Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T12:33:29.374Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Political Science and Political Understanding: Isaiah Berlin on the Nature of Political Inquiry

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 June 2004

RYAN PATRICK HANLEY
RYAN PATRICK HANLEY
Affiliation:
Marquette University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

I saiah Berlin is remembered for his positive/negative liberty distinction and his value pluralism, but he was also an active participant in the debate over the nature of political inquiry. This essay argues that his neglected contribution to this debate is central to his thought and a valuable resource in today's debate over political science's methods and ends. I first show how Berlin understood the relationship of empirical science to humanistic study. I then demonstrate that his conceptions of political judgment and the “sense of reality” were intended as alternatives to the scientific pursuit of political knowledge. Finally, I argue that his Churchill and Weizmann essays present exemplars of the moral excellence Berlin considered necessary to ennoble liberal society and the political understanding indispensable to comprehensive political inquiry. I conclude by noting how Berlin's critique of scientific political inquiry informs his liberalism and his own methods of political inquiry.

Type
ARTICLES
Information
American Political Science Review , Volume 98 , Issue 2 , May 2004 , pp. 327 - 339
Copyright
© 2004 by the American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Arendt Hannah. [1968] 1995. Men in Dark Times. New York: Harcourt Brace.
Behnegar Nasser. 2003. Leo Strauss, Max Weber, and the Scientific Study of Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1939] 1996. Karl Marx: His Life and Environment, 4th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [KM]
Berlin Isaiah. [1949] 2001. “Winston Churchill in 1940.” In Personal Impressions, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. 1950a. “The Trends of Culture.” In 1950 Britannica Book of the Year. Chicago, Toronto, London: Encyclopaedia Britannica.
Berlin Isaiah. 1950b [2002]. “Political Ideas in the Twentieth Century.” In Liberty, ed. Henry Hardy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. 1951a. “Nineteen Fifty: A Survey of Politico-Cultural Trends of the Year.” In 1951 Britannica Book of the Year. Chicago, Toronto, London: Encyclopaedia Britannica.
Berlin Isaiah. [1951b] 2002. “A Letter to George Kennan.” In Liberty, ed. Henry Hardy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Berlin Isaiah [under pseudonym “O. Utis”]. 1952. “Generalissimo Stalin and the Art of Government.” Foreign Affairs 30 (January): 197– 214.Google Scholar
Berlin Isaiah. [1953a] 1994. “The Hedgehog and the Fox.” In Russian Thinkers, ed. Henry Hardy and Aileen Kelly. London: Penguin.
Berlin Isaiah. [1953b] 1996. “Realism in History.” Reprinted as “The Sense of Reality.” In The Sense of Reality, ed. Henry Hardy. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Berlin Isaiah. [1953c] 2002. “The Origins of Israel.” In The Power of Ideas, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1954a] 2002. “Historical Inevitability.” In Liberty, ed. Henry Hardy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1954b] 2002. “Realism in Politics.” In The Power of Ideas, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1954c] 2002. “Chaim Weizmann's Leadership.” In The Power of Ideas, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1956] 2002. “The Father of Russian Marxism.” In The Power of Ideas, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1957] 1996. “Political Judgement.” In The Sense of Reality, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1958] 2001. “Chaim Weizmann.” In Personal Impressions, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1959] 2002. “John Stuart Mill and the Ends of Life.” In Liberty, ed. Henry Hardy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1960a] 1999. “The Concept of Scientific History.” In Concepts and Categories, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1960b] 2000. “The Philosophical Ideas of Giambattista Vico.” In Three Critics of the Enlightenment, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1962] 1999. “Does Political Theory Still Exist?” In Concepts and Categories, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. 1965. “The Thought of de Tocqueville.” History 50 (169): 199– 206.Google Scholar
Berlin Isaiah. 1970. “Weizmann as Exilarch.” In Chaim Weizmann as Leader, eds. Berlin and Israel Kolatt. Jerusalem: Hebrew University. [WE]
Berlin Isaiah. 1972a. Zionist Politics in Wartime Washington: A Fragment of Personal Reminiscence. Jerusalem: Hebrew University. [ZPWW]
Berlin Isaiah. [1972b] 2002. “Meinecke and Historicism.” In The Power of Ideas, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1978a] 1999. Concepts and Categories, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [CC]
Berlin Isaiah. [1978b] 1994. Russian Thinkers, ed. Henry Hardy and Aileen Kelly. London: Penguin. [RT]
Berlin Isaiah. [1979a] 2001. “Einstein and Israel.” In Personal Impressions, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berlin Isaiah. [1979b] 1997. Against the Current, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [AC]
Berlin Isaiah. [1980] 2001. Personal Impressions, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [PI]
Berlin Isaiah. 1992. The Crooked Timber of Humanity, ed. Henry Hardy. New York: Vintage. [CTH]
Berlin Isaiah. 1996. The Sense of Reality: Studies in Ideas and Their History, ed. Henry Hardy. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. [SR]
Berlin Isaiah. 2000. Three Critics of the Enlightenment: Vico, Hamann, Herder, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [TCE]
Berlin Isaiah. 2002a. Liberty, ed. Henry Hardy. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [L]
Berlin Isaiah. 2002b. The Power of Ideas, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [POI]
Berlin Isaiah. 2002c. Freedom and Its Betrayal: Six Enemies of Human Liberty, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [FB]
Cobban Alfred. 1953. “The Decline of Political Theory.” Political Science Quarterly 68 (September): 321– 37.Google Scholar
Cocks Joan. 1999. “Individuality, Nationality, and the Jewish Question.” Social Research 66 (Winter): 1191– 1216.Google Scholar
Cook Thomas. 1955. “The Prospects of Political Science.” Journal of Politics 17 (May): 265– 74.Google Scholar
Cracraft James. 2002. “A Berlin for Historians.” History and Theory 41 (October): 277– 300.Google Scholar
Easton David. 1951. “The Decline of Modern Political Theory.” Journal of Politics 13 (February): 36– 58.Google Scholar
Eckstein Harry. 1956. “Political Theory and the Study of Politics: A Report of a Conference.” American Political Science Review 50 (June): 475– 87.Google Scholar
Franco Paul. 2003. “The Shapes of Liberal Thought: Oakeshott, Berlin, and Liberalism.” Political Theory 31 (August): 484– 507.Google Scholar
Friedrich Carl J. 1958. “Political Philosophy and the Science of Politics.” In Approaches to the Study of Politics, ed. Roland Young. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
Galston William A. 1999. “Value Pluralism and Liberal Political Theory.” American Political Science Review 93 (December): 769– 78.Google Scholar
Grant Ruth W. 2002. “Political Theory, Political Science, and Politics.” Political Theory 30 (August): 577– 95.Google Scholar
Gray John. 1996. Isaiah Berlin. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Greaves H. R. G. 1960. “Political Theory Today.” Political Science Quarterly 75 (March): 1– 16.Google Scholar
Gunnell John. 1986. Between Philosophy and Politics: The Alienation of Political Theory. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.
Hampshire Stuart. 1991. “Nationalism.” In Isaiah Berlin: A Celebration, ed. Edna Margalit and Avishai Margalit. London: Hogarth Press.
Hausheer Roger. 1983. “Berlin and the Emergence of Liberal Pluralism.” In European Liberty, ed. Pierre Manent et al. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
Jervis Robert. 2002. “Politics, Political Science, and Specialization.” PS: Political Science and Politics 35 (June): 187– 89.Google Scholar
Leavis F. R. 1962. Two Cultures? The Significance of C. P. Snow. London: Chatto and Windus.
Lilla Mark, Ronald Dworkin, and Robert B. Silvers. 2001. “Introduction.” In The Legacy of Isaiah Berlin, ed. Mark Lilla, Ronald Dworkin, and Robert B Silvers. New York: New York Review of Books Press.
Oakeshott Michael. [1962] 1991. Rationalism in Politics. Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Fund.
Oakeshott Michael. 1993. Religion, Politics, and the Moral Life, ed. Timothy Fuller. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Pippin Robert. 2003. “The Unavailability of the Ordinary: Strauss on the Philosophical Fate of Modernity.” Political Theory 31 (June): 335– 58.Google Scholar
Riley Jonathan. 2001. “Interpreting Berlin's Liberalism.” American Political Science Review 95 (June): 283– 95.Google Scholar
Shapiro Ian. 2002. “Problems, Methods, and Theories in the Study of Politics, or What's Wrong with Political Science and What to Do about It.” Political Theory 30 (August): 596– 619.Google Scholar
Skinner Quentin. 2002a. Visions of Politics, Volume 1: Regarding Method. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Skinner Quentin. 2002b. “A Third Concept of Liberty.” Proceedings of the British Academy 117: 237– 68.
Skinner Q., P. Dasgupta, R. Geuss, M. Lane, P. Laslett, O. O'Neill, W.G. Runciman, and A. Kuper. 2002. “Political Philosophy: The View from Cambridge.” Journal of Political Philosophy 10 (March): 1– 19.Google Scholar
Smith Rogers M. 2002. “Should We Make Political Science More of a Science or More about Politics?” PS: Political Science and Politics 35 (June): 199– 201.Google Scholar
Snow C. P. [1959] 1998. The Two Cultures. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Strauss Leo. 1961. “Relativism.” In Relativism and the Study of Man, ed. Helmut Schoeck and J. W. Wiggins. Princeton: Van Nostrand.
Strauss Leo. [1962] 1995. “An Epilogue.” In Liberalism Ancient and Modern. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Strawson P. F. [1962] 1974. “Freedom and Resentment.” In Freedom and Resentment and Other Essays. London: Methuen.
Tocqueville Alexis de. 2000. Democracy in America, trans. Harvey Mansfield and Delba Winthrop. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
White Stephen K. 2002. “Pluralism, Platitudes, and Paradoxes: Fifty Years of Western Political Thought.” Political Theory 30 (August): 472– 81.Google Scholar
Wokler Robert. 2003. “Isaiah Berlin's Enlightenment and Counter-Enlightenment.” In Isaiah Berlin's Counter-Enlightenment, ed. Joseph Mali and Robert Wokler. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society.
Wollheim Richard. 1991. “The Idea of a Common Human Nature.” In Isaiah Berlin: A Celebration, ed. Edna Margalit and Avishai Margalit. London: Hogarth Press.
Submit a response

Comments

No Comments have been published for this article.