No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Between Rosas and Sarmiento: Notes on Nationalism in Peronist Thought
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 December 2015
Extract
Despite its crucial importance to the development of twentieth century Argentina and the volumes of scholarly, journalistic and partisan exegesis the movement has generated, historians have yet to reach a minimal consensus on the nature of Peronism. In the quarter century since Perón's first fall from power, numerous efforts have been made to explain, glorify or denigrate his regime. Many anti-Peronists have dismissed their bête noire as an unprincipled demagogue, motivated solely by political opportunism and an insatiable desire to retain power. Some supporters of the regime echo its propaganda by picturing Perón as taking the first great strides toward a politically free, economically independent and socially just Argentina. Certain anti-Peronists and a number of foreign commentators grudgingly admit that the movement had political and ideological content, but then label it as an imported fascist interlude, an alien virus that infected the body politic of Argentina just as it neared the end of the long march towards liberal democracy. The London Economist recently described the advent of Peronism as an instant replay of Italian Fascism. “The bulk of his supporters were the lower middle class immigrants who poured into the country from impoverished Italy after the second world war… The new arrivals cheered El Lider as they had cheered Il Duce for two decades. Perón representated the same historical phenomenon as Hitler and Mussolini…”
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Academy of American Franciscan History 1983
References
1 Anonymous, Libro negro de la segunda tiranía (Buenos Aires, 1958); Zinney, Eduardo Sánchez, El culto de la infamia. Historia documentada de la segunda tiranía Argentina (Buenos Aires, 1958).Google Scholar
2 Hernández Arregui, Juan José, La formación de la conciencia nacional (Buenos Aires, 1970).Google Scholar
3 Harvey, Robert, “Poor Little Rich Boy. Argentina: a Survey,” The Economist, 26 January 1980, p. 7.Google Scholar
4 Among the most notable contributions are Blanksten, George, Perón’s Argentina (Chicago, 1953)Google Scholar; Fayt, Carlos S., ed., La naturaleza del peronismo (Buenos Aires, 1967)Google Scholar; Potash, Robert, The Army and politics in Argentina (Stanford, 1969)Google Scholar; Alejandro, Carlos F. Diaz, Essays on the Economic History of the Argentine Republic (New Haven, 1970)Google Scholar; Waldman, Peter, Der Peronismus, 1943–1955 (Hamburg, 1974).Google Scholar
5 The view endorsed by Germani, Gino in Authoritarianism, Fascism and National Populism (New Brunswick, 1978).Google Scholar
6 The conclusions of this article are tentative and not based on a comprehensive survey of all Peronist literature. Many of Perón’s speeches and most of his writings from 1943 to 1953 have been examined. This includes material directed to the nation at large, the military, Peronist militants, workers and a variety of interest and professional groups. This documentation has been supplemented by Eva Perón’s statements, the writings of Peronist propagandists of divergent political origins and trajectories, and the regime’s official publications. These sources, while by no means exhaustive, reflect a reasonable cross-section of Peronist attitudes. Nevertheless, certain gaps should be noted. The Peronist popular press, especially Democracia, could yield significant new data. The most perishable and inaccessible documentation—street pamphlets and intra-party memoranda and publications-has not been available to this author. In addition, local Peronist literature would be invaluable in ascertaining to what extent the regime tailored its appeal to fit regional peculiarities. Due to these at present unavoidable lacunae this article is designed both to stimulate further research and present preliminary findings and hypotheses. Because of Perón’s abrupt shifts in foreign, political, economic and clerical policies after 1953 the final two years of the regime have been largely omitted from this analysis. It is questionable whether these policy changes were accompanied by commensurate changes in the Peronist perception of Argentine nationalism and history; unfortunately sources for the period, both primary and secondary, are as yet too thin to permit any useful speculations on this score.
7 Gino Germani and Peter H. Smith have presented opposing views in the debate over Peronism’s social base. Germani’s latest version is given in the previously cited work. He has sought to refute Smith, in “El surgimiento del peronismo: el rol de los obreros y los migrantes internos,” Desatollo económico 13 (octubre/diciembre 1973), pp. 435–488.Google Scholar Smith, has expressed his view in “Social mobilization, Political Participation, and the Rise of Perón,” Political Science Quarterly 84 (March 1969)CrossRefGoogle Scholar and in “The Social Base of Peronism,” Hispanic American Historical Review 52 (February 1972), pp. 55–73. A brief rebuttal of Germani appeared in Desarollo económico (14 julio/ septiembre, 1974). Walter Little has also made important studies of Peronism’s social base: Little, , “Electoral Aspects of Peronism,” Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs 15 (August 1973), pp. 267–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8 See especially Sarmiento’s, “Quinta carta a Don Rafael Minvielle,” Gaceta de Comercio, Santiago, 28 October 1843,Google Scholar quoted in Earle, Peter G., Prophet in the Wilderness: The Works of Ezequiel Martinez Estrada (Austin, 1971), p. 47.Google Scholar
9 Sarmiento in Facundo, quoted by Mafud, Julio, Psicologia de la viveza criolla (Buenos Aires, 1971), p. 214.Google Scholar
10 Sarmiento in Garcia, Eduardo Enrique, Radiografía política del general Perón (Buenos Aires, 1946), p. 5.Google Scholar
11 On liberalism see Romero, José Luis, A History of Argentine Political Thought (Stanford, 1963)Google Scholar and Botana, Natalio R., El orden conservador: la política argentina entre 1880y 1916 (Buenos Aires, 1977).Google Scholar
12 Rock, David, “Radical Populism and the Conservative Elite, 1912–1930” in Rock, David, ed., Argentina in the Twentieth Century (Pittsburgh, 1975), pp. 66–88 Google Scholar; Taylor, J.M., Eva Perón: The Myths of a Woman (Chicago, 1980), pp. 30–33.Google Scholar
13 Hernández, José, Martín Fierro, in Mafud, p. 290.Google Scholar
14 Whitaker, Arthur P., and Jordan, David C., Nationalism in Contemporary Latin America (New York, 1966), p. 55.Google Scholar
15 Kroeber, Clifton B., “Rosas and the Revision of Argentine History, 1880–1955,” Inter-American Review of Bibliography, V. 10, No. 1 (January 1960), pp. 3–25.Google Scholar
16 Hansen, Garth M., The Argentine Historical Novel, 1840–1970. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, 1979., pp. 152–153.Google Scholar
17 Gerassi, Marysa Navarro, Los nacionalistas (Buenos Aires, 1968), pp. 133–135.Google Scholar
18 See Perón’s, Eva, comments in Evita by Evita: Eva Duarte Perón Tells Her Own Story. (London, 1978), pp. 15–16,Google Scholar 77.
19 Conde, Roberto Cortés, “Partidos Políticos,” in Paita, Jorge A, ed., Argentina, 1930–1960 (Buenos Aires, 1961), pp. 146–147.Google Scholar
20 Germani, , Authoritarianism, pp. 166–170.Google Scholar
21 Ibid., p. 188.
22 Ibid., p. 170 and Scobie, James R., Argentina, A City anda Nation (New York, 1970), p. 248.Google Scholar
23 Ibid, p. 175.
24 Smith, “Social Base,” passim.
25 Ibid, p. 63.
26 Libro Negro, passim.
27 Sánchez Zinney, pp. 40, 91.
28 Ibid, p. 99.
29 Blanksten, p. 230.
30 Taylor, p. 30.
31 Anonymous, Synthetic History of the Argentine Republic (Buenos Aires, 1950), passim.
32 Perón, Juan, Discursos del Excmo. Sr. Presidente de la nación General Perón dirigidas a las fuerzas armadas, 1946–1951 (Buenos Aires, 1951)Google Scholar; Synthetic, pp. 16–17.
33 Babler, Luis, La nación Argentina: justa, libre, soberana (Buenos Aires, 1950), pp. 15–17.Google Scholar
34 Synthetic, p. 53.
35 Evita by Evita, p. 37.
36 Ibid., p. 53.
37 Babler, pp. 15–27.
38 Ibid., p. 26.
39 Perón, Juan, Discurso del Presidente de la nación Argentina General Juan Perón pronunciado durante la visita de los delegados al Congreso General Constituyente del Partido Peronista (Buenos Aires, 1947),Google Scholar np.
40 Eduardo, p. 7.
41 Babler, p. 7.
42 Molina, Horacio Rega, Proyección social del Martín Fierro (Buenos Aires, 1950), pp. 27.Google Scholar
43 Blanksten, p. 187
44 Perón, Juan, Discurso del Presidente de la nación Argentina General Perón. Pronunciado en el acto de homenaje tributado por las universidades argentinas al otorgársele el título de doctor “honoris causis” por su obra en favor de la cultura nacional (Buenos Aires, 1947).Google Scholar
45 Perón, Juan, Había Perón (Buenos Aires, 1951), p. 224.Google Scholar
46 Perón, Juan, Conferencia del Ecmo. Sr. Pres. Gral. Juan Perón. Pronunciada en el acto de clausura del Primer Congreo Nacional de Filosofía (Buenos Aires, 1948),Google Scholar passim.
47 Perón, Juan, Perón Expounds his Doctrine (Buenos Aires, 1948), p. 227.Google Scholar
48 Babler, pp. 239–253.
49 Navarro, p. 124.
50 Ibid., p. 125.
51 Perón Expounds, p. 18.
52 Perón, Juan, Discurso del Presidente de la nación Juan Perón. Pronunciada en la Academia Argentina de Letras con motivo del día de la raza, y come homenaje en memoria de Don Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra en el cuarto centenario de su nacimiento (Buenos Aires, 1947), p. 31.Google Scholar
53 Perón, Juan, Discurso … Nacional, p. 25.Google Scholar
54 Ibid., p. 47.
55 Perón, , Discurso … nacimiento, p. 8.Google Scholar
56 Blanksten, p. 236.
51 Ibid., p. 230.
58 Eva Perón, pp. 22, 26, 99, 145.
59 Blanksten, p. 235.
60 Taylor, p. 107
61 Eva Perón, p. 173.
62 Taylor, pp. 121–123.
63 Ibid., p. 115.
64 Perón, Juan, Teoría y práctica de la liberación económica, social y política de la República (Buenos Aires, 1949), p. 15.Google Scholar
65 Perón, Juan, Conducción política (Buenos Aires, 1973), p. 177.Google Scholar
66 Ibid., p. 38.
67 Ibid., p. 294.
68 Ibid., p. 32.
69 Ibid., pp. 54, 85.
70 Perón Expounds, p. 80.
71 See Perón, , Teoría y práctica, pp. 60–61 Google Scholar and the extracts in Peña, Milciades, ed., El Peronismo: selección de documentos para la historia (Buenos Aires, 1973), pp. 107–9.Google Scholar
72 Zuleta, Enrique, El nacionalismo argentino (Buenos Aires, 1975), pp. 512–13.Google Scholar
73 Hernández Arregui, pp. 278–281.
74 Perón Expounds, pp. 24, 46–47, 179; Juan, and de Perón, Eva Duarte, Cabildo abierto del Justicialismo (Buenos Aires, 1951), p. 13.Google Scholar
75 Eva Perón, pp. 6, 58–59, 79–83.
76 Corradi, Juan E., “Between Corporatism and Insurgency: Peronist Ideology,” in Terms of Conflict; Ideology in Latin American Politics, Blachman, Morris J., and Hellman, Ronald G., eds. (Philadelphia, 1977), p. 111.Google Scholar
77 Rock, p. 79 and Germani, , Authoritarianism, p. 142.Google Scholar The comparison with Yrigoyen is tentative as it is based solely on secondary sources. A full scale study of his attitudes on the subjects covered in this article is necessary before anything firm can be ventured on this matter.
78 Taylor, p. 31.