The Philosophy of Icons

doi:10.1017/CHOL9780521040549.034

Chapter 33 - The Philosophy of Icons

from Part VI - THE GREEK CHRISTIAN PLATONIST TRADITION FROM THE CAPPADOCIANS TO MAXIMUS AND ERIUGENA

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 March 2008

Edited by

A. H. Armstrong

Book contents

Get access

Summary

The Natural Image

It was said at the outset that Platonism and Christianism adopted different attitudes towards corporeal nature, the one regarding it as an obstacle to the soul's perfection, the other as an aid, and itself perfectible. The statement requires modification on both sides. Plato in his later works taught that the sensible world, being a copy of the intelligible, was a guide to the understanding of it, and his successors, under the influence of the Asiatic cults, adopted the same attitude to man-made images; while the early Christians, inheriting the Jewish abhorrence of idolatry, regarded as sacrilegious the representation of spiritual things through the medium of matter. Paganism and Christianism reacted to the same stimulus in contrary ways: the pagan cults which infected Platonism with theurgy stiffened the resistance of the Christians and turned their monotheism, for a time, into iconoclasm.

In the sensible world natural images are distinguished from artificial images by their causes. The causes of the former are the Forms: ‘ The Idea’, says Xenocrates, ‘is the exemplary cause of things which subsist naturally (κατα φυσιν).’ The causes of the latter are concepts in the mind of the artist: ‘Every artist possesses wholly the paradeigma in himself, and confers its shape upon matter.’ But if the Forms are themselves concepts in the Divine Mind, then both kinds of cause are concepts or thoughts, and the difference lies in the thinker, in the one case divine, in the other human.

Type: Chapter
Information: The Cambridge History of Later Greek and Early Medieval Philosophy , pp. 506 - 517

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521040549.034 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 1967

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Albinus, Épitomé, ed. Louis, P.. Paris, 1945.Google Scholar

Alexander, P. J.The Patriarch Nicephorus of Constantinople.Oxford, 1958.Google Scholar

Anonymous Commentator on St John's Gospel Ed. Hausmann, K.. Paderborn, 1930.Google Scholar

Bate, H. N. (Archbishop Germanos in Faith and Order, ed. (London, 1927).Google Scholar

Baynes, N. H. ‘Idolatry in the Early Church’, in Byzantine Studies (London, 1955).Google Scholar

Baynes, N. H. ‘The Icons before Iconoclasm’, in Byzantine Studies (London, 1955).Google Scholar

Bevan, E. R., Holy Images (1940).

Bidez, J., L'Empereur Julien: Œuvres complètes, 1 2 (Paris, 1924).Google Scholar

Borinski, K., Die Antike in Poetih und Kunsttheorie, I (Leipzig, 1914).Google Scholar

Cairns, D., The Image of God in Man (New York, 1953);Google Scholar

Dobschiitz, E., Christusbilder (Leipzig, 1899).Google Scholar

Dürig, W., Imago: Ein Beitrag zur Terminologie und Theologie der Römischen Liturgie (Munich, 1952);Google Scholar

Grabar, A., Martyrium : recherches sur le culte des reliques et l'art chrétien antique, 11 (Paris, 1946).Google Scholar

Hausmann, Karl, Ein neuentdeckter Kommentar zum Johannesevangelium (Paderborn, 1930).Google Scholar

Holl, K., ‘Der Anteil der Styliten am Aufkommen der Bilderverehrung’, Gesammelte Aufsatie zur Kirchengeschichte, 11 (Tubingen, 1928).Google Scholar

Jaeger, W., ‘Der neuentdeckter Kommentar zum Johannesevangelium und Dionysius Areopagites’, Sitzungsherichte der Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (1930).Google Scholar

,Johannes Scottus EriugenaAnnotationes in Marcianum, ed. Lutz, C.. Cambridge (Mass.), 1939.Google Scholar

,Johannes Scottus EriugenaCommentary on Boethius, ‘Deconsolatione Philosophiae iii met.9’, ed. Silvestre, H., in Revue d'histoire ecclésiastique, 17 (1952).

,Johannes Scottus EriugenaExpositiones super Ierarchiam caelestem iii–vii, ed. Dondaine, H. F., in Archives d'histoire doctrinale et littéraire du Moyen Âge, 18 (1951).

,John PhiloponusDe aeternitate mundi contra Proclum, ed. Rabe, H.. Leipzig, 1899 (reprinted 1964).Google Scholar

,John PhiloponusDe opificio mundi, ed. Reinhardt, G.. Leipzig, 1897.Google Scholar

Keble, , Church and Paget, The Works of Richard Hooker, 1 (Oxford, 1888).Google Scholar

Ladner, G., ‘Die mittelalterliche Reformidee und ihr Verhältnis zur Idee der Renaissance’, Mitteilungen des Instituts für Oesterreich. Geschichtsforschung, LX (1952).Google Scholar

Ladner, G. B. ‘The Concept of the Image in the Greek Fathers and the Byzantine Iconoclastic Controversy’, in Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 7 (1953).CrossRef Google Scholar

,Leontius The HermitSolutio argumentorum Severi, PG 86. 2. 1916ff.

Leys, R., L'Image de Dieu chez s. Grégoire de Nysse (Brussels and Paris, 1951);Google Scholar

Lipsius, R. A. and Bernet, M., Acta Apostolorum apocrypha, 11 (Leipzig, 1888).Google Scholar

Martin, E. J., A History of the Iconoclastic Controversy (London, 1930)Google Scholar

,Nicephorus of ConstantinopleContra Eusebium et Epiphanidem, ed. Pitra, J. B., Spicilegium solesmense (Paris, 1852–8), I; IV.

Ostrogorsky, G.Studien zur Geschichte des byzantinischen Bilderstreites.Breslau, 1929.Google Scholar

,PhiloWorks, ed. Cohn, L. and Wendland, P., 6 vols. Berlin, 1896–1915 (works extant in Greek only).Google Scholar

,PorphyryAgainst the Christians, fragments, ed. Harnack, A., in Abhandlungen der preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, phil-hist. Kl. 1916, 1 (additions in ibid. Sitzungsberichte, 1921, 1 and 11).Google Scholar

,Pseudo-DionysiusDe caelesti hierarchia, ed. and tr. Roques, R., Heil, G., Gandillac, M. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1958.

Schwartslose, K., Der Bilderstreit (Gotha, 1899)Google Scholar

Basil, Homiliae in Hexaëmeron, ed. and tr. Giet, S. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1950.

Basil, On the Holy Spirit, ed. and tr. Pruche, B. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1947.

,St Gregory NazianzenOrationes 27–31 (Orationes theologicae), ed. Mason, A. J.. Cambridge, 1899.Google Scholar

,St Gregory of NyssaDe Vita Moysis, ed. and tr. Daniélou, J. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1956.

,St Gregory of NyssaOratio catechetica, ed. Srawley, J. H.. Cambridge, 1903.Google Scholar

,St Gregory of NyssaWorks, ed. Jaeger, W., Langerbeck, H., etc. Leiden, 1952–, in progress.Google Scholar

,St Maximus Confessor ‘Gnostic Century’, in Epifanović, S. L., Materials to serve in the Study of the Life and Works of S. Maximus Confessor.Kiev, 1917.Google Scholar

,St Maximus ConfessorAscetic Life and Centuries on Charity, tr. and annotated by Sherwood, P.. Westminster (Mld) and London, 1955.Google Scholar

,The Greek ApologistsDie ältesten Apologeten, ed. Goodspeed, E. J.. Göttingen, 1914.Google Scholar