Putting evidence in its place: John Mill's early struggles with “facts in the concrete”

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511493317.016

15 - Putting evidence in its place: John Mill's early struggles with “facts in the concrete”

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 September 2009

Neil De Marchi

Edited by

Uskali Mäki

Show author details

Neil De Marchi: Affiliation:
Professor of Economics Duke University, Durham, North Carolina, USA
Uskali Mäki: Affiliation:
Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Overview

Experience versus assumed behavior

Mill was a realist in the most fundamental sense: he believed in the existence of an external world. Since he also believed that our knowledge of facts or phenomena is received via sense impressions, he had to show that there is indeed a reality independent of these. His approach to that problem remained much the same over time, though he experimented with various forms of words for articulating it. Basically it held two elements. First, not all sensations are fleeting. They can, and some do, retain the same properties under changed circumstances, even though those changes may affect appearances. For sensations having such persistent properties Mill adopted the Kantian label “perdurable.” Second, impressions and memories are personal but not necessarily individual: they may be common to vast numbers of individuals. That there are perdurable and public possibilities of sensation seemed to Mill sufficient to back his claim that there is an external world.

I will not probe Mill's grounds for realism. Rather, taking his realist convictions as fixtures of his mental apparatus, my aim here is to examine afresh his move in the early 1830s to portray inquiry in political economy as unavoidably a priori. He defined this phrase in his famous 1836 essay on method, “On the Definition of Political Economy; and on the Method of Investigation Proper to It.” A priori reasoning is “reasoning from an assumed hypothesis” ([1836b] 1967), Works IV, 325).

Type: Chapter
Information: Fact and Fiction in Economics
Models, Realism and Social Construction
, pp. 304 - 326

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511493317.016 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2002

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Bentham, Jeremy (1827). Rationale of Judicial Evidence, specially applied to English Practice, ed. J. S. Mill, 5 vols. London: Hunt & Clarke

Hollander, Samuel and Peart, Sandra (1999). John Stuart Mill's method in principle and practice: a review of the evidence, Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 21, 369–397CrossRef Google Scholar

Mill, John Stuart ([1823a] 1986). Free Discussion, Letter II, Morning Chronicle, 8 February; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, December 1822–July 1831, vol. XⅫ, Collected Works of John Stuart Mill. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 12–15

Mill, John Stuart ([1823b] 1986). Judicial Oaths, Morning Chronicle, 25 July; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, vol. XⅫ, Collected Works, 30–33

Mill, John Stuart ([1823c] 1986). Technicalities of English Law, Morning Chronicle, 18 September; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, vol. XⅫ, Collected Works, 60–62

Mill, John Stuart ([1823d] 1986). Practicability of Reform in The Law, Morning Chronicle, 8 October; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, vol. XⅫ, Collected Works, 70–72

Mill, John Stuart ([1823e] 1986). Old and New Institutions, Morning Chronicle, 17 October; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, vol. XⅫXⅫ, Collected Works, 72–74

Mill, John Stuart ([1824] 1967). War Expenditure, Westminster Review, II (July), 27–48; reprinted in Essays on Economics and Society, vol. IV, Collected Works, 3–22

Mill, John Stuart ([1826a] 1985). Mignet's French Revolution, Westminster Review, V (April), 385–398; reprinted in Essays on French History and Historians, vol. XX, Collected Works, 3–14

Mill, John Stuart ([1826b] 1967). Paper Currency and Commercial Distress, Parliamentary Review. Session of 1826. London: Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, & Green, 630–662; reprinted in Essays on Economics and Society, vol. IV, Collected Works, 73–123

Mill, John Stuart ([1827] 1988). The Use of History. Speech to London Debating Society; printed in Journals and Debating Speeches, vol. XXVI, Collected Works, 392–397

Mill, John Stuart ([1827?] 1988). The Influence of Lawyers; printed in Journals and Debating Speeches, vol. XXVI, Collected Works, 386–391

Mill, John Stuart ([1828] 1985). Scott's Life of Napoleon, Westminster Review, IX (April), 251–313; reprinted in Essays on French History and Historians, vol. XX, Collected Works, 55–110

Mill, John Stuart ([1830–1833] 1974). Early Draft of the Logic, appendix A in A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive, vol. VIII, Collected Works, 961–1110

Mill, John Stuart ([1831a] 1986). The Spirit of The Age, I, Examiner, 9 January, 20–21; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, vol. XⅫ, Collected Works, 227–234

Mill, John Stuart ([1831b] 1986). The Spirit of The Age, II, Examiner, 23 January, 50–52; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, vol. XⅫ, Collected Works, 238–245

Mill, John Stuart ([1831c] 1986). Herschel's Preliminary Discourse, Examiner, 20 March, 179–180; reprinted in Newspaper Writings, vol. XⅫ, Collected Works, 284–287

Mill, John Stuart ([1835] 1969). Sedgwick's Discourse, London Review, I (April), 94–135; reprinted in Essays on Ethics, Religion and Society, vol. X, Collected Works, 33–74

Mill, John Stuart ([1836a] 1977). State of Society in America, London Review, II (January), 365–389; reprinted in Essays on Politics and Society, vol. XVIII, Collected Works, 93–115

Mill, John Stuart ([1836b] 1967). On the Definition of Political Economy; and on the Method of Investigation Proper to It, London and Westminster Review, IV and XXVI (October), 1–29; reprinted in Essays on Economics and Society, vol. IV, Collected Works, 309–339

Mill, John Stuart ([1837] 1985). Carlyle's French Revolution, London and Westminster Review, V; and XXVII (July), 17–53; reprinted in Essays on French History and Historians, vol. XX, Collected Works, 133–166

Mill, John Stuart ([1838] 1969). Bentham, London and Westminster Review, 7 and 29 (August), 467–506; reprinted in Essays on Ethics, Religion and Society, vol. X, Collected Works, 77–115

Mill, John Stuart ([1843] 1973, 1974). A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive, vols. VII and VIII, Collected Works

Mill, John Stuart ([1844] 1985). Michelet's History of France, Edinburgh Review, ⅬXXIX (January), 1–39; reprinted in Essays on French History and Historians, vol. XX, Collected Works, 219–255

Mill, John Stuart ([1865] 1979). An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy, vol. IX, Collected Works

Mill, John Stuart ([1873] 1981). Autobiography, in Autobiography and Literary Essays, vol. I, Collected Works, 4–290

Ryan, Alan (1979). Introduction to An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy, in vol. IX, Collected Works, ⅶ–ⅼⅹⅶ