Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Foreword
- Translators' Note
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction
- Part I Preliminary Matters
- Part II Psychology
- 5 The Object and Method of Psychology
- 6 Faculties of the Soul
- 7 On Pleasure and Pain
- 8 The Inclinations
- 9 The Emotions and Passions
- 10 Theory of Knowledge
- 11 External Perception and Its Conditions. The Senses
- 12 External Perception. The Origin of the Idea of Externality
- 13 External Perception. On the Objectivity of the Idea of Externality. (1) Does the External World Exist?
- 14 External Perception. On the Objectivity of the Idea of Externality. (2) On the Nature of the External World
- 15 Consciousness. On the Conditions of Consciousness
- 16 Consciousness. On the Origin of the Idea of the Self
- 17 Consciousness. On the Nature of the Self
- 18 Reason. The Definition of Reason
- 19 Reason. The Material of Reason. (1) Principles of Reason
- 20 Reason. The Material of Reason (2) Rational or First Ideas
- 21 Reason. Empiricism
- 22 Reason. Evolutionism. The Theory of Heredity
- 23 Reason. On the Objectivity of Rational Principles
- 24 Faculties of Conception. On the Association of Ideas
- 25 Faculties of Conception. Memory
- 26 Faculties of Conception. Imagination
- 27 Faculties of Conception. Sleep. Dreams. Madness
- 28 Complex Operations of the Mind. Attention. Comparison. Abstraction
- 29 Complex Operations of the Mind. Generalization. Judgment. Reasoning
- 30 The Object and Method of Aesthetics
- 31 What Is Beauty?
- 32 Prettiness and the Sublime. Art
- 33 On Activity in General. Instinct
- 34 Habit
- 35 On the Will and on Freedom
- 36 On Freedom (Continued). Psychological Determinism
- 37 On Freedom (Conclusion). Scientific Determinism. Theological Fatalism
- Part III Logic
- Part IV Ethics
- Part V Metaphysics
- Appendix: Biographical Glossary
- Index
13 - External Perception. On the Objectivity of the Idea of Externality. (1) Does the External World Exist?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 October 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Foreword
- Translators' Note
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction
- Part I Preliminary Matters
- Part II Psychology
- 5 The Object and Method of Psychology
- 6 Faculties of the Soul
- 7 On Pleasure and Pain
- 8 The Inclinations
- 9 The Emotions and Passions
- 10 Theory of Knowledge
- 11 External Perception and Its Conditions. The Senses
- 12 External Perception. The Origin of the Idea of Externality
- 13 External Perception. On the Objectivity of the Idea of Externality. (1) Does the External World Exist?
- 14 External Perception. On the Objectivity of the Idea of Externality. (2) On the Nature of the External World
- 15 Consciousness. On the Conditions of Consciousness
- 16 Consciousness. On the Origin of the Idea of the Self
- 17 Consciousness. On the Nature of the Self
- 18 Reason. The Definition of Reason
- 19 Reason. The Material of Reason. (1) Principles of Reason
- 20 Reason. The Material of Reason (2) Rational or First Ideas
- 21 Reason. Empiricism
- 22 Reason. Evolutionism. The Theory of Heredity
- 23 Reason. On the Objectivity of Rational Principles
- 24 Faculties of Conception. On the Association of Ideas
- 25 Faculties of Conception. Memory
- 26 Faculties of Conception. Imagination
- 27 Faculties of Conception. Sleep. Dreams. Madness
- 28 Complex Operations of the Mind. Attention. Comparison. Abstraction
- 29 Complex Operations of the Mind. Generalization. Judgment. Reasoning
- 30 The Object and Method of Aesthetics
- 31 What Is Beauty?
- 32 Prettiness and the Sublime. Art
- 33 On Activity in General. Instinct
- 34 Habit
- 35 On the Will and on Freedom
- 36 On Freedom (Continued). Psychological Determinism
- 37 On Freedom (Conclusion). Scientific Determinism. Theological Fatalism
- Part III Logic
- Part IV Ethics
- Part V Metaphysics
- Appendix: Biographical Glossary
- Index
Summary
As we now know where the idea of externality comes from, it seems that we're in a position to decide if this idea corresponds to real objects existing outside of us. The idea of externality is given to us in the idea of space. So the question might be asked as follows: Does the idea of space correspond to an objective reality? But we're not quite ready to answer this question, which amounts to asking if objects really exist in space. This can't be answered until we've decided that objects really exist, and this is what we're going to consider in this lecture. The question of the objectivity of the idea of space is actually part of another, more complicated question of knowing if the laws of the mind are also the laws of things, to which we won't turn for a while.
So in order to know if anything really exists outside of ourselves, we'll have to proceed in some other way. Using an inductive approach, let's imagine that we have a sensation and then try to determine its cause. If we decide that the cause lies within us, we'll conclude that there's no such thing as the nonself. But if we decide that the cause lies outside of us, we'll conclude that the external world does exist.
How do we determine the cause of a phenomenon? Logic can be our guide.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Durkheim's Philosophy LecturesNotes from the Lycée de Sens Course, 1883–1884, pp. 80 - 81Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2004