Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T04:28:20.409Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Both Guns and Butter, or Neither: Class Interests in the Political Economy of Rearmament

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 August 2003

KEVIN NARIZNY
KEVIN NARIZNY
Affiliation:
postdoctoral fellow at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, 79 John F. Kennedy Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 ([email protected]).
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

A major rearmament program can have a lasting effect on the balance of political and economic power between societal groups. It will typically require the expansion of progressive taxation and government interference in the economy, both of which are disproportionately harmful to the interests of the upper classes. Consequently, conservative governments that face a sharp increase in international threat should be more likely than their leftist counterparts to try to substitute alliances and appeasement for arms. I test this hypothesis on Great Britain in 1895–1905, 1907–14, and 1931–39, France in 1904–14 and 1935–39, and the United States in 1938–41, 1948–60, and 1979–86. In all but one of these cases, I find that leftist governments did more to strengthen their countries' militaries than conservatives.This paper was made possible by the generous support of the Olin Institute for Strategic Studies and the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs at Harvard University. I would also like to thank Ben Fordham, P. R. Goldstone, Greg Mitrovich, Talbot Imlay, Brad Lee, Ken Schultz, Deborah Boucoyannis, Mark Haas, Sean Lynn-Jones, and the participants in the Olin Institute's National Security Seminar Series and the Belfer Center's International Security Program Seminar Series for their helpful comments and advice.

Type
ARTICLES
Information
American Political Science Review , Volume 97 , Issue 2 , May 2003 , pp. 203 - 220
Copyright
© 2003 by the American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Amenta Edwin Skocpol Theda 1988 Redefining the New Deal: World War II and the Development of Social Provision in the United States The Politics of Social Policy in the United States M. Weir A. S. Orloff T. Skocpol Princeton NJ Princeton University Press
Babij Orest M. 1995 The Second Labour Government and British Maritime Security, 1929–1931 Diplomacy and Statecraft 6 3 645-71Google Scholar
Baker Donald Noel. 1971 The Politics of Socialist Protest in France: The Left Wing of the Socialist Party, 1921–39 Journal of Modern History 43 1 2 41Google Scholar
Barnett Michael N. 1992 Confronting the Costs of War: Military Power, State, and Society in Egypt and Israel Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Barnett Michael N. Jack S. Levy 1991 Domestic Sources of Alliances and Alignments: The Case of Egypt, 1962–73 International Organization 45 3 369-95Google Scholar
Becker Jean-Jacques 1987 Les ‘Trois Ans’ et les Débuts de la Première Guerre Mondiale Guerres Mondiales et Conflits Contemporains 37 145 7 26Google Scholar
Blyth Mark 2002 Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Booth Alan 1996 How Long are Light Years in British Politics? The Labour Party's Economic Ideas in the 1930s Twentieth Century British History 7 1 1 26Google Scholar
Bowie Robert R. Richard H. Immerman 1998 Waging Peace: How Eisenhower Shaped an Enduring Cold War Strategy New York Oxford University Press
Brower Daniel R. 1968 The New Jacobins: The French Communist Party and the Popular Front Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press
Brownlee W. Elliot. 1996 Federal Taxation in America: A Short History Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Cain P. J. Hopkins A. G. 1993 British Imperialism: Crisis and Deconstruction, 1914–1990 London Longman
Cairns John C. 1953 International Politics and the Military Mind: The Case of the French Republic, 1911–1914 Journal of Modern History 25 3 273-85Google Scholar
Callet Pierre 1962 La Bataille de l'Impôt sur le Revenu: Fiscalité Moderne et Réactions Bourgeoises (1906–1917) Cahiers d'Histoire 7 4 465-92Google Scholar
Chapman Geoffrey W. 1971 Decision for War: The Domestic Political Context of French Diplomacy, 1911–1914 Ph.D. diss Princeton University
Christensen Thomas J. 1996 Useful Adversaries: Grand Strategy, Domestic Mobilization, and Sino-American Conflict, 1947–1958 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Clarke Jeffrey J. 1977 The Nationalization of War Industries in France, 1936–1937: A Case Study Journal of Modern History 49 3 411-30Google Scholar
Colton Joel 1987 Léon Blum: Humanist in Politics 2nd ed Durham, NC Duke University Press
Cuvillier Jean-Pierre 1978 Vincent Auriol et les Finances Publiques du Front Populaire: ou l'Alternative du Contrôle et de la Liberté (1933–1939) Toulouse Association des Publications de l'Université de Toulouse–Le Mirail
David Steven R. 1991 Choosing Sides: Alignment and Realignment in the Third World Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Press
D'Lugo David Rogowski Ronald 1993 The Anglo-German Naval Race and Comparative Constitutional Fitness The Domestic Bases of Grand Strategy R. Rosecrance A. A. Stein Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press
Douglas Roy 1999 Taxation in Britain since 1660 London Macmillan
Ehrhart Robert C. 1975 The Politics of Military Rearmament, 1935–1940: The President, the Congress, and the United States Army Ph.D. diss University of Texas at Austin
Emy H. V. 1972 The Impact of Financial Policy on English Party Politics Before 1914 Historical Journal 15 1 103-31Google Scholar
Ferguson Niall 1994 Public Finance and National Security: The Domestic Origins of the First World War Revisited Past and Present 142 141-68Google Scholar
Fordham Benjamin O. 1998 Building the Cold War Consensus: The Political Economy of U.S. National Security Policy, 1949–51 Ann Arbor University of Michigan Press
Fordham Benjamin O. 1998 Partisanship, Macroeconomic Policy, and U.S. Uses of Force, 1949–1994 Journal of Conflict Resolution 42 4 418-39Google Scholar
Frankenstein Robert 1982 Le Prix du Réarmement Français, 1935–1939 Paris Publications de la Sorbonne
French David 1982 British Economic and Strategic Planning, 1905–1915 London Allen and Unwin
Friedberg Aaron L. 1988 The Weary Titan: Britain and the Experience of Relative Decline, 1895–1905 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Friedberg Aaron L. 2000 In the Shadow of the Garrison State: America's Anti-Statism and Its Cold War Strategy Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Gaddis John L. 1982 Strategies of Containment: A Critical Appraisal of Postwar American National Security Policy Oxford Oxford University Press
Greene Nathanael 1969 Crisis and Decline: The French Socialist Party in the Popular Front Era Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press
Haggie Paul 1981 Britannia at Bay: The Defence of the British Empire against Japan, 1931–1941 Oxford Clarendon
Hall Peter A. 1989 The Political Power of Economic Ideas: Keynesianism across Nations Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Halperin Sandra 1997 The Politics of Appeasement: The Rise of the Left and European International Relations during the Interwar Period Contested Social Orders and International Politics D. Skidmore Nashville, TN Vanderbilt University Press
Hibbs Douglas A. Jr 1987 The American Political Economy Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
Higgs Robert 1987 Crisis and Leviathan: Critical Episodes in the Growth of American Government New York Oxford University Press
Hill William Steinert Jr 1980 The Business Community and National Defense: Corporate Leaders and the Military, 1943–1950 Ph.D. diss Stanford University
Hilsman Roger 1967 To Move a Nation: The Politics of Foreign Policy in the Administration of John F. Kennedy Garden City, NY Doubleday
Hoff Pierre 1982 Les Programmes d'Armement de 1919 à 1939 Château de Vincennes Ministére de la D´efense, Etat-Major de l'Arm´ee de Terre, Service Historique
Hogan Michael J. 1998 A Cross of Iron: Harry S. Truman and the Origins of the National Security State, 1945–1954 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Huntington Samuel P. 1961 The Common Defense: Strategic Programs in National Politics New York Columbia University Press
Ikenberry G. John Lake David A. Michael Mastanduno 1989 Toward a Realist Theory of State Action International Studies Quarterly 33 4 457-74Google Scholar
Imlay Talbot C. 1997 How to Win a War? Strategy, Domestic Politics, and the Political Economy in France and Britain, 1938–40 Ph.D. diss Yale University
Joffre Joseph J. C. 1932 Mémoires du Maréchal Joffre (1910–1917) Paris Librairie Plon
Jordan Nicole 1998 Strategy and Scapegoatism: Reflections on the French National Catastrophe, 1940 The French Defeat of 1940: Reassessments J. Blatt Providence, RI Berghahn
Kennedy George C. 1992 The 1930 London Naval Conference and Anglo-American Maritime Strength, 1927–1930 Arms Limitation and Disarmament: Restraints on War, 1899–1939 B. J. C. McKercher Westport, CT Praeger
Kent Bruce 1989 The Spoils of War: The Politics, Economics, and Diplomacy of Reparations, 1918–1932 Oxford Clarendon
Krumeich Gerd 1984 Armaments and Politics in France on the Eve of the First World War: The Introduction of Three-Year Conscription, 1913–1914 Trans. S. Conn Worcester, UK Berg
Lake David A. 1999 Entangling Relations: American Foreign Policy in Its Century Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Lambert Walter K. 1970 New Deal Revenue Acts: The Politics of Taxation Ph.D. diss University of Texas at Austin
Lamborn Alan C. 1991 The Price of Power: Risk and Foreign Policy in Britain, France, and Germany Boston Unwin Hyman
Lee R. Alton. 1970 The Truman–80th Congress Struggle over Tax Policy Historian 33 1 68 82Google Scholar
Lee William T. Richard F. Staar 1986 Soviet Military Policy since World War II Stanford, CA Stanford University Press
Leffler Melvyn P. 1992 A Preponderance of Power: National Security, the Truman Administration, and the Cold War Stanford, CA Stanford University Press
Leighton Richard M. 2001 History of the Office of the Secretary of Defense: Strategy, Money, and the New Look, 1953–1956 Washington, DC Office of the Secretary of Defense
Levine Robert H. 1988 The Politics of American Naval Rearmament, 1930–1938 New York Garland
Lo Clarence Y. H. 1982 Theories of the State and Business Opposition to Increased Military Spending Social Problems 29 4 424-38Google Scholar
Mallet Bernard 1913 British Budgets, 1887–88 to 1912–13 London Macmillan
Marder Arthur J. 1940 The Anatomy of British Sea Power: A History of British Naval Policy in the Pre-Dreadnought Era, 1880–1905 New York Knopf
Marder Arthur J. 1961 From Dreadnought to Scapa Flow: The Royal Navy in the Fisher Era London Oxford University Press
Massie Robert K. 1991 Dreadnought: Britain, Germany, and the Coming of the Great War New York Random House
May Ernest R. 2000 Strange Victory: Hitler's Conquest of France New York Hill and Wang
McKeown Timothy J. 1991 The Foreign Policy of a Declining Power International Organization 45 2 257-79Google Scholar
Meltzer Allan H. Scott F. Richard 1978 Why Government Grows (and Grows) in a Democracy Public Interest 52 111-18Google Scholar
Michon Georges 1935 La Préparation à la Guerre: La Loi de Trois Ans (1910–1914) Paris Librarie des Sciences Politiques et Sociales
Minot Bernard 1981 La Chute du Premier Gouvernement Blum et l'Action des Commissions des Finances, 1936–1937 Revue d'Économie Politique 92 1 35 51Google Scholar
Mintz Alex 1989 Guns versus Butter: A Disaggregated Analysis American Political Science Review 83 4 1285-93Google Scholar
Mitchell Allan 1981 A Situation of Inferiority: French Military Reorganization after the Defeat of 1870 American Historical Review 86 1, Supplement 49 62Google Scholar
Modigliani Andre Modigliani Franco 1987 The Growth of the Federal Deficit and the Role of Public Attitudes Public Opinion Quarterly 51 4 459-80Google Scholar
Monger George 1963 The End of Isolation: British Foreign Policy, 1900–1907 London Nelson
Morgan Iwan W. 1990 Eisenhower versus ‘the Spenders’: The Eisenhower Administration, the Democrats, and the Budget, 1953–60 London Pinter
Morrow James D. 1993 Arms versus Allies: Trade-Offs in the Search for Security International Organization 47 2 207-33Google Scholar
Most Benjamin A. Randolph M. Siverson 1987 Substituting Arms and Alliances, 1870–1914: An Exploration in Comparative Foreign Policy New Directions in the Study of Foreign Policy C. F. Hermann C. W. Kegley Jr. J. N. Rosenau Boston Allen and Unwin
Murray Bruce K. 1980 The People's Budget 1909/10: Lloyd George and Liberal Politics Oxford Clarendon Press
Narizny Kevin 2003 The Political Economy of Alignment: Great Britain's Commitments to Europe, 1905–39 International Security 27 4 184 219Google Scholar
Naylor John F. 1969 Labour's International Policy: The Labour Party in the 1930s London Weidenfeld and Nicolson
Newton Scott 1996 Profits of Peace: The Political Economy of Anglo-German Appeasement Oxford Clarendon
O'Brien Phillips Payson. 1998 British and American Naval Power: Politics and Policy, 1900–1936 Westport, CT Praeger
O'Hanlon Michael 2000 Clinton-Gore Defense Policy Was on Target Los Angeles Times 2 November 11Google Scholar
O'Sullivan John 1982 From Voluntarism to Conscription: Congress and Selective Service, 1940–1945 New York Garland
Owen Stephen W. Jr 1982 The Politics of Tax Reform in France, 1906–1926 Ph.D. diss University of California, Berkeley
Parker R. A. C. 1981 British Rearmament 1936–9: Treasury, Trade Unions, and Skilled Labour English Historical Review 96 379 304-43Google Scholar
Patterson James T. 1967 Congressional Conservatism and the New Deal: The Growth of the Conservative Coalition in Congress, 1933–1939 Lexington, KY University of Kentucky Press
Peacock Alan T. Wiseman Jack 1961 The Growth of Public Expenditure in the United Kingdom London Oxford University Press
Peden G. C. 1979 British Rearmament and the Treasury: 1932–1939 Edinburgh Scottish Academic Press
Peden G. C. 2000 The Treasury and British Public Policy, 1906–1959 Oxford Oxford University Press
Peterson Paul E. 1985 The New Politics of Deficits Political Science Quarterly 100 4 575 601Google Scholar
Pickersgill J. W. 1939 The Front Populaire and the French Elections of 1936 Political Science Quarterly 54 1 69 83Google Scholar
Pollard Robert A. 1989 The National Security State Reconsidered: Truman and Economic Containment, 1945–1950 The Truman Presidency M. J. Lacey Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Porch Douglas 1981 The March to the Marne: The French Army, 1871–1914 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Porter Bruce D. 1994 War and the Rise of the State: The Military Foundations of Modern Politics New York Free Press
Postan M. M. 1952 British War Production London Her Majesty's Stationery Office
Powell Robert 1996 Uncertainty, Shifting Power, and Appeasement American Political Science Review 90 4 749-64Google Scholar
Price Christopher 2001 Britain, America, and Rearmament in the 1930s: The Cost of Failure New York Palgrave
Quartararo Rosaria 1977 Imperial Defence in the Mediterranean on the Eve of the Ethiopian Crisis (July–October 1935) Historical Journal 20 1 185 220Google Scholar
Ralston David B. 1967 The Army of the Republic: The Place of the Military in the Political Evolution of France, 1871–1914 Cambridge, MA MIT Press
Reardon Steven L. 1984 History of the Office of the Secretary of Defense: The Formative Years, 1947–1950 Vol. I Washington, DC Office of the Secretary of Defense
Reichard Gary W. 1975 The Reaffirmation of Republicanism: Eisenhower and the Eighty-Third Congress Knoxville, TN University of Tennessee Press
Rollings Neil 2001 Whitehall and the Control of Prices and Profits in a Major War, 1919–1939 Historical Journal 44 2 517-40Google Scholar
Rosecrance Richard Arthur A. Stein 1993 The Domestic Bases of Grand Strategy Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press
Rowe David M. 1999 World Economic Expansion and National Security in Pre-World War I Europe International Organization 53 2 195 231Google Scholar
Sabine B. E. V. 1966 A History of the Income Tax London Allen Unwin
Sauvy Alfred 1967 Histoire Économique de la France entre les Deux Guerres (1931–1939) Paris Fayard
Sawyer Malcolm 1982 Income Distribution and the Welfare State The European Economy: Growth and Crisis A. Boltho Oxford Oxford University Press
Shay Robert Paul. 1977 British Rearmament in the Thirties: Politics and Profits Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Sloan John W. 1991 Eisenhower and the Management of Prosperity Lawrence University Press of Kansas
Snyder Glenn H. Schilling Warner R. Hammond Paul Y. 1962 Strategy, Politics, and Defense Budgets New York Columbia University Press
Stein Arthur A. 1978 The Nation at War Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Press
Stevenson David 1996 Armaments and the Coming of War: Europe, 1904–1914 Oxford Clarendon
Stolfi R. H. S. 1970 Equipment for Victory in France in 1940 History 52 183 1 20Google Scholar
Stromberg N 1953 American Business and the Approach of War, 1935–1941 Journal of Economic History 13 1 58 78Google Scholar
Sumida Jon T. 1989 In Defense of Naval Supremacy: Finance, Technology and British Naval Policy, 1889–1914 Boston Unwin Hyman
Sundquist James L. 1983 Dynamics of the Party System: Alignment and Realignment of Political Parties in the United States Rev. ed Washington, DC Brookings
Sweet D. W. 1977 Great Britain and Germany, 1905–1911 British Foreign Policy under Sir Edward Grey F. H. Hinsley Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Thomas Martin 1992 French Economic Affairs and Rearmament: The First Crucial Months, June–September 1936 Journal of Contemporary History 27 659-70Google Scholar
Thompson Loren B. 2002 The Pentagon's Dilemma Washington Post 15 April 2002 21Google Scholar
Toye Richard 2001 The Labour Party and the Economics of Rearmament, 1935–39 Twentieth Century British History 12 3 303-26Google Scholar
Trachtenberg Marc 1999 A Constructed Peace: The Making of the European Settlement, 1945–1963 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Trubowitz Peter 1998 Defining the National Interest: Conflict and Change in American Foreign Policy Chicago University of Chicago Press
United States Bureau of the Census 1954 Statistical Abstract of the United States Washington, DC U.S. Government Printing Office
United States Bureau of the Census 1960 Statistical Abstract of the United States Washington, DC U.S. Government Printing Office
United States Bureau of the Census 1996 Statistical Abstract of the United States Washington, DC U.S. Government Printing Office
United States Department of Commerce Economic Bureau of Analysis 2002 Current-Dollar and ‘Real’ Gross Domestic Product <http//www.bea.doc.gov/bea/dn/gdplev.xls>
Weinrich William A. 1971 Business and Foreign Affairs: The Roosevelt Defense Program, 1937–1941 Ph.D. diss University of Oklahoma
Weinroth Howard S. 1971 Left-Wing Opposition to Naval Armaments in Britain before 1914 Journal of Contemporary History 6 4 93 120Google Scholar
Wells Samuel F. Jr 1983 A Question of Priorities: A Comparison of the Carter and Reagan Defense Programs Orbis 27 3 641-66Google Scholar
Westerfield H. Bradford. 1955 Foreign Policy and Party Politics: Pearl Harbor to Korea New Haven, CT Yale University Press
Wileman Donald G. 1994 Not the Radical Republic: Liberal Ideology and Central Blandishment in France, 1901–1914 Historical Journal 37 3 593 614Google Scholar
Witte John F. 1985 The Politics and Development of the Federal Income Tax Madison University of Wisconsin Press
Young Robert J. 1978 In Command of France: French Foreign Policy and Military Planning, 1933–1940 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
Zakaria Fareed 1990 The Reagan Strategy of Containment Political Science Quarterly 105 3 373-95Google Scholar
Submit a response

Comments

No Comments have been published for this article.