Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Foreword, by Louis J. Moses
- Acknowledgments
- Note added in proof
- Part I Comparative and Developmental Approaches to Self-awareness
- 1 Expanding dimensions of the self: Through the looking glass and beyond
- 2 Myself and me
- 3 Self-recognition: Research strategies and experimental design
- 4 From self-recognition to theory of mind
- 5 Mutual awareness in primate communication: A Gricean approach
- 6 Multiplicities of self
- 7 Contributions of imitation and role-playing games to the construction of self in primates
- Part II The Development of Self in Human Infants and Children
- Part III Self-awareness in Great Apes
- Part IV Mirrors and Monkeys, Dolphins, and Pigeons
- Part V Epilogue
- Author index
- Subject index
4 - From self-recognition to theory of mind
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 November 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Foreword, by Louis J. Moses
- Acknowledgments
- Note added in proof
- Part I Comparative and Developmental Approaches to Self-awareness
- 1 Expanding dimensions of the self: Through the looking glass and beyond
- 2 Myself and me
- 3 Self-recognition: Research strategies and experimental design
- 4 From self-recognition to theory of mind
- 5 Mutual awareness in primate communication: A Gricean approach
- 6 Multiplicities of self
- 7 Contributions of imitation and role-playing games to the construction of self in primates
- Part II The Development of Self in Human Infants and Children
- Part III Self-awareness in Great Apes
- Part IV Mirrors and Monkeys, Dolphins, and Pigeons
- Part V Epilogue
- Author index
- Subject index
Summary
Gordon Gallup's significant contribution to the psychological study of the self is twofold: He introduced an objective empirical method to examine selfrecognition in nonverbal organisms through the mirror self-recognition (MSR) test, and he developed a challenging theoretical account that postulates an inherent link between the ability for MSR and the capacity to infer mental states in others, that is, for having a theory of mind (ToM). Briefly, Gallup's model states that
MSR implies self-awareness;
this “self-awareness is tantamount to being aware of being aware” (Gallup, 1991, p. 123); and
being aware of one's own “mental states and their relation to various external events” allows one “to gain inferential access” to the mental states of others (Gallup, 1991, p. 123).
Thus, because Gallup's model attributes to the organism showing MSR a level of self-awareness that satisfies the representational preconditions for inferring beliefs in others, he predicts a developmental synchrony between the appearance of MSR and “introspectively based social strategies”, such as intentional deception, that implies a ToM.
Evidence demonstrating that organisms that seem to possess a ToM – such as young children (Astington, Harris, & Olson, 1988) and chimpanzees (Povinelli, Nelson, & Boysen, 1990; Woodruff & Premack, 1979) – also show MSR (Gallup & Suarez, 1986), is clearly in line with this prediction.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Self-Awareness in Animals and HumansDevelopmental Perspectives, pp. 51 - 60Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1994
- 10
- Cited by