Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Note on Sources and Texts
- Introduction
- 1 On Whether or Not the Florentines Should Wage War against the Church
- 2 On Whether or Not the Florentines Should Accept the Peace Agreement that the Duke of Milan is Offering
- 3 On Whether or Not the Florentines Should Launch a War of Aggression against Lucca
- 4 On Whether or Not the King of France Should Make Peace with the Duke of Milan
- 5 On Whether or Not the Venetians Should Sign an Offensive Alliance with the King of France
- 6 On Whether the Venetians Should Ally with the King of the Romans or Stick to the Alliance with the King of France
- 7 On Whether the Venetians Should Ally with the Emperor or Stick to the Alliance with the King of France
- 8 On Whether the Emperor Should Be Magnanimous towards the King of France, Whom He Holds Prisoner, or Impose Severe Terms on Him
- 9 On Whether or Not the Venetians Should Make an Agreement with the Emperor or Risk War against Him
- 10 On Whether the Pope Should Make an Agreement with the Emperor or Wage War against Him
- 11 On Whether the Emperor Should Make an Agreement with the Italian States or the King of France
- Name index
- Subject index
3 - On Whether or Not the Florentines Should Launch a War of Aggression against Lucca
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 April 2017
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Note on Sources and Texts
- Introduction
- 1 On Whether or Not the Florentines Should Wage War against the Church
- 2 On Whether or Not the Florentines Should Accept the Peace Agreement that the Duke of Milan is Offering
- 3 On Whether or Not the Florentines Should Launch a War of Aggression against Lucca
- 4 On Whether or Not the King of France Should Make Peace with the Duke of Milan
- 5 On Whether or Not the Venetians Should Sign an Offensive Alliance with the King of France
- 6 On Whether the Venetians Should Ally with the King of the Romans or Stick to the Alliance with the King of France
- 7 On Whether the Venetians Should Ally with the Emperor or Stick to the Alliance with the King of France
- 8 On Whether the Emperor Should Be Magnanimous towards the King of France, Whom He Holds Prisoner, or Impose Severe Terms on Him
- 9 On Whether or Not the Venetians Should Make an Agreement with the Emperor or Risk War against Him
- 10 On Whether the Pope Should Make an Agreement with the Emperor or Wage War against Him
- 11 On Whether the Emperor Should Make an Agreement with the Italian States or the King of France
- Name index
- Subject index
Summary
At the end of the war that had followed the 1420 agreement with the Duke of Milan (see the previous debate), Florence remained empty- handed and embittered by the territorial gains achieved by her ally, Venice. Now that the threat posed by the Duke seemed under control, however, the Florentines resumed their century-long design to take Lucca, the conduct of whose lord, during the last war, provided a pretext. The debate below is introduced by the words of Niccolò Machiavelli, who, in his Florentine Histories (IV, 18), offers an account of the events that is fully consistent with Guicciardini's:
Niccolò Fortebraccio […] had been for a considerable time in the service of the city of Florence during the wars with the Duke of Milan Filippo Maria Visconti. Upon the declaration of peace he was discharged by the Florentines […]. Rinaldo degli Albizzi persuaded Niccolò to attack Lucca under some pretext, pointing out to Niccolò that if he did so, he, Rinaldo, would make the Florentines openly declare war against Lucca, and that then Niccolò would be made commander of their forces […]. [Thus Niccolò] with 300 mounted men and 300 infantry, seized, in November 1429, the Lucchese castles of Ruoti and Compito, and then descended into the plain, where he took a large amount of booty. When this became known in Florence people of all sorts gathered in groups throughout the city, the greater part of which wanted war to be waged against Lucca. Of the principal citizens who were in favour of this were the adherents of the Medici with whom Rinaldo had sided, being influenced either by the belief that it would be advantageous for the republic, or perhaps by the ambitious hope that he would have the merit of victory. Those who were opposed to it were Niccolò da Uzzano and his party. It would almost seem incredible that in the same city there should be such a diversity of opinion as to the undertaking of this war; for those very citizens and the same people who, after ten years of peace, had blamed the war undertaken against Duke Filippo in defence of the independence of the republic, now, after the heavy expenditures and affliction in which that war involved the city, eagerly demanded that a war should be undertaken against Lucca to suffocate somebody else's independence.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Debating Foreign Policy in the RenaissanceSpeeches on War and Peace by Francesco Guicciardini, pp. 58 - 66Publisher: Edinburgh University PressPrint publication year: 2017