Book contents
- Why the Electoral College Is Bad for America
- Why the Electoral College Is Bad for America
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Tables
- Preface
- 1 Raising Questions
- 2 How the Electoral College Works
- 3 The Electoral College and Political Equality
- 4 Contingent Elections
- 5 The Origins of the Electoral College
- 6 Protecting Interests
- 7 Maintaining Cohesion
- 8 Preserving the Party System
- 9 Conclusion
- Appendix US Constitutional Provisions Relating to Presidential Elections
- Notes
- Index
- References
5 - The Origins of the Electoral College
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 09 November 2023
- Why the Electoral College Is Bad for America
- Why the Electoral College Is Bad for America
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Tables
- Preface
- 1 Raising Questions
- 2 How the Electoral College Works
- 3 The Electoral College and Political Equality
- 4 Contingent Elections
- 5 The Origins of the Electoral College
- 6 Protecting Interests
- 7 Maintaining Cohesion
- 8 Preserving the Party System
- 9 Conclusion
- Appendix US Constitutional Provisions Relating to Presidential Elections
- Notes
- Index
- References
Summary
It is not possible to argue that the framers wisely created the electoral college and provided a sound basis for selecting the president in the twenty-first century. The electoral college does not work at all as the framers anticipated. Electors rarely exercise discretion and are condemned when they do. Instead, they are agents of political parties, which did not exist in 1787. The House has not selected the president since 1824. In addition, most of the motivations behind the creation of the electoral college are simply irrelevant today. Legislative election is not an option, there is little danger that the president will be too powerful if directly elected, voters have extraordinary access to information on the candidates, there is no justification at all for either electors or state legislatures to exercise discretion in selecting the president, defending the interests of slavery is unthinkable, and the short-term pressures have long dissipated. Those delegates who wanted electors to exercise independent judgment or be selected by state legislatures would soon be disappointed, and there is no support—and no justification—today for either option. In addition, the broad thrust of constitutional revision over the past two centuries has been in the direction of democratization and majority rule.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Why the Electoral College Is Bad for America , pp. 99 - 111Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2023