, 180, 214–216; Morgado, pp. 62–63.; Malagón-Barceló, Javier, “The Role of the Letrado in the Colonization of America,” The Americas, XVIII (July, 1961), 12 Google Scholar.