No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
British Imperial Attitudes in the Early Modern Era: The Case of Charles Ware Malet in India*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 July 2014
Extract
Relationships between the representatives of British imperial expansion and the people of the regions which came under their influence have long been subjected to scholarly investigation. Such studies have focused on economic interdependencies, racial tensions, and military confrontations. In the case of India the best discussion of cultural interactions was presented fifty years ago by Percival Spear who examined the “social life of the English in eighteenth century India.” Spear was much concerned with the attitudes which the British developed towards the peoples of India in a period of transition which later led to “many of the problems of racial relations in India.” He pointed out that the early English traders were not burdened with color prejudice and were willing to adopt Indian customs when useful or profitable. As the number of Europeans, especially soldiers and women, increased in India, the early tolerance was overwhelmed by the view that Indian society was stagnant and morally inferior.
Subsequent evaluations of British attitudes in eighteenth century India have differed little from Spear's picture. George Bearce emphasized the sense of wonder many Englishmen held toward India and that their motivation in going there was primarily one of profit. He also underscored what Spear had previously noted, that “the British relied principally on British prejudices and thought, rather than a knowledge of India or standards devised from Indian experience.” The British believed that India had little to offer the West intellectually and that the climate combined with despotism had created a society incapable of change. There were rare exceptions to such generalizations, particularly in the period after Clive's success. Scholars such as William Jones and officials such as Warren Hastings came to have a greater appreciation for Indian culture. However, even Hastings measured Indian society by European standards, which led in less perceptive minds to “an acutely messianic form of racial pride and religious smugness.” By the turn of the nineteenth century most Europenas had adopted the “Peter Pan theory” of Asians as unchanging children. Subsequently, the inflexible attitudes of Evangelicals and Utilitarians produced “a ruling class consciously isolated and imbued with a sense of racial superiority.”
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © North American Conference on British Studies 1982
Footnotes
*
Funds for research were provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities and the Penrose Fund of the American Philosophical Society.
References
1 Spear, Percival, The Nabobs: A Study of the Social Life of the English in Eighteenth Century India (Rev. P.B. edition, London, 1963; original ed. Oxford, 1932).Google Scholar
2 Ibid., p. v.
3 Ibid., pp. 9, 32.
4 Ibid., pp. 29, 129-134, 140-142.
5 Bearce, George, British Attitudes Towards India, 1789-1858 (Oxford, 1961), p. 299Google Scholar; “British Attitudes To India” in Iyer, Raghavan ed., The Glass Curtain Between Asia and Europe (London, 1965), p. 201.Google Scholar
6 Spear, , Nabobs, p. 143.Google Scholar
7 Bearce, , Attitudes, p. 299.Google Scholar
8 Marshall, P.J. ed., The British Discovery of Hinduism in the Eighteenth Century (Cambridge, 1970), p. 3.Google Scholar
9 Marshall, P.J., “French and British Approaches to India in the Eighteenth Century,” Bengal Past and Present 89 (1970): 1–15Google Scholar; Mukherjee, S.N., Sir William Jones: A Study in Eighteenth Century British Attitudes in India (Cambridge, 1968)Google Scholar; Van Aalst, Frank D., “The Eighteenth Century French View of India,” Bengal Past and Present 88 (1969): 90–102Google Scholar. The last presents a more negative opinion of British attitudes, comparing the English unfavorably with the French.
10 Marshall, P.J., “Warren Hastings as Scholar and Patron” in Whiteman, Ann, Bromley, J.S. and Dickson, P.G.M. eds., Statesmen, Scholars and Merchants: Essays in Eighteenth Century History Presented to Dame Lucy Sutherland (Oxford, 1973), p. 262.Google Scholar
11 Iyer, Raghavan, “The Glass Curtain Between Asia and Europe” in Iyer, ed., The Glass Curtain, pp. 15–16.Google Scholar
12 Stokes, Eric, The English Utilitarians and India (Oxford, 1959), p. 27Google Scholar. For similar views of the nineteenth century see Greenberger, Allen J., The British Image of India: A Study in the Literature of Imperialism (London, 1969), pp. 19–42Google Scholar; Pannikar, K.M., Asia and Western Dominance: A Survey of the Vasco da Gama Epoch of Asian History, 1498-1945 (London, 1953), p. 116.Google Scholar
13 D.N.B.
14 Malet's letters are in the India Office Library (hereafter cited as I.O.L.) of the Commonwealth Relations Office (London) in the series Eur. F/149. Some of these letters have been published in Sardesai, Govind Sakharam, ed., Poona Residency Correspondence 1786-1797 (Malet Embassy) (Bombay, 1936) 2Google Scholar. Letters to Cornwallis are in the P.R.O. Cornwallis Correspondence (30/11). Additional miscellaneous letters are among the Additional MSS in the British Library.
15 Spear, , Nabobs, pp. 72–74.Google Scholar
16 I.O.L. Eur. F149/47/p. 4.
17 Bickford to Sir Thomas Smith, March 4, 1617, in Foster, William, ed., Letters Received by the East India Company from its servants in the East, Transcribed from the Original Correspondence Series of the India Office Records, 6 vols. (London, 1896–1902), 5:134.Google Scholar
18 Pearce, Roy Harvey, The Savages of America: A Study of the Indian and the Idea of Civilization (Baltimore, 1965), p. 12Google Scholar, from Nova Britannic (1609), p. 8Google Scholar (cited in Purchas, Samuel, Hakluyt's Posthumus or Purchas His Pilgrims, (1625).Google Scholar
19 Rich, Barnabe, A New Description of Ireland … (London, 1610), pp. 8, 15.Google Scholar
20 In Hughes, Charles, Shakespeare's Europe: Unpublished Chapters of Fynes Moryson's Itinerary (London, 1903), p. 482.Google Scholar
21 Hodgen, Margaret, Early Anthropology in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries (Philadelphia, 1964), p. 178.Google Scholar
22 Gordon, Rosemary, “Stereotype and Imagery of Belief as an Ego Defence,” British Journal of Psychology Monograph Supplements 34 (Cambridge, 1962): 5, 18–46.Google Scholar
23 Ballhatchet, Kenneth, Race, Sex and Class Under the Raj: Imperial Attitudes and Policies and their Critics, 1793-1905 (London, 1980), p. 12.Google Scholar
24 Gordon, , Stereotype and Imagery, p. 89Google Scholar; Ballhatchet, Ibid., p. 8.
25 The British perceived a French threat in eighteenth century India and Ireland, but the foe was seen as Spain in seventeenth century Ireland and America.
26 I.O.L. Eur. F 149/47/p. 7.
27 Memmi, Albert, The Colonizer and the Colonized (New York, 1965), pp. 4–7.Google Scholar
28 Marshall, P. J., East India Fortunes: The British in Bengal in the Eighteenth Century (Oxford, 1976), p. 17.Google Scholar
29 Ibid., p. 18; Cannon, Garland, Oriental Jones: A Biography of Sir William Jones (1746-1794) (London, 1964), pp. 54–55Google Scholar; Mukherjee, , Sir William Jones, pp. 2, 13.Google Scholar
30 Jackson, Donald, Intermarriage in Ireland, 1550-1650 (Montreal and Minneapolis, 1970), p. 16.Google Scholar
31 To Alderman Faulkner, July 1, 1762, in Dobree, Bonamy, ed., The Letters of Philip Dormer Stanhope, 4th Earl of Chesterfield 6 vols., (London, 1932) 6:2394.Google Scholar
32 Sutherland, Lucy S., The East India Company in Eighteenth Century Politics (Oxford, 1952), p. 53.Google Scholar
33 Marshall, , Fortunes, p. 158.Google Scholar
34 Ibid., p. 49.
35 Ibid., pp. 180-196.
36 Ibid., pp. 215, 219.
37 Nightingale, Pamela, Trade and Empire in Western India, 1784-1806 (Cambridge, 1970), pp. ix, 5, 24.Google Scholar
38 August 12, 1772, B.L. Add. MSS 45438 f. 69.
39 Sutherland, , East India Company, p. 81.Google Scholar
40 Ross, Charles ed., Correspondence of Charles, First Marquis Cornwallis, 4 vols. (London, 1859) 1:176.Google Scholar
41 Franklin, and Wickwire, Mary, Cornwallis: The Imperial Years (Chapel Hill, 1980), p. 29.Google Scholar
42 Mornington to Grenville, Feb. 21, 1799, B.L. Add. MSS 58911/ f. 140.
43 Dundas to Grenville, April 27, 1797, B.L. Add. MSS 58916/ ff. 5-7.
44 Malet to Grenville, August 8, 1795, B.L. Add. MSS 58915/ ff. 202-203.
45 I.O.L. Eur. F 149/ 58/ f. 19.
46 David Scott to William Fairlie, Jan. 8, 1796 in Philips, C.H., ed., The Correspondence of David Scott Director and Chairman of the East India Company, 2 vols. (Camden Society 3rd series, 75, 76, 1951) 1:52.Google Scholar
47 I.O.L. Eur. F. 149/ 58/ f. 19.
48 Malet to John Griffith, Jan. 29, 1777, I.O.L. Eur. F. 149. 49/ n.p.
49 Malet to William Pemberton, July 23, 1779, I.O.L. Eur. F. 149/ 50/ pp. 192-194.
50 Edmund Welles, B.L. Add. MSS 29252/ f. 21; Jennings, Francis, The Invasion of America: Indians, Colonialism and the Cant of Conquest (Chapel Hill, 1975), p. 59.Google Scholar
51 Stevens, John, The Journal of John Stevens Containing a Brief Account of the War in Ireland, 1689-1691, ed., Murray, Robert H. (Oxford, 1912), p. 217.Google Scholar
52 Lawrence, Richard, The Interest of Ireland in its Trade and Wealth Stated, 2 parts (London, 1682) 1:5.Google Scholar
53 P.R.O. 30/11/14/ f. 255.
54 Malet to John MacPherson, April 5, 1786, I.O.L. Eur. F. 149/ 1/ p. 66.
55 Malet to Cornwallis, June 3, 1787, P.R.O. 30/11/17/ f. 326.
56 Ibid., f. 333.
57 Malet to Cornwallis, June 27, 1787, P.R.O. 30/11/17/ f. 399.
58 June 27, 1787, P.R.O. 30/11/17/ ff. 392-393.
59 Malet to Cornwallis, Aug. 4, 1787, P.R.O. 30/11/10/ f. 461.
60 Andrew Trollope to Francis Walsingham, Sept. 12, 1581, P.R.O. S.P. 63/85/ f. 198.
61 Dunton, John, The Life and Errors of John Dunton, Citizen of London … to which are added, Dunton's Conversations in Ireland …, 2 vols. (London, 1818), 2:616.Google Scholar
62 Malet to Cornwallis, Oct. 3, 1787, P.R.O. 30/11/20/ f. 223.
63 Malet to Cornwallis, Feb. 3, 1788, P.R.O. 30/11/22/ff. 277-278.
64 Malet to Sir John Shore, Feb. 20, 1797, I.O.L. Eur. F. 149./ 57/ p. 217.
65 Hogan, James, Ireland in the European System, 1500-1557 (london, 1920), pp. xxiv–xxv.Google Scholar
66 Pieronus, Peter J., “The Desmond Imperial Alliance of 1529: Its Effects on Henry VIII's Policy Toward Ireland,” Eire-Ireland 9(1975):20.Google Scholar
67 Knowler, William ed., The Earl of Strafforde's Letters and Dispatches 2 vols. (London, 1739) 1: Feb. 26, 1631(2).Google Scholar
68 J. Craggs to Lord Bolton, P.R.O. S.P. 67/7 ff. 37, 71.
69 June 13, 1798, B.L. Add. MSS 13459/ f. 6.
70 MacPherson to Hastings, March 15, 1776, B.L. Add. MSS 29317/ ff. 104-107.
71 David Anderson to Hastings, Feb. 1, 1793, B.L. Add. MSS 45418/ ff. 60-61.
72 Nightingale, , Trade, pp. 157–160, 196.Google Scholar
73 June 27, 1791, I.O.L. Eur. F. 149/ 54/ pp. 894-895.
74 Sardesai, , ed., Poona Residency Correspondence, 2:202.Google Scholar
75 B.L. Add. MSS 58974/ ff. 7-10(Feb. 14, 1797), ff. 17-20(Aug. 31, 1792), ff. 21-22 (Aug. 14, 1792), ff. 27-29 (Feb. 7, 1793), ff. 35-36 (Dec. 3, 1793).
76 Aug. 8, 1795, B.L. Add. MSS 58915/ ff. 202-203.
77 April 27, 1796, B.L. Add. MSS 58019/ ff. 5-7.
78 For exceptions see note 9.
79 See Mannoni, O., Prospero and Caliban: The Psychology of Colonization, Trans., Powesland, Pamela (New York, 1956)Google Scholar, and Mason, Philip, Prospero's Magic: Some Thoughts on Class and Race (London, 1962).Google Scholar