Stress Analysis of Thin Metal Construction

H. L. Cox

doi:10.1017/S0368393100105048

Stress Analysis of Thin Metal Construction

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 July 2016

H. L. Cox

Article contents

Extract
References

Get access

Rights & Permissions

Extract

In seeking to analyse the stress distribution in a complex structure, our object is really twofold. In the first place, if the stress in each part is accurately known, the strength of each part separately can be assessed on the basis of tests on simple units and the necessity for testing the complete structure may be avoided. In the second place, if the stress distribution can be expressed as a function of the geometry of the structure, the effect of varying that geometry, particularly with the object of realising Holmes’ one-hoss-shay, can be examined theoretically and arbitrary-features of the design can be eliminated. If our knowledge were complete, any structure designed to a maximal or minimal condition would not permit any variation from one ideal form, the design would be uniquely determined by the stated requirements.

Type: Proceedings
Information: The Aeronautical Journal , Volume 44 , Issue 351 , March 1940 , pp. 231 - 282

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0368393100105048 [Opens in a new window]
Copyright: Copyright © Royal Aeronautical Society 1940

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

I. General

(a) Theory

(b) Practical

II. Flat Panels

(a) Theory of Buckling

(i) Compression

(ii) Shear

(b) Behaviour after Buckling and Strength

(i) Compression

(ii) Shear

III. Curved Panels

(a) Theory of Buckling

(i) Compression

(ii) Shear

(b) Behaviour after Buckling and Strength

(i) Compression

(ii) Shear

IV. Tubes

(a) Theory of Buckling

(i) Compression and Bending

(ii) Torsion

(b) Behaviour after Buckling and Strength

(i) Compression

(ii) Bending

(iii) Torsion

(iv) Combined Bending and Shear

V. Strength of Stiffeners

VI. Stability Under Compression of Combinations of Stiffeners and Panels

(a) Theoretical

(b) Experimental

VII. Stability of Corrugated and Orthotropic Panels

(a) Theoretical

(b) Experimental

VIII. Stability of Orthotropic Cylinders

IX. Stiffening of Holes Cut in Monocoque Structure

X. Diffusion of Concentrated Loads into Monocoque Structure

XI. Rivets

1. Timoshenko, S.. The Theory of Elastic Stability (Book). McGraw Hill, 1936.Google Scholar

2. Southwell, R. V.. On the General Theory of Elastic Stability. Phil, Trans. A., Vol. 213, p. 187.Google Scholar

3. Donnell, L. H., Sechler, E. E. and Kármán, Th. V.. Survey of Problems of Thin- Walled Structures. C.I.T. Pub., No. 16.Google Scholar

4. Gerard, I. J.. Monocoque Construction. J.R.Ae.S., Vol. 41, p. 467.Google Scholar

5. Heck, O. S. and Ebner, H., Formulæ and Methods of Calculation of the Strength of Plate and Shell Structures in Aeroplane Construction. J.R.Ae.S., Vol. 40, p. 769.Google Scholar

6. Hoff, N. J.. Instability of Monocoque Structures in Pure Bending. T.R.Ae.S., Vol. 42, p. 291.Google Scholar

7. Wagner, H.. The Stress Distribution in Shell Bodies and Wings as an Equilibrium Problem. N.A.C.A. Techl. Mem., No. 817.Google Scholar

8. Ebner, H.. The Strength of Shell Bodies—Theory and Practice. N.A.C.A. Techl. Mem., No. 838.Google Scholar

9. Southwell, R. V.. On the Analysis of Experimental Observations in Problems of Elastic Stability. Proc. Roy. Soc. A., Vol. 135, p. 601.Google Scholar

10. Bryan, G. H.. On the Stability of a Plane Plate under Thrust. Proc. Lond. Math. Soc., Series 1, Vol. 22, p. 54.Google Scholar

11. Taylor, G. I.. The Buckling Load of a Rectangular Plate with Four Clamped Edges. Z.A.M.M. 13, p. 147.Google Scholar

12. Faxen, H.. Buckling of a Rectangular Plate. Z.A.M.M. 15, p. 268.Google Scholar

13. Weinstein, A.. On a Minimal Problem in the Theory of Elasticity. Jour. Lond. Math. Soc., Vol. 10, p. 184.Google Scholar

14. Trefftz, E.. The Estimation of the Buckling Load of a Rectangular Plate under Compression. Z.A.M.M. 15, p. 339.Google Scholar

15. Southwell, R. V. and Skan, S. W.. On the Stability under Shearing Forces of a Flat Elastic Strip. Proc. Roy. Soc. A., Vol. 105, p. 582.Google Scholar

16. Gough, H. J. and Cox, H. L.. Some Tests on the Stability of Thin Strip Material under Shearing Forces in the Plane of the Strip. Proc. Roy. Soc. A., Vol. 137, p. 145.Google Scholar

17. Aldous, C. W., Cox, H. L. and Gough, H. J.. The Strength of Panel Bracing. A.R.C. Techl. Rep. No. 3029 (unpublished).Google Scholar

18. Cox, H. L.. The Buckling of Thin Plates in Compression. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1554.Google Scholar

19. Kármán, Th. V.. The Strength of Thin Plates in Compression. C.I.T. Pub. No. 13.Google Scholar

20. Schuman, L. and Back, G.. Strength of Rectangular Plates under Edge Compression. N.A.C.A. Techl. Rep. No. 356.Google Scholar

21. Sechler, E. E.. The Ultimate Strength of Thin Flat Sheets in Compression. C.I.T. Pub. No. 27.Google Scholar

22. Lahde, R. and Wagner, H.. Experimental Studies of the Effective Width of Buckled Sheet. L.F.F. 18, p. 214.Google Scholar

23. Marguerre, K.. The Effective Width of a Compressed Plate. L.F.F. 14, p. 121.Google Scholar

24. Wagner, H.. Plane Panel Frames of very Thin Sheet. Z.F.M. 20, p. 200 et seq.Google Scholar

25. Kuhn, P.. A Summary of Design Formulae for Beams having Thin Webs in Diagonal Tension. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 469.Google Scholar

26. Atkin, E. H.. Stiffness in Stressed Skins. Aircraft Engineering, Vol. 8, p. 213.CrossRef Google Scholar

27. Schapitz, E.. Contributions to the Theory of the Incomplete Tension Bay. L.F.F. 14, p. 129.Google Scholar

28. Redshaw, S. C.. Elastic Stability of a Curved Plate under Axial Thrust. J.R.Ae.S., Vol. 42, p. 536.Google Scholar

29. Leggett, D. M. A.. The Elastic Stability of a Long Slightly Bent Rectangular Plate under Uniform Shear. Proc. Roy. Soc. A., Vol. 162, p. 62.Google Scholar

30. Sechler, E. E.. Preliminary Report on the Ultimate Compressive Strength of Curved Panels. C.I.T. Pub. No. 36.Google Scholar

31. Cox, H. L. and Clenshaw, W. J.. Compression Tests on Curved Panels of Thin Sheet Duralumin. A.R.C. Techl. Rep. No. 1576 (unpublished).Google Scholar

32. Marguerre, K.. On the Strength of Shells of Small Curvature. Proc. 5th Int. Cong. App. Mechanics. (See also Ref. 8.)Google Scholar

33. Smith, G. M.. Strength in Shear of Thin Curved Sheets of Alclad. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 343.Google Scholar

34. Wagner, H. and Ballerstedt, W.. Fields of Tension Stress in Thin Plates, Initially Curved, under Shear Load. L.F.F. 12, p. 70.Google Scholar

35. Chwalla, E.. Collapse of Tubes under End Thrust. Z.A.M.M. 10, p. 72.Google Scholar

36. Donnell, L. H.. A New Theory for the Buckling of Thin Cylinders under Axial Compression'and Bending. A.S.M.E., AER-56-12.Google Scholar

37. Brazier, L. G.. The Flexure of Thin Cylindrical Shells and other Thin Sections. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1081. (See also Ref. 2.)Google Scholar

38. Schwerin, E.. Torsional Stability of Thin-Walled Tubes. Z.A.M.M., Vol. 5, p. 235.Google Scholar

39. Donnell, L. H.. Stability of Thin-Walled Tubes under Torsion. N.A.C.A. Techl. Rep. 479.Google Scholar

40. Southwell, R. V.. On the Torsion of Conical Shells. Proc. Roy. Soc. A., Vol. 163, p. 337.Google Scholar

41. Robertson, A.. The Strength of Tubular Struts. Proc. Roy. Soc. A., Vol. 121, p. 558.Google Scholar

42. Lundquist, E. E.. Strength Tests of Duralumin Cylinders in Compression. N.A.C.A. Techl. Rep. No. 473.Google Scholar

43. Lundquist, E. E.. Strength Tests of Duralumin Cylinders in Pure Bending. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 479.Google Scholar

44. Lundquist, E. E. and Burke, W. F.. Strength Tests of Thin-Walled Duralumin Cylinders of Elliptic Section. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 527. (See also Ref. 4.)Google Scholar

45. Robertson, A. and Newport, A. J.. Torsion of Metal Tubes. III. Elastic Instability of Thin Tubes. A.R.C. Techl. Rep. No. 28.Google Scholar

46. Lundquist, E. E.. Strength Tests of Thin-Walled Duralumin Cylinders in Torsion. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 427.Google Scholar

47. Bridget, F. J., Jerome, C. C. and Vosseller, A. B.. Some New Experiments, on Buckling of Thin-Wall Construction—Buckling under Combined Bending and Torsion. A.S.M.E., APM-56-6.Google Scholar

48. Lundquist, E. E.. Strength of Thin-Walled Duralumin Cylinders in Combined Transverse Shear and Bending. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 523. (See also Ref. 4.)Google Scholar

49. Trayer, G. W. and March, H. W.. Elastic Instability of Members having Sections common in Aircraft Construction. N.A.C.A. Techl. Rep. No. 382Google Scholar

50. Wagner, H. and Pretschner, W.. Torsion and Buckling of Open Sections. N.A.C.A. Techl Mem. No. 784.Google Scholar

51. Parr, W. S. and Beakley, W. M.. An Investigation of Duralumin Channel Section Struts under Compression. J. Aero. Sci., Vol. 3, p. 21.Google Scholar

52. Lundquist, E. E.. The Compressive Strength of Duralumin Columns of Equal Angle Section. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 413. (See also Ref. 47.)Google Scholar

53. Taylor, J. L.. Stability of a Monocoque in Compression. A.R.C, R. & M. 1679.Google Scholar

54. Cox, H. L. and Smith, H. E.. The Buckling of Grids of Stringers and Ribs. A.R.C. Techl. Rep. No. 2731. (To be published.)Google Scholar

55. Cox, H. L. and Clenshaw, W. J.. The Buckling of Combinations of Sheet and Stringers. A.R.C. Techl. Rep. No. 1586 (unpublished).Google Scholar

56. Lundquist, E. E.. Comparison of Three Methods for Calculating the Compressive Strength of Flat and Slightly Curved Sheet and Stringer Combinations. N.A.C.A. Techl. Note No. 455.Google Scholar

57. Newell, J. S. and Gale, W. H.. Report on Aircraft Materials Research at Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1930–31.Google Scholar

58. Gerard, I. J. and Dickens, B. G.. Stressed Skin Structures. Compression Tests of Panels with Tubular Stiffeners. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1830.Google Scholar

59. Ramberg, W., McPherson, A. E. and Levy, S.. Experimental Study of Sheet Stringer Panels under End Compression. Proc. 5th Int. Cong. App. Mech.Google Scholar

60. Dean, W. R.. The Elastic Stability of a Corrugated Plate. Proc. Roy. Soc. A., Vol. III , p. 144. (See also Ref. 53.)Google Scholar

61. Bergmann, S. and Reissner, H.. The Buckling of Corrugated Sheet in Shear. Z.F.M. 20, p. 475.Google Scholar

62. Seydel, E.. Buckling Tests of Panels of Corrugated Sheet. J.D.V.L. 1931, p. 233.Google Scholar

63. Greene, C. F. and Brown, C. G.. The Column Properties of Corrugated Aluminium Alloy Sheet. A.C.I.C. No. 699. (U.S. Army Air Corps.)Google Scholar

64. Djuan-Dschou, D.. The Buckling under Pressure of a Stiffened Cylindrical Shell. L.F.F. 9, p. 35. (See also Refs. 4, 6 and 8.)Google Scholar

65. Cox, H. L.. Stiffening of Webs containing Holes. A.R.C. Techl. Rep. No. 2158 (unpublished).Google Scholar

66. Gurney, C.. An Analysis of the Stresses in a Flat Plate with a Reinforced Circular Hole under Edge Forces. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1834.Google Scholar

67. Schüssler, K.. Sheet Strip with Bedded Circular Holes in Shear. L.F.F. 11, p. 74.Google Scholar

68. Sezawa, K. and Kubo, K.. Stresses in a Plate with a Flanged Circular Hole. Tokyo Imp. Univ., Aero. Res. Inst., Rep. No. 84.Google Scholar

69. Mathar, J.. The Resistance to Shear and Buckling of Thin Plates with Lightening Holes. Proc. Aero. Inst., Aachen, 1929.Google Scholar

70. Cox, H. L., Smith, H. E. and Conway, C. G.. Diffusion of Concentrated Loads into Monocoque Structures. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1780.Google Scholar

71. Duncan, W. J.. Diffusion of Load in Certain Sheet-Stringer Combinations. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1825.Google Scholar

72. Smith, H. E.. Diffusion of Load in Sheet-Stringer Combinations having a Tapered Centre Stringer. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1862.Google Scholar

73. Cox, H. L.. Diffusion of Concentrated Loads into Monocoque Structure. General Considerations with particular reference to Bending Load Distributions. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1860.Google Scholar

74. Winny, H. F.. The Distribution of Stress in Monocoque Wings. A.R.C, R. & M. No. 1756.Google Scholar

75. Reissner, E.. On the Problem of Stress Distribution in Wide Flanged Box Beams. J. Aero. Sci., Vol. 5, p. 295.Google Scholar

76. Lovett, B. B. C. and Rodee, W. F.. Transfer of Stress from Main Beams to Intermediate Stiffeners in Metal Sheet covered Box Beams. J. Aero. Sci., Vol. 3, p. 426.Google Scholar

77. White, R. J. and Autz, H. M.. Tests on the Stress Distribution in Reinforced Panels. J. Aero. Sci., Vol. 3, p. 209.Google Scholar

78. Schapitz, E., Feller, H. and Köller, H.. Experimental and Analytical Investigation into the Bending of a Model Monocoque Wing. L.F.F. 15, p. 563.Google Scholar

79. Kuhn, P.. Stress Analysis of Beams with Shear Deformation of the Flanges. N.A.C.A. Rep. No. 608.Google Scholar

80. Kuhn, P.. Approximate Stress Analysis of Multi-Stringer Beams with Shear Deformation of the Flanges. N.A.C.A. Rep. No. 636.Google Scholar

81. Ebner, H. and Köller, H.. Calculation of Load Distribution in Stiffened Cylindrical Shells. N.A.C.A. Techl. Mem. No. 866.Google Scholar

82. Ebner, H. and Köller, H.. On the Load Distribution in Longitudinally and Laterally Stiffened Shells. L.F.F. 15, p. 527.Google Scholar

83. Howland, W. L.. Effect of Rivet Spacing on Stiffened Thin Sheet underCompression. J. Aero. Sci., Vol. 3, No. 12, p. 434.Google Scholar

84. Kromm, A.. The Effect of Rivet Spacing on the Pressure Resistance of Reinforced Duralumin Shells. L.F.F. 14, No. 3, p. 116.Google Scholar

85. Portier, H.. The Riveting of Thin Sheets in Aeronautical Construction. Pub. Sci. et Tech. du Min. de l'air. B.S.7, No. 87.Google Scholar