COMPARATIVE HISTORICAL ANALYSIS AND KNOWLEDGE ACCUMULATION IN THE STUDY OF REVOLUTIONS

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511803963.003

2 - COMPARATIVE HISTORICAL ANALYSIS AND KNOWLEDGE ACCUMULATION IN THE STUDY OF REVOLUTIONS

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2014

Jack A. Goldstone

Edited by

James Mahoney and

Dietrich Rueschemeyer

Show author details

Jack A. Goldstone: Affiliation:
University of California, Davis
James Mahoney: Affiliation:
Brown University, Rhode Island
Dietrich Rueschemeyer: Affiliation:
Brown University, Rhode Island

Book contents

Get access

Summary

A Tale of Two Methods

It is striking that those works on the subject of revolutions that have had lasting influence have been almost exclusively built around comparative case studies. From Crane Brinton's (1938) The Anatomy of Revolution to Barrington Moore Jr.'s (1966) Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy to Theda Skocpol's (1979) States and Social Revolutions, this pattern holds true. Even books with widely divergent theoretical perspectives, such as Samuel Huntington's (1968) Political Order in Changing Societies, Chalmers Johnson's (1966) Revolutionary Change, and Ted Robert Gurr's (1970) Why Men Rebel build their arguments around series of brief analytic case accounts, rather than efforts at statistical analysis of large data sets.

This is not because such data sets do not exist. Although it is sometimes argued that revolutions – particularly great social revolutions, such as those of France in 1789 or Russia in 1917 – are too few for formal data analysis, this seems to exaggerate the truth. Jeff Goodwin (2001) lists no fewer than eighteen “major social revolutions” (presumably the most restrictive category of revolutions) from France in 1789 to the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe in 1989. John Foran (1997a), using only a slightly less restrictive definition, lists thirty-one revolutions occurring merely in the Third World since 1900. If we extend the definition to cover not only revolutions but also revolutionary movements, the Encyclopedia of Political Revolutions (Goldstone 1998c) lists over 150 cases around the world since the sixteenth century.

Type: Chapter
Information: Comparative Historical Analysis in the Social Sciences , pp. 41 - 90

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511803963.003 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Abbott, Andrew. 1990. “Conceptions of Time and Events in Social Science Methods: Causal and Narrative Approaches.” Historical Methods 23: 140–50CrossRef Google Scholar

Abbott, Andrew 1992. “From Causes to Events: Notes on Narrative Positivism.” Sociological Methods and Research 20: 428–55CrossRef Google Scholar

Almond, Gabriel A., ed. 1973. Crisis, Choice, and Change: Historical Studies of Political Development. Boston: Little, Brown

Arjomand, Said A. 1988. The Turban for the Crown: The Islamic Revolution in Iran. New York: Oxford University Press

Armstrong, David. 1993. Revolution and World Order: The Revolutionary State in International Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Bates, Robert H., Avner Greif, Margaret Levi, Jean-Laurent Rosenthal, and Barry R. Weingast. 1998. Analytic Narratives. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press

Bennett, Andrew and Alexander L. George. 1997. “Process Tracing in Case Study Research.” Paper presented at the MacArthur Foundation Workshop on Case Study Methods, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs (BCSIA), Harvard University, October 17–19

Brinton, Crane. 1938. The Anatomy of Revolution. New York: W. W. Norton

Calhoun, Craig. 1994. Neither Gods Nor Emperors: Students and the Struggle for Democracy in China. Berkeley: University of California Press

Cobban, Alfred. 1964. The Social Interpretation of the French Revolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Collier, David. 1993. “The Comparative Method.” Pp. 105–19 in Political Science: The State of the Discipline II, edited by Ada Finifter. Washington, DC: American Political Science Association

Dix, Robert. 1983. “The Varieties of Revolution.” Comparative Politics 15: 281-95CrossRef Google Scholar

Dix, Robert 1984. “Why Revolutions Succeed and Fail.” Polity 16: 423–46CrossRef Google Scholar

Eckstein, Susan. 1982. “The Impact of Revolution on Social Welfare in Latin America.” Theory and Society 11: 43–94CrossRef Google Scholar

Edwards, Lyford P. 1927. The Natural History of Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

Eisenstadt, S. N. 1978. Revolution and the Transformation of Societies. New York: Free Press

Emirbayer, Mustafa and Goodwin, Jeff. 1994. “Network Analysis, Culture and the Problem of Agency.” American Journal of Sociology 99: 1411–54CrossRef Google Scholar

Farhi, Farideh. 1990. States and Urban-Based Revolution: Iran and Nicaragua. Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press

Feierabend, Ivo K., Rosalind L. Feierabend, and Betty A. Nesvold. 1969. “Social Change and Political Violence: Cross-National Patterns. Pp. 606–68 in Violence in America: Historical and Comparative Perspectives, edited by Hugh D. Graham and Ted R. Gurr. New York: Praeger

Foran, John. 1992. “A Theory of Third World Social Revolutions: Iran, Nicaragua, and El Salvador Compared.” Critical Sociology 19: 3–27CrossRef Google Scholar

Foran, John 1997a. “The Comparative-Historical Sociology of Third World Social Revolutions: Why a Few Succeed, Why Most Fail.” Pp. 227–67 in Foran 1997b

Foran, John ed. 1997b. Theorizing Revolutions. London: Routledge

Foran, John and Goodwin, Jeff. 1993. “Revolutionary Outcomes in Iran and Nicaragua: Coalition Fragmentation, War, and the Limits of Social Transformation.” Theory and Society 22: 209–47CrossRef Google Scholar

Forster, Robert. 1980. “The French Revolution and the New Elite, 1800–1850.” Pp. 182–207 in The American and European Revolutions, 1776–1850, edited by J. Pelenski. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press

Furet, François. 1981. Interpreting the French Revolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Garton Ash, Timothy. 1989. “Refolution in Hungary and Poland.” New York Review of Books 36 (August 17): 9–15Google Scholar

George, Alexander with Andrew Bennett. 1997. “The Role of the Congruence Method for Case Study Research.” Paper presented at the 38th Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, Toronto, March 18–22

Glenn, John K. 1999. “Competing Challengers and Contested Outcomes to State Breakdown: The Velvet Revolution in Czechoslovakia.” Social Forces 78: 187–212CrossRef Google Scholar

Goldstone, Jack A. 1984. “Urbanization and Inflation: Lessons from the English Price Revolution of the 16th and 17th Centuries.” American Journal of Sociology 89: 1112–60CrossRef Google Scholar

Goldstone, Jack A. 1991. Revolution and Rebellion in the Early Modern World. Berkeley: University of California Press

Goldstone, Jack A. 1994a. “Is Revolution Individually Rational?” Rationality and Society 6: 139–66CrossRef Google Scholar

Goldstone, Jack A. 1994b. “Revolution in Modern Dictatorships.” Pp. 70–7 in Revolutions: Theoretical, Comparative, and Historical Studies, 2nd ed., edited by Jack A. Goldstone. Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace

Goldstone, Jack A. 1998a. “Social Movements or Revolutions? On the Evolution and Outcomes of Collective Action.” Pp. 125–45 in Democracy and Contention, edited by Marco Guigni, Doug McAdam, and Charles Tilly. Boulder, CO: Rowman &Littlefield

Goldstone, Jack A. 1998b. “The Soviet Union: Revolution and Transformation.” Pp. 95–123 in Elites, Crises, and the Origins of Regimes, edited by Mattei Dogan and John Higley. Boulder, CO: Rowman & Littlefield

Goldstone, Jack A. ed. 1998c. The Encyclopedia of Political Revolutions. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly Press

Goldstone, Jack A. 1999. “Initial Conditions, General Laws, Path Dependence, and Explanation in Historical Sociology.” American Journal of Sociology 104: 829–45CrossRef Google Scholar

Goldstone, Jack A. 2001. “Toward a Fourth Generation of Revolutionary Theory.” Annual Review of Political Science 4: 139–87CrossRef Google Scholar

Goldstone, Jack A., Ted Robert Gurr, and Farrokh Moshiri, eds. Revolutions of the Late Twentieth Century. Boulder, CO: Westview

Goldthorpe, John H. 1997. “Current Issues in Comparative Macro-Sociology: A Debate on Methodological Issues.” Comparative Social Research 16: 1–26Google Scholar

Goodwin, Jeff. 1994. “Old Regimes and Revolutions in the Second and Third Worlds: A Comparative Perspective.” Social Science History 18: 575-604CrossRef Google Scholar

Goodwin, Jeff 1997. “The Libidinal Constitution of a High-Risk Social Movement: Affectual Ties and Solidarity in the Huk Rebellion, 1946 to 1954.” American Sociological Review 62: 53–70CrossRef Google Scholar

Goodwin, Jeff 2001. No Other Way Out: States and Revolutionary Movements, 1945–1991. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Goodwin, Jeff and Skocpol, Theda. 1989. “Explaining Revolutions in the Contemporary Third World.” Politics and Society 17: 489–507CrossRef Google Scholar

Gould, Roger V. 1995. Insurgent Identities: Class, Community, and Protest in Paris from 1848 to the Commune. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

Griffin, Larry J. 1992. “Temporality, Events, and Explanation in Historical Sociology: An Introduction.” Sociological Methods and Research 20: 403–27CrossRef Google Scholar

Gugler, Josef. 1982. “The Urban Character of Contemporary Revolutions.” Studies in Comparative International Development 17: 60–73CrossRef Google Scholar

Gurr, Ted Robert. 1968. “A Causal Model of Civil Strife: A Comparative Analysis Using New Indices.” American Political Science Review 62: 1104–24CrossRef Google Scholar

Gurr, Ted Robert 1970. Why Men Rebel. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press

Gurr, Ted Robert ed. 1980. Handbook of Political Conflict. New York: Free Press

Halliday, Fred. 1999. Revolution and World Politics. London: Macmillan

Haydu, Jeffrey. 1998. “Making Use of the Past: Time Periods as Cases to Compare and as Sequences of Problem Solving.” American Journal of Sociology 104: 339–71CrossRef Google Scholar

Hibbs, Douglas A. 1973. Mass Political Violence: A Cross-National Causal Analysis. New York: Wiley

Huntington, Samuel P. 1968. Political Order in Changing Societies. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press

Johnson, Chalmers. 1966. Revolutionary Change. Boston: Little, Brown

Katz, Mark. 1997. Revolutions and Revolutionary Waves. New York: St. Martin's Press

King, Gary, Robert O. Keohane, and Sidney Verba. 1994. Designing Social Inquiry: Scientific Inference in Qualitative Research. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Kiser, Edgar. 1996. “The Revival of Narrative in Historical Sociology: What Rational Choice Theory Can Contribute.” Politics and Society 24: 249–71CrossRef Google Scholar

Kiser, Edgar and Hechter, Michael. 1991. “The Role of General Theory in Comparative-Historical Sociology.” American Journal of Sociology 97: 1–30CrossRef Google Scholar

Kuran, Timur. 1991. “Now out of Never: The Element of Surprise in the Eastern European Revolution of 1989.” World Politics 44: 7–48CrossRef Google Scholar

Kuran, Timur 1995. Private Truths, Public Lies: The Social Consequences of Preference Falsification. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press

Kurzman, Charles. 1996. “Structural Opportunity and Perceived Opportunity in Social Movement Theory.” American Sociological Review 61: 153–70CrossRef Google Scholar

Lakatos, Imre. 1983. The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes, edited by John Worrall and Gregory Currie. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Lenin, Vladimir Ilich. [1973]. What Is to Be Done? Burning Questions of Our Movement. Translation of the 1st ed. of 1902. Peking: Foreign Languages Press

Lichbach, Mark I. 1989. “An Evaluation of ‘Does Economic Inequality Breed Political Conflict?’ Studies.” World Politics 41: 431–70CrossRef Google Scholar

Lichbach, Mark I. 1995. The Rebels' Dilemma. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press

Lieberson, Stanley. 1991. “Small N's and Big Conclusions: An Examination of the Reasoning in Comparative Studies Based on a Small Number of Cases.” Social Forces 70: 307–20CrossRef Google Scholar

Little, Daniel. 1998. Microfoundations, Method, and Causation: On the Philosophy of the Social Sciences. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers

Mahoney, James. 1999. “Nominal, Ordinal, and Narrative Appraisal in Macrocausal Analysis.” American Journal of Sociology 104: 1154–96CrossRef Google Scholar

Mahoney, James 2000a. “Strategies of Causal Inference in Small-N Analysis.” Sociological Methods and Research 28: 387–424CrossRef Google Scholar

Mahoney, James 2000b. “Path Dependence in Historical Sociology.” Theory and Society 29: 507–48CrossRef Google Scholar

Mahoney, James and Snyder, Richard. 1999. “Rethinking Agency and Structure in the Study of Regime Change.” Studies in Comparative International Development 34: 3–32CrossRef Google Scholar

Markoff, John. 1996. The Abolition of Feudalism. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press

McAdam, Doug. 1982. Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency, 1930–1970. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

McAdam, Doug, Sidney Tarrow and Charles Tilly. 1997. “Toward a Comparative Perspective on Social Movements and Revolution.” Pp. 142–73 in Comparative Politics: Rationality, Culture, and Structure, edited by Mark Lichbach and Alan Zuckerman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

McAdam, Doug, Sidney Tarrow and Charles Tilly 2001. Dynamics of Contention. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

McKeown, Timothy J. 1999. “Case Studies and the Statistical Worldview.” International Organization 53: 161–90CrossRef Google Scholar

Midlarsky, Manus I. 1982. “Scarcity and Inequality: Prologue to the Onset of Mass Revolution.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 26: 3–38CrossRef Google Scholar

Moghadam, Val M. 1997. “Gender and Revolutions.” Pp. 137–67 in Foran 1997c

Moore, Barrington, Jr. 1966. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Boston: Beacon Press

Muller, Edward N. 1985. “Income Inequality, Regime Repressiveness, and Political Violence.” American Sociological Review 50: 47–61CrossRef Google Scholar

Nichols, Elizabeth. 1986. “Skocpol on Revolution: Comparative Analysis vs. Historical Conjuncture.” Comparative Social Research 9: 163–86Google Scholar

Oberschall, Anthony. 1994a. “Protest Demonstrations and the End of Communist Regimes in 1989.” Research in Social Movements, Conflict, and Change 17: 1–24Google Scholar

Oberschall, Anthony 1994b. “Rational Choice in Collective Protests.” Rationality and Society 6: 79–100CrossRef Google Scholar

Olson, M., Jr. 1965. The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press

Opp, Karl-Dieter. 1989. The Rationality of Political Protest. Boulder, CO: Westview

Opp, Karl-Dieter 1999. “Contending Conceptions of the Theory of Rational Action.” Journal of Theoretical Politics 11: 171–202CrossRef Google Scholar

Opp, Karl-Dieter and Roehl, Wolfgang. 1990. “Repression, Micromobilization, and Political Protest.” Social Forces 69: 521–47CrossRef Google Scholar

Opp, Karl-Dieter, Peter Voss, and Christianne Gern. 1995. Origins of a Spontaneous Revolution: East Germany, 1989. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press

Osa, Maryjane. 1997. “Creating Solidarity: The Religious Foundations of the Polish Social Movement.” East European Politics and Society 11: 339–65CrossRef Google Scholar

Page, Jeffrey M. 1975. Agrarian Revolution. New York: Free Press

Parsa, Mashing. 2000. States, Ideologies, and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of Iran, Nicaragua, and the Philippines. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Parsons, Tailcoat. 1966. Societies: Evolutionary and Comparative Perspectives. Englobed Cliffs, NJ: Pertinence-Hall

Pettee, George S. 1938. The Process of Revolution. New York: Harper & Row

Pfaff, Steven. 1996. “Collective Identity and Informal Groups in Revolutionary Mobilization: East Germany in 1989.” Social Forces 75: 91–110CrossRef Google Scholar

Przeworski, Adam and Henry Teune. 1970. The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry. New York: Wiley-Interscience

Ragin, Charles C. 1997. “Turning the Tables: How Case-Oriented Research Challenges Variable-Oriented Research.” Comparative Social Research 16: 27-42Google Scholar

Rasler, Karen. 1996. “Concessions, Repression, and Political Protest in the Iranian Revolution.” American Sociological Review 61: 132–52CrossRef Google Scholar

Scott, James C. 1990. Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press

Selbin, Eric. 1993. Modern Latin American Revolutions. Boulder, CO: Westview

Sewell, William Jr. 1985. “Ideologies and Social Revolutions: Reflections on the French Case.” Journal of Modern History 57: 57–85CrossRef Google Scholar

Sewell, William, Jr 1996. “Three Temporalities: Toward an Eventful Sociology.” Pp. 245–80 in The Historic Turn in the Human Sciences, edited by Terence J. McDonald. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press

Skocpol, Theda. 1979. States and Social Revolutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Skocpol, Theda 1982. “Rentier State and Shi'a Islam in the Iranian Revolution.” Theory and Society 11: 265–303, with responses by Nikki Keddie, Walter Goldfrank, and Eqbal Ahmed

Skocpol, Theda 1994. Social Revolutions in the Modern World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Snyder, Richard. 1998. “Paths out of Sultanistic Regimes: Combining Structural and Voluntarist Perspectives.” Pp. 49–81 in Sultanistic Regimes, edited by H. E. Chehabi and J. J. Linz. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press

Snyder, Robert S. 1999. “The U.S. and Third World Revolutionary States: Understanding the Breakdown in Relations.” International Studies Quarterly 43: 265–90CrossRef Google Scholar

Stinchcombe, Arthur L. 1999. “Ending Revolutions and Building New Governments.” Annual Review of Political Science 2: 49–73CrossRef Google Scholar

Stryker, Robin. 1996. “Beyond History versus Theory: Strategic Narrative and Sociological Explanation.” Sociological Methods and Research 24: 304–52CrossRef Google Scholar

Tarrow, Sidney. 1998. Power in Movement: Social Movements and Contentious Politics, 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Taylor, George V. 1972. “Noncapitalist Wealth and the Origins of the French Revolution.” American Historical Review 67: 956–77Google Scholar

Tétreault, M. A., ed. 1994. Women and Revolution in Africa, Asia, and the New World. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press

Tilly, C. 1973. “Does Modernization Breed Revolution?” Comparative Politics 5: 425–47CrossRef Google Scholar

Tilly, C. 1978. From Mobilization to Revolution. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley

Tilly, C. 1984. Big Structures, Large Processes, Huge Comparisons. New York: Russell Sage Foundation

Trotsky, Leon. 1959. The Russian Revolution, selected and edited By F. W. Dupee, translated by Max Eastman. New York: Doubleday/Anchor Books

Tullock, G. 1971. “The Paradox of Revolution.” Public Choice 1: 89–99CrossRef Google Scholar

Urban, M., V. Igrunov, and S. Mitrokhin. 1997. The Rebirth of Politics in Russia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1974. The Modern World System, Vol. 1. New York: Academic Press

Walt, Stephen M. 1996. Revolution and War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press

Wasserstrom, Jeffrey N. 1994. “Gender and Revolution in Europe and Asia.” Journal of Women's History 5: 170–83; 6: 109–20CrossRef Google Scholar

Weede, Eric. 1987. “Some New Evidence on Correlates of Political Violence: Income Inequality, Regime Repressiveness, and Economic Development.” European Sociological Review: 97–108CrossRef Google Scholar

Western, Bruce. 2000. “Bayesian Thinking About Macrosociology.” Estudio/ Working Paper 2000/152. Madrid: Juan March Institute

Wickham-Crowley, Timothy. 1991. Exploring Revolution: Essays on Latin American Insurgency and Revolutionary Theory. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe

Wickham-Crowley, Timothy 1992. Guerrillas and Revolution in Latin America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press

Wolf, Eric. 1970. Peasant Wars of the Twentieth Century. New York: Harper