On 6 April 1927, the tenth anniversary of the American entry into the Great War, Aristide Briand announced to the press that his government was willing to conclude an agreement with the United States that would renounce war ‘as an instrument of national policy’ in Franco-American relations. The Coolidge Administration did not receive formal notification of Briand's proposal until late June 1927, when the American ambassador at Paris, Myron Herrick, brought the suggested text for a renunciatory pact to Washington during his annual holiday. There was no official American reply until 28 December 1927, when Kellogg informed Paul Claudel, the French ambassador at Washington, that the Coolidge Administration could not entertain the idea of a bilateral Franco-American renunciatory pact.

Kellogg followed this with an interesting diplomatic counter. The existing Franco-American arbitration treaty, concluded in 1908 under the guidance of the then American secretary of state, Elihu Root, was about to lapse. Kellogg tied together the two ideas of international arbitration and a political instrument to renounce the resort to war in international politics.