Book contents
- Convergence and Divergence of Private Law in Asia
- Convergence and Divergence of Private Law in Asia
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Tables
- Contributors
- Acknowledgments
- Abbreviations
- 1 Introduction
- 2 Uniform Law and the Production and Circulation of Legal Models
- 3 Convergence, Divergence and Diversity in Financial Law: The Experience of the UNCITRAL Model Law and Cross-Border Insolvency
- 4 The New York Convention and the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration: Existing Models for Legal Convergence in Asia?
- 5 Convergences and Divergences: Comparing Contractual and Organizational Models in International Regulatory Cooperation
- 6 Law as a Market Standard: Voluntary Unification in Contract and Company Law
- 7 Is the Harmonisation of Asian Contract Law Possible? The Example of the European Union
- 8 The Presumption of Regularity in Chinese Corporate Contracting: Evidence and the Prospect of Regional Convergence
- 9 Mind the Gap: Studying the Implementation Discrepancy for the ASEAN Economic Community
- 10 The Rule of Law as Key to the ASEAN Legal Order: How Can It Be Ensured?
- 11 How Asian Should Asian Law Be?
- Index
11 - How Asian Should Asian Law Be?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 17 February 2022
- Convergence and Divergence of Private Law in Asia
- Convergence and Divergence of Private Law in Asia
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Tables
- Contributors
- Acknowledgments
- Abbreviations
- 1 Introduction
- 2 Uniform Law and the Production and Circulation of Legal Models
- 3 Convergence, Divergence and Diversity in Financial Law: The Experience of the UNCITRAL Model Law and Cross-Border Insolvency
- 4 The New York Convention and the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration: Existing Models for Legal Convergence in Asia?
- 5 Convergences and Divergences: Comparing Contractual and Organizational Models in International Regulatory Cooperation
- 6 Law as a Market Standard: Voluntary Unification in Contract and Company Law
- 7 Is the Harmonisation of Asian Contract Law Possible? The Example of the European Union
- 8 The Presumption of Regularity in Chinese Corporate Contracting: Evidence and the Prospect of Regional Convergence
- 9 Mind the Gap: Studying the Implementation Discrepancy for the ASEAN Economic Community
- 10 The Rule of Law as Key to the ASEAN Legal Order: How Can It Be Ensured?
- 11 How Asian Should Asian Law Be?
- Index
Summary
Legal unification is often said to be necessary for trans-border commerce: Europe is an optimal market, facilitated through the institution of the European Union. Alternatively, legal unification in Europe is linked to an idea of a European cultural identity. Behind these two justifications are two ideas about what Europe is. Can the same be said about Asia? In this chapter, Michaels connects discussions about an Asian identity with four concepts of Asia. The first concept is a European idea of Asia and Asian law, which defines a presumably homogeneous Asia on the basis of its level of difference from Europe. Of next three concepts, two of them explicitly invoke leadership of one country: China or Japan. Finally, the idea of Asian values attempts to avoid leadership by any one country in favour of a truly Asian identity. The three chapters cannot avoid the central problems of the European projection: they are all defined by their relation to the West. Michaels closes with an alternative concept of Asia “as method” to overcome these two shortcomings and may offer a more promising path towards an idea of Asian law.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Convergence and Divergence of Private Law in Asia , pp. 227 - 251Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2022