Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Editors' acknowledgments
- 1 Interests, values, and explanations
- 2 Fiction and reality in painting
- 3 Franz Kafka: the necessity for a philosophical interpretation of his work
- 4 On relocating ethical criticism
- 5 Explanation and value: what makes the visual arts so different, so appealing?
- 6 Is art history?
- 7 Objectivity and valuation in contemporary art history
- 8 Fullness and parsimony: notes on creativity in the arts
- 9 Principles of a sociology of cultural works
- 10 Althusser and ideological criticism of the arts
- 11 Film, rhetoric, and ideology
- Index
5 - Explanation and value: what makes the visual arts so different, so appealing?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 February 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Editors' acknowledgments
- 1 Interests, values, and explanations
- 2 Fiction and reality in painting
- 3 Franz Kafka: the necessity for a philosophical interpretation of his work
- 4 On relocating ethical criticism
- 5 Explanation and value: what makes the visual arts so different, so appealing?
- 6 Is art history?
- 7 Objectivity and valuation in contemporary art history
- 8 Fullness and parsimony: notes on creativity in the arts
- 9 Principles of a sociology of cultural works
- 10 Althusser and ideological criticism of the arts
- 11 Film, rhetoric, and ideology
- Index
Summary
In Joyce Cary's novel of 1944, The Horse's Mouth, the down-and-out London painter Gulley Jimson seizes the opportunity to paint a huge and wildly imaginative mural, on the twenty-five-by-forty-foot wall of an old chapel that is scheduled for imminent demolition. Rich aristocratic patrons who have acquired his work in the past and a knowledgeable professor who has written about it come to visit while he is at work and ask questions about what the mural “means,” or how exactly it represents its supposed theme of the Creation. Jimson keeps them at bay with jokes – “it means…getting up at seven o'clock every morning…to use all the light available,” and the subject in question is “very likely…a good idea”; but what really engages all of his thoughts and feelings is, as he describes it, simply being in a position to get on with the job:
I wanted to shout [loud] for standing on the top of a scaffold in front of a good new wall always goes to my head…what nobler elevation could you find in this world than the scaffold of a wall painter? No admiral on the bridge of a new battleship could feel more pleased with himself than Gulley…with his palette table beside him, his brush in his hand…cleared for action.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Explanation and Value in the Arts , pp. 94 - 108Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1993