Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Table of Contents
- 1 Writing History in Late Antique Iberia: Theory and Praxis
- 2 Para qué sirve la Historia : Principios teóricos de la historiografía hispana tardoantigua
- 3 From Christian Historiography to the Emergence of National Histories : Spanish Historiography between Romans and Visigoths
- 4 Orosius: An Iberian Patriot’s History of Rome
- 5 Orosius, Barbarians, and the Christian Success Story
- 6 Prophecies and Omens of the Fall of the Roman Empire in the Chronicle of Hydatius of Lemica
- 7 La dimensión política de los historiadores del reino visigodo de Toledo
- 8 The Definitions and Uses of Historia in Isidore of Seville
- 9 Bishops and Their Biographers : The Praxis of History Writing in Visigothic Iberia
- 10 Local Powers and Construction of the Past in the Visigothic Kingdom of Hispania
- 11 The Contemplation of the Past in the Libellus Precum of Faustinus (and Marcellinus)
- 12 Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy : The Historiography of Hispania in Late Antiquity
- 13 Expulsados de la Historia : El argumento histórico en la polémica antijudía hispana (siglos IV-VII)
- 14 Consideraciones sobre la temporalidad en las Vitae Sanctorum visigóticas
- 15 The Image of Leovigild as Arian Monarch in the ‘Vitas Patrum Emeritensium’ : From Historical Reality to Hagiographical Deformation
- Index
3 - From Christian Historiography to the Emergence of National Histories : Spanish Historiography between Romans and Visigoths
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 18 April 2023
- Frontmatter
- Table of Contents
- 1 Writing History in Late Antique Iberia: Theory and Praxis
- 2 Para qué sirve la Historia : Principios teóricos de la historiografía hispana tardoantigua
- 3 From Christian Historiography to the Emergence of National Histories : Spanish Historiography between Romans and Visigoths
- 4 Orosius: An Iberian Patriot’s History of Rome
- 5 Orosius, Barbarians, and the Christian Success Story
- 6 Prophecies and Omens of the Fall of the Roman Empire in the Chronicle of Hydatius of Lemica
- 7 La dimensión política de los historiadores del reino visigodo de Toledo
- 8 The Definitions and Uses of Historia in Isidore of Seville
- 9 Bishops and Their Biographers : The Praxis of History Writing in Visigothic Iberia
- 10 Local Powers and Construction of the Past in the Visigothic Kingdom of Hispania
- 11 The Contemplation of the Past in the Libellus Precum of Faustinus (and Marcellinus)
- 12 Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy : The Historiography of Hispania in Late Antiquity
- 13 Expulsados de la Historia : El argumento histórico en la polémica antijudía hispana (siglos IV-VII)
- 14 Consideraciones sobre la temporalidad en las Vitae Sanctorum visigóticas
- 15 The Image of Leovigild as Arian Monarch in the ‘Vitas Patrum Emeritensium’ : From Historical Reality to Hagiographical Deformation
- Index
Summary
Abstract
Between the fifth and seventh centuries, the historiographical genre of Christian inspiration and Roman orientation gradually gave way to the national histories of the Roman-Germanic peoples settled in the pars occidentis of the empire. Because of their structure, national histories have many things in common with the ancient historiographical works but differ in their ideological foundation and interpretation of the episodes narrated. Christian authors combine ecclesiastical and political events, interpreting them according to a providential conception of history. This phenomenon can also be observed in Spanish historiography. The writings of Hydatius of Lemica, John of Biclaro, Isidore of Seville, and Julian of Toledo provide us with valuable insights into the various reactions to the invasions of Germanic peoples in the Iberian Peninsula and other events otherwise unknown.
Keywords: Christian Historiography, National Histories, Romans, Visigoths
The proliferation of known ‘Ecclesiastical Histories’ should be located in the Greek-Byzantine world, where a theological-political reflection on the empire, conceived as universal and providential, made inroads. Eusebius of Caesarea is unanimously considered the founder of this Christian historiographic genre, which spread in later centuries in both the East and the West. Eusebius’s Chronici canones , in fact, radically transformed the formulation of Christian Chronography and he created a new literary genre with the Historia Ecclesiastica . This author conceived a new type of history, unconventional in outlook and methodological in approach, grounded in a new religion. He established and transmitted the notion that God’s plan of salvation realises itself through the centuries.
Eusebius’s notion is characterised as a providential vision of history, devoid of free will. This is one of the key differences that would soon distinguish pagan from Christian historiography. The first was based on free judgement, which was a source of pride for ancient historians. Conversely, the other was grounded in scriptural authority. Concerning pagan historiography, Eusebius’s originality lies in the object of his history, namely, the church/ churches, which he characterises as the people or the Christian nation (ethnos ). Indeed, the very title of his work, Historia Ecclesiastica , does not refer to the church as a theological and institutional entity. In this work, the word ‘church’ seldom appears in the singular, indicating the theological notion of a universal church intended as an assembly united by faith, feeling, and institutions.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Writing History in Late Antique IberiaHistoriography in Theory and Practice from the 4th to the 7th Century, pp. 43 - 64Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2022