Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Introduction: The Many Senses of Community in Kant
- 1 Kant's Standpoint on the Whole: Disjunctive Judgment, Community, and the Third Analogy of Experience
- 2 Making Sense of Mutual Interaction: Simultaneity and the Equality of Action and Reaction
- 3 Kant on the Relationship between Autonomy and Community
- 4 Kantian Communities: The Realm of Ends, the Ethical Community, and the Highest Good
- 5 Religion, Ethical Community, and the Struggle against Evil
- 6 Kant's Conception of Public Reason
- 7 Original Community, Possession, and Acquisition in Kant's Metaphysics of Morals
- 8 Community and Normativity: Hegel's Challenge to Kant in the Jena Essays
- 9 Paradoxes in Kant's Account of Citizenship
- 10 Kant's Conception of the Nation-State and the Idea of Europe
- 11 Kant's Parergonal Politics: The Sensus Communis and the Problem of Political Action
- 12 Aesthetic Reflection and Community
- 13 Social Demands: Kant and the Possibility of Community
- Bibliography
- List of Contributors
- Index
8 - Community and Normativity: Hegel's Challenge to Kant in the Jena Essays
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 April 2013
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Introduction: The Many Senses of Community in Kant
- 1 Kant's Standpoint on the Whole: Disjunctive Judgment, Community, and the Third Analogy of Experience
- 2 Making Sense of Mutual Interaction: Simultaneity and the Equality of Action and Reaction
- 3 Kant on the Relationship between Autonomy and Community
- 4 Kantian Communities: The Realm of Ends, the Ethical Community, and the Highest Good
- 5 Religion, Ethical Community, and the Struggle against Evil
- 6 Kant's Conception of Public Reason
- 7 Original Community, Possession, and Acquisition in Kant's Metaphysics of Morals
- 8 Community and Normativity: Hegel's Challenge to Kant in the Jena Essays
- 9 Paradoxes in Kant's Account of Citizenship
- 10 Kant's Conception of the Nation-State and the Idea of Europe
- 11 Kant's Parergonal Politics: The Sensus Communis and the Problem of Political Action
- 12 Aesthetic Reflection and Community
- 13 Social Demands: Kant and the Possibility of Community
- Bibliography
- List of Contributors
- Index
Summary
Historians of philosophy face a difficulty in conceptualizing the relationship between Kant and his Idealist successors, for the latter offer a wide range of options—from completing the architectonic of reason (by offering a single principle from which it could be deduced), to overcoming entirely what they take to be the deep contradictions of the critical project. This ambivalence is nowhere more evident than in the writings of the young Hegel, which swing from one pole to the other within the span of a few years. In his Berne (1795) essay on Christianity, Hegel attributes to Jesus a thinly veiled Kantian gospel of pure reason and moral legislation. And this enthusiasm is only corroborated in contemporaneous letters to Schelling and Hölderlin, which demonstrate that all three thinkers had sworn to transform corrupt social conditions by working toward the Kingdom of God familiar to them from Kant's Religion within the Limits of Reason Alone. Hegel's earliest published writings, however, take an acerbic tone when they denounce Kantian morality as self-domination and the wider critical system as an “unphilosophy” that eventuates in the “total crushing of reason.”
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Kant and the Concept of Community , pp. 183 - 208Publisher: Boydell & BrewerPrint publication year: 2011