Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Acknowledgements
- Contents
- Note on Orthography, Transliteration, and Special Usages
- List of Tables
- List of Abbreviations
- Introduction. The Dutch Jerusalem: The Distortions of History
- 1 ‘The True Book of Experience’: Amsterdam's Toleration of the Jews
- 2 Refuge and Opportunity: The Geography of a Jewish Migration
- 3 Commerce, Networks, and Other Relations: The Inner Workings of Portuguese Jewish Entrepreneurship
- 4 Nação and Kahal: A Religious Community in the Making
- 5 ‘Dissonant Words’, ‘Bad Opinions’, and ‘Scandals’: Varieties of Religious Discord and Social Conflict
- 6 A Patchwork Culture: Iberian, Jewish, and Dutch Elements in Peaceable Coexistence
- Conclusion. Reluctant Cosmopolitans: Jewish Ethnicity in statu renascendi
- Appendix: Details of Freight Contracts
- Bibliography
- Index of Persons
- Index of Subjects
1 - ‘The True Book of Experience’: Amsterdam's Toleration of the Jews
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Acknowledgements
- Contents
- Note on Orthography, Transliteration, and Special Usages
- List of Tables
- List of Abbreviations
- Introduction. The Dutch Jerusalem: The Distortions of History
- 1 ‘The True Book of Experience’: Amsterdam's Toleration of the Jews
- 2 Refuge and Opportunity: The Geography of a Jewish Migration
- 3 Commerce, Networks, and Other Relations: The Inner Workings of Portuguese Jewish Entrepreneurship
- 4 Nação and Kahal: A Religious Community in the Making
- 5 ‘Dissonant Words’, ‘Bad Opinions’, and ‘Scandals’: Varieties of Religious Discord and Social Conflict
- 6 A Patchwork Culture: Iberian, Jewish, and Dutch Elements in Peaceable Coexistence
- Conclusion. Reluctant Cosmopolitans: Jewish Ethnicity in statu renascendi
- Appendix: Details of Freight Contracts
- Bibliography
- Index of Persons
- Index of Subjects
Summary
The city of Amsterdam reaps the fruit of this freedom [of conscience] in its own great prosperity and in the admiration of all other people. For in this most flourishing state and most splendid city, men of every nation and religion live together in the greatest harmony, and ask no questions before trusting their goods to a fellowcitizen, save whether he be rich or poor, and whether he generally acts honestly, or the reverse. His religion and sect is considered of no importance: for it has no effect before the judges in gaining or losing a cause, and there is no sect so despised that its followers, provided that they harm no one, pay every man his due, and live uprightly, are deprived of the protection of the magisterial authority.
BENTO ALIAS BARUH DE SPINOZATO this very day both Jewish and non-Jewish Amsterdammers colloquially refer to their city as ‘Mokum’—‘the place’. Nothing expresses so simply and eloquently the very special place of Amsterdam in Jewish history. This reputation derives, in large measure, from the city's centuries-long toleration of Jews and the flourishing of Jewish life that this attitude made possible.
Toleration is as old as Jewish diasporic history itself. Not, admittedly, toleration as we have come to know and value it where it has existed in the last two centuries: prior to the modern era no toleration, anywhere, was ever absolute. Unlike the modern concept of toleration, in which religious liberty is based on acknowledgement of the individual's natural or inalienable rights, pre-modern toleration was more nearly synonymous with permission, granted by an authority. Whether the case involved Jews or, in Europe, fellow Christians, the authority more or less seriously disapproved of the tolerated belief or practice, but had, for reasons of its own, decided not to press its case and apply the full weight of its coercive power against the dissenting group.
Needless to say, there was a great deal of variety in the reasons inspiring dominant groups to extend toleration to dissenting minorities. Sometimes toleration was based on tradition, as, for instance, when the Christian Roman emperors inherited the doctrine of Judaism as religio licita from their pagan
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Reluctant CosmopolitansThe Portuguese Jews of Seventeenth-Century Amsterdam, pp. 8 - 53Publisher: Liverpool University PressPrint publication year: 2000