Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-05T13:14:22.001Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Escaping the Confines of Normative Thought: A Reevaluation of Puebloan Prehistory

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Linda S. Cordell  and
Fred Plog
Linda S. Cordell
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM 87131
Fred Plog
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85281
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Our recent efforts in preparing syntheses of Puebloan prehistory suggest that most of the standard, normative generalizations are empirically false and that the conceptual framework traditionally employed to organize the archaeological data is inadequate and inappropriate. We show that the patterned variability manifest in the archaeological record is obscured by normative treatment. An approach to southwestern prehistory that is at once more faithful to the data and to processual, evolutionary anthropology is provided by describing the variable strategies that prehistoric groups used to cope with the continually changing natural and social environments in which they lived. We argue that some aspects of demographic, productive, and social organizational strategies are appropriate for treatment in syntheses of broad scope. We trace these strategies as they seem to have occurred in the northern Southwest from about A.D. 1 to the protohistoric period. In so doing, we find that successful strategies were those that facilitated the articulation of diversity. At some times productive specialization, organized redistributive exchange, and status differentiation were among the more important strategies.

Type
Research Article
Information
American Antiquity , Volume 44 , Issue 3 , July 1979 , pp. 405 - 429
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for American Archaeology 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Adams, Robert McC. 1974 The Mesopotamian social landscape: a view from the frontier. In Reconstructing complex societies, an archaeological colloquium, edited by Moore, Charlotte B., pp. 1–21. Supplement to the Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research No. 20.Google Scholar
Ambler, H. Richard, Lindsay, Alexander, and Stein, Mary Anne 1964 Survey and excavations on Cummings Mesa, Arizona and Utah, 1960-1961. Museum of Northern Arizona Bulletin 39.Google Scholar
Athens, John Stephen 1977 Theory building and the study of evolutionary process in complex societies. In For theory bui Jding inarchaeology: essays on faunal remains, aquatic resources, spatia J analysis, and systematic modeling, edited by Binford, Lewis R., pp. 353–384. Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
Barth, Frederik 1961 Nomads of south Persia. Little, Brown, Boston.Google Scholar
Binford, Lewis R. 1968 Post-Pleistocene adaptations. In New perspectives in archaeology, edited by Binford, S. R. and Binford, L. R., pp. 313–342. Aldine, Chicago.Google Scholar
Binford, Lewis R., and Chasko, W. J. Jr 1976 Nunamiut demographic history: a provocative case. In Demographic anthropology: quantitative approaches, edited by Zubrow, Ezra B. W., pp. 63–144. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Blanton, Richard 1976 The role of symbiosis in adaptation and sociocultural change. In The valley of Mexico, edited by Eric, Wolf, pp. 181–202. A School of American Research Book, University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Bluhm, Elaine 1957 The Sawmill site. Fieldiana: Anthropology 47(1).Google Scholar
Bradfield, Maitland 1971 The changing pattern of Hopi agriculture Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland, Occasional Paper 30. Google Scholar
Breternitz, David A. 1966 An appraisal of tree-ring dated pottery in the Southwest. Anthropological Papers of the University of Arizona, No. 10.Google Scholar
Carneiro, Robert L. 1970 A theory of the origin of the state. Science 169:733–738.Google Scholar
Colton, Harold S. 1936 The rise and fall of the prehistoric population of northern Arizona. Science 84:337–343.Google Scholar
Colton, Harold S. 1955a Pottery types of the Southwest. Museum of Northern Arizona, Ceramic Series No. 3A.Google Scholar
Colton, Harold S. 1955b Pottery types of the Southwest. Museum of Northern Arizona, Ceramic Series No. 3B.Google Scholar
Colton, Harold S. 1956 Pottery types of the Southwest. Museum of Northern Arizona, Ceramic Series No. 3C.Google Scholar
Cordell, Linda S. 1975 Predicting site abandonment at Wetherill Mesa. Kiva 40:189–202.Google Scholar
Cordell, Linda S. 1978 A cultural resources overview of the middle Bio Grande Valley, New Mexico. Ms. on file, USDA Forest Service, Southwestern Region, Albuquerque, and Bureau of Land Management, New Mexico State Office, Sante Fe.Google Scholar
Davis, Irvine 1959 Linguistic clues to northern Rio Grande prehistory. El Palacio 66:73–84.Google Scholar
Dick, Herbert W. 1976 Archaeological excavations in the Llaves area, Sante Fe National Forest, New Mexico, 1972-1974. Part 1, Architecture. USDA Forest Service, Southwestern flegion, Albuquerque, Archaeological Report No. 13.Google Scholar
Dittert, Alfred E., and Ruppe, R. J. 1952 The development of scientific investigations of the Cebolleta Mesa area. Kiva 18:38–46.Google Scholar
Douglas, Mary 1962 The Lele—resistance to change. In Economic anthropology, edited by Edward Le, Clair and Harold, Schneider, pp. 322–340. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York.Google Scholar
Douglass, Andrew E. 1929 The secret of the Southwest solved by talkative tree-rings. National Geographic 56:736–770.Google Scholar
Dozier, Edward P. 1961 Rio Grande Pueblos. In Perspectives in American Indian culture change, edited by Edward, Spicer, pp. 94–186. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
Dozier, Edward P. 1970 The Pueblo Indians of North America. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York.Google Scholar
Earle, Timothy K., and Ericson, Jonathan E. 1977 Exchange systems in prehistory. Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
Eddy, Frank 1968 Prehistory in the Navajo Reservoir District, northwestern New Mexico, parts I and II. Museum of New Mexico Papers in Anthropology No. 15.Google Scholar
Eggan, F. 1950 Social organization of the Western Pueblos. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
El-Najjar, Mahmoud Y., Ryan, D. J., Turner, C. G. II, and Lozoff, B. 1976 The etiology of porotic hyperostosis among the prehistoric and historic Anasazi Indians of the southwestern United States. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 44:477–488.Google Scholar
Ford, R. 1972 An ecological perspective on the Eastern Pueblos. In New perspectives on the Pueblo, edited by Ortiz, A., pp. 1–21. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Fox, R. 1967 The Keresan Bridge. London School of Economics Monograph in Social Anthropology No. 35. Athlone Press, London.Google Scholar
Fried, Morton H. 1960 On the evolution of social stratification and the state. In Culture in history: essays in honor of Paulfladin, edited by Stanley, Diamond, pp. 713–731. Columbia University Press, New York.Google Scholar
Fried, Morton H. 1967 The evolution of political society: an essay in political anthropology. Random House, New York.Google Scholar
Frisbie, Theodore R. 1967 The excavation and interpretation of the artificial Leg Basket Maker III—Pueblo I sites near Corrales, New Mexico. M. A. thesis, Department of Anthropology, University of New Mexico.Google Scholar
Gauthier, Rory P., Prince, Patricia A., and Frances, Joan Mathien 1978 An archaeological sample survey of proposed timber sale areas on the Picuris Pueblo Reservation. Office of Contract Archaeology, University of New Mexico.Google Scholar
Gould, Stephen J. 1977 Ever since Darwin. Norton, New York.Google Scholar
Gould, Stephen J., and Eldridge, Niles 1977 Punctuated equilibria: the tempo and mode of evolution reconsidered. Paleobiology 3:115–151.Google Scholar
Graves, Michael W. 1978 White Mountain redware design variability. Paper presented at the 77th Annual Meeting, American Anthropological Association, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Grebinger, Paul 1978 Prehistoric social organization in Chaco Canyon, New Mexico. In Discovering past behavior, experimentsin the archaeology of the American Southwest, XI, edited by Paul, Grebinger, pp. 73–100, Gordonand Breach, New York and London.Google Scholar
Green, Ernestene L. 1976 Valdez phase occupation near Taos, New Mexico. Fort Burgwin Research Center Report No. 10. Southern Methodist University, Dallas.Google Scholar
Green, Margie 1975 Patterns of variation in chipped stone raw materials for the Chevelon drainage. M. A. thesis, Departmentof Anthropology, State University of New York, Binghamton.Google Scholar
Gumerman, George 1969 Archaeology of the Hope Buttes District, Arizona. Ph. D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Arizona.Google Scholar
Gumerman, George 1975 Southwestern demographic change. In Population studies in archaeology and biological anthropology, edited by Swedlund, Alan C., pp. 104–115. Memoirs of the Society /or American Archaeology 30. American Antiquity 40(2).Google Scholar
Hack, John T. 1942 The changing physical environment of the Hopi Indians of Arizona. Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology 35(1):1–85.Google Scholar
Hall, Edward T. Jr. 1944 Early stockaded settlements in the Governador, New Mexico. Columbia Studies in Archaeology and Ethnology 2, Part 2.Google Scholar
Harrill, Bruce G. 1973 The Do Bell site: archaeological salvage near the Petrified Forest. Kiva 39:35–67.Google Scholar
Harris, Marvin 1968 Comments. In New perspectives in archaeology, edited by Binford, S. R. and Binford, L. R., pp. 356–361. Aldine, Chicago.Google Scholar
Hawley, Florence M. 1934 The significance of the dated prehistory of Chetro Ketl, Chaco Canyon, New Mexico. The University of New Mexico Bulletin 1(1).Google Scholar
Hawley, Florence M. 1936 Field manual of prehistoric southwestern pottery types. The University of New Mexico Bulletin, Anthropological Series 1(4).Google Scholar
Hawley, Florence M. 1937 Pueblo social organization as a lead to Pueblo prehistory. American Anthropologist 39:504–522.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hayes, Alden C. 1964 The archaeological survey of Wetherill Mesa. National Parks Service Archaeological Research Series 7-A.Google Scholar
Hill, James N. 1970a Broken K Pueblo: prehistoric social organization in the American Southwest. Anthropological Papers of the University of Arizona 18.Google Scholar
Hill, James N. 1970b Prehistoric social organization in the American Southwest: theory and method. In Reconstructingprehistoric Pueblo societies, edited by Longacre, William A., pp. 11–58. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Jacquard, Albert 1974 The genetic structure of populations. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, New York.Google Scholar
Jennings, Jesse 1966 Glen Canyon: a summary. University of Utah Anthropological Papers 81.Google Scholar
Jorde, Lynn B. 1977 Precipitation cycles and cultural buffering in the prehistoric Southwest. In For theory building inarchaeology: essays on faunal remains, aquatic resources, spatial analysis, and systemic modeling, edited by Binford, Lewis R., pp. 385–396. Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
Judge, W. James 1976 The development of a complex cultural ecosystem in the Chaco Basin, New Mexico. Ms. paper submittedto the First Conference on Scientific Research in the National Parks, November 9-13, 1976, New Orleans.Google Scholar
Kidder, Alfred V. 1924 An introduction to the study of Southwestern archaeology, with a preliminary account of the excavationsat Pecos. Papers of the Phillips Academy Southwestern Expedition No. 1, New Haven.Google Scholar
Kidder, Alfred V. 1927 Southwestern archaeological conference. Science 68:489–491.Google Scholar
Kidder, Alfred V., and Shepard, Anna O. 1936 The pottery of Pecos, Vol. 2. Papers of the Phillips Academy Southwestern Expedition, No. 7. New Haven.Google Scholar
Klesert, Anthony L. 1978 Excavation on Black Mesa, 1977: a preliminary report. Center /or Archaeological Investigations Research Paper 1. Southern Illinois University, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Layhe, Robert 1978 A multivariate approach for estimating prehistoric population change on Black Mesa, northeastern Arizona. M. A. thesis, Department of Anthropology, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Lightfoot, Kent G. 1978a An archaeological survey of the Nicks Camp timber sale. OCRM Report 36. Arizona State University.Google Scholar
Lightfoot, Kent G. 1978b Multi-site communities in the prehistoric Southwest: an example from Pinedale. Ms. on file, Departmentof Anthropology, Arizona State University.Google Scholar
Lightfoot, Kent G. 1979 Food distribution among prehistoric Pueblo groups. Kiva, in Press.Google Scholar
Lipe, William D. 1970 Anasazi communities in the Red Rock Plateau, southeastern Utah. In Reconstructing prehistoric Pueblosocieties, edited by Longacre, William A., pp. 84–139. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Longacre, William A. 1970 Archaeology as anthropology: a case study. Anthropological Papers of the University of Arizona 17.Google Scholar
Loose, Ann A. 1974 Archaeological excavations near Arroyo Hondo, Carson National Forest. USDA Forest Service, Southwestern Region, Albuquerque. Archaeological Report No. 4.Google Scholar
Lyons, Thomas R., and Hitchcock, Robert K. 1977 Remote sensing interpretation of Anasazi land route system. In Aerial remote sensing techniques inarchaeology, edited by Lyons, T. R. and Hitchcock, R. K., pp. 111–134. Reports of the Chaco Center 2. National Park Service and the University of New Mexico. Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Martin, Paul S., and Plog, Fred 1973 The archaeology of Arizona. American Museum of Natural History, Doubleday/Natural History Press, Garden City, New York.Google Scholar
Martin, Paul S., and Rinaldo, John B. 1947 The SU site. Field Museum of Natural History Anthropological Series 32(3).Google Scholar
Martin, Paul S., and Rinaldo, John B. 1960a Excavations in the upper Little Colorado drainage. Fieldiana: Anthropology 51(1).Google Scholar
Martin, Paul S., and Rinaldo, John B. 1960b Table Rock Pueblo, Arizona. Fieldiana: Anthropology 51(2).Google Scholar
Martin, Paul S., Rinaldo, John B., and Longacre, William 1961 Mineral Creek site and Hooper Ranch Pueblo. Fieldiana: Anthropology 52.Google Scholar
Martin, Paul S. , Renaldo, John B., Longacre, William A., Constance, Cronin, Freeman, Leslie G. Jr. , and James, Schoenwetter 1962 Chapters in the prehistory of eastern Arizona, 1. Fieldiana: Anthropology 53. Google Scholar
Maybury-Lewis, David 1967 Akwe-Shavante society. Oxford University Press, New York, London, Toronto.Google Scholar
McGregor, John C. 1965 Southwestern archaeology. University of Illinois Press, Urbana.Google Scholar
Meggitt, M. J. 1962 Desert people: a study of the Walbiri Aborigines of central Australia. Angus and Robertson, Sidney.Google Scholar
Minnis, Paul, and Plog, Stephen 1976 A study of the site specific distribution of Agave parryi in east-central Arizona. Kiva 41:299–308.Google Scholar
Morris, Earl H., and Burgh., Robert F. 1954 Basket Maker II sites near Durango, Colorado. Carnegie Institution of Washington Publication 604. Google Scholar
Orcutt, Janet 1974 The measurement of prehistoric population size. M. A. Thesis, Department of Anthropology, University of California, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Ortiz, Alfonso A. 1969 The Tewa world. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
Parsons, Elsie Clews 1936 Taos Pueblo. General Series in Anthropology No. 2. George Banta, Menasha, Washington.Google Scholar
Plog, Fred 1974 The study of prehistoric change. Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
Plog, Fred 1978 The Keresan Bridge: an ecological and archaeological analysis. In Social archaeology: beyond subsistenceand dating, edited by Redman, Charles L., Mary Jane, Berman, Curtin, Edward B., Versaggi, Nina M., and Wagner, Jeffrey L., pp. 349–372. Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
Plog, Fred, Effland, R., and Green, D. 1978 Inferences using the SARG data bank. In Investigations of the Southwestern Anthropological Research Group, edited by Euler, R. and Gumerman, G., pp. 139–148. Museum of Northern Arizona, Flagstaff.Google Scholar
Plog, Fred, and Garrett, Cheryl K. 1972 Explaining variability in prehistoric southwestern water control systems. In Contemporary archaeology:a guide to theory and contributions, edited by Leone, Mark P., pp. 280–288. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Plog, Stephen 1969 Prehistoric population movements: measurement and explanation. Ms. on Jile, Field Museum of Natural History, Chicago.Google Scholar
Plog, Stephen 1976 The inference of prehistoric social organization from ceramic design variability. Michigan Discussionsin Anthropology 1:1–47.Google Scholar
Plog, Stephen 1977a Excavation on Black Mesa, 1976: a preliminary report. Archaeological Service Report 50. Southern Illinois University, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Plog, Stephen 1977b A multivariate approach to the explanation of ceramic design variation. Ph. D. dissertation, Departmentof Anthropology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Reinhart, Theodore R. 1976 The Alameda phase: an early Basketmaker III culture in the middle Rio Grande Valley, New Mexico. Southwestern Lore 33(1):24–32.Google Scholar
Reyman, Jonathan E. 1978 Pochteca burial at Anasazi sites. In Across the Chichimec Sea: papers in honor of J. Charles Kel Jey, edited by Riley, Carroll L. and Hedrick, Basil C., pp. 242–259. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Roberts, Frank H. Jr. 1929 Shabik'eschee Village, a late Basket Maker site in the Chaco Canyon, New Mexico. Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin 92.Google Scholar
Roberts, Frank H. Jr. 1936 A survey of southwestern archaeology. In Smithsonian Annual Report for 1935, pp. 507–533.Google Scholar
Rohn, Arthur H. 1971 Mug House, Mesa Verde National Park, Colorado. National Park Service Archaeological Series No. 7-D.Google Scholar
Rohn, Arthur H. 1977 Cultural change and continuity on Chapin Mesa. Regents Press of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas.Google Scholar
Sahlins, Marshall D. 1958 Social stratification in Polynesia. University of Washington Press, Seattle.Google Scholar
Sahlins, Marshall D. 1963 Poor man, rich man, big man, chief: political types in Melanesia and Polynesia. Comparative Studiesin Society and History 5:285–303.Google Scholar
Sahlins, Marshall D. 1972 Stone age economics. Aldine-Atherton, Chicago and New York.Google Scholar
Sanders, William T. 1956 The central Mexican symbiotic region, Viking Fund Publications in Anthropology, No. 21, pp. 115–127.Google Scholar
Sanders, William T., and Price, Barbara J. 1968 Mesoamerica: the evolution of a civilization. Random House, New York.Google Scholar
Schoenwetter, James, and Dittert, Alfred E. Jr 1968 An ecological interpretation of Anasazi settlement patterns. In Anthropological archaeology in the Americas, edited by Meggers, Betty J., pp. 41–66. Anthropological Society of Washington, Washington, D. C.Google Scholar
Schroeder, Albert H. 1965 Unregulated diffusion from Mexico into the Southwest prior to A. D. 700. American Antiquity 31:683–704.Google Scholar
Service, Elman R. 1962 Primitive social organization: an evolutionary perspective. Random House, New York.Google Scholar
Shepard, Anna O. 1942 Rio Grande glaze paint ware. Contributions to American Anthropology and History No. 39, Carnegie Institute of Washington Publication 528. Google Scholar
Slatter, Edwin D. 1973 Climate in Pueblo abandonment of the Chevelon drainage, Arizona. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Anthropological Association, New Orleans.Google Scholar
Slobodkin, L. B. 1972 On the inconstancy of ecological efficiency and the form of ecological theory. Transactions of the Connecticut Academy of Arts and Sciences 44:293–305.Google Scholar
Snow, David H. 1974 The excavation of Saltbush Pueblo, Bandelier National Monument, New Mexico, 1971. Laboratory of Anthropology Notes No. 87. Sante Fe.Google Scholar
Stanislawski, Michael B. 1969 What good is a broken pot? an experiment in Hopi-Tewa ethnoarchaeology. Southwestern Lore 35:11–18.Google Scholar
Stanislawski, Michael B. 1978 If pots were mortal. In Explorations in ethnoarchaeology, edited by Gould, Richard A., pp. 201–228. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Steward, J. 1937 Ecological aspects of Southwestern society. Anthropols 32:87–104.Google Scholar
Stiger, Mark A. 1977 Anasazi diet: the coprolife evidence. M. A. thesis, Department of Anthropology, University of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Struever, Stuart 1968 Problems, methods and organization: a disparity in the growth of archaeology. In Anthropologicalarchaeology in the Americas, edited by Meggers, Betty J., pp. 131–151. Anthropological Society of Washington, Washington, D. C.Google Scholar
Swedlund, Alan, and Sessions, Steven 1976 A developmental model of prehistoric population growth, Black Mesa, northeastern Arizona. In Paperson the archaeology of Black Mesa, edited by George, Gumerman and Robert, Euler, pp. 136–148. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Titiev, M. 1944 Old Oraibi. Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology 32(1).Google Scholar
Upham, Steadman 1979 Final report on archaeological investigations at Chavez Pass Ruin: 1978 field season. Ms. on file, USD A Forest Service, Coconito National Forest, Arizona.Google Scholar
Vivian, R. Gwinn 1970 An inquiry into prehistoric social organization in Chaco Canyon. In Reconstructing prehistoric Pueblosocieties, edited by Longacre, William A., pp. 59–83. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Vivian, R. Gwinn 1974 Conservation and diversion: water-control systems in the Anasazi Southwest. In Irrigation's impacton Society, edited by Downing, Theodore E. and McGuire, Gibson, pp. 95–112. Anthropological Papers of the University of Arizona No. 25.Google Scholar
Wendorf, Fred, and Reed, Erik K. 1955 An alternative reconstruction of northern Rio Grande prehistory. El Palacio 62:131–173.Google Scholar
Wetherington, Ronald K. 1968 Excavations at Pot Creek Pueblo. Fort Burgwin Research Center Report No. 6. Fort Burgwin Research Center, Taos, New Mexico.Google Scholar
Windes, Thomas C. 1977 Typology and technology of Anasazi ceramics. In Settlement and subsistence along the lower Chaco River: the CGP survey, edited by Reher, Charles A., pp. 279–370. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Wittfogel, Karl, and Goldfrank, Esther 1943 Some aspects of Pueblo mythology and society. Journal of American Folklore 56:17–30.Google Scholar
Wobst, Martin H. 1977 Stylistic behavior and information exchanges. In Papers for the director: research essays in honor of James B. Griffin, edited by Cleland, Charles E., pp. 317–342. Anthropological Papers No. 61, University of Michigan, Museum of Anthropology.Google Scholar
Woodbury, Richard 1954 Prehistoric stone implements of northeastern Arizona. Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology 34.Google Scholar
Yoffee, Norman 1979 The decline and rise of Mesopotamian civilization: an ethnoarchaeological perspective on the evolutionof social complexity. American Antiquity 44:5–35.Google Scholar
Zubrow, Ezra 1975 Prehistoric carrying capacity: a model. Cummings, Menlo Park, California.Google Scholar
Zubrow, Ezra 1976 Stability and instability: a problem in long-term regional growth. In Demographic anthropology:quantitative approaches, edited by Zubrow, E., pp. 245–273. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar