Book contents
- Legal Reasoning
- Legal Reasoning
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface
- 1 A Brief Introduction to the Common Law
- 2 Rule-Based Legal Reasoning
- 3 Reasoning from Precedent and the Principle of Stare Decisis
- 4 How It Is Determined What Rule a Precedent Establishes
- 5 Reasoning from Authoritative Although Not Legally Binding Rules
- 6 The Role of Moral, Policy, and Empirical Propositions in Legal Reasoning, and the Judicial Adoption of New Legal Rules Based on Social Propositions
- 7 Legal Rules, Principles, and Standards
- 8 The Malleability of Common Law Rules
- 9 Hiving Off New Legal Rules from Established Legal Rules, Creating Exceptions to Established Rules, and Distinguishing
- 10 Analogy-Based Legal Reasoning
- 11 The Roles of Logic, Deduction, and Good Judgment in Legal Reasoning
- 12 Reasoning from Hypotheticals
- 13 Overruling
- Acknowledgments
- Index
5 - Reasoning from Authoritative Although Not Legally Binding Rules
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 September 2022
- Legal Reasoning
- Legal Reasoning
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface
- 1 A Brief Introduction to the Common Law
- 2 Rule-Based Legal Reasoning
- 3 Reasoning from Precedent and the Principle of Stare Decisis
- 4 How It Is Determined What Rule a Precedent Establishes
- 5 Reasoning from Authoritative Although Not Legally Binding Rules
- 6 The Role of Moral, Policy, and Empirical Propositions in Legal Reasoning, and the Judicial Adoption of New Legal Rules Based on Social Propositions
- 7 Legal Rules, Principles, and Standards
- 8 The Malleability of Common Law Rules
- 9 Hiving Off New Legal Rules from Established Legal Rules, Creating Exceptions to Established Rules, and Distinguishing
- 10 Analogy-Based Legal Reasoning
- 11 The Roles of Logic, Deduction, and Good Judgment in Legal Reasoning
- 12 Reasoning from Hypotheticals
- 13 Overruling
- Acknowledgments
- Index
Summary
The most prominent type of rules employed in American legal reasoning consists of rules established in binding legal precedents. The next most prominent type consists of authoritative although not legally binding rules. An authoritative although not legally binding rule is one that courts treat as a rule not because after due consideration they regard it as a good rule but because it was adopted in a source to which the courts give deference. In the common law there are several sources of authoritative although not legally binding rules. One source consists of decisions by the Supreme Courts of other jurisdictions. Another source consists of cases decided by coordinate courts in the same jurisdiction as the deciding court. Perhaps the most important sources of authoritative although not legally binding rules are Restatements and leading treatises.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Legal Reasoning , pp. 34 - 40Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2022