Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
- INTRODUCTION TO THIS VOLUME
- BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTE
- Modern Painters, Vol. IV. (CONTAINING THE TEXT OF ALL THE EDITIONS)
- PREFACE
- PART V “OF MOUNTAIN BEAUTY”
- CHAP. I OF THE TURNERIAN PICTURESQUE
- CHAP. II OF TURNERIAN TOPOGRAPHY
- CHAP. III OF TURNERIAN LIGHT
- CHAP. IV OF TURNERIAN MYSTERY:—FIRST, AS ESSENTIAL
- CHAP. V OF TURNERIAN MYSTERY:—SECONDLY, WILFUL
- CHAP. VI THE FIRMAMENT
- CHAP. VII THE DRY LAND
- CHAP. VIII OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—FIRST, COMPACT CRYSTALLINES
- CHAP. IX OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—SECONDLY, SLATY CRYSTALLINES
- CHAP. X OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—THIRDLY, SLATY COHERENTS
- CHAP. XI OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—FOURTHLY, COMPACT COHERENTS
- CHAP. XII OF THE SCULPTURE OF MOUNTAINS:—FIRST, THE LATERAL RANGES
- CHAP. XIII OF THE SCULPTURE OF MOUNTAINS:—SECONDLY, THE CENTRAL PEAKS
- CHAP. XIV RESULTING FORMS:—FIRST, AIGUILLES
- CHAP. XV RESULTING FORMS:—SECONDLY, CRESTS
- CHAP. XVI RESULTING FORMS:—THIRDLY, PRECIPICES
- CHAP. XVII RESULTING FORMS:—FOURTHLY, BANKS
- CHAP. XVIII RESULTING FORMS:—FIFTHLY, STONES
- CHAP. XIX THE MOUNTAIN GLOOM
- CHAP. XX THE MOUNTAIN GLORY
- APPENDIX
- Plate section
CHAP. XVIII - RESULTING FORMS:—FIFTHLY, STONES
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 07 September 2011
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
- INTRODUCTION TO THIS VOLUME
- BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTE
- Modern Painters, Vol. IV. (CONTAINING THE TEXT OF ALL THE EDITIONS)
- PREFACE
- PART V “OF MOUNTAIN BEAUTY”
- CHAP. I OF THE TURNERIAN PICTURESQUE
- CHAP. II OF TURNERIAN TOPOGRAPHY
- CHAP. III OF TURNERIAN LIGHT
- CHAP. IV OF TURNERIAN MYSTERY:—FIRST, AS ESSENTIAL
- CHAP. V OF TURNERIAN MYSTERY:—SECONDLY, WILFUL
- CHAP. VI THE FIRMAMENT
- CHAP. VII THE DRY LAND
- CHAP. VIII OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—FIRST, COMPACT CRYSTALLINES
- CHAP. IX OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—SECONDLY, SLATY CRYSTALLINES
- CHAP. X OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—THIRDLY, SLATY COHERENTS
- CHAP. XI OF THE MATERIALS OF MOUNTAINS:—FOURTHLY, COMPACT COHERENTS
- CHAP. XII OF THE SCULPTURE OF MOUNTAINS:—FIRST, THE LATERAL RANGES
- CHAP. XIII OF THE SCULPTURE OF MOUNTAINS:—SECONDLY, THE CENTRAL PEAKS
- CHAP. XIV RESULTING FORMS:—FIRST, AIGUILLES
- CHAP. XV RESULTING FORMS:—SECONDLY, CRESTS
- CHAP. XVI RESULTING FORMS:—THIRDLY, PRECIPICES
- CHAP. XVII RESULTING FORMS:—FOURTHLY, BANKS
- CHAP. XVIII RESULTING FORMS:—FIFTHLY, STONES
- CHAP. XIX THE MOUNTAIN GLOOM
- CHAP. XX THE MOUNTAIN GLORY
- APPENDIX
- Plate section
Summary
§ 1. It is somewhat singular that the indistinctness of treatment which has been so often noticed as characteristic of our present art shows itself always most when there is least apparent reason for it. Modern artists, having some true sympathy with what is vague in nature, draw all that is uncertain and evasive without evasion, and render faithfully whatever can be discerned in faithless mist or mocking vapours; but having no sympathy with what is solid and serene, they seem to become uncertain themselves in proportion to the certainty of what they see; and while they render flakes of far-away cloud, or fringes of inextricable forest, with something like patience and fidelity, give nothing but the hastiest indication of the ground they can tread upon or touch. It is only in modern art that we find any complete representation of clouds, and only in ancient art that, generally speaking, we find any careful realization of Stones.
§ 2. This is all the more strange, because, as we saw some time back, the ruggedness of the stone is more pleasing to the modern than the mediæval, and he rarely completes any picture satisfactorily to himself unless large spaces of it are filled with irregular masonry, rocky banks, or shingly shores: whereas the mediæval could conceive no desirableness in the loose and unhewn masses; associated them generally in his mind with wicked men, and the martyrdom of St. Stephen; and always threw them out of his road, or garden, to the best of his power.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Works of John Ruskin , pp. 365 - 384Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2010First published in: 1904