Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Foreword by E. THOMAS SULLIVAN
- Introduction: An overview of the volume
- Part I The constitutional developments of international trade law
- 1 Sovereignty, subsidiarity, and separation of powers: The high-wire balancing act of globalization
- 2 Constitutionalism and WTO law: From a state-centered approach towards a human rights approach in international economic law
- 3 WTO decision-making: Is it reformable?
- 4 Some institutional issues presently before the WTO
- 5 Domestic regulation and international trade: Where's the race? Lessons from telecommunications and export controls
- Part II The scope of international trade law: Adding new subjects and restructuring old ones
- Part III Legal relations between developed and developing countries
- Part IV The operation of the WTO dispute settlement procedure
- Bibliography of works by ROBERT E. HUDEC
- Index
3 - WTO decision-making: Is it reformable?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 02 September 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Foreword by E. THOMAS SULLIVAN
- Introduction: An overview of the volume
- Part I The constitutional developments of international trade law
- 1 Sovereignty, subsidiarity, and separation of powers: The high-wire balancing act of globalization
- 2 Constitutionalism and WTO law: From a state-centered approach towards a human rights approach in international economic law
- 3 WTO decision-making: Is it reformable?
- 4 Some institutional issues presently before the WTO
- 5 Domestic regulation and international trade: Where's the race? Lessons from telecommunications and export controls
- Part II The scope of international trade law: Adding new subjects and restructuring old ones
- Part III Legal relations between developed and developing countries
- Part IV The operation of the WTO dispute settlement procedure
- Bibliography of works by ROBERT E. HUDEC
- Index
Summary
The task confronting … all who seek to set up a constitution of a particular kind, is not only, or even mainly, to set it up, but rather to keep it going.
AristotlePreliminary remarks
The riotous fiascos in Seattle, in London and Berlin on May Day and, more recently, in Nice at the summit of the European Union have at least one thing in common: some measure of popular disaffection with the workings of intergovernmental constitutions. It therefore seems appropriate and timely to raise certain issues of World Trade Organisation (WTO) institutional reform again. After all, such debates, both in governmental and academic circles, have all along accompanied the birth and lifetime of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and, of course, featured prominently immediately prior to, during and after the Uruguay Round of Multilateral Trade Negotiations (UR). Furthermore, “constitutionalism,” underpinning a third liberal revival, “turning to Market Democracy,” has become part of building a new post-Cold War world which had produced both an age of uncertainty about basic goals and a shift in “world views” or simply “the mood of the time.” It also prompted some socio-economic engineering aimed at changing the socio-economic and socio-ecological context of a more complex and interdependent international economic order, a kind which had previously led to a resounding defeat for the draft Havana Charter and led to the claims made by some Developing Countries (DCs) at the time that “the apparent equality of the procedure can involve the most tremendous and unjust inequalities.”
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Political Economy of International Trade LawEssays in Honor of Robert E. Hudec, pp. 68 - 80Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2002