Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Foreword
- Contents
- Chapter 1 Introduction
- Chapter 2 Small States in a Total War
- Chapter 3 The Mystery of the Dying Dutch
- Chapter 4 Feeding the People
- Chapter 5 From Riches to Rags
- Chapter 6 Value for Money
- Chapter 7 Poverty in Moneyed Times
- Chapter 8 The Shadow Economy
- Chapter 9 Filth, Food and Infectious Disease Mortality
- Chapter 10 Conclusion
- A Note on Archival Sources and Abbreviations
- Appendix 1
- Appendix 11
- Bibliography
- Index
Chapter 9 - Filth, Food and Infectious Disease Mortality
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 15 January 2021
- Frontmatter
- Foreword
- Contents
- Chapter 1 Introduction
- Chapter 2 Small States in a Total War
- Chapter 3 The Mystery of the Dying Dutch
- Chapter 4 Feeding the People
- Chapter 5 From Riches to Rags
- Chapter 6 Value for Money
- Chapter 7 Poverty in Moneyed Times
- Chapter 8 The Shadow Economy
- Chapter 9 Filth, Food and Infectious Disease Mortality
- Chapter 10 Conclusion
- A Note on Archival Sources and Abbreviations
- Appendix 1
- Appendix 11
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
Until September 1944 rations were low, but without causing any irreparable problems. Death rates increased, contagious diseases increased, partly undoubtedly as a result of inferior nutrition, but for a large part as a consequence of the lack of other products, such as clothing, footwear, fuel, cover, and last but not least soap…
The above quote from S.L. Louwes, which stems from his defence of his policies as leader of the RBVVO, makes clear why it is difficult to establish causal relations in historical epidemiology. The number of factors potentially contributing to disease or mortality regimes is almost literally endless. This poses a problem, of course, to any investigation of Dutch wartime mortality. As explained in Chapter 2, child and adolescent mortality increased significantly in the Netherlands in the years before September 1944, but not in Denmark. The standard of living in the two countries, which has been investigated in detail in the past five chapters, must in one or more ways have been so different that it can explain the divergent impact of occupation on public health. The comparative investigation of Denmark and the Netherlands offers a possible way out of the problem of identifying the causes of Dutch wartime mortality. Hitherto, as noted, rather generic explanations, not dissimilar to the ones given in the Louwes quote above, have dominated Dutch historiography. Lou de Jong, in his seminal history of the Netherlands during World War II, placed food shortages (of which he had little concrete understanding at the time) centre stage as the cause of declining health, alongside the cold, the mass movements of people and, especially, the loose wartime morals. In contrast, Trienekens and Klemann are much more optimistic about the wartime diet, but they too adhere to the image of a general decline in the material standard of living as the main cause of increased mortality in the Netherlands before the Hunger winter. However, these explanations do not differentiate quantitively between the various contributing factors. In the light of the previous four chapters, this is hardly satisfactory: many of the developments traditionally considered to explain the Dutch mortality regime clearly took place in Denmark as well, without having any such impact.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Lard, Lice and LongevityThe Standard of Living in Occupied Denmark and the Netherlands, 1940–1945, pp. 192 - 223Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2009