Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Table of Contents
- Abbreviations
- Preface
- 1 Introduction: Discordant Minds and Hostile Nations
- 2 Morbidity and Murder: Lombard Kingship’s Violent Uncertainties 568-774
- 3 Insurgency and Counterinsurgency in Lombard Italy (c600-700)
- 4 Troubled Times: Narrating Conquest and Defiance between Charlemagne and Bernard (774-818)
- 5 ‘Nec patiaris populum Domini ab illis divinitus fulminandis Agarenis discerpi’: Handling ‘Saracen’ Violence in Ninth-Century Southern Italy
- 6 Formosus and the ‘Synod of the Corpse’: Tenth Century Rome in History and Memory
- 7 Sex, Denigration and Violence: A Representation of Political Competition between Two Aristocratic Families in Ninth Century Italy
- 8 ‘Italy and her [German] Invaders’: Otto III’s and Frederick Barbarossa’s Early Tours of Italy – Pomp, Generosity and Ferocity
- 9 ‘I Predict a Riot’: What Were the Parmense Rebelling Against in 1037?
- 10 The Strange Case of Deusdedit and Pandulf: Two Accounts of Honorius II’s Election
- Afterword
- Index
9 - ‘I Predict a Riot’: What Were the Parmense Rebelling Against in 1037?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 07 September 2022
- Frontmatter
- Table of Contents
- Abbreviations
- Preface
- 1 Introduction: Discordant Minds and Hostile Nations
- 2 Morbidity and Murder: Lombard Kingship’s Violent Uncertainties 568-774
- 3 Insurgency and Counterinsurgency in Lombard Italy (c600-700)
- 4 Troubled Times: Narrating Conquest and Defiance between Charlemagne and Bernard (774-818)
- 5 ‘Nec patiaris populum Domini ab illis divinitus fulminandis Agarenis discerpi’: Handling ‘Saracen’ Violence in Ninth-Century Southern Italy
- 6 Formosus and the ‘Synod of the Corpse’: Tenth Century Rome in History and Memory
- 7 Sex, Denigration and Violence: A Representation of Political Competition between Two Aristocratic Families in Ninth Century Italy
- 8 ‘Italy and her [German] Invaders’: Otto III’s and Frederick Barbarossa’s Early Tours of Italy – Pomp, Generosity and Ferocity
- 9 ‘I Predict a Riot’: What Were the Parmense Rebelling Against in 1037?
- 10 The Strange Case of Deusdedit and Pandulf: Two Accounts of Honorius II’s Election
- Afterword
- Index
Summary
Abstract
Contemporary narrative sources would have us believe that the 1037 riot in Parma against the Emperor Conrad II was a drunken assault on the imperial person. However, in reality this was a much more complex affair and part of the political and social changes underway in the Italian cities of the early eleventh century. This chapter argues that the 1037 riot was sparked by the collision of two conflicting imperial policies: the empowerment of the leading clergymen of Italy, including the bishop of Parma; and the strengthening of the legal position of the lower nobility (the valvassores). These policies exacerbated tensions between the bishops and their vassals which could, as happened in Parma in 1037, erupt in spectacular fashion.
Keywords: Salian Italy; Bishops, communal violence, Parma; valvassores
At the end of 1037 the Emperor Conrad II celebrated Christmas in Parma. That evening a violent confrontation took place when a group of locals attacked the imperial party. Both sides sustained casualties and a section of the city was destroyed in an accompanying fire. The scholarship which addresses the causes of the riot in Parma generally falls into two camps. The first presents the riot as a consequence of the same motivations as the earlier riot in Milan, envisaging an attack on the bishop by those excluded from his circle which sought to reduce its burdens and extend its powers. In contrast, Salvatorelli and more recently Zimmerman and Wolfram present fundamentally different causes for the riot in Parma, seeing it as simply a reaction against a display of imperial domination within the city; Conrad, as the representative of this domination, was therefore a natural target for the rioters. This article will argue that the former of these schools is partially correct, but that the political situation in Parma was more complicated than is typically allowed, that the tension between the bishop and a section of his city was more nuanced than is often presented, and that the presence of the emperor was not coincidental to the riot.
The Parmense riot was not the earliest incident in which a group within an Italian city became involved in conflict with imperial forces. Similar uprisings were recorded in Pavia and Ravenna during the early years of Conrad's reign.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Conflict and Violence in Medieval Italy 568-1154 , pp. 265 - 298Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2021